Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this benefit fraud?

258 replies

ahzixy · 21/10/2022 18:03

I recently have gotten back together with the father of my kids. We've been seeing each other and he's been staying over at my house. I claim housing benefit.

He doesn't pay towards any of my bills and I don't to his either.

We've always had an agreement between the two of us that he pays £200 per month in child maintenance. That is all he pays to me. In times I have borrowed money like small amounts( but I also do this with my mum and that doesn't tie us financially)

His car is registered at his house, all his bills etc, his work has him as registered at his house.

My name is on my wifi bill, phone bill and I have pre paid metres under my name.

He pays all his council tax etc and gas and electricity which in his one bed flat cost £70 combined but he's paying of a huge debt so he pays £300-400 a month to that.

Things like days out etc or new things for the kids we do go half.

I've also gotten him things through catalog credit like very and Argos since his credit is bad so every other month he will bank transfer money for that but he labels each transfer (I know that doesn't hold much)

We have 3 kids together and he is over often and on his days off takes the kids to and from school.

My close friends would say we are seeing each other but neighbours I exchange polite exchanges would say we are a couple.

I know it's nothing to do with nights spent here it's about finances. I have a lot of proof he pays nothing to my house.

The only thing is I use his Netflix. But before this I used my best friends nextflix too I only changed to his to not lose my place on shows.

The only thing is he's so tight with money even before seeing me he never had wifi. We can prove this also. But to me that looks odd no wifi.

He's also the cheapest person I know with bills. He refuses to have heating on, does washing at his parents house and showers at his gym. Making his bills as low as possible.

My downstairs neighbours told me to my face in April they've reported him living here. Nothing at all came from this so surely it's not fraud??

Is it fraud?? I'm terrified I really don't like this situation and want to get him added asap but we literally couldn't afford to live if he did with his huge debts and until he sells his house.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
anzuuu · 27/10/2022 15:03

Hello

A little update on this thread. I finally got through to my local citizens advice.

Brief general information was

  • I've recieved no letters from benefits so that could mean they don't have any investigations on me
  • my housing officer confirming he didn't live here is good but my housing officer also told them stop reporting this to her if they wish to take it anywhere go to safer communities etc, so they would have stopped reporting to her since she disproved it and moved onto other authorities.

Nothing seems to be against me as of now especially when the housing officer disproved this in March/April when we first ever seen each other again.

Does this sound correct to everyone?

My call back is in 2 weeks for a specialist to speak to me.

She thinks I do not have anything to worry about, it isn't criminal.

She thinks this is a long amount of time for me to have been waiting to hear if anyone thinks he lives here

Does this sound right?

SmileyClare · 23/10/2022 01:14

It’s difficult to get a grasp on your situation op because you name changed half way through this thread and your updates aren’t high lighted.

However, your situation sounds really sad if I’ve worked it out right!

…You have 3 children together, the youngest just 2 yet in all that time he hasn’t committed to you?

He’s (somehow) got a mortgage despite being in a minimum wage job (?) has run up huge debts and all the while seen you and his dc evicted, in emergency accommodation and on benefits.

Now he’s flitting in and out of your lives, treats your house like a hotel, and you say you’re concerned he “may pack up and leave” at anytime Sad

Does he know or care how concerned you are by him staying over? What is he actually doing to “become a couple/proper family” in the future ?

Will he actually change? Or does this set up benefit him too well?

Its time for him to shit or get off the pot isn’t it?
Hes treating you like he does his mum; he turns up, gets fed, washing done, waited on while keeping his bachelor pad (a considerable asset) all to himself.

Hes benefitting massively while you’re stressed and panicking about jeopardising your benefits, and potentially having to be in dept to the DWP. Is he worried?

im sorry if that sounds harsh and off topic but you and your children deserve so so much better Flowers

incheon · 22/10/2022 22:01

I work for UC and not declaring living together with a partner is at the top of the list for fraudulent claims. There isn’t a hard rule but I’m sure you can search the decision maker guidance online. They have entire departments dedicated to investigating this.

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 22/10/2022 21:55

cheshirebloke · 22/10/2022 21:43

This thread is interesting because the rules seem particularly vague, bit concerned it could affect me and my DP. We've been in a committed relationship together for 4 years, but don't live together, and won't until the kids are older. We have our own houses, 10 miles apart, and both have children from previous relationships, but none together. I do stay over at DP's house sometimes (less than 3 nights a week though), and obviously we eat together when we are together - whether that's take away, meal out, or cooking at home. I don't keep any clothes or belongings at DP's house, other than a toothbrush.

We don't share any finances, except for going on holiday together, where we split the costs. And cost of food when we eat together. I have lent my DP money in the past, but always on a loan basis and it always gets repaid.

We've never considered that we should be claiming benefits as a couple though, and I'd like to think that the benefits people wouldn't class us as trying to defraud the system. But this thread has concerned me a bit.

I would have thought that having children together is a major consideration in these matters, but it doesn't sound like the benefits people take that as a significant factor?

One of the things that would be asked would be WHY you are not living together, in your case I can see a perfectly valid reason for not as it is not the time until the kids are older.

As I said ages ago, DWP do not stop people having a relationship, they don't stop people staying over at their partners, in your case from what you have said there is no way you would be found to be living together.

cheshirebloke · 22/10/2022 21:43

This thread is interesting because the rules seem particularly vague, bit concerned it could affect me and my DP. We've been in a committed relationship together for 4 years, but don't live together, and won't until the kids are older. We have our own houses, 10 miles apart, and both have children from previous relationships, but none together. I do stay over at DP's house sometimes (less than 3 nights a week though), and obviously we eat together when we are together - whether that's take away, meal out, or cooking at home. I don't keep any clothes or belongings at DP's house, other than a toothbrush.

We don't share any finances, except for going on holiday together, where we split the costs. And cost of food when we eat together. I have lent my DP money in the past, but always on a loan basis and it always gets repaid.

We've never considered that we should be claiming benefits as a couple though, and I'd like to think that the benefits people wouldn't class us as trying to defraud the system. But this thread has concerned me a bit.

I would have thought that having children together is a major consideration in these matters, but it doesn't sound like the benefits people take that as a significant factor?

StarfishBrain · 22/10/2022 21:27

I said I cook for him every time he's over and I've had flat mates the deal is one cooks one cleans the dishes.

But why would an analogy to a flatmate be relevant if he is just a guest in your house as you claim he is? A flatmate is someone who lives with you, by definition.

Newsorrynewagain · 22/10/2022 20:53

My cousin was taken to court for benefit fraud as someone reported that her ex partner (father of her children was living with her). They assessed of the following:
cooking and eating family meals together
going family days out
going on holiday together
social media posts - tagging each other etc
what their friends and family would describe their relationship as

she was found not guilty. The problem you have is that your in a relationship with him. Any from an outsider looking in it can look as if he has his own address / bills - albeit very low amounts which allows him to pay off the debt he has incurred whilst your receiving benefits to cover the living costs. I’m not saying this is the case however it may be viewed as that.

I think phoning for advice is your best bet. I hope you get it sorted

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/10/2022 20:51

Honestly? ‘Seeing’ vs. ‘Being a couple’ is just semantics.

If he is looking to sell the house he supposedly lives in, but spends a week at a time at yours going back to his mum’s to do laundry Hmm then not only is he is he a complete tightwad but it also sounds like he’s living with you because you’ll put the heating on.

Raise your bar. He’s taking advantage regardless.

Redkettle · 22/10/2022 20:46

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:22

@Redkettle I don't know what those options mean sorry

My landlord sold our house so I applied to homeless. I was given a temporary accommodation with that I got a housing officer who did regular checks in my house, all the rooms etc not just for him living there but to make sure I wasn't knocking down walls etc. she was my point of contact for all the compliments my neighbours made - saying kids were loud etc (all disproved too, they had noise apps etc)

And then I got my offer for the temporary accommodation to become my full time permanent council house (this doesn't happen often and I was told wouldn't happen but I updated my preferences to include the area my now permanent house is in.

I hope that answers either one

Ah I know. Same applies really. As long as he's not in full time relationship and not contributing, staying over, clothes toothbrush etc there, paying for meals you are okay x

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:23

@Redkettle I've never heard of starter licence so I'll say it can't be that

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:22

@Redkettle I don't know what those options mean sorry

My landlord sold our house so I applied to homeless. I was given a temporary accommodation with that I got a housing officer who did regular checks in my house, all the rooms etc not just for him living there but to make sure I wasn't knocking down walls etc. she was my point of contact for all the compliments my neighbours made - saying kids were loud etc (all disproved too, they had noise apps etc)

And then I got my offer for the temporary accommodation to become my full time permanent council house (this doesn't happen often and I was told wouldn't happen but I updated my preferences to include the area my now permanent house is in.

I hope that answers either one

Redkettle · 22/10/2022 20:19

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:17

@Redkettle if I declare if from last month when I stopped following temporary rules will I be fine? Since my housing officer regularly checked ?
@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs

Temporary rules? Are you on a starter licence or in temp accommodation. Sorry haven't read whole thread

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:17

@Redkettle if I declare if from last month when I stopped following temporary rules will I be fine? Since my housing officer regularly checked ?
@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs

Redkettle · 22/10/2022 20:16

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:15

@Redkettle from your advice my housing officer disproving him staying here with regular checks is this enough to prove he wasn't here? She also issued no warnings etc

Yes this is good. Xxxx don't worry xxxx

Redkettle · 22/10/2022 20:15

Anzuu didn't mean to worry you lovely. You just have to be v careful. I'm probably posting the exception nor the norm but when I see advice like he xan stay 3 nights a week etc it annoys me as this gets people in trouble. You would know if there were concerns and you would be given chance to rectify or give your side but in all honesty if you have a full blown relationship with someone who stays with you eats with you keeps his clothes there, his toothbrush, takes you all out for the day declare it even if its just to cover ur back. Don't stress xxxxxxx

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:15

@Redkettle from your advice my housing officer disproving him staying here with regular checks is this enough to prove he wasn't here? She also issued no warnings etc

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:12

No he has a pair of shoes here from a day out that got left

Nope I do online asda shops. He does not take me shopping. Also don't get him anything in them either. His card details have never been on my Asda account.

Newsorrynewagain · 22/10/2022 20:11

Is his clothes at yours? Do you food shop together, this is things that will be looked at to determine if your a couple

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 22/10/2022 20:10

I really can't say the thresholds or criteria for prosecution, but I did also say that from what you've said you won't be going to court and it will be dealt with in house.

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:10

@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs housing officer regularly searched my rooms etc to see if he was here and she disproved it. Told them to stop reporting it.

This is why I assumed they reported me else where for everything. Would my housing officer in temporary accommodation who came out to visit monthly and wrote it wasn't true and never once gave me a warning - be enough to prove them wrong and that's why no one's looked into us?

SmileyClare · 22/10/2022 20:10

Why not try citizensadvice.org.uk/contact-us/web-chat-service

You can talk to a trained advisor and it's entirely confidential. You've had some well meaning advice from some posters but it's best to go through your personal circumstances with an impartial advisor before making any decisions.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/10/2022 20:09

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:04

@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs do I meet the other factors?

Like I posted a moment ago I'm worried if he picks up and leaves - my neighbour will report that
Then if he does what will happen? I can be seen as fraudulent?

I see my best option is adding him on, paying the amount I shouldn't have gotten if that happens then i can't be caught out months later asking why I never said?

Don't be so silly. Your best option is to get shot of the financially abusive, lazy, scrounging arsehole before he drags you and your children down with him.

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:07

@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs also sorry completely forgot this is probably key information they reported me to my Hosuing officer in temporary accommodation who disproved him living here. I was very honest with her and she said in temporary accommodation no more than 3 days rules are different permanently and we followed this until last month. She put on my file he's not here, she said if she caught him she'd give me 3 warning and I'd lose my accommodation. I never got a single warning and I'm now here full time.

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:05

@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs or if from what I've told you I am close to it?

anzuuu · 22/10/2022 20:05

@Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs can you answer if an average person could be close to it?