Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dump nanny by text

264 replies

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:51

Seems harsh but let me explain. She started with us 2 weeks ago on a fixed term contract for a few months. she brings her own daughter with her which I was fine with, didn’t see any problems. My DD is 9 months, her DD is 6 months so their needs are fairly similar in terms of eating/napping/playing.

The problem is she can’t seem to take any initiative, when she feeds DD she needs me to make it up, she then proceeds to feed her own DD so I’m left feeding whilst I should be working. DD cries frequently through the day, when she wakes up early from her nap the nanny rarely gets her back down because she seeing to her own child. I never see her holding, cuddling or focusing on DD in any meaningful way.

We’re not happy with her and so we are letting her go. We have to give her notice which I’m happy to do, but don’t want to wait until her next working day, as that will prolong the length of notice. We have alternative childcare lined up.

So… AIBU to text her letting her know we know longer need her, bearing in mind length of service (she’s effectively worked only a handful of days) and the fact I’d like her gone sooner rather than later?

OP posts:
Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 16:25

So for those asking, I’ve dropped her a text letting her know I’d like to discuss how things are going, and asked her to let me know when she’s free. She said she’s free at 6pm…

watch this space!! Don’t know why I feel nervous…

OP posts:
ClocksGoingBackwards · 21/10/2022 16:23

A call would be nicer, but when she’s that bad at her job that she’s watching you do the most fundamental part of it by letting you sort out feeds, and she doesn’t improve when she’s clearly told, I think it’s fine to get rid in any way that you’re comfortable with.

Obki · 21/10/2022 16:18

How did the call go, OP?

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 16:11

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 15:23

You have already hired a replacement and had a trial?

So when did you first start to have misgivings? Must have been on day 1?

Yes day 1 I was unhappy, gave feedback. Nothing changed on day 2 so I made arrangements with a lady that applied after I’d already agreed a contract with nanny 1. The trial was yesterday. That went exceedingly well, she has accepted a job offer today!

OP posts:
Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 16:09

Discovereads · 21/10/2022 15:21

“Same difference for employees/self employed.” is completely incorrect.

It really depends on the T&Cs of the contract you both signed what the rights and responsibilities are. So I can’t comment on specifics. But generally you can’t terminate her contract without compensating her unless she has breached the contract. The compensation is usually payment for the rest of the contract term…so she’d get the full 10 weeks pay and no, she wouldn’t have to work any of that time past the termination date.

But again, I don’t know what you had her sign. But the way you are talking it sounds like you had her sign an employment contract, making her an employee.

Did you do this? and tried to put in that she is “self-employed on an FTC” to avoid employment law and taxes?

You need to watch out because if HMRC rules that she was an employee and not a self-employed contractor you would be liable for things like NI payments.

You must be a troll, purposefully trying to wind me up with nonesense 😂😂

There is no other explanation for this level of ineptitude. So haha good laugh, let’s move on from this sci fi !!

OP posts:
Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 15:23

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 13:23

We were a bit nervous about this, and wondered if that might be why the baby was so unsettled with the first nanny. However… the nanny we have since hired did a trial with her (I’ve learned my lesson) and DD was happy, giggly, smiley all day. Not one cry, not one tantrum! I work on a different level and do not hover/interrupt! So hopefully this works, if not I would rather go back to the office than further disrupt DD childcare routine so I’ll have to cross this bridge if it comes to it.

You have already hired a replacement and had a trial?

So when did you first start to have misgivings? Must have been on day 1?

Discovereads · 21/10/2022 15:21

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 15:11

Same difference for employees/self employed.

Again… not relevant to me as I’ve decided how to handle it per countless posts above. But for other people in a similar situation a contract is a contract. If you have a contractual notice period, it clearly states that the notice is for both parties.
If a employee/contractor/other self employed person chooses not to work the notice in the contract… then they won’t get paid or provided a reference!

and yes… before you say it… self employed nannies do still ask you to provide a reference.

The previous post before said ‘she doesn’t have to work her notice as it doesn’t apply to her… we it does if a) she wants to be paid for it and b) if the contract stipulates it relates to both parties!

so where exactly is the difference??

“Same difference for employees/self employed.” is completely incorrect.

It really depends on the T&Cs of the contract you both signed what the rights and responsibilities are. So I can’t comment on specifics. But generally you can’t terminate her contract without compensating her unless she has breached the contract. The compensation is usually payment for the rest of the contract term…so she’d get the full 10 weeks pay and no, she wouldn’t have to work any of that time past the termination date.

But again, I don’t know what you had her sign. But the way you are talking it sounds like you had her sign an employment contract, making her an employee.

Did you do this? and tried to put in that she is “self-employed on an FTC” to avoid employment law and taxes?

You need to watch out because if HMRC rules that she was an employee and not a self-employed contractor you would be liable for things like NI payments.

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 15:19

jannier · 21/10/2022 12:44

Why doubt the care. It is very possible to treat the children equally once they are independent in basic feeding etc. If you don't you shouldn't be with children. I guess you don't like childminders?

I’m not talking about care @jannier
It would be a cruel person that didn’t treat your own child the same as the child you are nannying the same in terms of feeding them, ensuring they are warm, clean, well fed and entertained.

I am talking about when there is an accident / an emergency / you need to grab to get them away from a vehicle / you need to tend to them if both fall badly from tree etc.

Would you honestly not instinctively go to your own child without hesitation irrespective of who is closer

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 15:16

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 21/10/2022 12:16

You're not a company so you don't need notice. You can fire her on the spot. Just enter into text what you said in your OP, and then send it to her, ie:

Hello, I am very sorry to say this but I feel our arrangement isn't working out. My daughter is 9 months, yours is 6 months so their needs are fairly similar in terms of eating/napping/playing and I had no problems you bringing your child with you. However, the problem is I feel that you can’t seem to take any initiative, when you feed (insert your baby's name) you she need me to make it up, you then feed your own baby and I'm left feeding while I should be working. My baby cries frequently through the day, when she wakes up early from her nap you rarely get her back down because you're busy seeing to your own child. I never see you holding, cuddling or focusing on (baby's name) in any meaningful way.
We feel you juggling two babies is harder than we anticipated and therefore don't feel it's working out, so we are letting her go. We already have alternative childcare lined up. I am willing to transfer (pro rata amount) into your account. We hope you understand.

I’m guessing your approach is “why use a dozen words when you could write a novel”?

Endlesslysurprised84 · 21/10/2022 15:13

Jb2182 · 21/10/2022 11:58

I'm a nanny. I've been taking my own DD to work with me since she was 9 months (children I look after were 3 and also 9 months). I now take both my DC with me and have been with the family for 4 years. It does work.

Yes I imagine it does work for you.

however would buy out honestly treat all children the same in the event of an accident or hazard when all in need of very urgent attention from you?

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 15:11

Discovereads · 21/10/2022 15:05

But everything you are saying applies to employees.

You said the nanny was self-employed and on a fixed term contract. So she is a self-employed contractor, not an employee.

So by “letting her go” you are technically terminating the contract you have with her. You aren’t “dismissing” an employee.

Same difference for employees/self employed.

Again… not relevant to me as I’ve decided how to handle it per countless posts above. But for other people in a similar situation a contract is a contract. If you have a contractual notice period, it clearly states that the notice is for both parties.
If a employee/contractor/other self employed person chooses not to work the notice in the contract… then they won’t get paid or provided a reference!

and yes… before you say it… self employed nannies do still ask you to provide a reference.

The previous post before said ‘she doesn’t have to work her notice as it doesn’t apply to her… we it does if a) she wants to be paid for it and b) if the contract stipulates it relates to both parties!

so where exactly is the difference??

OP posts:
jannier · 21/10/2022 15:09

Idontevenknow · 21/10/2022 13:44

What on earth has that got to do with anything in this conversation? I was merely saying that I can understand why the OP originally thought it was a good idea. I agreed it wasn't. Why are you raving about spoons

Becouse you also said nursery workers work find with a 1 to 2 ratio....they often don't and often actually have more to physically care for why staff tidy up etc. The feeding is one example of even its not fine. I've been in many nurseries over 30 years and cared on my own with twins and triplets. It's not ideal hence why childminder ratios are 1 under 1 ......but why are you being so rude I'm not raving about anything?

Discovereads · 21/10/2022 15:05

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 14:13

So… a few things

  1. I’ve already said in a previous post that I’m going to call, and going to pay notice in lieu
  2. however, ordinarily a notice period is provided to protect both parties. If an employee chooses not to work contracted notice then the contractual obligation to pay that notice is also void.
  3. and finally, I can require her to work her notice, as can any employer. It’s the point of a contract. If an employee chooses not to fulfil their contractual obligations to work their notice then they cannot expect pay for that period or a reference!

above not relevant to me as I’ve already said I will pay in lieu, but thought you should know you are completely wrong on all points, just in case you try to repeat it!

But everything you are saying applies to employees.

You said the nanny was self-employed and on a fixed term contract. So she is a self-employed contractor, not an employee.

So by “letting her go” you are technically terminating the contract you have with her. You aren’t “dismissing” an employee.

RoseGoldEagle · 21/10/2022 14:22

I’d send a text saying ‘can we arrange a time to have a chat, ideally as soon as possible?’ So she has warning it will be something like that, then explain on the phone you just don’t feel it’s working. I wouldn’t want her back, but appreciate if you need the childcare until you get something else sorted you might have to.

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 14:13

Discovereads · 21/10/2022 13:49

I would not text to someone that they are sacked. I would call and send an email. Also

We ultimately will still see her and deal with her whilst she’s working her notice

I don’t think a person you have sacked on the spot after only a few weeks owes you any work for their notice period. The notice period is when they wish to resign, not if you’re sacking them. So I don’t think you can legally require her to work after you’ve sacked her.

So… a few things

  1. I’ve already said in a previous post that I’m going to call, and going to pay notice in lieu
  2. however, ordinarily a notice period is provided to protect both parties. If an employee chooses not to work contracted notice then the contractual obligation to pay that notice is also void.
  3. and finally, I can require her to work her notice, as can any employer. It’s the point of a contract. If an employee chooses not to fulfil their contractual obligations to work their notice then they cannot expect pay for that period or a reference!

above not relevant to me as I’ve already said I will pay in lieu, but thought you should know you are completely wrong on all points, just in case you try to repeat it!

OP posts:
Discovereads · 21/10/2022 13:49

I would not text to someone that they are sacked. I would call and send an email. Also

We ultimately will still see her and deal with her whilst she’s working her notice

I don’t think a person you have sacked on the spot after only a few weeks owes you any work for their notice period. The notice period is when they wish to resign, not if you’re sacking them. So I don’t think you can legally require her to work after you’ve sacked her.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 21/10/2022 13:46

TweetnDour · 21/10/2022 10:04

What unfair dismissal? She's self employed not an employee of the op.

From the situation described she is far more likely to be an employee than self employed.

Idontevenknow · 21/10/2022 13:44

jannier · 21/10/2022 13:22

Having assessed in many baby rooms I can tell you I've seen many times when staff have used same spoon busy talking about other things like their personal life.

What on earth has that got to do with anything in this conversation? I was merely saying that I can understand why the OP originally thought it was a good idea. I agreed it wasn't. Why are you raving about spoons

eveoha · 21/10/2022 13:43

I am absolutely appalled at the way you are discussing another human being - it makes me fear for the future if this is how unfeeling and insensitive people are - I dare say you all pay lipservice to the ‘be kind’ dictum - sham in you all 😡☘️

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 21/10/2022 13:43

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:58

She’s been with us for 2 weeks not 2 years. She’s also self employed on a FTC.
so not relevant in any way.

Self employed? Really. I very much doubt that is the case.

You might call it that as it saves you paying employer's NI contributions but how much autonomy does she have?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 21/10/2022 13:37

Text and offer to follow up with a call if she wants to discuss.

I'm a twin mum and I think the "Oh she couldn't possibly cope!" stuff is nonsense really. Especially for an experienced nanny who has dealt with multiple children together. I'm not even sure it's my twin experience clouding my judgment - before I had these two I did a childcare swap with a friend and each of us had the other's (literally) 6 month old + their own for three hour blocks while the other worked. It was absolutely fine. And that was me as a new mum and with the other child being, er, on the more challenging side.

She just sounds a bit crap.

Excited101 · 21/10/2022 13:35

A nanny with own child can (and does) work just fine, it’s very common. A decent nanny will do their job with the same amount of professionalism. It sounds like you’ve got a bit of a rubbish nanny there op, and I would think a text would be fine. Less awkward for both of you if she has time to process.

You’ve done nothing wrong, don’t let it put you off.

Liz1tummypain · 21/10/2022 13:31

Texting seems cowardly

LondonWolf · 21/10/2022 13:30

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 09:56

I did think of that but I know I won’t be able to articulate my reasons as clearly over the phone. It’s also bloody awkward “hi - we’re letting you go”!
mat least by text she can read, absorb and then respond. We ultimately will still see her and deal with her whilst she’s working her notice so I’d like the exchange to be considered… I don’t want to put her on the spot over the phone and make it super awkward!

I'd prefer a text for the reasons you've stated here.

Newmum0322 · 21/10/2022 13:23

ItsNotReallyChaos · 21/10/2022 13:12

Just to echo what others said, if I could press rewind I would not have DD being looked after in the house while I was working in the house. It's too confusing for the baby. They know you're there so they want YOU. You either need to work away from the house or have childcare out of the house.

Or make a work area for you that is so separate from where your baby will be that there is a physical separation so that to the baby it doesn't feel like you're there.

I haven't rtft so apologies if you've already covered this.

We were a bit nervous about this, and wondered if that might be why the baby was so unsettled with the first nanny. However… the nanny we have since hired did a trial with her (I’ve learned my lesson) and DD was happy, giggly, smiley all day. Not one cry, not one tantrum! I work on a different level and do not hover/interrupt! So hopefully this works, if not I would rather go back to the office than further disrupt DD childcare routine so I’ll have to cross this bridge if it comes to it.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread