Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To sack cleaner for this?

383 replies

Katrinawaves · 21/10/2022 20:33

My husband and I had a mix up today and both left cash out to pay the cleaner. She has taken both lots of cash so double her normal payment for the day. Would I be unreasonable to sack her for this? My husband is saying we should just not pay her next week but I am concerned now about her honesty. What would you do?

OP posts:
dudsville · 21/10/2022 21:37

I used to do home care for the very elderly. I worked with quite a frail old couple and the wife died and I provided the husband with a lot of emotional supportin addition to my duties. When i was leaving my post he gave me a card with a large amount of cash. He was a little frail, so i wasn't sure he was in his right mind, and i never wanted his family to be suspicious, so i went to them straight away. It was the most awkward thing ever, because it turned out he was fully aware of his gift, as were his family, but it was still the right thing for me to do. She should have checked it out with you.

CarefreeMe · 21/10/2022 21:37

To those saying it could be a mistake, it’s a pile of cash not in an envelope, where would you put it, oh your pocket or wallet where the other cash already is. Depending on rates in the area that’s 3-5 hours work, so even if you’re her second job of the day that’s still half a day’s pay extra, who wouldn’t notice that?

I run on autopilot all of the time.

She could have also been paid her weeks wages from her other jobs so had cash on her anyway.

Or she may have known what she was doing and just thought it was a bonus.

OP just needs to ask the agency for her number and have a chat to her.

BadNomad · 21/10/2022 21:35

If she works for an agency, are you not supposed to pay the agency then they pay their cleaners?

AllyCatTown · 21/10/2022 21:33

it could be dishonesty but also it could just be autopilot and not thinking about it. Or maybe some of her clients pay in advance and she just took it thinking that. I guess it depends how you feel about her generally and if there’s been other issues.

dudsville · 21/10/2022 21:32

I'm surprised by the responses on here. You need to be able to trust the people coming into your home. She should not have made any assumptions and you should be able to leave any belongings out without worry they'd take anything outside of what's been contracted. I have little wriggle room for this so i doubt I'd even discuss it.

GloriousGlory · 21/10/2022 21:31

Martinisarebetterdirty · 21/10/2022 21:27

To those saying it could be a mistake, it’s a pile of cash not in an envelope, where would you put it, oh your pocket or wallet where the other cash already is. Depending on rates in the area that’s 3-5 hours work, so even if you’re her second job of the day that’s still half a day’s pay extra, who wouldn’t notice that?

For those with any nouse, why would you pay a cleaner employed via an agency, cash in hand....

Augend23 · 21/10/2022 21:30

FirewomanSam · 21/10/2022 21:21

I was going to say exactly this. If it was the same amount of money, in the same place, at two different moments, she could easily have picked it up by mistake.

Imagine you took some money off a table and then when you went to the table again an hour later the money was still there. You’d probably think ‘oh whoops, I thought I picked that up earlier’ and pocket it again.

Just speak to her about it and I’m sure the mix-up will be cleared right up.

This is a good point actually -. Can imagine doing that. If she doesn't have your number she wouldn't be able to contact you when she got home and found the other £50 in a pocket/whatever?

puddingandsun · 21/10/2022 21:29

Oh dear. Does she only come once a week and is not due back until next Friday?

You are hiring via agency and paying a higher rate precisely to avoid issues like that yet I understand you don't want to risk her her job.

If you decide to let her go, I'd do it after getting one more clean or my money back. It's hard to trust someone after something like that, although it is possible she was too distracted and didn't herself notice she took two lots of the money... I guess she has your number though and she would've been in touch as soon as she realised...

Also, is it possible your husband thought he left the money but he didn't?! We all have our moments.

GloriousGlory · 21/10/2022 21:29

If she's via an agency, why aren't you paying via the agency? Instead of cash directly?

Greatcheeser · 21/10/2022 21:27

Can I change my vote...I was Unreasonable until you made it clear that she'd picked up one payment early and then a second one later, so I'm veering towards Reasonable now. I do hate half a story.

MouldyCheeseandBiscuits · 21/10/2022 21:27

You can only sack someone you employ
If you employ her then you need to instigate your disciplinary procedures.

If you procure a service then you terminate the service- you do not sack an individual.

(just helping you avoid an expensive legal action as you seem confused)

Martinisarebetterdirty · 21/10/2022 21:27

To those saying it could be a mistake, it’s a pile of cash not in an envelope, where would you put it, oh your pocket or wallet where the other cash already is. Depending on rates in the area that’s 3-5 hours work, so even if you’re her second job of the day that’s still half a day’s pay extra, who wouldn’t notice that?

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 21/10/2022 21:25

dontknowwhatisbest · 21/10/2022 20:45

MN is so fucking weird about cleaners.

So, if I left a tenner on the kitchen counter for my teen before I went to work, it would be OK for the cleaner to assume it was meant for him/her and pocket it?

Exactly!

HaPPy8 · 21/10/2022 21:24

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 21/10/2022 21:23

Yep I agree with this. It's dishonesty. How could anyone think the same amount of cash paid twice was anything but a mistake? And she should have said something, whether it was your mistake or not. It's called integrity.

3rd this! It may be innocent!

Martinisarebetterdirty · 21/10/2022 21:24

I’d sack her. You were in the house and she didn’t mention it to you, she could have left a note thanking you or sent a message via the agency. She’s in your home you have to trust her and I wouldn’t after this. id also tell the agency, she could ruin their business. If it’s an honest mistake she will have told them.

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 21/10/2022 21:23

dontknowwhatisbest · 21/10/2022 20:40

Presumably the two lots of cash were in two separate piles? Sorry, I don't for a minute believe that anyone would think that exactly the same amount of money, left in a different place, without and prior discussion, was some kind of cost of living bonus.

I think she has knowingly stolen from you OP.

Yep I agree with this. It's dishonesty. How could anyone think the same amount of cash paid twice was anything but a mistake? And she should have said something, whether it was your mistake or not. It's called integrity.

CarefreeMe · 21/10/2022 21:22

You can’t punish her for your mistake.

It sounds like you are too embarrassed to speak to her about it so instead just want to sack her.

She could have thought it was a bonus or as it was at different times she just picked them up automatically and didn’t clock that she’d already picked some up.

FirewomanSam · 21/10/2022 21:21

gavisconismyfriend · 21/10/2022 21:17

It could easily be a mistake. If it was in the same place at different times she might have picked the second lot up on automatic pilot as she left. Peri-menopausal brain means I could v easily do this kind of thing at the moment, no harm intended!

I was going to say exactly this. If it was the same amount of money, in the same place, at two different moments, she could easily have picked it up by mistake.

Imagine you took some money off a table and then when you went to the table again an hour later the money was still there. You’d probably think ‘oh whoops, I thought I picked that up earlier’ and pocket it again.

Just speak to her about it and I’m sure the mix-up will be cleared right up.

MarshaBradyo · 21/10/2022 21:20

I don’t think you should pay twice due to mistake but I also wouldn’t assume dishonesty / theft

It could be just auto pilot or thinking you’re away next week. She deserves a chance imo to say why

NormaTheWife · 21/10/2022 21:20

@Katrinawaves you must have some kind of idea about what kind of person she is? What are your feelings about this really? I would feel that I would be able to trust her less but obviously I don't know her like you.

gavisconismyfriend · 21/10/2022 21:17

It could easily be a mistake. If it was in the same place at different times she might have picked the second lot up on automatic pilot as she left. Peri-menopausal brain means I could v easily do this kind of thing at the moment, no harm intended!

ThisIsHardcore · 21/10/2022 21:16

@Katrinawaves I can see this from both angles. I had a cleaner when my DC were little (I'm still in touch with her now, 20 years on). I can see how a cleaner could very reasonably take double pay on the assumption that you had deliberately left it out, so I'd ask her rather than sack her. Communication is always the best way. That said, I know for an absolute 100% fact that my cleaner would never, ever have taken double pay, even if we'd left it out either accidentally or on purpose. I could have left a thousand pounds out and she wouldn't have touched it. The fact that your cleaner comes via an agency is an added complication, but I'd definitely speak to her before doing anything.

scoobydoo1971 · 21/10/2022 21:16

I was in a very similar situation last year. I ended up sacking the cleaner. She was overpaid, in the middle of a sudden family bereavement. She had worked for my mother, but came to work for me when she died. I hadn't been through the books at the point so I paid her as she claimed to be owed money. A week later I discovered she had been paid twice. My mother had paid one month salary in advance, died suddenly and then the cleaner claimed she wasn't paid so I had to remedy that on the spot. Upon being discovered, she refused to pay it back as had spent it. She didn't want to give back all the cleaning equipment she borrowed either unless I promised her more hours, better pay etc, so I told her to make it appear or I would inform the police as it was quite a bit of money involved in the equipment. I was furious about the deception at a time of family crisis, and lack of decency. I sacked her when she turned up with my equipment, but she came back months later to ask for her job back. It is not the money OP, but the principle. I suggest you wait this out and see if your cleaner admits to the payment error. If not, I would find another trustworthy cleaner as you cannot have someone in your home with no integrity.

Meagainalready · 21/10/2022 21:15

goodbyestranger · 21/10/2022 20:38

You sound quite tight/ mean. You can afford a cleaner. She has to clean up your dirt to make a living. You made a mistake/ your problem.

Don’t demean the cleaner this way.
She isn’t their slave. She is working in a good job of her choice and hopefully making a decent living. There is no shame in being a cleaner.

girlmom21 · 21/10/2022 21:15

How long was she there for?