Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that I'll only be a MIL / other mother / other nan

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

OP posts:
bridgetreilly · 21/10/2022 11:33

With respect, this is bonkers.

SeaGlassShining · 21/10/2022 11:32

My Mum loved my Granny, her MIL, so very much. She was so close to her compared to her own Mum. We had the most fantastic relationship with my Dad’s parents, compared to my Mum’s family.

I love my MIL. I’m not as close to her as I am to my Mum. But I’m bringing up our children a mile away from MIL, on a different island to my own parents.

We’ve made sure our children have lovely relationships with both sets of grandparents. MIL used to sit and cuddle our son each evening when he was born (prematurely) so that my DH could work and I could sleep in between expressing. She never overstepped any boundary with DS (did a little with DD), but was a huge help and we were really appreciative.

sjxoxo · 21/10/2022 11:31

I agree with you that this is the reality.
Women are the glue that holds families together imo - I also don’t really know anyone who loves their MIL! Including myself in that. Honestly I’d rather spend time with my own mum. DH also makes little effort with his mum tbh so I try and have a relationship with her for the sake of my DS but she definitely spends more time with her own daughter & her son. It doesn’t bother me. I feel like you that if I don’t have a daughter I’ll probably be the ‘other nanny’ when I’m old… never mind - I’ll have a good relationship with my son and hopefully DIL but if she’s closer to her own mum I’ll understand and spend more time on holiday in my old age! 😬 xx

DarkShade · 21/10/2022 11:29

The "other mum / other nan" thing comes from family set ups where the mother takes on the main family burdens. If the mother is at home doing all the housework and childcare of course the kids might well end up seeing her mother more. The mum's mum will be more involved because the mum will be calling her for help and keeping her updated with her own life, which by extension includes the kids.

So raise your sons to be active participants in family and you won't have this problem. Me and my DP do not do split time with DS exactly 50/50, but we have equal says and responsibilities in decision making. He has a day a week that he spends with DS, and he usually takes him to his mums. I have a day a week when it's just me and DS, and often my mum comes to see us. At weekends we both have him, and visit parents equally. Both grandparents get equal involvement because we parents are equally invovled.

Frazzlefrazle · 21/10/2022 11:19

I prefer my MIL to my actual mum so therefore my kids spend lots of time with her and she is always the first one we ring to tell her about our news ect. It's about effort and being non judgemental.

Bookclub99 · 21/10/2022 11:19

Crunchymum · 21/10/2022 10:13

MN is just full of people moaning ergo any posts about MIL's aren't going to be positive.

In the interest of balance, My MIL is an absolute Godsend (helps with childcare, has always been respectfully involved in our lives and other than my DP she is the person I trust most with our children) and it helps that she is also a wondeful person, whom I love and respect. I lost my mum suddenly in 2020 but I'm so bloody glad to still have my MIL.

I agree with this. MN presents a biased view due to people seeking validation or help with problem MILs who don't respect boundaries and criticise the parenting style/choices of their DS and his partner.

Both my mum and my DH's mum had terrible problems with their MILs who were overprotective of their sons and hostile to their DILs.

However, I'm happy to say that the next generation is nothing like this. My MIL is an absolute delight and we have a terrific relationship. I love having her involved in our lives and with our two DCs (both boys). She is a highly intelligent woman who understands and respects boundaries. She offers her advice and opinions, but always accepts the choices my DH and I make, whether they fit in with her own views or not. It helps that I am easygoing and not territorial. I think of her as a trusted friend and happily spend time on my own with her as we share many interests (particularly the arts and nature).

I hope, one day, I will share a similar bond with my DCs' partners. I will do my best to follow my MIL's example by respecting my DCs' partners' boundaries, providing support when invited, and treating them as a friend whose good opinion I want to keep.

Newusernameaug · 21/10/2022 11:18

people Only post when there’s an issue, you’re not going to get people posting about how much they love and see their MIL when there’s no issue are you?!

spiderlight · 21/10/2022 11:17

It doesn't always work that way. My DH is one of four sons, and all four of us daughters-in-law absolutely adore our MIL. I probably speak to her more than DH does!!

Thereisnolight · 21/10/2022 11:17

Crunchymum · 21/10/2022 10:13

MN is just full of people moaning ergo any posts about MIL's aren't going to be positive.

In the interest of balance, My MIL is an absolute Godsend (helps with childcare, has always been respectfully involved in our lives and other than my DP she is the person I trust most with our children) and it helps that she is also a wondeful person, whom I love and respect. I lost my mum suddenly in 2020 but I'm so bloody glad to still have my MIL.

I could write this too.
Hey, she’s not my personal bestie by any means…but she and our DC are very close. She has always been very respectful to me and always available at short notice to help with our DC/dog/cat/house. She bent over backwards - and I’m sure bit her lip many, many times when I found her irritating and pushed her away when I was tired.

I value her more and more as the years go by.

WetLettuce2 · 21/10/2022 11:16

I had a very difficult relationship with my DM and have an amazing relationship with my MiL - don’t assume your not going to have awesome DiLs and close ties with all GC.

Maraa · 21/10/2022 11:16

Honestly think it is dependant on the mil. My ex mil, I still see regularly and speak too and sees her grandchild often. My current mil - horrid woman

Yazo · 21/10/2022 11:14

My MIL welcome here any time, she's not been for 3 years however, her choice completely, she's barely left her neighbourhood in that time. Instead my husband and kids are going to her this weekend. I get on fine with her but she's the one with this MIL thing. I don't get it and although I only have boys I'm going to be visiting any grandchildren I get! Times have changed, I know loads of MILs more involved than mother's mum.

BlueRaincoat1 · 21/10/2022 11:13

I love my MIL. She's great, she is mad about her grandsons and a brilliant Granny. I see her more often than my own mum because she lives closer. I send lots of photos to the inlaws as well as to my own mum. We have a great relationship and me, dh and the kids go on holiday every year with my MIL and PIL. So it can be totally fine.

PlumPudd · 21/10/2022 11:12

If you raise your son to be a capable, independent, loving young man who takes an active role in organising his family life, then you should be fine. I think the issue here may be that some men devolve responsibility for arranging to see family, send birthday cards, do visits with kids to their partners, who then naturally gravitate to spending more time with their own M&D than their husbands’ family.

My kids have two mums so whoever they end up with will have two mothers in law, me and my wife - the lucky things 😉

Herecomestreble1 · 21/10/2022 11:11

Happy to mention that as the mother of a three week old baby boy, I love and admire my mother in law. She's quite different to my own mum (who is bloody incredible) and I think that helps us get on even better as there's no "other mum" issues. She steps up for us when we need her, and us for her and I'm pleased it's the kind of MIL relationship I'll be able to model for my son.

SalviaOfficinalis · 21/10/2022 11:08

It does go both ways though.

It always seems down to the wife to put in the effort with her own family, and with her PILs. You say yourself that you make an effort with your MIL. Does your DH make that same effort with your parents?

I think it’s completely artificial to imagine that a woman would have the same relationship with her MIL as she would with her own mother. I think a lot of problems arise because sons don’t make the effort with their own parents and his wife is expected to do it instead.

My own mother and my SIL get on very well, so it is possible!

MolliciousIntent · 21/10/2022 11:08

The majority of MIL issues are actually DH issues. So to a certain extent, how well you get on with your DIL and your future grandchildren is dependent on what sort of man you raise.

The reason a lot of MILs don't have the relationship they want with their GC is that in the vast majority of families it is the woman who does the lion's share of the mental load and admin. It's the woman who organises days out, buys gifts, facilitates contact, books trips, etc etc etc, and obviously she would prioritise her own family. So if you want to have a close relationship with your son's family as an adult, you need to raise him to take responsibility for his own family life rather than abdicate that to his wife.

Arou · 21/10/2022 11:08

I think you’re being unreasonable. My brother’s kids ‘main grandma’ is definitely my mum but it’s because my mum makes an effort, she’s fun and easy to be around and has never made his partners (ex wife or future partner) feel like they’ve had something to prove! She’s always up for days out, always knows when to butt out, there’s never been a weird power play or emotional manipulation.

My MIL on the other hand… Flip all of that on its head and add narcissism to the mix.

Keha · 21/10/2022 11:07

I'm close to my MiL, she does more for my DC than my mum and I have more day to day contact with her. Maybe because she has several children and lots of grandchildren, she is not particularly overbearing and has always just been friendly and helpful. Maybe Mumsnet just has a lot of people complaining and moaning.

zaffa · 21/10/2022 11:06

To provide the other perspective by MiL is delightful! We spend loads of time together and I seek out her company - DD adored her and we see her and FIL most weeks (sadly my own parents live ages away so don't get to see them frequently but do talk a lot via video call).

Not everyone hates their MIL - I adore mine!

Fink · 21/10/2022 11:06

This is such an odd post!

  1. There's no reason you wouldn't have daughters. Even if your DH has a genetic predisposition to have sons (he produces more y chromosomes than x), it's a rigged die rather than a guarantee, he can still father girls. And you don't even know that he carries this gene, you just think that he might because there's a lot of boys in his family.
  2. There's no reason to suppose grandchildren born from a son rather than a daughter would be less close. It depends on the individual family dynamics. You might have a gay son, you might have a son whose partner doesn't get on with her family, you might just have a son who ends up living close by you and further away from his partner's family, you might have a son who ends up with sole parental responsibility for his children. There are a million situations in which your son might stil be close to you as an adult, and probably a million more why he might not. It depends on upbringing and family dynamics much more than your child's sex.
  3. There's no blanket MIL dislike. It usually takes time to build a relationship with in-laws because, by definition, you didn't grow up with them or have the same long-standing attachment that you have to your own family. Some people in life you get on with, others you don't as much, for a variety of reasons. If you love your partner and s/he gets on well with his/her family, then there's probably a better chance than not that you'll also get on with his/her family, but it will still take time to adjust to them and build a relationship. There's no reason a hypothetical DIL would dislike you just because you're the MIL.
codehelp · 21/10/2022 11:05

I don't know if it's a helpful perspective but we weren't able to have children. We'll never be any kind of parents or grandparents at all ever.

Your own personal relationship might or might not be everything you've ever fantasised about - but you have the power to try to build it by being a helpful and supportive and kind parent and grandparent. Smile

CheshireCat1 · 21/10/2022 11:04

I have three grown up sons and have a great relationships with all their partners. Everyone gets on with each other and we’re always having girls days out and breaks away. I also get on with the girl’s mums and have days out with them too. Life is too short.

DistantSkye · 21/10/2022 11:03

I really like my MIL and we probably spend more time with her than my mum! Don't assume the worst before it's even begun.

forlornlorna1 · 21/10/2022 11:02

Honestly my daughter in law is Wonderful. We gave a great relationship. I treat her like my own. Very good relationship.

People only come on here to talk about in-laws when there's a problem. I bet there's loads of people like me who have good relationships with their sons partners x

Swipe left for the next trending thread