Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paying my daughters debts enables her

181 replies

Rowinandgowin · 21/10/2022 17:21

recently my daughter had two friends come to me and tell me she had borrowed a substantial amount of money off them each, she started ignoring them and reached out to me to talk to her. This was a few months apart and I’m really disappointed. Another friend had mentioned they had lent her money and never got it back.

i feel really upset, my daughter is quite vulnerable, she doesn’t work, she had two kids very closely together, two under two. Her childrens father left her with a huge rent to pay and I have spent a lot of money on sorting her out each month as she can’t make ends meet. I would love to have her back home but I have no space. Now she is borrowing money off friends that I have had to pay back, I’ve spoken to her in tears as I fear she will end up even lonelier. I suppose I paid up to try to mend things but these friends want nothing to do with her. I feel so sad as she wouldn’t apologise to them and it’s like she is self sabotaging

OP posts:
Miisty · 23/10/2022 07:17

Don’t bail her out again we did that with our son and we are in debt Loan sharks target these people Use social services but they are stretched Our social worker discharged our son (just attempted suicide )being targeted by people who steal all his food drink tobacco and he’s frightened to call the police as they will beat him up She’s got to take responsibility you won’t be around for ever and whose looking after her children

Stewball01 · 23/10/2022 06:39

That's terrible @ justcallmebebes.
You must stop paying for her and tell her everything everybody has said. That's the only way I'm afraid.

PickAnyName · 23/10/2022 00:46

Rowinandgowin · 21/10/2022 17:51

I’m not angry at her friends, at all I understand why they came to me. She was upset at being publicly embarrassed. I know I am enabling her, I spoilt her growing up as I was a single mum and I felt guilty. Now I feel guilty I can’t fix her problems. I just feel publicly exposing her wasn’t the kindest move

It's not up to you to fix her problems - it's up to her. You are enabling her by digging her out of holes of her own making every time. She has come to expect that you will always do this. You should insist that she apologises to her former friends. At least others have been warned (even though you might not like the way it was done) as this will end up saving you more bailing out situations.

If she's had a holiday and has an expensive car, she's not struggling. She might be struggling to manage her finances, but she's not struggling. The friends who 'loaned' her money may have left themselves short to help her, and she doesn't seem to be at all bothered about that. Tough love is the answer. If you always bail her out, what happens if the time comes when you can no longer do so?

Derkle · 22/10/2022 22:18

Rowinandgowin · 21/10/2022 17:51

I’m not angry at her friends, at all I understand why they came to me. She was upset at being publicly embarrassed. I know I am enabling her, I spoilt her growing up as I was a single mum and I felt guilty. Now I feel guilty I can’t fix her problems. I just feel publicly exposing her wasn’t the kindest move

If youre daughter doesn't want to be embarrassed in public then don't do anything that would be embarrassing if it was publicly known/seen. Simple.
Also, stop enabling her.
Support her in regards to getting financial counselling, professional budgeting advice etc. But do NOT pay her bills, debts or puck up the financial slack.
Imo the only thing financial I would be doing is maybe school excursions etc for the children so they aren't penalised socially because of their mother.

Teaismymiddlename · 22/10/2022 21:07

I think the phrase you are looking for here is 'tough shit' love...

Can't afford nails? Tough shit
Can't afford holidays? Tough shit

She isn't 'used to a certain lifestyle'... She is an adult acting like an entitled spoiled brat

Single parent here in full time university

Haven't had my hair cut in three years. Haven't had a holiday in 10. Paint my nails with £6 nail varnish

Not saying that you should be happy just scraping by, but there is a world of difference between living within your means and being on the verge of poverty

She is neither.
A student loan is enough to get by reasonable on. I do it ok and manage and still put my son in clubs etc and pay for classes and days out

She's letting you feel guilted into proboding a lifestyle she's not willing to fund herself

If she that badly needs hair and nail then she needs to be working more or cutting back somewhere else

No sympathy I'm afraid from someone who sees real people *actually struggling

Gemcat1 · 22/10/2022 20:39

This is where you put your foot down, all you are doing is enabling her, as other have said and it is obviously affecting you emotionally. First of all, go through her finances with her. If the rent is too much then she needs to move to a smaller place. If her car is too expensive then she needs to get a smaller cheaper one. DD also needs to get a job to help with her finances, I assume that she's receiving maintenance from her hubby. And, she's broke and goes on holiday? What an insult, holidays are not a right, they are a luxury. When my kids were little and we struggled, I never once asked family for help. We bought some clothes from a cheap place and others from a charity shop, we got toys there too. And, no, we didn't go on holiday. I cooked cheaper food. As for the uni loan, that is a form of theft. She will have to pay it back, it doesn't vanish. If she does go to uni then what is she going to do with her kids and, no, they are NOT your responsibility. As for being vulnerable, yes, depression is awful but she should be on medication and referred for counselling. A lot of people suffer from depression as well as anxiety and manage a normal life. We have been through this with my younger son so I know how you feel. But you are not helping DD by bailing her out and you are not helping yourself either. Good luck and stay firm.

MustWeDoThis · 22/10/2022 20:30

I work with vulnerable people - Your daughter is not vulnerable.

Your daughter is living a champagne lifestyle on a cider budget.

You've paid enough, it's time to stop. Offer to have the children so she can work, or help find a minder and sign up for UC so they can pay 80% of the minding fees.

Do things which will enable her progression and work ethic, not her mounting debt.

Sit her down, call up Step-Change (Free debt help charity who will take an affordable lump sum each month and pay her debtors out of it.)

She wants what everyone else has without earning it.

Jellywellyfish · 22/10/2022 20:24

It sounds like she’s taking advantage of you. When I was in my early 20s I flew the nest and got my own rented apartment and after a year ran up a credit card bill of £900. I rang my mum in tears and told her I was struggling. She paid it off for me no questions asked, and I never let myself get into that situation again. I had a crap car, got a second job on the weekend pulling pints and learnt from my mistakes. She should put her kids first, and that means getting rid of the expensive car, doing cheap weekend breaks away with the kids etc until she can stand on her own two feet. You wasted your money paying her debts with her friends because she’s too pig headed to apologise to them anyway.

CantFindMyMarbles · 22/10/2022 20:23

I’d sit her down for a frank conversation about where her money goes and what her bills are.

Murdoch1949 · 22/10/2022 20:14

You have done enough. You have to tell her that you can no longer financially support her. If she has an expensive car, holidays and beauty treatments she is taking the piss. You keep on enabling her she is going to get into massive debt, that YOU will feel obligated to erase. Draw a line.

GucciBear · 22/10/2022 19:40

Why doesn't she find a cheaper house to rent? If you are subsidising housing, car and holidays you are certainly making her life much easier. What will happen when (a) you run out of money or (b) you die?

Talia99 · 22/10/2022 08:59

Just to say, I’ve picked ‘you are being unreasonable’ because of the excuses you are making for her and the way you are blaming her victims for not being ‘kind’ for telling people what she has done not because I think you should give her money

pilates · 22/10/2022 05:47

Op, do you think there are drugs involved?

bonzaitree · 22/10/2022 01:13

EmmaH2022 · 22/10/2022 00:46

bonzaitree "It's only £250 and £150 she owes. Not a huge amount she realistically should be able to pay that back."

but she doesn't earn. She took that money knowing full well she wouldn't pay it back.

It's a few shifts of a minimum wage job. She can earn it fairly easily if she really wanted to.

Min wage is £9.50.

8 hour shift on min wage of £9.50 is £76.

So in 6 8 hour shifts she could earn the money and pay it off. So a week and a day of normal work. In this job market I'm sure she could find something.

Not much really, which is why I'm saying it's not much money.

Maybe you could offer to babysit whilst she earns it back? That would offer help but not enable her running up debt.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 22/10/2022 00:47

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

EmmaH2022 · 22/10/2022 00:46

bonzaitree "It's only £250 and £150 she owes. Not a huge amount she realistically should be able to pay that back."

but she doesn't earn. She took that money knowing full well she wouldn't pay it back.

knockyknees · 22/10/2022 00:41

Good on her (hopefully ex) friends exposing your daughter. All scam/con artists should be named and shamed to prevent other people being taken in by them.

None of her circumstances (depression, young children, single (but with lots of time off from her children by the sounds of it) justify her actions in any way, nor you bailing her out. Years ago my friend was unexpectedly widowed in her 20s and left with a very young child. I've no doubt she understandably suffered depression after this, but did she use it as an excuse to scam people? No. She went back to work, paid her bills (didn't waste it on nails or hair dos), and looked after her child.

I think most people know someone like your daughter. She's disgusting, and 99% of the time people like this always have a parent in the background enabling their vile behaviour.

KinshipGran · 22/10/2022 00:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

IvysMum12 · 21/10/2022 23:09

Does the children's father support his family?
If not, why not?

bonzaitree · 21/10/2022 22:48

It's only £250 and £150 she owes. Not a huge amount she realistically should be able to pay that back.

It's not like it's thousands.

I'd honestly just tell her you can't afford any more and let her get on with it. She might struggle but then she kind of needs to. If she complains to you about money offer to help her with a budget etc. don't give her another penny you're literally just digging a grave for yourself.

Only exception would be having her and kids over for meals. You could just say well I can't afford any money but you're always welcome for tea if you get stuck.

mogsrus · 21/10/2022 22:43

Bailing out her debts is offering an alcoholic a drink, be strong , as this attitude will continue until you can’t do it, & then you will be vilified

DontMakeMeShushYou · 21/10/2022 22:35

Rowinandgowin · 21/10/2022 17:51

I’m not angry at her friends, at all I understand why they came to me. She was upset at being publicly embarrassed. I know I am enabling her, I spoilt her growing up as I was a single mum and I felt guilty. Now I feel guilty I can’t fix her problems. I just feel publicly exposing her wasn’t the kindest move

Maybe not, but the kindness her friends have shown her so far has not been repaid. Literally!

Calandor · 21/10/2022 22:29

And FYI my sister was the same. It was all on nails and hair and designer clothes she couldn't afford. Thankfully she only ever borrowed for family but I know how stressful it is. It's horrible. You want to help but then feel like why should you pay for her hair and nails when you don't even get that yourself!

My sister no longer does this and is very money savvy now. But she was 'cured' when she had her son. Sounds like your DD hasn't learned even having had kids.

I really feel for you OP. It's SO hard. I'm 27 and was lending my elder sister money from when I was 16 :/ if I added it up it would be well over a grand.

Calandor · 21/10/2022 22:17

She also needs to learn to stop begging from people though as that's what she's doing. If she's at uni she shouldn't have an expensive car....

Calandor · 21/10/2022 22:12

Tbh it's not your loan. My mum has learnt my sister thousands. If she hadn't helped with the money tbh I would have... even though it would've been my life's savings.

I'd pay these off then have a chat with DD saying you will not do so from here on. If it's for rent etc I really feel for her. Can you not get a sofa bed and let her live at home if she's struggling