Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the so called Uinionist party are the most devisive of them all!

80 replies

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 10:14

Conservatives and the DUP! both parties who claim to believe in the "Union" Yet both doing a great job at convincing the rest of us we would be better off out of the mess that is Westminster! AIBU for wanting a Border poll in NI?

OP posts:
StrataZon · 21/10/2022 12:43

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 12:10

@StrataZon That's how I feel. I wonder is it a matter for public record how they would legislate or manage an independent scotland? Would they seek to rejoin the EU?

Yes an independent Scotland would seek to join the EU. That's the whole basis that SNP are promoting a 2nd referendum, we were taken out against our will and most Scottish people are gutted.

However they think vote for independence and we'll be back in EU.
The problem is it's not going to be as simple as that (it never is!)
It would take several years to extricate ourselves from the Union, and then we would need our own currency and meet all the financial targets required before applying for EU membership, then join the queue. It will take years!

Paslaptis · 21/10/2022 12:22

Winterscomingagain · 21/10/2022 10:30

Interesting response, it would make Brexit look like a piece of cake.

It would automatically reverse Brexit and bring the UK back into the EU, like German reunification did for the former East Germany.

Better for the UK just to apply to rejoin; this idea is a non-starter as no fool in Ireland would vote for it, nor would the Irish government agree to waste money on it.

SilverViking · 21/10/2022 12:13

"Soft Nationalist" here too!!

I think it is much too soon for a straight border poll ... on both sides, too many people alive that still have raw memories of what happened, coupled with a younger generation who don't know what it was really like and could be persuaded into some glorified conflict.

Also, there is no proposals on what the outcome of a border poll would offer. There will be many proposals.. depending on which party/ government makes the proposals.

The best option is a "United People" where our politics are fought on social issues that are common. When the best Northern Ireland is worked for, Nationalise or Unionists will not feel threatened and would be accepting and benefit from a unique position as part of a United Kingdom / United Ireland that would be recognised and supported world wide.

In recent years, I'm less convinced the ideal solution is fully UK or fully United Ireland.
There is no utopia where we will be equal to a Dublin centric economy and political power base... just ask the folks from Donegal, Kerry or the West how it is now. Similarly, we will never have equal status to the powerful London based financial services centered UK powerhouse - again, talk to the "Northeners" in Newcastle, Carlisle etc.

The unfortunate situation is that there is little empathy for neighbours. I accept my friends and neighbours will want to vote DUP/UUP and march on the 12th July and be British citizens. That will never magically change after a border poll.
All I ask is that neighbours equally accept I can enjoy Gaelic football, the Irish language and not be a Royalist ... but that does not make me a diehard Republican and a threat to them.

I feel sad that people will want to taunt "the other side" with songs, banners and confrontation. But some people will always do this... some to deliberately cause offence and some may s not even realise they cause offence. I think sometimes the media thrives on devision as it gives them a headline but ultimatly gives fuel to those pushing their own agenda. Again, this works equally on both sides.

I think the best solution has yet to be proposed... but maybe it is an evolution from where we are now... with a self governed Northern Ireland with equal relationship with UK and Irish governments.

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/10/2022 12:11

YANBU, this administration is fucked up. However, I'm not keen. I'm a soft Unionist and would rather see an us remain in the UK with the Protocol for a while to see how it works.

A border poll will come and I would like us to be more stable when it happens.

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 12:10

@StrataZon That's how I feel. I wonder is it a matter for public record how they would legislate or manage an independent scotland? Would they seek to rejoin the EU?

OP posts:
abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 12:09

@rainstorm101 I've just ordered the paperback on Amazon. Heading to Galway for a quiet weekend next week i'll take it with me.

OP posts:
StrataZon · 21/10/2022 11:20

Same in Scotland @abstractplantpot
They are called Conservative and Unionist party here. But they are the SNP's greatest asset!
All the SNP has to promote is vote for independence and you'll get rid of the Tory shitshow

rainstorm101 · 21/10/2022 11:14

YES, i would say don’t start with this one it’s full on and only because I am writing a book. Except mumsnetting instead.

I beg you to read: A History of Ireland in 250 episodes by Jonathan Bardon. He was from Dublin but taught in orangefield, a boys secondary, so he is AMAZING at explaining the endless complexities of the history. It was a history programme on bbc radio, then made into a book of 250 shortish chapters. Actually life changing read.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Bardon

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 11:08

@rainstorm101 Thank you so much for commenting. i'm not a highly educated person and i'm learning as I go along. I feel exactly like you. i'm a "soft nationalist" Howevver I live in a very unionist zone and our constituency is steeped in tribal voting. our ballot ticket is generally DUP. UUP. an independent unionist and possibly a couple of Alliance. I've tried discussions with neighbours about why they vote DUP despite being unhappy with things here but they can't explain it. I will get a response like the one above. I'm British and they care about keeping us British.

No consideration for the shit show they have produced so far!

I'm going to have a look at this book Have you any other recommendations?

OP posts:
rainstorm101 · 21/10/2022 10:57

FinallyHere · 21/10/2022 10:56

Thanks @rainstorm101

I'll put the phone down now.

So frustrating though!

FinallyHere · 21/10/2022 10:56

Thanks @rainstorm101

I'll put the phone down now.

rainstorm101 · 21/10/2022 10:55

FinallyHere · 21/10/2022 10:54

@Dotjones

I think it would be a good idea to unite Ireland, but bring the republic back into the UK. That way everyone wins, NI unionists are still part of the UK and NI nationalists have a united Ireland like they want.

Brilliant idea.

Oh, wait, what about the actual citizens of the sovereign nation of Ireland. Whatever makes you think that they might prefer being part of the UK rather than part of the EU

Never mind the size of the potential market, the general stability and growth rates. A moments consideration how Ireland has fared in the two different unions might stop anyone making such a colossally insensitive suggestion.

Incase I have to spell it out, would you suggest that it would be 'best all round' if Ukraine just shut up and asked to be joined back up with Russia ?

I think that posters just on the wind up.

FinallyHere · 21/10/2022 10:54

@Dotjones

I think it would be a good idea to unite Ireland, but bring the republic back into the UK. That way everyone wins, NI unionists are still part of the UK and NI nationalists have a united Ireland like they want.

Brilliant idea.

Oh, wait, what about the actual citizens of the sovereign nation of Ireland. Whatever makes you think that they might prefer being part of the UK rather than part of the EU

Never mind the size of the potential market, the general stability and growth rates. A moments consideration how Ireland has fared in the two different unions might stop anyone making such a colossally insensitive suggestion.

Incase I have to spell it out, would you suggest that it would be 'best all round' if Ukraine just shut up and asked to be joined back up with Russia ?

rainstorm101 · 21/10/2022 10:52

So freaky as I am just sitting here reading this and thinking about the same thing.

I want to see some proper laid out plans from someone and everyone about what a UI would look like and what provisions will be made for the 800,000 (is that about right?) people who strongly, passionately believe they are British. Because no matter what side you think you’re on and what you believe in, if you don’t take it very, very seriously then there will be a new wave of utter carnage. I am a soft nationalist (ie I believe we would ultimate be better off in a UI and the EU, with a strong mandate and a PLAN) but if you look at socio-economic current outcomes for working class protestant boys in the current system (and I believe they are being let down by society and their political leadership) then what have they got to lose, they will go nuts.

To think the so called Uinionist party are the most devisive of them all!
To think the so called Uinionist party are the most devisive of them all!
Winterscomingagain · 21/10/2022 10:52

As a unionist voter in NI I'm more interested in what's going on in politics generally rather than having a knee jerk UI response. Why are our leaders unable to lead, what on earth is going on. It's such a toxic situation and it's worrying that we might reach a situation where no-one will want to be PM. My local council chief executive earns more than the PM and that makes no sense.
I'd like to see a general election next year and think all the parties need time to regroup and refocus. Remember David Cameron skipping out of Downing Street and off to his shepherds hut leaving someone else to figure out Brexit. Imagine if one of our children announced they were hoping to have a career in politics, it would be enough to give a parent a nervous breakdown.I know a 21 yr old who has made this choice and the scrutiny he lives under is horrendous.
What advice did Liz Truss have from her civil servants before launching her ridiculous budget, is the civil service really functioning as it should?
You can't extrapolate the horrendous political mess in the UK to the constitutional question in NI any more than you could a crisis in the Republic of Ireland but things are seriously wrong at present.

deliverooyoutoo · 21/10/2022 10:39

I feel part of the uk because I'm British and I live in Britain.

The Assembly is a joke.

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 10:36

@deliverooyoutoo I beg your pudding. that was a case of my fingers working faster than my brain

i'm interested to know why Unionists in NI still feel part of the UK when we they clearly have low regard for us. (not being judged BTw i'm looking to understand it) How do you feel about what's happening in Stormont?

OP posts:
asblindasabat · 21/10/2022 10:35

i wonder if the DUP will come out largest party in the next election?

balalake · 21/10/2022 10:34

The Democratic Unionist Party by being seen as backwards by people in England and Wales, and given views on social matters made it a lot easier for the half-Brexit deal to be done with the EU.

I'd like to see the island of Ireland be one country, but doubt that any border poll currently would be in favour.

deliverooyoutoo · 21/10/2022 10:32

SDLP are nationalists though, not republicans?

Winterscomingagain · 21/10/2022 10:30

Dotjones · 21/10/2022 10:20

I think it would be a good idea to unite Ireland, but bring the republic back into the UK. That way everyone wins, NI unionists are still part of the UK and NI nationalists have a united Ireland like they want.

This would solve all the Brexit border problems overnight. Ireland could still be allowed a devolved parliament/assembly like happens with the Welsh and Scots, their own regional TV programmes etc.

It's win-win really.

Interesting response, it would make Brexit look like a piece of cake.

abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 10:29

@deliverooyoutoo I'm an alliance voter too and I am delighted to see their percentage of the vote increase. However I'm increasingly erring on the side of the republicans due to the terrible devisive behaviour of the unionist party's. I'm not talking about SF either as they are as bad. I'm looking seriously as SDLP.

OP posts:
abstractplantpot · 21/10/2022 10:27

@Dotjones You are joking right? Bring the republic back to the UK??????

OP posts:
2ManyPjs · 21/10/2022 10:26

Dotjones · 21/10/2022 10:20

I think it would be a good idea to unite Ireland, but bring the republic back into the UK. That way everyone wins, NI unionists are still part of the UK and NI nationalists have a united Ireland like they want.

This would solve all the Brexit border problems overnight. Ireland could still be allowed a devolved parliament/assembly like happens with the Welsh and Scots, their own regional TV programmes etc.

It's win-win really.

How can you bring a republic into a constitutional monarchy? By definition it's not a republic any more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread