Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that I'll only be a MIL / other mother / other nan

233 replies

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

OP posts:
5128gap · 21/10/2022 19:53

Minimalme · 21/10/2022 19:33

This infuriates me.

Why do people ignore all the posts from daughters who despise their Mothers?

Or those why are no contact?

If you are kind, fair and helpful, your family will love you.

I listened to Maxine Peake's Desert Island Discs today - she lived with her Step Granddad from 15 to 21. She adored him.

Just stop with all this bloody nonsense talk.

I don't agree that if you're kind fair and helpful your family will love you.
I'm willing to bet most everyone who has family issues imagines themselves to be kind fair and helpful. But for one thing, it tends to be subjective, and for another, some people are so difficult and hostile that you couldn't win them over if you were a saint.
I've seen a thread on here with a DiL berating her MiL for buying a rug for the babys nursery. DiL considered it overstepping. MiL no doubt thought it kind.
A more recent thread saw posters claiming grandparents were obliged to offer free childcare to be helpful. MiL might think its quite helpful enough to babysit once a month.
For in laws to love each other both parties need to be kind fair and helpful, and more importantly to have a shared understanding of what that means.

Minimalme · 21/10/2022 19:33

This infuriates me.

Why do people ignore all the posts from daughters who despise their Mothers?

Or those why are no contact?

If you are kind, fair and helpful, your family will love you.

I listened to Maxine Peake's Desert Island Discs today - she lived with her Step Granddad from 15 to 21. She adored him.

Just stop with all this bloody nonsense talk.

Dogsandbabies · 21/10/2022 17:07

I adore my DPs mum. She is absolutely smashing with our kids. She adores them and they adore her. We certainly see her more than my parents.

She never interferes and is always helpful and cheerful. She is not the smartest woman but she is very kind and means well. I think you get out of it what you put.

Saying this my previous MIL was great fun to be around but quite patronising and arrogant so I was a lot less likely to instigate contact.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 21/10/2022 16:01

I love my MIL. She rings me to check in more often than my own mother! Some of the experiences on MN are the compete opposite end of the spectrum to mine.

Sprogonthetyne · 21/10/2022 15:46

My MIL is lovely and objectively easier to get on with then my own mum, but we do see her less often. Part of that is distance, but mainly it's because DH never organises anything without prompting and I refuse to take on the wife-work of organising his family relationships. Poor MIL also generally gets last minute Christmas gifts for the same reason, not my mum so not my responsibility.

Teach your son (and your daughters, which you may well have) to take equal responsibility for maintaining their own relationships.

Calphurnia88 · 21/10/2022 15:31

No one's going to write a post about how much they love their MIL and how great she is with their kids. It's not Trust Pilot.

FWIW I have a great relationship with my MIL and she is wonderful with our son/her grandson. I only wish we could see her more, but sadly we live in different parts of the country.

Untitledsquatboulder · 21/10/2022 15:29

My mil is lovely and we've always had a really good relationship. I can get on with most people. If I end up with a not so lovely dil then I fully intend just to leave her to it.

BigFatLiar · 21/10/2022 15:28

It's just the nature of mumsnet, it's a mainly female forum where people complain so it's the husbands mother is a problem, the husband is a problem. Not many come on here to admit that they are the problem.
My MiL died ages ago and she treated me like a daughter, she was amazing.

Avoid listening to mumsnet or instead of worrying about your future mother in law you'll be worried about raising a violent abuser, potential rapist etc as that's the default view of men.

Lentil63 · 21/10/2022 15:27

You may yet have a daughter….
I have two sons both married with a child and another on the way. I adore my daughters in law and my grandchildren, we all have a fabulous relationship. I think you should concentrate on enjoying every stage of your children’s lives, it all goes so soon. Be a good mummy and love them and then trust them to make good choices about their life partners.

Worriedddd · 21/10/2022 15:17

I love my MIL she loves my DD and she's more reliable than my own DM.

Miajk · 21/10/2022 15:15

Thisismynamenow · 21/10/2022 10:06

Following another post where OP is blatantly creating double standards between the frequency and allowance of MIL visiting over her DM, I feel very sad that this is the case for most people.

MN seems to demonise MILs and the 'Inlaw' family to a point where they should only be tolerated and visited as infrequently as possible and only out of duty not desire.

My MIL is hard work with multiple addition needs and narcissism as a result of past trauma so I don't have that usual MIL experience, but I do make lots of effort, go shopping with her, invite her for dinner regularly and spend alot of time with the DH side of the family.

My mom doesn't like her MIL either because my mom wasn't good enough for my dad apparently. I don't actually know anyone who likes their MIL :(

I have a baby son, and future children are likely to be sons (my DH family is mainly boys). I love my son massively but sad I'll likely always be a mother of sons. Sad because mother of sons always seem to be the other mother, the tolerated and hated one, some for good reason but others just because your not the DILs mom.

I hope to raise my son(s) to be independent, loving and committed, and would eventually love a DIL (or SIL whatever he wants) I could have a great relationship with rather than the negative one relayed on here. But reading all these posts makes me feel it's never going to happen and I'll just be the tolerated mother.

Is this just a MN thing hating MIL or is this reallife?

Well maybe the DIL sees her own mum more often as she makes effort to arrange contact?

Also, when a baby is involved the mother of the DIL is not just the baby's grandma, it's someone very close and trusted to the new mom, therefore it's normal she would like to have her around more than her MIL where the dynamic is totally different.

ahunf · 21/10/2022 14:14

My MIL understands exactly what I have to put up with. She's the only one who truly knows her son is a NOB most of the time!!

Refrosty · 21/10/2022 14:13

I have a brilliant MIL. I have a DH who is close to her mum. I have two sons so I do share your concerns but actually, I wouldn't blame my DILs if I felt like the 'other nan'. I'd be looking firmly at my sons if I felt slighted at all, but I don't expect to be in competition with the other nan tbh lol.

My mum has 3 kids but 2 of us have DC. She is kinda my children's 'other nan' mostly because of where we are located, but my DC do see her and stay with her. My DB also has two kids and DM is their main nan because they live closer to each other, and my SIL isn't too fond of her own mother (SIL's mother doesn't really want to make time to be with her grandkids.. SIL even had my mum present at the birth of her kids).

You never know how things will be until they are so.

5128gap · 21/10/2022 14:12

The spite and antipathy towards MiLs on here doesn't reflect my experience in RL. Most women I know have feelings for their MiL that range from amused, slightly irritated tolerance, to genuine love.
That said, unless your DiL has a poor relationship with her mother or she lives further away, or your sons become their childrens primary carers, I think its almost inevitable that as a paternal grandmother you will be the 'junior' grandma; and when the children are young your relationship with them may be largely dependent on keeping your DiL on side.
As they get older though, with more autonomy, this can change and they can build strong relationships in their own right. For this reason it's important not to allow any hurt to make you back too far off and further sideline yourself.
I also agree with PP that your relationship with your sons is key as they are as capable of facilitating their children's relationships with you as their mothers are.

Furrydogmum · 21/10/2022 14:03

Don't lose hope! My future dil loves me to bits and I love her too. She has a good relationship with her parents and wider family so it isn't through lack of that either! I'm not blind to my son's "failings" which may help..

XelaM · 21/10/2022 13:58

I have always got on really well with my ex-MIL. She's lovely and even though my ex-husband is a piece of work, I still have a great relationship with her. As my own mum lives abroad, my ex-MIL did all the childcare for my daughter when she was a baby. She's a great woman I have the utmost respect for and a real pleasure to be around.

SugarNspices · 21/10/2022 13:55

Daughter is more needy it should say (due to health problems)

SugarNspices · 21/10/2022 13:51

Not another "I'm sad I will be a mil to women because I have just a son" threads!
I love my Mil she actually is more of a hands on gran then my own mum . I know lots of people people good relationships with their mil and lots that don't. Don't base the mil bashing threads on real life. women often make these threads because there husband's don't talk to the mil when boundaries are over stepped or that they find it not as comfortable to iron out problems with their mil themselves like you can with your own mum, so problems fester and they come here for advice.

I asked my mil how her son's relationships differs in marriage and she said it's often easier with her son's marriages than her daughter's in her case as her daughter is more needed (just her personality) She told me she does her best to take an interest, be kind, give them space but let them know you are a support, understand at the beginning with a new baby she might want her own mum don't take it personal. Be patient and loving it takes more time like any relationship at time to build.

There are obviously crazy people and unreasonable people but anyone half decent you shouldn't worry.

museumum · 21/10/2022 13:44

My mil is lovely but she’s not my mum. I see my mum more and am closer to her. BUT my dh sees his mum more and is close to her and because we share childcare my ds sees all his gps regularly and is actually closer to my mil.
If you want to be close to your potential future gcs then you need to bring up your sons to take an equal role in arranging and maintaining extended family relationships and in childcare in his own home.

35965a · 21/10/2022 13:43

I also have to ask I have a great relationship with my own MIL. We aren’t extremely close but we get on well, I don’t take the piss asking for favours, she has never ever tried to step on my toes as a mother and therefore I trust her with my children implicitly. The way she is has left a good footprint for me to follow if and when my own son marries and has children.

Goldbar · 21/10/2022 13:43

If your DS is an active and involved parent and you are close to him, then of course you will be an involved grandparent.

If you're expecting your DIL to facilitate your relationship with your son and grandchildren (as opposed to just being friendly and welcoming when you see her), then YABU.

35965a · 21/10/2022 13:40

I think the problem is sometimes MILs expect the same relationship with their DIL that she has with her own mother particularly and this will never be the case no matter how well you get on. This leads some MILs to try and ‘push’ their way in and it just ends in disaster and conflict.

I think the important thing is to accept that you can have a good relationship with your DIL but if she’s close to her mother you’ll never replicate that with her - it’s not possible.

Build a good relationship with your son and make sure he isn’t a lazy bastard who leaves everything to his partner to sort out because you’ll lose out eventually.

Also build a good relationship with your DIL before any possible children arrive on the scene.

When your DIL has a child do not try and muscle in and turn obsessively baby crazy, so many people do (this isn’t a MIL thing, some family members just go a bit temporarily insane when a family member has a baby).

I am not saying there aren’t some DILs who make it hard, of course there are. However, as a MIL you need to know your son will always pick his wife over you so you do need to cultivate that mutually respectful relationship. That is just the way it is.

MumChats · 21/10/2022 13:40

Far too soon to worry. You may not have another son, your son may marry a man in which case traditional mil/dil dynamic would change anyway, your son may marry a woman who is not close to her mum or whose mum is not alive. If you have a good relationship with your son you are likely to have a good relationship with your grandchildren. Agree with pp who say that there are lots of threads about problem mils because there is no need to start a thread about a nice one! Also I think it helps to vent about mil because you sometimes can't be as blunt with them as you can your own family so maybe people just getting things off their chests in a forum rather than real life...but doesn't mean the mil is "worse" than their own dm.

elizzza · 21/10/2022 13:39

I love my MIL. I’m much closer to her than to my own mum. She’s a brilliant grandma and a good friend - I genuinely think even if DH and I split up I’d still see his parents. SIL feels exactly the same. You can choose the sort of relationship you have with your childrens’ partners.

Hankunamatata · 21/10/2022 13:37

We moved to be near dh family. Mil and fil always have my kids. Help out etc. My parents live in another country

Swipe left for the next trending thread