Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dump nanny by text

264 replies

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:51

Seems harsh but let me explain. She started with us 2 weeks ago on a fixed term contract for a few months. she brings her own daughter with her which I was fine with, didn’t see any problems. My DD is 9 months, her DD is 6 months so their needs are fairly similar in terms of eating/napping/playing.

The problem is she can’t seem to take any initiative, when she feeds DD she needs me to make it up, she then proceeds to feed her own DD so I’m left feeding whilst I should be working. DD cries frequently through the day, when she wakes up early from her nap the nanny rarely gets her back down because she seeing to her own child. I never see her holding, cuddling or focusing on DD in any meaningful way.

We’re not happy with her and so we are letting her go. We have to give her notice which I’m happy to do, but don’t want to wait until her next working day, as that will prolong the length of notice. We have alternative childcare lined up.

So… AIBU to text her letting her know we know longer need her, bearing in mind length of service (she’s effectively worked only a handful of days) and the fact I’d like her gone sooner rather than later?

OP posts:
tenbob · 21/10/2022 10:47

Thehonestbadger · 21/10/2022 10:40

I don’t think it’s legal for nannies/ mothers aids to be self employed in the U.K. I might be wrong but when I was looking into getting a nanny a while ago I came up against this as a barrier, it seemed to be there to stop nannies being done out of employment rights, so I’d check the legalities of this arrangement you’ve created between you. That being said yes she’s only been with you a couple of weeks so unfair dismissal is only moral not legal.

All the extra info you gave after my comment feels like a bit of a drip feed. To me your original OP didn’t scream ‘she came with 15 years experience with children of a similar age and glowing references’ but with that in mind then yes you do have more right to be annoyed/disappointed she’s not delivering as expected. I suspect looking after her own child is very different from looking after two that weren’t hers and as others have said she’s probably still recovering from birth and not sleeping well.

There are specific circumstances where it is fine for a nanny to be self employed

Doing temporary contracts, such as night nannies or temp nannies, is one of them…

ICanHideButICantRun · 21/10/2022 10:47

I wouldn't want her to work her notice if she can't do the job when things are OK between you.

Katapolts · 21/10/2022 10:46

Thehonestbadger · 21/10/2022 10:40

I don’t think it’s legal for nannies/ mothers aids to be self employed in the U.K. I might be wrong but when I was looking into getting a nanny a while ago I came up against this as a barrier, it seemed to be there to stop nannies being done out of employment rights, so I’d check the legalities of this arrangement you’ve created between you. That being said yes she’s only been with you a couple of weeks so unfair dismissal is only moral not legal.

All the extra info you gave after my comment feels like a bit of a drip feed. To me your original OP didn’t scream ‘she came with 15 years experience with children of a similar age and glowing references’ but with that in mind then yes you do have more right to be annoyed/disappointed she’s not delivering as expected. I suspect looking after her own child is very different from looking after two that weren’t hers and as others have said she’s probably still recovering from birth and not sleeping well.

It's the role that is self-employed or employed, not the person.

If you can set your own terms and conditions, rates and availability, say when and how you work, you are probably self-employed eg a childminder, hairdresser, plumber, cleaner.

If the employer sets the days, hours, wage, tells you how and where to work, it's probably an employment situation.

So some nannies - emergency or ad-hoc nannies, night nannies, maternity nurses, travel nannies are often self employed.
A nanny who has set days and hours and can't just pick and choose their days is employed - even if the job is part time or fixed term.

Lots of employers like to pretend their nannies are self-employed so they can avoid giving them employment rights though Hmm

HanSB · 21/10/2022 10:46

You do need to speak with her, it's pretty terrible to fire someone by text! You don't really owe her an explanation since she hasn't worked with you for very long. I would tell her it's not working out as your child is not getting the attention you expected and so you will be looking for one on one care instead.

I don't understand the self-employed nanny role either. If she is not choosing her working hours etc then you must legally employ her and give her employee benefits such as holiday pay, sick pay, pension, maternity leave. You can use a payroll company which specialises in nannies to do this on your behalf but you cannot shirk your responsibilities as an employer - which you are.

Eatmycake3333 · 21/10/2022 10:45

I put Yabu only for the reason, why on earth would you employ Someone who was bringing their own child so small to work everyday. That was never going to work. Fair enough if the child was 4, snd a bit more independent. Did you employ her at a cheaper rate because of this?

Cherryblossoms85 · 21/10/2022 10:42

Just a few observations: being on an FTC is not the same thing as being self employed. She is not self employed, you employ her and pay employment taxes accordingly, I hope.
I also had a nanny who brought her own 4 month old to work when she came back from mat leave, and I had three children, one under 1. It was fine, but then I wasn't sitting in the house getting involved in every interaction. I think the arrangement needed much stronger discussion of how in practice things like feeding were going to work.

balalake · 21/10/2022 10:42

Please speak to her by a phone call. I agree with letting her go, but be the better person and talk to her.

NCHammer2022 · 21/10/2022 10:41

Idontevenknow · 21/10/2022 10:18

While I agree it wasn't the best idea, nursery workers have a ratio of 1:2 for babies this age and it works fine. Similiar with twins.

The big difference - that’s startlingly obvious even to a first time parent - is that one of the babies is her baby. That’s a completely different situation to twins or a 1:2 ratio.

I won’t even use a childminder who has their own kids there, I don’t want any childcare situation where one child is a higher priority than the others.

Thehonestbadger · 21/10/2022 10:40

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:58

She’s been with us for 2 weeks not 2 years. She’s also self employed on a FTC.
so not relevant in any way.

I don’t think it’s legal for nannies/ mothers aids to be self employed in the U.K. I might be wrong but when I was looking into getting a nanny a while ago I came up against this as a barrier, it seemed to be there to stop nannies being done out of employment rights, so I’d check the legalities of this arrangement you’ve created between you. That being said yes she’s only been with you a couple of weeks so unfair dismissal is only moral not legal.

All the extra info you gave after my comment feels like a bit of a drip feed. To me your original OP didn’t scream ‘she came with 15 years experience with children of a similar age and glowing references’ but with that in mind then yes you do have more right to be annoyed/disappointed she’s not delivering as expected. I suspect looking after her own child is very different from looking after two that weren’t hers and as others have said she’s probably still recovering from birth and not sleeping well.

Katapolts · 21/10/2022 10:39

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 10:31

Bloody hell op - why on earth did you think this would work??

as for how to approach, ring “I think we both can agree that unfortunately not working out having the two babies together. Thanks so much for last two weeks but I’m going to call a day on this”

It works absolutely fine for loads of people - lots of childminders and nannies have their own children.

Maybe you have personally had a bad experience but that doesn't mean it is the case for everyone.

Endlesslaundry123 · 21/10/2022 10:39

Write down all your points before calling her, to help you articulate what you want to say.

GodInventedAmazon · 21/10/2022 10:39

We all do things with the best intentions that don't work out . Call her , I bet she's expecting it, she's probably realised its not working out as you both expected it to
Get it over and done with

geraniumsandsunshine · 21/10/2022 10:37

Text her to say your like to call her to chat about the current situation.

Then call her and ask her how she thinks it's going. Let her lead. She may say oh it's not quite right in which case that makes it easier. If she says it's fine, you then say, actually from your perspective it's not working and so you are sorry but will be giving notice. Then follow up the call with an email or letter summarizing the call.

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 10:37

olympicsrock · 21/10/2022 10:36

Nanny with own child can be ok. We have done it twice . Cheaper but with pitfalls. Can be made to work though.
Our first nanny had been a childminder and treated our son with as much love and care as her daughter 2 years older. They played well together. She did take my son to her daughter’s weekly school assemblies rather than activities just for him but I thought this was probably quite exciting for a toddler.

Second nanny was superwoman. She came back for a while when her baby was 6 months old but eventually found it to difficult to get him up and to our house for 7:30 am.

i don’t think this nanny arrangement was ever going to work. Nanny’s own child was too young.

Our first nanny had been a childminder and treated our son with as much love and care as her daughter 2 years older.

honestly, I very very much doubt it when you weren’t around

Kabbalah · 21/10/2022 10:36

Inconsiderate and unacceptable. Pay her the courtesy and talk to her properly.

olympicsrock · 21/10/2022 10:36

Nanny with own child can be ok. We have done it twice . Cheaper but with pitfalls. Can be made to work though.
Our first nanny had been a childminder and treated our son with as much love and care as her daughter 2 years older. They played well together. She did take my son to her daughter’s weekly school assemblies rather than activities just for him but I thought this was probably quite exciting for a toddler.

Second nanny was superwoman. She came back for a while when her baby was 6 months old but eventually found it to difficult to get him up and to our house for 7:30 am.

i don’t think this nanny arrangement was ever going to work. Nanny’s own child was too young.

Obki · 21/10/2022 10:35

If she's had 15 years experience then she's not naive, she has played you for a fool, OP.

Find your anger and call her and calmly and professionally explain to her it's not working. and you have to let her go.

And follow it up with an email or text straight after so she can't claim

ErmNoThankYou · 21/10/2022 10:35

I completely agree that it was never going to work because her mother's instinct would take over and her child would be prioritised over yours.
I think doing it by text is very informal, you should email if you must do it this way but obviously face to face is more appropriate.
She may try and talk you round and say she will change so stick to your guns.

I have a friend who is a child minder assistant and she has just gone back to work with her own baby of 10 weeks. I don't understand how that will work as the baby won't be put down and she would naturally sort her child out before any of the others, she's also a bit precious about people coming near him and it's a small setting so I'm interested to see how her situation pans out- my prediction is it would be similar to yours.

LindaEllen · 21/10/2022 10:34

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:56

I did think of that but I know I won’t be able to articulate my reasons as clearly over the phone. It’s also bloody awkward “hi - we’re letting you go”!
mat least by text she can read, absorb and then respond. We ultimately will still see her and deal with her whilst she’s working her notice so I’d like the exchange to be considered… I don’t want to put her on the spot over the phone and make it super awkward!

You're sacking her because something you agreed with isn't working, and you're expecting her to work her notice? Wow.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 21/10/2022 10:34

Good Lord, if you're using a nanny's services then you should think about situations like these and how you will handle them! This needs to be done face to face. one more day is neither here more there. Would you like your job to be terminated by text/email.

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 10:32

Do not offer to provide a reference

Blondeshavemorefun · 21/10/2022 10:32

Calling is better

why is she se

nannies who are on fixed days and hours are employed

sounds like a tax avoidance plus pension and employers ni by yourself

who decided she would be se

if she is se she will have her terms that you signed

what is the notice period

a nwoc can work well for similar ages but equally better when toddlers. Not 6/9mth babies

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 10:31

Bloody hell op - why on earth did you think this would work??

as for how to approach, ring “I think we both can agree that unfortunately not working out having the two babies together. Thanks so much for last two weeks but I’m going to call a day on this”

NoSki · 21/10/2022 10:31

I’d send an email, so it’s more like a letter and then send a text saying you’ve sent an mail so it doesn’t get missed. I’d probably go with paying her the notice so she doesn’t come back as that’s super awkward.
to the poster saying you can’t let her go after 2 weeks of course you can!!

SatinHeart · 21/10/2022 10:31

Call her and then follow up with an email setting out all your points in writing. Text messages aren't very professional.

Swipe left for the next trending thread