Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this benefit fraud?

258 replies

ahzixy · 21/10/2022 18:03

I recently have gotten back together with the father of my kids. We've been seeing each other and he's been staying over at my house. I claim housing benefit.

He doesn't pay towards any of my bills and I don't to his either.

We've always had an agreement between the two of us that he pays £200 per month in child maintenance. That is all he pays to me. In times I have borrowed money like small amounts( but I also do this with my mum and that doesn't tie us financially)

His car is registered at his house, all his bills etc, his work has him as registered at his house.

My name is on my wifi bill, phone bill and I have pre paid metres under my name.

He pays all his council tax etc and gas and electricity which in his one bed flat cost £70 combined but he's paying of a huge debt so he pays £300-400 a month to that.

Things like days out etc or new things for the kids we do go half.

I've also gotten him things through catalog credit like very and Argos since his credit is bad so every other month he will bank transfer money for that but he labels each transfer (I know that doesn't hold much)

We have 3 kids together and he is over often and on his days off takes the kids to and from school.

My close friends would say we are seeing each other but neighbours I exchange polite exchanges would say we are a couple.

I know it's nothing to do with nights spent here it's about finances. I have a lot of proof he pays nothing to my house.

The only thing is I use his Netflix. But before this I used my best friends nextflix too I only changed to his to not lose my place on shows.

The only thing is he's so tight with money even before seeing me he never had wifi. We can prove this also. But to me that looks odd no wifi.

He's also the cheapest person I know with bills. He refuses to have heating on, does washing at his parents house and showers at his gym. Making his bills as low as possible.

My downstairs neighbours told me to my face in April they've reported him living here. Nothing at all came from this so surely it's not fraud??

Is it fraud?? I'm terrified I really don't like this situation and want to get him added asap but we literally couldn't afford to live if he did with his huge debts and until he sells his house.

OP posts:
sashh · 22/10/2022 08:29

Oops, I may have been wrong about the three days. Anyway this is how the DWP decide if you are a couple.

www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/claimant-compliance-manual/ccm15040

lentilly · 22/10/2022 08:23

Autumndays123 · 22/10/2022 08:12

You're missing the point. Yes, the fact he has another house counts for something but that is not sufficient for DWP to say ok no problem, we will keep paying OPs benefits.

They look at:
Does he stay over
How often
Do they eat together
Do they have days out together
Do they holiday together
How they attend family events together
How do people view their relationship status
Are ANY of his belongings in OPs house

Based on the above and from what is said here, he is absolutely living with OP and should be seen as such.

He owns a property and OP knows that if they 'lived together' she would be worse off - she says that. So instead, they keep a separately owned property for future investment purposes, he keeps his bills to a minimum by showering in the gym (let's face it, this was a lie,, if he's in the OPs for a week at a time he's not going to the gym to use the shower), and washing his clothes in his parents (again, willing to bet OP washes his clothes too) and OP claims as many benefits as she can as a single person.

The difference between this scenario and other posters nieces and nephews and cousins dog or whatever nonsense comparisons people are making, is that the OP and her OH are in a relationship and have children together. They are a family. They are a family where the mother is claiming to be a single parent and she is not.

OP if you genuinely think what you're doing is fine, ring DWP Monday and tell them the situation and the exact facts and let them decide. If you don't want to do this (and let's face it, if you did you would have done that instead of posting here) then you know it's benefit fraud.

I agree seriously just give them a ring. They won't be like AH HA GOTCHA! They'll be like thanks for letting us know yes that counts as living together or no it doesn't.

Autumndays123 · 22/10/2022 08:12

Faultymain5 · 22/10/2022 08:02

So if he only stays a week this week and not for the next three weeks is he still living there? What is written is a snapshot. Can only go off what is written. As I don’t lie much, I don’t make the assumption that everyone is lying.

now if she said he had moved someone in his place whilst staying at hers then yeah. Benefit fraud.
Should they have set days? Probably, should her neighbour mind her own business even bigger yes.

You're missing the point. Yes, the fact he has another house counts for something but that is not sufficient for DWP to say ok no problem, we will keep paying OPs benefits.

They look at:
Does he stay over
How often
Do they eat together
Do they have days out together
Do they holiday together
How they attend family events together
How do people view their relationship status
Are ANY of his belongings in OPs house

Based on the above and from what is said here, he is absolutely living with OP and should be seen as such.

He owns a property and OP knows that if they 'lived together' she would be worse off - she says that. So instead, they keep a separately owned property for future investment purposes, he keeps his bills to a minimum by showering in the gym (let's face it, this was a lie,, if he's in the OPs for a week at a time he's not going to the gym to use the shower), and washing his clothes in his parents (again, willing to bet OP washes his clothes too) and OP claims as many benefits as she can as a single person.

The difference between this scenario and other posters nieces and nephews and cousins dog or whatever nonsense comparisons people are making, is that the OP and her OH are in a relationship and have children together. They are a family. They are a family where the mother is claiming to be a single parent and she is not.

OP if you genuinely think what you're doing is fine, ring DWP Monday and tell them the situation and the exact facts and let them decide. If you don't want to do this (and let's face it, if you did you would have done that instead of posting here) then you know it's benefit fraud.

ExpectMore · 22/10/2022 08:05

@ahzixy

I recently have gotten back together with the father of my kids.

Isn't the answer obvious given your opening statement...?

You're a couple that currently has two houses. Many couples have that situation however other hard working folk the government shouldn't have to fund them both for you. I'm pretty sure that's fraud, and if not, it's at the very least immoral.

Faultymain5 · 22/10/2022 08:02

So if he only stays a week this week and not for the next three weeks is he still living there? What is written is a snapshot. Can only go off what is written. As I don’t lie much, I don’t make the assumption that everyone is lying.

now if she said he had moved someone in his place whilst staying at hers then yeah. Benefit fraud.
Should they have set days? Probably, should her neighbour mind her own business even bigger yes.

Faultymain5 · 22/10/2022 07:52

lentilly · 22/10/2022 07:11

Anyway OP don't sweat it just ring them up and let them know the circumstances and let them decide

Best advice yet. Most of the so called experts here would have her locked up simply cause she’s on benefits with a boyfriend.

Autumndays123 · 22/10/2022 07:52

I can't believe how gullible some people are. Wake up!

He's living with OP - she says he was there a whole week last week. He keeps his property because he owns in. Living with the OP means they can keep a property that they own AND claim a full whack of benefits because the OP is treated as single

Can't believe people actually think DWP wouldn't see this as benefit fraud.

Faultymain5 · 22/10/2022 07:50

sashh · 22/10/2022 07:45

Watch out for cheap watches in the road. One way to see if someone is living at a property is to put a cheap watch very close to a car wheel.

When you drive off it breaks the watch but shows the time you left.

The rules are about the number of nights he stays. It used to be 3 times a week.

Can you show a link to the OP where it says that with DWP? That would be helpful for her.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 22/10/2022 07:49

I thought as long as he was paying council tax elsehwere it was ok.

Ignore your neighbours they're shit stirring.

WhatTheHellIsAQuasar · 22/10/2022 07:47

You should raise your bar when it comes to relationships

sashh · 22/10/2022 07:45

Watch out for cheap watches in the road. One way to see if someone is living at a property is to put a cheap watch very close to a car wheel.

When you drive off it breaks the watch but shows the time you left.

The rules are about the number of nights he stays. It used to be 3 times a week.

WonkasBooboofixer · 22/10/2022 07:44

It's benefit fraud he lives with you but you are claiming as though he doesn't. The fact he's a tight wad is totally irrelevant

DontGoBreakingMyHeart · 22/10/2022 07:38

Amazes me that as a rule MN positively condones benefit fraud, someone posts about someone they know having a cash in hand job/claiming more benefits than they’re entitled to and the general response is “keep your nose out, in the current crisis if they claim a bit more what does it matter? Amazon do far worse.” But as soon as a poster has a man in the picture who she is legitimately seeing, people start accusing her of having no morals and scrounging from the taxpayer.

He pays towards the children because they are his children. It’s not remotely the same as getting together with someone who is funding their children as those children are not the new partner’s.

People on benefits are entitled to have relationships y’know. And part of building a relationship is, you know, spending time together, with a view to perhaps being together full time one day. Nothing says that you are committing fraud because he owns a toothbrush at your house.

Or perhaps posters would have this man move straight back in? People’s views on the man aside, the OP has chosen to be with him and as such is not yet ready to make him a permanent part of the relationship.

Oh and OP your neighbours are wankers. Hth.

TootMootZoot · 22/10/2022 07:35

This definition is from WWW.Gov.Uk

I don't know about benefits but I don't think you can call the £200 child maintainence . Can anyone confirm?

What child maintenance is
Child maintenance covers how your child’s living costs will be paid when one of the parents does not live with the child. It’s made when you’ve separated from the other parent or if you’ve never been in a relationship

Darbs76 · 22/10/2022 07:33

peanutbutterontoast7 · 22/10/2022 07:31

Sorry to jump. It how many nights are you allowed to have people stay per week in a council/UC housing paid property?

There isn’t a set number of nights. It’s based on if they have 2 properties and can prove they pay bills on 2 properties

peanutbutterontoast7 · 22/10/2022 07:31

Sorry to jump. It how many nights are you allowed to have people stay per week in a council/UC housing paid property?

Hoppinggreen · 22/10/2022 07:31

Aside from anything else why are you getting back with him?
He sounds awful

TootMootZoot · 22/10/2022 07:29

I don't know about benefits but is there a problem with the the £200 he sends her. She's calling it child maintainence but if they are a couple then surely it's not child maintenance?

caringcarer · 22/10/2022 07:28

With neighbours like yours who are likely to report you is it worth the constant worry? You are a together couple, with children, but have 2 houses. I think you need to update benefits and see what they do or say. They might do nothing as you have 2 homes. It would take away stress of neighbours though.

Darbs76 · 22/10/2022 07:17

I believe the rules are he needs to prove he pays bills / mortgage etc at the other house. Which he does. So you should be ok

Boredsoentertainme · 22/10/2022 07:15

I think that it reads like your dodging how often he’s there and the fact you immediately considered telling them he’s living there makes me think he is. He’s not just staying the occasional night is he? When he’s here he stays every night. That’s living there

oldstudentmum · 22/10/2022 07:13

Coconut212 · 21/10/2022 18:45

I work for a council this isn’t fraud you have a house, he has a house and both paying bills for each house. The investigation would check your both registered at separate addresses end of investigation. If he wasn’t they’d check social media etc and then come to you with their findings and it’s would be up to you to prove he lives elsewhere. It’s not fraud and also there’s no 3 night rule

This. No fraud at all . You run separate households the fact he sends you money for kids , you send to him etc is a non point as you have kids together . However, You have a vindictive neighbour problem. You aren’t breaking any laws.

lentilly · 22/10/2022 07:11

Anyway OP don't sweat it just ring them up and let them know the circumstances and let them decide

lentilly · 22/10/2022 07:10

Faultymain5 · 22/10/2022 06:24

My nephew and niece have a toothbrush and clothes at my home, they do not live with me.

Can’t imagine trying to start over in a new relationship with someone and because they spend time with me having to change the way I claim a benefit. If he wasn’t the kids’ dad would you still consider it fraud?

It's not the main criteria is it. But it is something they would look out for.

anzuu · 22/10/2022 07:06

@knittingaddict no I didn't could you tag me in it please

Swipe left for the next trending thread