Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overstayed welcomes & terrible tantrums...

66 replies

remymartinn · 21/10/2022 15:20

Has anyones children's behaviour changed while having family stay?

I have had family visitors since JULY. Since then, my daughters behaviour has become progressively worse to the point she is having tantrums.

Is it attention?

DD who is 4 has just started school, we moved to a new home in April. Dad came to stay in July, sister in August for 4 weeks, then brother in October for 4 weeks. Dad & brother still here.

She doesn't know my dad & brother well at all, they haven't seen her since she was a baby. They try to discipline her but it ends in tears, they try telling me how to discipline her (brother especially, he's like the male version of supernanny). My daughter tells me all the time she doesn't like her uncle, she loves my dad though.

I'm so tired of trying to keep the peace.

Has anyone had any similar issues?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
knockyknees · 21/10/2022 23:19

Your poor daughter.

As for the TV, that would not be happening any longer (or after the first night). Tell dad it needs to be turned to a normal level (or do it yourself) and that if he can't hear it, that he can use the closed caption option.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but brother would have been told the first time he tried to discipline my child that he has to stop, and that any further issues were to be brought to my attention. Had he continued, he'd have been told to leave immediately.

For the next four nights, tell dad and brother that they are responsible for all evening meals, whether that be buying/cooking/cleaning up, or ordering takeaway.

TheNinny · 21/10/2022 21:18

My sil had a friend stay the week my niece started school. Her tantrums were extreme that week and out of the ordinary (though she is tantrumy a lot) Could it be a combination of school and strangers (essentially) in the house?

Johnnysgirl · 21/10/2022 21:03

Hold on, you hadn't spoken to these people for literally years and you let them all move in because they asked?!
What??

LicoricePizza · 21/10/2022 20:50

I feel for you OP - it’s so easy to preach how to be on here - far harder to do in practise.

Enjoy your peace & keep the door closed because I suspect there’ll be future invasions/requests/pleas for help.

mavismorpoth · 21/10/2022 20:44

remymartinn · 21/10/2022 20:35

I appreciate all your advice & somewhat harsh truth comments.
I think because they are family I feel obliged to help. On the other hand I have my own little family now (Me & DD) I have had to learn to live independently without the help of my family.
Even when I do express my opinion & feelings, they do seem to do what's best for them, rather than take into account the huge difficulty it may bring.
I remember only one week after my dad arriving, I sat him down & explained he couldn't stay for more than 2 weeks. No effort was made to find alternative accommodation. I think he simply did not want to leave. Then cue my sister, she stayed for a month (that was exhausting for me) she's a big character & i remember getting really depressed & not wanting to be around her. She left, it was easy for a while with just dad, then brother arrived & the entire dynamic changes AGAIN. I made it clear I'd had enough of people staying, & didn't want anymore visitors in September due to school starting.
I had let my sister & dad stay, so couldn't just say no to my brother.

I hadn't really spoken or seen my brother for 2 years, my dad 3. So I held huge resentment when they turned up at my doorstep needing my help.
I wasn't needed when I lived in a small flat, but low and behold as soon as I have a house with a spare room and an attic, their eyes lit up.

I don't even think my sister said thank you.

They are respectful in they do what I say/ask but it's just been so difficult for me & DD when we were so used to our little lives just us. Throw in school & work plus a house move, it's a recipe for a mental breakdown (child included)

Anyway, this time next week we will be alone again, I've promised DD one of our special pizza & popcorn nights we haven't had for months, then a girls day out. She deserves it and I feel terrible for not standing my ground more. It's definitely a lesson learnt.

Well done. That's great.

remymartinn · 21/10/2022 20:35

I appreciate all your advice & somewhat harsh truth comments.
I think because they are family I feel obliged to help. On the other hand I have my own little family now (Me & DD) I have had to learn to live independently without the help of my family.
Even when I do express my opinion & feelings, they do seem to do what's best for them, rather than take into account the huge difficulty it may bring.
I remember only one week after my dad arriving, I sat him down & explained he couldn't stay for more than 2 weeks. No effort was made to find alternative accommodation. I think he simply did not want to leave. Then cue my sister, she stayed for a month (that was exhausting for me) she's a big character & i remember getting really depressed & not wanting to be around her. She left, it was easy for a while with just dad, then brother arrived & the entire dynamic changes AGAIN. I made it clear I'd had enough of people staying, & didn't want anymore visitors in September due to school starting.
I had let my sister & dad stay, so couldn't just say no to my brother.

I hadn't really spoken or seen my brother for 2 years, my dad 3. So I held huge resentment when they turned up at my doorstep needing my help.
I wasn't needed when I lived in a small flat, but low and behold as soon as I have a house with a spare room and an attic, their eyes lit up.

I don't even think my sister said thank you.

They are respectful in they do what I say/ask but it's just been so difficult for me & DD when we were so used to our little lives just us. Throw in school & work plus a house move, it's a recipe for a mental breakdown (child included)

Anyway, this time next week we will be alone again, I've promised DD one of our special pizza & popcorn nights we haven't had for months, then a girls day out. She deserves it and I feel terrible for not standing my ground more. It's definitely a lesson learnt.

OP posts:
BatshitBanshee · 21/10/2022 19:33

Erm... Stressed mum and two invaders guests "disciplining" a child they don't know?? They're the problem, not DD. This is an absolutely ridiculous set up, it was never going to work for a four year old just starting school as well.

I'd also give my brother and my father a good old size 9 boot up the hole if they tried to Supernanny my child. Go the fuck home if you don't like it.

LicoricePizza · 21/10/2022 18:10

Given how you feel no wonder you’re seeing it in her behaviour.

Just because they’re family doesn’t mean they can’t trample all over your boundaries & needs.

It sounds like you’ve got caught into facilitating them through no fault of your own but they are taking liberties.

However as is always the case we get caught into letting them.

I would view your poor little girl’s behaviour & feelings as a useful barometer for when things are just way too much.

And as a good prompt to realise that she needs more containment, security & less disruption than this moving forwards.

Whilst it is not bullying per se & this is not meant to offend - I feel for you running ragged being a good mum, daughter, sister, cleaner, cook, carer to your dad - but if you look at it from the outside in - there is a little girl acting out & “misbehaving” at times because she feels all of the things she’s told you & that you too feel - but amplified & from the perspective of a child, where the ability to self regulate & rationalise & soothe is developing.

She’s being asked to be able to behave like an adult & when unable to cope with the disruption in the home any more, is being actively told off & punished by all - & two (especially one unfamiliar) adult male.

That’s not fair on her & your job as a woman & mother is to prevent this scapegoating from happening.

It’s not bullying but it’s not her fault.

But very very common & often why kids “misbehave’. Because of the adults.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/10/2022 17:57

Actually, thinking about it, they should be treating you to them either cooking or buying in dinner for the 4 remaining nights. You deserve nothing less!!!

Doowop1919 · 21/10/2022 17:55

Honestly op, your daughter sounds normal. I, as an adult, would be grumpy and unaccommodating to people staying in my house for long periods of time whom I didn't know. Especially if they told me off all the time.

Whatwouldnanado · 21/10/2022 17:41

Smile and ask what they are ordering in for dinner for the next couple of nights because you are going to be busy. Take the little one out on your own and have fun. Then tell them your spare rooms won't be available for the foreseeable. Your daughter comes first.

Wnikat · 21/10/2022 17:30

their behaviour often deteriorates when they start school, they are very tired. She needs patience and understanding, not some men she doesn’t know very well telling her off

LookItsMeAgain · 21/10/2022 17:30

Sorry - I'd be a wizard if I could count - 4 nights until Tuesday!

LookItsMeAgain · 21/10/2022 17:30

As there are only 3 nights until Tuesday, can't they decamp to a B&B until then?

I really would be looking to get them out sooner rather than have them stay until Tuesday.

Herejustforthisone · 21/10/2022 17:13

Well yeah, there’s two overbearing and opinionated men that she doesn’t know, in her home. I’d fucking kick off about that as well.

When are they (and their unwanted and ignorant) opinions on discipline fucking off home?

mavismorpoth · 21/10/2022 17:11

remymartinn · 21/10/2022 17:09

@LookItsMeAgain I will be putting a giant sign outside saying 'no vacancies'. There's no way in hell I'm ever doing this again.

None of this matters to be honest. What matters is your child. How come your dad is homeless? You are completely within your rights to kick him out and I only say that because he is affecting your world, your priority, your life, your daughter. Nothing is more important than her.

remymartinn · 21/10/2022 17:09

@LookItsMeAgain I will be putting a giant sign outside saying 'no vacancies'. There's no way in hell I'm ever doing this again.

OP posts:
remymartinn · 21/10/2022 17:07

It's been a very long winded strung out few months, of which I was totally unprepared for.
My sister asked months ago if she could stay for a month before she moved abroad, I agreed to this. My daughter is obsessed with her auntie so I knew it wouldn't be a problem.

I was initially told my dad would be staying for a couple of weeks, but due to complications with his health he has stayed longer.

The whole thing has been extremely stressful. Suddenly I'm cooking 3 times as much, constantly having to top up food during the week. They contribute but I'm definitely spending way more than I would normally.

They've helped with decorating and fixing, gardening etc which is great, but it's the smaller things they don't see. I'm absolutely done in by 8pm. It's school run, work, school run, dinner prep, cook, bath/shower, bedtime, Im most days I get a message saying they've run out of something, I'm the only one with a car & I live in the country so they are stranded while I'm at work. Even on my days off I have said they are welcome to use my car and go out for the day (hint hint) which they don't do unless they need to. So we are pretty much all at home together.

I don't work Fridays & DD is at school so i spent the day in my room. I can't stand how loud my dad has the TV so don't like being in the sitting room. I just wanted to rest & be alone. Right now my brother is playing a computer game & dad is watching the TV at volume 100000. It's shit.

I know people have far worse problems but this has been going on for months.

I'm counting down the days.

OP posts:
Theskyisfallingdown · 21/10/2022 17:03

@Goldbar it says in the OP that these men hadn’t seen the child since she was a baby.

She’s literally crying out for OP to keep her safe and prioritise her.

mavismorpoth · 21/10/2022 16:58

Firstly if she is doing something for attention the answer is to give her that attention. A child expressing a need should have that need met, and attention is a need.

You're going about this all the wrong way by seeming to prioritise your dad and brother, who should in no way ever even attempt to discipline your child. When you should be prioritising your child.

Start focusing on prioritising your child and meting her needs and things will change because you will act to your focus. Your child is very young but if you see some posts on here 'my daughter hates me' 'i hate my daughter' etc. etc. this is where you're heading but you have a chance to turn that around by prioritising her.

This is HER home and and not theirs. Tell them to leave and take control of your life and your relationship with your child.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/10/2022 16:51

Is there any way that they can leave sooner than next Tuesday?

I would take a MASSIVE break from hosting anyone. Family or friends. Just say that you've had loads of people to stay since you moved in and you need a break.

My honest advice at this stage would be for you to make some time next weekend, once your father and brother have left, to have a day for just you and your DD.
It can be something as simple as a pyjama day where you stay in and watch junk on the telly or get dressed and go out for a coffee and cake or go to the cinema but it's just you and your DD. Then I'd get her involved in planning and decorating your new home for Christmas. She can put decorations up in her room and help dress the tree (if you're getting one).

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/10/2022 16:51

Your brother in particular sounds like he’s massively overstepped the mark. Neither of them should be disciplining your child. He in particular sounds very overbearing. He should also be pitching in with the housework as though he lived there on such a long stay.

They shouldn’t have been allowed to stay for so long, especially not your brother. You’re not a hotel.

Season0fTheWitch · 21/10/2022 16:50

Gosh your poor child. She needs love and attention from the person she has a secure attachment with (you), not negative attention from strangers. She may like your dad but he shouldn't be disciplining or rewarding her, she needs stable discipline from you. Your brother needs to go, and your Dad shouldn't be there much longer.

She's not having tantrums she's trying to communicate how unsettled she is with your life choices

Goldbar · 21/10/2022 16:48

Guests go off after 3-4 days. No doubt your DD feels this too.

Did your DD have much of a relationship with either of them before they came to stay? My mother will discipline my DC sometimes when she is babysitting but she has had a close relationship with DC since birth and follows my lead (and is also softer than me!). I would also flip my lid if I'd just started school, had all the stress of that and then 2 strange men showed up in my house, telling me what to do and expecting my mother to cook and clean for them so she had less time and energy for me.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/10/2022 16:44

KettrickenSmiled · 21/10/2022 15:22

She doesn't know my dad & brother well at all, they haven't seen her since she was a baby. They try to discipline her but it ends in tears, they try telling me how to discipline her (brother especially, he's like the male version of supernanny). My daughter tells me all the time she doesn't like her uncle, she loves my dad though.

Tell them to stop bullying your child.
Also that their visit is now over.

DD will get back to normal once you have re-established her routine.

This - They don't get to discipline her. That's down to her parents (i.e. you and/or your OH).

I'd also say that their visits are coming to an end and they need to plan to leave and the sooner the better.