Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To sack cleaner for this?

383 replies

Katrinawaves · 21/10/2022 20:33

My husband and I had a mix up today and both left cash out to pay the cleaner. She has taken both lots of cash so double her normal payment for the day. Would I be unreasonable to sack her for this? My husband is saying we should just not pay her next week but I am concerned now about her honesty. What would you do?

OP posts:
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 08:17

Icepinkeskimo · 22/10/2022 01:29

Just ring her and ask!
Good grief, what is wrong with people making all these holier than thou opinions? Tell you what drag her through the village, flog her and tie her to the stake…
You haven’t even discussed it but yep
your up for sacking her….your bloody stupid mistake do the decent thing and ring her. No one has time for this pathetic “woe is me, the servant stole from us”
ohh best check the silver she’s probably sold that as well.
Get a bloody grip, the woman has been working for you for years and you take to a forum over something like this? You either have a pathetically boring life or love drama. You need to get out more. Reality check there are real life dramas going on in peoples life’s and this is not one of them.

Blimey, @Icepinkeskimo - OP hasn’t been drowning puppies!

Titsflyingsouth · 22/10/2022 08:16

MN is so fucking weird about cleaners.

Totally agree.

blanketyblank97 · 22/10/2022 08:16

Tiani4 · 22/10/2022 07:35

@GloriousGlory

Report to the police

Yes. The cleaner took her wages £50. Then she stole a £50 of a separate pile of cash left laying around inside OPs house. She took her wages and then stole £50,

You sound horribly suspicious, I assume you've not heard of benefit of the doubt?
Of it was a mistake and she didn't mean to steal the second £50, The cleaner has had plenty of time to count the money once home and to contact OP via the agency

If you read my post properly, it basically is saying contact her ask her, then if she seems dishonest still (doesn't offer to return the money she "accidentally" (if that's what she's saying) stole, or to say don't worry that's next weeks wages then she is clearly intending to keep the £50 she stole. It's theft. Straight forward theft and yes the police do take a report and give you crime reference for it. Not sure why that's difficult to comprehend - some
MNs don't have a clue!

You honestly think the police would be the slightest bit interested in this? They don't come out when houses are broken into? You get a crime number only.

I suggest you would be wasting OPs time, with it's a theft, call the police.

I agree the thought of this is Grin

daisychain01 · 22/10/2022 08:14

GloriousGlory · 22/10/2022 07:05

Report to the police GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

You sound horribly suspicious, I assume you've not heard of benefit of the doubt?

..... or innocent until proven guilty.

You need to go into the conversation with your cleaner on the assumption that they are innocent. This will ensure that whatever the outcome, you both come away with dignity intact.

"DH and I each left £50 for you this week, by mistake. It was a mix up on our part as we were in a rush that day. Did you see both lots of money on the table?"

note the wording "did you see ..." not "did you take...."

say the above and no more. Let your cleaner talk about the situation from their point of view.

there are many possible scenarios and outcomes:

  1. Supposing your DH hadn't even left the money, maybe he thought he had, but had not. Are you 100% certain he had? What then? The reality is they were innocent of any wrong doing, but there is no proof unless of course you have the MN security CCTV camera footage, panning down on the table showing two separate piles of money From your cleaner's perspective they were completely innocent and will say "I only took the £50 you left for me". Are you going to sack them anyway because you think they're lying, but you only have your DHs word not actual proof.
  2. Supposing they took the 2 x £50. But then deny it vociferously and say there was only 1 x £50 . You have no proof, you then have to decide if you believe them or not.
  3. Supposing they admit wrong-doing and apologise, yes they took the 2 x £50 but state they honestly thought they had been left a bonus. Are you really going to sack that person? Even after they apologise?
  4. Supposing they admit they took the money but didn't feel they did anything wrong, they thought it was a bonus. in this case, you can sack them for stealing, but at a time like this, be aware people are doing desperate things to keep the wolf from the door, you'd have to be a pretty harsh person to send them packing. Sadly when cash is left out it does put temptation in peoples way, that's life. You'd do well to learn a lesson from this and agree with your DH that only one of you should ever leave the cleaner their money so it never happens again.
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 08:12

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 21/10/2022 22:17

That's exactly what it is.

Sounds to me like cleaner is self employed as carrying out serves at multiple households

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 22/10/2022 08:10

Someone definitely needs to speak to her about this and ask why she took two sets of money.

Tiani4 · 22/10/2022 08:09
  • The money was left where the cleaner's money is left. It's not unreasonable for the cleaner to think it is her money. It is perfectly possible for the cleaner to have seen it the second time and to have not remembered she had already picked it up. The number of people here with perfect recall is incredible.*

If you read previous Posts you'll see why that is unlikely the cleaner didn't realise.
You don't get the reality of being £50 in cash - you count it, you put it in your purse:wallet where lo and behold there's another £50 oops I already took my wages this isn't my money..! If you are collecting multiple amounts from different customers you keep records. You count the money when you get home and contact to see you soon theres been a mistake

I'm pretty sure even with your 'not perfect recall ' you don't steal from shops picking up an item twice as you've already paid or walking out without paying your cafe bill.., The cleaner will have known fairly quickly that she mistakenly ahem took £50 not her money. A table is a table in OPs house, it's not fair game to steal anything off of it that's not due to her!

hugefanofcheese · 22/10/2022 08:08

Not reading 8 pages but just ask her about it- she might've assumed something like you'd be away next week so paying in advance now. Perhaps she's got other clients who do this.

Give her the opportunity to return it or clean next week without payment on the day.

If you're not happy after that then it's your home so you don't need to keep her, but at least give her the chance to put it right and explain why she picked up both payments.

ChaosDemon · 22/10/2022 08:08

The money was left where the cleaner's money is left. It's not unreasonable for the cleaner to think it is her money.

It sounds like both lots of cash were in two separate places, otherwise whoever put the second lot down (Dh or the OP) would have seen the first lot?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 08:06

Greatcheeser · 21/10/2022 21:27

Can I change my vote...I was Unreasonable until you made it clear that she'd picked up one payment early and then a second one later, so I'm veering towards Reasonable now. I do hate half a story.

Ditto!

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 08:05

MouldyCheeseandBiscuits · 21/10/2022 21:27

You can only sack someone you employ
If you employ her then you need to instigate your disciplinary procedures.

If you procure a service then you terminate the service- you do not sack an individual.

(just helping you avoid an expensive legal action as you seem confused)

OP was using a colloquial expression / her only confusion lies in whether to sack the cleaner now the trust is largely gone or hear her out

Tiani4 · 22/10/2022 08:03

@ExpectMore

Even if she did, opportunistically take it on purpose and knowingly, it might be a sign that she's really struggling and needs your help rather than to lose her job.

Be kind

So... she stole £50 from OPs house because she's hard up ..? I think you'll find many criminals steal because "they needed it" or "they wanted kt, yikes are tough".

You are misusing "Be Kind" here.

That movement was about not bullying people. Not about saying it's a free for all for thieves to steal money from peoples houses abusing their trust.

You assume OP can afford to lose £50, but the cleaner stole it so must be hard up? There are many reasons someone might need a cleaner but not be rich nor want to be doves to pay the cleaner double their wages because the cleaner stole money that day!
Some MNers don't live in real world ...

ExpectMore · 22/10/2022 08:01

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle

Numerous’?
Absent dishonesty, there are two

I would suggest there are others:
OP thought she'd left money out but hadn't
OPs DH thought he'd left money out but hadn't
Cleaner thought one was an advance payment (I often do this when paying cleaners / dog walkers etc)

marcopront · 22/10/2022 07:59

*How is someone taking twice the amount of money they're owed the OP's mistake?

For all the cleaner knows the next £50 was for OP's night out or her kids pocket money.*

The money was left where the cleaner's money is left.
It's not unreasonable for the cleaner to think it is her money.
It is perfectly possible for the cleaner to have seen it the second time and to have not remembered she had already picked it up. The number of people here with perfect recall is incredible.

girlmom21 · 22/10/2022 07:56

hotdiggetydog · 22/10/2022 07:54

Sack the cleaner for YOUR mistake?

Odd one.

How is someone taking twice the amount of money they're owed the OP's mistake?

For all the cleaner knows the next £50 was for OP's night out or her kids pocket money.

ExpectMore · 22/10/2022 07:55

Katrinawaves · 21/10/2022 20:46

I work from home so I was in the house at the time so she could have checked with me if she was unsure!

my husband had left the money out when he went to work and she picked it up first thing. I left the same amount out towards the end of the shift so she did not lift them both together without counting.

I’m not sure why some think not wanting to pay someone twice makes me tight or cheap!

She could always have been on autopilot and lifted the second lot without thinking?

Unless you have other reasons to doubt her integrity, try to see the best in people and remember all humans make mistakes (eg forgetting she'd already picked up payment).

Even if she did, opportunistically take it on purpose and knowingly, it might be a sign that she's really struggling and needs your help rather than to lose her job.

Be kind

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 07:55

ohfook · 21/10/2022 21:05

No don't sack her when there's numerous other explanations- the most likely one being that she thought it was a tip or a bit extra because you were pleased with her work.

‘Numerous’?
Absent dishonesty, there are two

  • a bonus
  • she forgot
(or a pigeon came in through an open window and stole it)
hotdiggetydog · 22/10/2022 07:54

Sack the cleaner for YOUR mistake?

Odd one.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 22/10/2022 07:54

This is not double her SALARY
She's on hourly pay. It's probably quite a small amount of money. A salary is an annual income fgs.

OP, sack her if you want, but if she does good work she would not be easy to replace. Perhaps she thought you were being particularly generous? Just speak with her an explain your mistake, apologise

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 07:50

Katrinawaves · 21/10/2022 20:46

I work from home so I was in the house at the time so she could have checked with me if she was unsure!

my husband had left the money out when he went to work and she picked it up first thing. I left the same amount out towards the end of the shift so she did not lift them both together without counting.

I’m not sure why some think not wanting to pay someone twice makes me tight or cheap!

Ah, apologies, OP - I hadn’t read your follow on when you posted. Doesn’t sound like an accident

Tiani4 · 22/10/2022 07:48

@marcopront
If you report to the police the question may be raised why is there no record of the payments.

The police won't question this , they aren't interested in tax fraud unless HMRC have investigated and referred it to them , they won't send someone round to take a statement, it'll be a online report of theft.

HMRC would be interested though. Either way talking to the cleaner first is way to go, then the agency if she refuses to return money she stole or accept it as next weeks wages. Then police as last resort. Either way I'd change cleaner in due course telling agency why

ChaosDemon · 22/10/2022 07:48

Ex cleaner here. If I'd seen two lots of cash and didn't feel I could disturb you WFH, I'd have just taken one knowing that if it was a bonus you'd just tell me next week and give it to me then.

You don't just grab cash lying around in someone else's home!

Yemelade · 22/10/2022 07:48

OP, are you able to contact the agency and ask for her contact details, or ask the agency to pass on your number to request a call? You don't need to state the reasons, but if they ask you could explain you're planning a holiday and want to check hours and things direct with your existing cleaner. That way, you aren't dobbing her in but it gives you a chance to discuss prior to her arriving next week.

She might have been on autopilot like you say, or she may have considered it a gift, but it would be pretty awful if she showed up, cleans, then is expecting cash and you mention she's already been paid. Might turn sour quickly. Unless you plan to confront her immediately?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/10/2022 07:45

Travis1 · 21/10/2022 20:36

Have you actually had a conversation with her about this?

Well, quite clearly she hasn’t - which is why she’s posting

Tiani4 · 22/10/2022 07:45

Maybe she didn't count it and took it all together?

OP clearly said hee guan and left £50 out . Cleaner took it. The OP left second lot of £50 out. Loose, on the half table.

I've collected wages in cash, in the past. You count it. I don't know anyone that doesn't. You can tell what £50 of notes looks like. It takes seconds to see that. It is unlikely to be a mistake and certainly not one that the cleaner wouldn't quickly notice once they got home that they'd been "paid" twice and taken money they shouldn't have!

There were many chances to spot they'd already taken her £50 wages from the table, If the cash is loose you put it immediately in your purse/ wallet. You can see in your purse/ wallet that there is already £50 in there of wages!!

Nb If you are collecting multiple amounts of cash from severs customers that day, You keep a record of who's paid who hasn't.

So given that the cleaner didn't contact OP to say "I think there's been a mistake" (ie I accidentally took money from your house that wasn't my wages) , then they are dishonest and attempting to keep it.