Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that I'll only be a MIL / other mother / other nan

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

OP posts:
SatinHeart · 21/10/2022 10:37

I think on MN you only hear the bad stuff. We are careful to treat each set of GPs as equally as we can in terms of frequency of visits etc.

I think sometimes its a logistical thing as much as anything else. GPs who love closer to their GC tend to have a closer relationship and be more involved. Our parents are each about an hour away so its easy to treat them the same.

My MIL is really hard work at times but we put in the work as we want her to be a part of our kids lives. They adore her. (It helps that DH finds her hard work too, so it's not just me)

NoSki · 21/10/2022 10:36

Stop seeing your own MIL if she’s evil, simple.
The most loving relationship I’ve seen is with a woman and her MIL. So someone with sons. She’s closer than with her own MIL

BloodyHellKen · 21/10/2022 10:36

I think it really depends more on different personalities rather than if you are a mother to sons or daughters.

I didn't get on with my MIL largely because she disliked me before we'd even met and refused to have anything to do with me for months (she preferred my OH's previous GF and couldn't get over their break up). She then tried to interfere in our relationship at every opportunity. I found this very difficult to deal with and it drove a huge wedge between us and between her and her son also.

On a positive note it taught me a valuable lesson and I go out of my way to have a good, understanding relationship with my potential DILs and I don't stick my nose in to my son's relationships!!

GoSomewhereThatDoes · 21/10/2022 10:35

As a pp has said, people don’t come on here to post about someone they have a good relationship with.

I’m not at all close to mine. I did make a big effort but MiL was clearly never going to be a fan, so I gave up and now she just gets politeness for the sake of my DH. However, before we lost her, I was very close to stepMiL, who was absolutely wonderful and I miss her very much. Just be nice and the chances are you’ll have a good relationship with your future DiLs.

mondaytosunday · 21/10/2022 10:34

It has more to do with your relationship with your son, rather than he being a son. And your relationship with any future daughter in law.
I get on well with my mil, my husband's ex did not. So my mil has not much of a relationship at all with my stepsons, but a good one with my children.

HappinesDependsOnYou · 21/10/2022 10:34

I had an awful relationship with MIL as she refused to acknowledge me even when I was in front of her. She chose to treat me with utter disrespect and disgust from day 1. However she started to show more interest once marriage was on the cards and a grandchild and I remained civil.

Now after my H had an affair and our marriage is destroyed she is like a second mum to me. It's bitter sweet really as she has been amazing. A great support, unjudgemental, taken our child at the drop of a hat to support us and shown me and her grandchild unwavering love. I also am a mother of a son and worried I would have an awful relationship with and DIL but if you are a decent person who respects other people's boundaries and opinions even when they don't align with your own then there can be a great relationship. I no longer feel destined to always be the 2nd best mother or grandmother. I instead focus on being the best mum I can be in the hope he will want me in his life as an adult

CoisFarraige · 21/10/2022 10:33

I also have sons. My own mother has a bad relationship with both of her DILs. But a lot of that is of her own making. She is a suspicious, negative person, who finds it difficult to keep her thoughts to herself. Her expectations of people are set so high, no one could meet them. She jumps to conclusions, always comes up with the worst interpretation of events. So if DIL is asked to get something for her while shopping, and tells her there was none, she will always assume that DIL just didn’t bother. That’s a mild example.

On the other hand my MIL keeps her opinions to herself unless asked. She never criticises, has a positive outlook and fully supports her grown-up children, no matter what they do - unconditional love for the grandchildren too. Tolerant of taciturn teens, doesn’t take it personally. I am sure she has had lots to complain about her DILs over the years but she is basically not a selfish person, is tolerant and has set her expectations at a realistic level. She can be annoying at times, and I’m sure I annoy her at times too but we have a great relationship, never had a cross word in the 30 years I’ve know her.
I think it comes down to personality - and a bit of luck. If MIL and DIL are both interested in having a positive relationship, it can work really well. It can feel that it’s always the DILs family that ‘wins’ out but there are so many factors that can influence this. My kids have a much easier relationship with my MIL than my mother, as do I.

pantsville · 21/10/2022 10:31

I don’t think this forum is an honest reflection of reality in this regard. The people with healthy IL relationships have no reason to post about it.

The horror stories on here are often one sided, extreme examples. But it does look very bleak that the default stance here is once you enter a relationship with somebody, you should be their only priority and their “old” family should back off.

But like I say, I find this exceptionally rare IRL and even people who aren’t keen on their in laws seem to all manage to muddle through okay.

ZiriForEver · 21/10/2022 10:31

it doesn't have to be like that. My MIL has 3 sons. All of them has partners, some DC and with all she has good relationship.

She has always been respectful, ready to discuss stuff, tell her opinion in conversation, but not judgemental or pressing her point.

The key is your son. Yes, he will need to put his future new family first. In the same time if he has good relationship with you and takes care of arranging meetings and communication, it can work fine.
Part of the common troublesome pattern is that MIL expects/blame her son's partner for stuff he could had covered.

Herbie0987 · 21/10/2022 10:28

I loved my MIL when she was alive, she was there if you needed her, loved all her grandchildren and when marriages broke up welcomed new partners. Her view was the family just got bigger. My mum died when I was early 30s and MIL became my mum.

Penelope987 · 21/10/2022 10:27

I think it goes both ways. Does your MIL put in the same effort that you do into the relationship?

Midnights · 21/10/2022 10:27

I think it all hangs on you - are you going to be over possessive of your son, dismissive of their partner / spouse, certain you know best in all situations etc?

Are you going to raise your son to be able to sort his own life out - a lot of the issues I see on here lie with sons who've been over mothered, they're unable to sort visits, plans, birthday presents / cards etc for themselves - and when their partner stops making all of the effort for them, the ILs think the partner has an issue, when it's just their son who they raised to be incapable 🤷🏻‍♀️

My MIL is of course annoying at times - I'm sure I am too! She's got a heart of gold and nothing ever comes from a bad place. She would do anything for us, and we would for her. We have a great relationship, because she's raised a son who can look after his own family relationships - so I get to have a relationship with her that's built on our own connection, not based on me being a second mother to her son.

Georgeskitchen · 21/10/2022 10:26

I'm a MIL of 2 daughter in laws. Semi retired and live close enough to one of the grandchildren to help out with childcare.
Other grandchild lives 3 hours away but stay with us a week or 2 every year in school hols.
So my recommendation is, be your DILs ally, help out when you can, love your grandchildren and never judge your DILs parenting x

Lindy2 · 21/10/2022 10:26

Plenty of women have very good relationships with their MILs.

Raise your sons to be caring and respectful. If you're also caring and respectful then I'm sure that helps create a good family dynamic.

My mum has always been good at helping without judging and has a good relationship with everyone. I hope I'm like her when I become a MIL. I will try to be.

My MIL is as crazy as a box of frogs and thinks of no one other than herself. Her relationships with everyone in the family, direct family and in laws, are very strained because of how she is, not because she's a MIL.

Pynapple · 21/10/2022 10:23

My kids are far closer to my MIL than my own Mom. We see her more, go on holidays etc - they love spending time with her.

Difference is, she doesn't try to undermine me or cause problems whereas my Mom just isn't that pleasant to be around.

You'll be fine; the fact that you're thinking about it means you'll be sensitive your DIL's opinions which will only help the relationship.

RaininSummer · 21/10/2022 10:23

It's an mn thing although obviously some mILs are no doubt awful just the same as general people can be awful. I think I am an ok maybe a good MIL and have good relationships with pmy sons in law. Their own mother's are very included.

PuttingDownRoots · 21/10/2022 10:23

My MIL is wonderful. Shes a genuinely nice woman. She dotes on her five grandchildren (as does FIL). Despite having two sons... there are four granddaughters and one grandson. They treat them all equally. (Not the sane, as there's 14 years from eldest to youngest. But equally according to their needs).

The main reason children end up closer to maternal grandparents is the mothers being the main carers. Bring up your sons to be an active part in their children's lives and they will ensure you are part of their children's lives.

senior30 · 21/10/2022 10:21

My relationship with my MIL is not good, despite my best efforts. The thing that brings me comfort having a son myself is that I encourage my OH to maintain a good relationship (his feeling towards her aren’t great) and I make sure that my son has a wonderful relationship. If my future DIL does the same I think I’ll be happy with that. We don’t have to love each other but we can play nice

Realfastfoodie · 21/10/2022 10:20

My mil is amazing. I’m not as close to her as my own mum but we all love her, she is an amazing granny and I like and respect her as a person. I suspect that it took a bit of biting our tongues on both our sides, particularly in the early years, we are very different people. As time goes by we see the best in each other.

AnnaMagnani · 21/10/2022 10:19

Mumsnet is also chock-full of women moaning about their mothers!

The best thing you can do is bring up your boys to not expect their partner to be responsible for all contact with you.

The other thing is be supportive of their partners, not demanding.

I know women with better relationships with the MIL than their mums. Didn't happen for me and my MIL's own idiotic behaviour in the early days is a big reason.

IhearyouClemFandango · 21/10/2022 10:17

I think it is the nature of a forum tbh. Most posters here are women, most only post about specific relationships if there is an issue...so it isn't a representative sample. If that makes any sense.

FWIW, I loved my MiL very much. She was a fabulous mother, grandmother and MiL and we were lucky to have her. She was always welcome in our home, she came on holiday with us, my children adored her and she raised 4 lovely sons.

ComtesseDeSpair · 21/10/2022 10:17

You need to teach your sons to step up and consider themselves as - and act as - equal parents to their future children, so that they aren’t left toeing the line to a partner who does everything with the DC and therefore sees them largely hers and hers to control parental access to. If they’re doing an equal share of the parenting and family life then they can feel empowered to make decisions about family relationships which heavily include you.

Puffalicious · 21/10/2022 10:17

FairShare13 · 21/10/2022 10:13

I voted yabu. Just because your DH family are mainly boys, doesn't mean that you'll also just have boys, it doesn't work like that.
You are dwelling over a hypothetical issue.

Exactly. I have 3 boys, yes 3 (and too old for more). So I'm destined to be the MIL begging for scraps. I'm being facetious: I think if I'm as lovely as I usually am to any partners of my boys I'll be fine.

FanTaill · 21/10/2022 10:17

The thing is people don’t make the effort to come on here and write threads about perfectly normal, happy relationships. I mean, why would they. So you’re only ever hearing the extreme cases.

(Also with a lot of the MIL threads keep in mind it’s often actually a DH (or FIL) problem.)

Kanaloa · 21/10/2022 10:16

The issue is though that it would be a bit weird to start a thread going ‘AIBU that my mil is so nice? She’s like a mum to me and the only nana my kids have, I love when she pops round because I always want to see her, she brightens my day. I hope she never needs care because I want her to always be healthy and happy but when she is elderly if she’s infirm I hope she lives with us so we can care for her. I love her so much.’ That would be my aibu about mil but obviously I wouldn’t post it because what’s the point? I know I’m not bu. But that’s why you can’t really judge stepmum/mil/husbands by mumsnet - you’re only seeing people’s problems.