Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I over protective/controlling parent?

59 replies

Frogsanddogs · 21/10/2022 17:40

I'm wondering about my parenting as my parent friends seem to have very different ideas to me. I had bad post natal anxiety after ds was born and thought my feelings then were perfectly valid, I now know I did some ridiculous things. Now I also feel my feelings are 'right', but can I trust them?

My ds is oldest at 3, all other children range from 1.5-2.5. These are things they are allowed to do, which I don't let my ds.

-Play out of sight in a public space. In the house he's welcome to disappear in his bedroom or living room while I'm pottering about, in a busy public park if I'm sat on a bench I'll move bench/ stand up so I can always see him.

-Ride in the car without a car seat. I'm often told by friends "It's fine, we're only going two minutes down the road" that's only a 5 minute walk. I refuse and walk.

-Walk/run next to a busy road without holding hands. Friends child actually ran into the road the other day and a car had to slam his brakes on, but they still let the child carry on.

-Let a friend of a friend baby sit for ten minutes. Often get something like "Come with me to the shop, Dave will watch them" If I've never met Dave then there's not a chance. Even if you say Dave is fine.

And lastly
-Go further than the garden when he's in bed (alone in house) Happy to sit in the garden and spend some child free time when he's asleep, but going to to the end of the road to meet a friend or going inside nextdoors house, no.

Mumsnets judgement please. Is this the right level of safety for a 3 yr old? Or have I let my anxiety take over again without realising it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Greengagesnfennel · 22/10/2022 20:57

I am quite laidback but I would not have done any of those things either. I agree with you. Trust your instinct it's them not you who is unusual.

knockyknees · 21/10/2022 22:47

Your friends are shit parents. I absolutely despise adults/parents who deliberately put their toddlers and young children in danger by allowing them to walk/run near roads or within carparks without holding their hand or using reins/backpacks with reins. Not to mention the trauma to the poor driver who may unavoidably hit the child if they suddenly appear on the road.

lovelilies · 21/10/2022 20:27

LadyDanburysHat · 21/10/2022 17:55

I am about as lax and laid back as you can get, but all of those things are bad. The only exception is the park. If it is a fenced in playpark I would be happy to be less vigilant.

I'm the same. Was ready to jump in and say over protective (I'm super laid back) but all of those are neglectful imo

Wigglesworththe5th · 21/10/2022 20:26

OP...I can relate.

I often question things in the exact same way.

I developed huge anxiety after dc was born. I was contstantly on edge in case he died. It was truly terrifying for me. I was living in perpetual fear to ve honest.

Dc is 3 now and it has only been very recently that I have noticed I don't wake up in the morning with the urge to check the monitor in case he is not breathing.

I know I am very cautious and protective when we are out. I am comfortable with him being in ore school but I have never left him with anyone else not even my mum or family members. I know that is not normal but i feel i can't trust. It doesn't really make sense logically which I am aware if, so I truly understand your post and the need to check in to see if it's your head or not. @Frogsanddogs

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 21/10/2022 20:21

Nope, you are completely reasonable. My dd is 4 and i also have a 9 month old, I have never let anyone babysit or look after either of them, other than myself or my partner ( thier dad). I would never leave them in the house alone when they are asleep, I have a tapo camera on them at all times when I am downstairs and they are upstairs asleep. Everything else you've mentioned holding hands, car seats etc is a given, it only takes a minute for something to go wrong.

MistyFrequencies · 21/10/2022 20:21

Yeah your friends are bad parents. You're not.

WonderingWanda · 21/10/2022 20:09

Trust your judgement op, it sound spot on None of what you are saying is over the top protective, even if some people are a little more relaxed on some things. Your friends sound quite neglectful.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/10/2022 19:46

Can’t imagine anyone sensible thinking differently to you on this.

Most of them sound like death traps waiting to happen.

In fact, even in the house I’d want a pretty close eye on a child that little - not more than a few mins totally out of sight/ ear shot.

NoSquirrels · 21/10/2022 19:36

Your friends are irresponsible bordering on actively negligent. I am not a paranoid parent at all but your friends sound awful if they won’t insist on safety first. I sincerely hope their DC never come to any harm because of it.

riotlady · 21/10/2022 19:34

Your friends sound like genuinely shitty parents and I am generally pretty relaxed as a parent

addler · 21/10/2022 19:34

I don't know anyone who would do any of those things.

mamabear715 · 21/10/2022 19:26

Some of them I'd be wary of, & mine are over 21! :-)

Blessedbethefruitz · 21/10/2022 19:24

The only one of those I do is walk without holding hands with ds almost 4. It's up to him if he wants to now. He was a bolter as a toddler (walking way before 1) so I used reigns until around 2 I think. He knows to stop way back from the road when we need to cross. He gets told off if he walks/scoots round a corner though.

Frogsanddogs · 21/10/2022 19:15

Thank you @CoffeeLover90 💐

OP posts:
CoffeeLover90 · 21/10/2022 19:10

@Frogsanddogs I also had bad post natal anxiety and my DS is now 3. I still use a baby monitor. May seem extreme to some but I do like to sit in the garden while he sleeps in the summer, he also stays silent if he's sick through the night and it's impossible to hear him do it without the monitor. I also find myself questioning is this normal or my anxiety, you do need to ask others opinions sometimes, you're absolutely right. When I've explained my reasoning for the monitor no one has disagreed. I don't use it every night now either. There's not one thing on your list I'd be comfortable doing and neither would any of my parent friends. It's not anxiety this time but never feel ashamed to check with people you trust. The car seat thing is ridiculous, the only time that would happen is an emergency, rushing to hospital for example with no car seat available, but what you described is sheer laziness and stupidity.
Sounds like you're doing a great job. Ignore these friends of yours.

drkpl · 21/10/2022 19:08

I’ve always been a very relaxed mum and I wouldn’t do any of the things your friends do. I think you’re definitely in the right here.

BecauseICan22 · 21/10/2022 19:03

Your friends sound reckless unless all their children are much older.

Everything you're doing right now considering your DC's age is normal, healthy and what a attentive and engaged parent does.

Aria999 · 21/10/2022 19:02

Ye gods.

I am a pretty laid back parent and I would never do any of those things.

Your friends are crazy!

Oysterbabe · 21/10/2022 18:54

Oojamaflipp · 21/10/2022 17:46

I suspect you know full well your feelings are right on this one. If your friends are genuinely doing those things, that's definitely not the norm with anyone I know.

Yep this.
This thread is all about showing off about your superior parenting.

bluesky45 · 21/10/2022 18:50

Your feelings are correct, stand by them. If this is the judgement of your friends on car seats, running into road, playing out of sight etc then I certainly would not trust my DC with "Dave" either, because these friends clearly have bad judgement generally.
Oh and my DC are 5 and 3 and I wouldn't be letting them out of sight at a park etc for a while yet. Dc1 is allowed to walk just in front of me on the pavement while I hold dc2s hand but he's a very sensible child and I trust him because we do it every day on the way to school, plus I can see him and probably reach him in necessary. Unfortunately the pavement isn't wide enough for all 3 of us to walk next to each other.

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 18:44

These are all things common sense, so regardless of MH that should be a given. No one needs to confirm whether any of what you listed is ok.

MintJulia · 21/10/2022 18:42

I wouldn't do any of the first four ever.

The fifth - I admit I once left a sleeping DS for about five minutes while I sprinted to the corner shop for some calpol.

Every good parent assesses risk. You're risk averse and that's a good thing.

YouSoundLovely · 21/10/2022 18:32

I'm often the one boggling at the over-protectiveness in evidence on MN, but all your examples are entirely reasonable/normal IMO and exactly what I did at that age and older tbh. Actually my youngest is 7 and I don't think I would be comfortable about doing any of those with her (possibly going briefly out of sight at the park would be OK, and walking without holding hands would be OK too but if it's a properly busy road/narrow pavement I still prefer her to hold hands).

Frogsanddogs · 21/10/2022 18:31

@Worthyornot As I said in my op, I have struggled with my metal health and anxiety before. I thought I was just as reasonable when I wouldn't let baby ds stay with his dad while I went to the toilet incase he died. I have since got help and believe it's under control. I do believe my parenting is completely normal but when you have multiple friends saying "It's totally fine, we do X all the time!" I had made me question it.

I think it would be "stupid" if I 1) blindly believed my friends and put ds in a dangerous situation. Or 2) believed I was right 100% of the time and never accepted others opinions.

I don't think I'm stupid for checking in on my mental health by getting a range of responses in a place full of parents.

OP posts:
FilthyforFirth · 21/10/2022 18:29

You cant possibly think any of these things are remotely normal for a 3 year old, let alone younger. I wouldnt let my 5 year old do any of these.