Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that I'll only be a MIL / other mother / other nan

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 21/10/2022 12:48

YABU. MN isn’t a community with a hive mind so “MN demonises” doesn’t make sense. That’s your interpretation of comments that you see. When there’s a wish to wish to see in-laws less often than parents, there’s a reason for it based on those people’s bad behaviour and attitudes. Sometimes it’s the MIL who is preferred over the parent.
As pp have said, threads on MN are not representative of the majority of family relationships, because most of the time people are posting about a problem.

MonkeypuzzleClimber · 21/10/2022 12:47

I absolutely adored my mother-in-law. She died just before lockdown and we all still miss her so much. I love my own mum, but my MIL was far more family oriented and to be honest the relationship was simpler and we were probably closer. I spoke to her several times a week, and came to stay with the kids whenever we were able (sometimes without my husband).

She treated me as family very quickly, didn’t interfere in me and my husband’s relationship, she loved him very much, but was never possessive in any way, just loved and supported us all. She really loved the kids. That made me so happy. No piece of family news was too small for her to care about. She had a busy life, but called regularly (as did I) but was never offended if it wasn’t a good time or we couldn’t visit. It wasn’t always perfect, and we had to do some negotiating around boundaries with the kids (grandma‘s rules and grandma‘s house, mine in ours, mine for all food and sleep), which we mostly managed calmly and tolerantly on both sides. I think I was a good daughter in law, but it was so easy to love her. Raise your sons to be good men and, treat your son’s future partners with love and kindness and don’t interfere in their relationship, and hopefully any future daughter-in-laws (or son-in-laws) will do the same!

lamaze1 · 21/10/2022 12:46

I was hopeful I'd get on with my MIL as she seemed straight talking but lovely and I adored my FIL who has sadly passed away. However my MIL has made it very clear she hates me and my family (she is jealous of my parents and resents her son spending any time with them). Despite trying to include her she has been vile over the years so now the end result is I see her as little as possible. Sad as I would have preferred for things to not be as they are now, but life is too short.

Sirrah · 21/10/2022 12:46

You're making an awful lot of assumptions!

I'm a mother-in-law, and get on really well with my son's wife! She always involves us in our grandson's lives, makes sure they visit us, and we're just back from a few days looking after them.

You will be the key when your son meets the girl he wants to spend his life with, be friendly, welcoming, and don't judge their choices. I had a MiL who was interfering, and I learned from that experience. I embraced my role as grandmother, there to help when asked, but doing things their way. If I'm honest they're better parents than I ever was, because things have changed in the 30+ years since my children were born!

glassfully · 21/10/2022 12:46

I really like my MIL. I've never had to post about her because there's nothing to ask advice about when it comes to our relationship.

ahunf · 21/10/2022 12:45

My husband is one of 4 boys. Only one of his brothers has kinds, 4 sons. I assumed we would have boys but we had 2 girls.

I get on ok with his mum. Don't see her that often even though she's down the road.

Buttons294749 · 21/10/2022 12:44

yabu my MIL is lovely and an equal grandparent to the DC.

She actually helps with childcare so is an angel imo :)

UsernameIsCopied · 21/10/2022 12:44

MN generally gives a negative view of everything. Look around you at RL relationships with MILs. Are they really all that bad? For every unpopular MIL who is not allowed to see the grandkids as much as she would like I can think of one paternal grandmother who is much more involved with her grandchildren than the maternal grandmother. It's the luck of the draw, whether you have a daughter or a son.

Macaroni1924 · 21/10/2022 12:44

I hated my in-laws, they were clearly not happy that I had ‘taken’ their son and had issues with my religion. I have to say though I have grown to care for them. I don’t wish to spend time I don’t need to with them but can have conversations, ask for advice and even at times enjoy their company. At the end of the day they love my DD and are an important part of her life.
My brothers wife loves my parents. She txts my mum often and enjoys spending time with her. I have to say I’d like their relationship if I could have it with mine. It just depends on personalities I suppose. I think my MIL and I are both strong , independent characters so possibly a clash there. My brother is close to my parents though and even from when he first moved out he kept in regular contact, maybe this has helped 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mylak · 21/10/2022 12:42

People will naturally post when they have an issue. They are plenty of people who post with difficult mothers but lovely MIL too.

My mum died when I was a child and so there would definitely not have been any competition/automatic favouritism between my MIL and my mother - I would have very much welcomed a closer relationship for me (and DH) and our DC. We don't have one but she also doesn't have a great relationship with her own daughter or have any real friends and there are reasons for this - just luck of the draw to some extent.

Pallisers · 21/10/2022 12:42

My MIL is fantastic. I don't post about it on MN because what is there to say/ask? I don't have a problem.

I love her as do all her daughters in law (she only had sons). My bil and sil live around the corner from her and my sil is better than a daughter to her. All the grandkids adore her and she minded them all. She stays with us for weeks at a time. My sil had her living with her for nearly a year at one point.

Don't be taking a view on MILs from people on MN posting about problematic relationships.

SooticaSootyWhiskers · 21/10/2022 12:42

It's quite simple op.
People distance themselves from their in-laws when it is hard work. Be judgemental, interfering and downright unpleasant and you'll be held at arms length. Try to enforce your own way ditto.
This goes for both sets of grandparents.
Expect your dil to do the social work your son should be, you'll get resentment. Expect to get your own way and start playing him off against his wife, he'll have to choose and he may not choose you.
Then there's the fact your son may not even want or be able to have children. Or he might have a husband instead of a wife (who probably won't have the added expectations of sexism in his role)
The fact that you are giving this so much headspace says to me you need to chill out a bit. Nothing worse than a mother in law who creates problems that are not there.

A big part of it is accepting grandchildren do not belong to you. You had your go at parenting. Your role as a GC is to be a loving, stable and kind presence and above all support your dil and sons parenting decisions.

MeridianB · 21/10/2022 12:42

MN is a snapshot of some appalling MIL behaviour. It's also a snapshot of some appalling mother behaviour - so I don't think MILs are singled out. It's totally subjective. If you treat people with consideration then you shouldn't expect any drama, unless you get massively unlucky and end up with a horrible DIL!

Also, most people post when they have a problem or dilemma. So you're not likely to read tons of glowing stories on here.

FrozenGhost · 21/10/2022 12:39

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 21/10/2022 12:00

Why on earth are you putting all this on your potential future DIL? It sounds like you're expecting her to do all the work in their relationship with you, and she doesn't even exist yet.

My DP had a fantastic relationship with my mum before she died, because my mum knew where the boundaries were. They were good friends, they went out to coffee together, DP would offer to pick up some bits for her when out shopping, Mum would offer childcare, Mum was there to support DP when her mother died.

But Mum would only pop round unnanounced if she knew it was just me and DD at home, if DP was likely to be around she'd text first.

When I accidentally forgot Mums birthday one year, she was fuming with me, not DP.

When she had a concern that we weren't feeding DD healthily enough (excited 5 year old had decided that pizza two days on the trot as a one off now meant that she was eating pizza every single day), she came to me to discuss it, not her DIL.

When Mum was feeling a bit down because she'd not seen us in a month, she spoke to me about it, not DP.

In short, you can have a fantastic relationship with your son and any future DIL, but if your son isn't interested in facilitating that relationship, then that's not your DIL's fault or problem.

This.

shieldmaiden7 · 21/10/2022 12:38

I love my MIL she's wonderful, we have her over for dinner quiet often.. My XH mother only seem to like me when the marriage broke down. We got along, had plenty in common and were nice enough to each other. I just wasn't her type of person and honestly she wasn't mine.
I have more sons than daughters and do hope I'm not seen as the horrid MIL when they are older.

saraclara · 21/10/2022 12:37

I loved my MIL so much. But then everyone did because she was just a lovely, loving and accepting person. It also helped that my own mum was and is the opposite.

I'm glad I have girls though, because I'm quite introverted and a bit socially clumsy. So some DILs might find it hard work or misinterpret my intentions or words however hard I tried. It's a lot easier to be accepted as a MIL if you're naturally easy company.

Notanotherwindow · 21/10/2022 12:37

It's a bit like customer reviews online OP. A happy person might tell Facebook what a good experience they had. A unhappy person will tell Facebook, twitter, trustpilot, Google and anyone they happen to meet along the way.

MN is a place lots of people vent. There might be 3000 users who have a great relationship with their mother in law and only 300 who don't. But it's the 300 you hear from. Because they're pissed off and need advice or to vent. The 3000 are happily chatting to their mother in law and not posting about them.

C8H10N4O2 · 21/10/2022 12:37

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

YABU. You also need to get a bit of a grip - you have one child so far, he is a baby and you are already catastrophising about relationships with his future wife/husband?

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people

I've no idea which thread this is about but if you are talking the immediate post natal period - women should be allowed to have whoever they want, even if its godzilla.

If you are talking in general - what is this based on? What evidence? Distance is usually the main determinant of visiting - distant family are going to be less frequent visitors. If its based on threads on MN - well people post about problems, not everything running smoothly.

If you want good relations with future DiL/SiLs then treat them as you would want to be treated and not surrogate mothers for your own child. Expect to have some differences in views and aim for working relationship not BFF. Anything else grows from there.

Mostly though - you might want to think about why in general, people talk more about DiL/MiL relationships than SiL/MiL or DiL/FiL relationships. Largely its because we still live in a male dominated society which sets up women against each other with respect to men.

Freegal · 21/10/2022 12:36

My own mother is a horrible horrible person and I'm so grateful I have my mother in law. She's everything I ever could have asked for in a mother

Coyoacan · 21/10/2022 12:34

I separated from my ex before my dd was even born, but his mother was always really good to us and my dd grew up viewing her as a second mother.

Scianel · 21/10/2022 12:32

Your son might not even have children.

Winceybincey · 21/10/2022 12:30

I have boys and I’m not worried. My MIL rarely sees my boys, rarely bothers with us, asks how they’re doing once every couple of months and when we do see her it always feels as though she’s doing it out of obligation rather than because she wants to see them. Other times she’s cancelled visits last minute because she wanted to see her friends instead, some of those times she didn’t even let us know until the following day so we were waiting for her not knowing she wasn’t coming. There’s no bond there, they don’t even know that she’s ‘nan’ as she’s pretty much a stranger to them.

My mum is the complete opposite and they love her to bits. This isn't because she’s my mum, and MIl is my husbands mum, it’s because my mum makes a huge effort (I say effort but it comes across naturally).

I will be the same with my boys and their children. If you as a MIL make the effort to bond with your sons wife and to bond with, and love their children, see them often, ask about them often and be a nan who adores her grandchildren then you won’t have a problem. Children use the term ‘other nan’ for the one who is called nan but who they don’t really know or love.

Bumbers · 21/10/2022 12:29

I love my MIL (and FIL). Not in a Mum role (my own mum passed away a few years before DC), but i am so happy to have her/them in our lives. I take time to take DC to visit them and have been on holiday with them without DH. They are great!!!

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 12:29

I think that parents and in-laws tend to get seen as much or little as circumstances (such as distance and their behaviour) make appropriate. For me visiting the in-laws is an incredibly pleasant and relaxing way of spending family time, whereas (keeping things vague for non-outing purposes) visits to my side of the family are much more of a pleasant enough obligation that I do for others more than for myself.

People tend to like doing things which are easy and pleasant - I presume that when you become a grandparent the better job you can do of making your visits to family and theirs to yours a simple, pleasant, easy, stress-free experience then it'll happen more often. If there's drama, or nastiness, or you never have food in so can't even offer the kids a sandwich then visits are liekly to be shorter and less frequent.

jammydodgersforever · 21/10/2022 12:28

Crunchymum · 21/10/2022 10:13

MN is just full of people moaning ergo any posts about MIL's aren't going to be positive.

In the interest of balance, My MIL is an absolute Godsend (helps with childcare, has always been respectfully involved in our lives and other than my DP she is the person I trust most with our children) and it helps that she is also a wondeful person, whom I love and respect. I lost my mum suddenly in 2020 but I'm so bloody glad to still have my MIL.

I'll second this; my MIL is wonderful.