Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My girls hate their SM

154 replies

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:04

I am a rubbish parent just dropped off 2 DDs at breakfast club the youngest in tears. They are at there dads this weekend and they hate there SM.
I had a good thing with there dad when we seperated still parented well went out for dinners. Then he met his new wife and she stopped everything. My DDs see there dad two weekends a month and he picks them up from school two nights a week he's a good dad just a rubbish husband. What can I say to my DDs that makes them feel better I can't believe he chooses his new wife over his kids.The girls are 13 and 15.

OP posts:
hardtochangename · 21/10/2022 09:43

Your DDs are used to things being different and now have to grow up a bit more and adjust to new arrangements. You can help them with that. Family dinners might be understandable for special occasions but as a regular event that seems to be perpetuating a falsity. Your ex has a new life and has a home with a new wife, she's going to be there when your DDs go round. What is she doing exactly that's so terrible?

Novum · 21/10/2022 09:42

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:42

She would not want him to come to my house alone and I don't want him in my house. They want to see there dad just not her.

But that simply isn't going to happen, and crying won't change it. They need to get used to the fact that she is in their dad's life and, if they want a relationship with him, they need to accept that.

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 09:42

HeddaGarbled · 21/10/2022 08:11

He sees them every other weekend and two nights a week. In what way is he choosing his new wife over his kids? Stop stirring.

This. It's pretty normal to not want to play happy families and go for dinners if you have moved on and remarried. You are definitely stirring Here by saying you can't believe he has done this. They probably get some of the issue from you.

beachcitygirl · 21/10/2022 09:41

Hmmm

A bit of both here & we don't know enough to go on.

OP you need to "allow" your kids to like stepmum.

But

I'd be having a round the table chat with my daughters.
Do they have their own space in dads home?
Do they get to spend alone time with dad or is stepmum there every minute.
Does she do anything unkind or rude
Does she obviously prioritise her kids & make them feel second best.

If none of the above is the problem then YOU are the problem.

Realityloom · 21/10/2022 09:40

LittleOwl153 · 21/10/2022 09:33

I couldn't read and run on this one as I was your 13yr old....

Slightly different in that dad never had space for us to stay - or just didn't want us to. So we used to get 1 weekend day. It was awful. To the point that by the time I was 17/18 I dropped contact and didn't see much of him for 20 years. These days we tolerate each other but...

In terms of your girls. I'd ask outright if there is any nasty business going on. They are old enough to understand what you mean and even if they don't open up straight thevway they will know youbare open to hearing any real problems. Beyond that I think you do have to get over the fact that he's moved on. My mother still holds grudges and that did impact me and probably still does. I will always be loyal to her.

Talk to your girls about what they can get out of the time with him. Is there things nearby he will take them too, do they have friends nearby they can go visit? You don't say how close they are to you but secondary often have big catchments. They need to build something of a life in his area. You cannot change them going if you are relying on that for work so talk to them try and help them make the best of it. Do you work nights? I'm wondering if it is truly necessary for them to be with him overnight if they really don't want to be. Ultimately though at their ages they do not have to go so maybe you need to start looking at your plans to accommodate that before much longer.

Try talking to them on Monday and see what they did, try and get the positives from they visit. They will be negative before they go but hopefully more positive afterwards. That will give you a more balanced view.

When I read the title of OP I thought she was speaking about little girls of 6 and 8 years old. OP is projecting onto her TEENS. I worked at 16 and caught 2 buses to get to work each way. I would come home at 10pm at night sometimes. I loved it and its made me fiercely independent. The court would not advise OP forcing her DDs to go to their dads if one of them is unhappy regardless of ANY job.

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:40

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 21/10/2022 09:12

Err, your thread title? Confused

My thread title does not say I hate her. I have said hate is to strong for me to say they don't like her.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 21/10/2022 09:37

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:33

I am talking to them Zero and trying to find out if there a bigger problem. Im not goading them to dislike her but I don't like her and maybe they pick up on it.

Too bloody right they pick up on it. This sounds like pure jealousy because your ex is happy with someone else.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 21/10/2022 09:37

Have you tried speaking to their father about this? He needs to know just how unhappy they are.

ITookABathWithAinsleyHarriott · 21/10/2022 09:37

Reverse*

ITookABathWithAinsleyHarriott · 21/10/2022 09:34

@youngestisapsycho I suspect it’s because there is no real reason they dislike her.

My DH’s ex was fine with me until we got engaged and bought a home together (5 years into dating so definitely not rushed). She then tried to alienate my SDs from me who were 11 & 15 at the time and I’d previously had a lovely relationship with them.

I had them saying things like “
Mum said it’s unfair we don’t have the biggest bedroom”
”Mum said dad doesn’t take us out as much anymore”
”Mum said dad wouldn’t let her have the key to the house to use the washing machine because hers is broken”.

They don’t have the biggest bedroom because my DD is a full time resident of the house and all her worldly possessions need room to store them. SDs stay a max of 8 nights a month.

Dad was in a shit tonne of debt when I met him, mostly pertaining to the ridiculous sums of money he was spending on the other household so their mum could choose not to work. I told him I wouldn’t marry him or buy a home with him whilst he was in debt so he tightened his belt and sorted out his finances. This has also brought long term stability to his children.

No, we were not willing to allow their mum to have a key to our house and free reign of our appliances. We did however offer to pick up the kids washing and drop it back clean.

Because of this, his ex tried poison her kids against me with sly comments and twisting things to fit her own agenda.

At 11 & 15 (now 13 & 17) they were old enough to be told the truth from our perspective and luckily we were able to reserve a lot of the damage.

We are now married and his ex still tries to feed into any perceived drama by encouraging the girls to dislike me. She can’t see that the only people she is hurting by doing this are her own children.

I really hope for your daughters’ sakes that your ex can sit them down and have a mature conversation about things and then hopefully they’ll realise how bizarre your reaction to their SM is.

LittleOwl153 · 21/10/2022 09:33

I couldn't read and run on this one as I was your 13yr old....

Slightly different in that dad never had space for us to stay - or just didn't want us to. So we used to get 1 weekend day. It was awful. To the point that by the time I was 17/18 I dropped contact and didn't see much of him for 20 years. These days we tolerate each other but...

In terms of your girls. I'd ask outright if there is any nasty business going on. They are old enough to understand what you mean and even if they don't open up straight thevway they will know youbare open to hearing any real problems. Beyond that I think you do have to get over the fact that he's moved on. My mother still holds grudges and that did impact me and probably still does. I will always be loyal to her.

Talk to your girls about what they can get out of the time with him. Is there things nearby he will take them too, do they have friends nearby they can go visit? You don't say how close they are to you but secondary often have big catchments. They need to build something of a life in his area. You cannot change them going if you are relying on that for work so talk to them try and help them make the best of it. Do you work nights? I'm wondering if it is truly necessary for them to be with him overnight if they really don't want to be. Ultimately though at their ages they do not have to go so maybe you need to start looking at your plans to accommodate that before much longer.

Try talking to them on Monday and see what they did, try and get the positives from they visit. They will be negative before they go but hopefully more positive afterwards. That will give you a more balanced view.

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2022 09:31

She didn’t stop the meals. He did. If you’d got a boyfriend first you’d probably have done the same. You haven’t so you’re fixating on your ex’s behaviour being someone else’s responsibility.

Why would she be loving towards them? What would that even look like? They don’t even want her to be in her own home two weekends a month. Based on their strong feelings and your clear vendetta I can’t imagine they’re very nice to her. She probably tolerates them and is happy he takes them out alone.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 21/10/2022 09:29

Oh and as others have said, it's not just his house. It's their house.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 21/10/2022 09:28

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:00

Mrs Keats she stopped our family dinners together. He does see them on his own its when they go to his house and she's there that they don't like it.

Why shouldn't she? You aren't a family anymore. You are now two separate family units. You need to remind your children of that. Your ex is entitled to move on and find someone else. It doesn't matter how fast it was. You weren't together.

SusanKennedy · 21/10/2022 09:25

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:00

Mrs Keats she stopped our family dinners together. He does see them on his own its when they go to his house and she's there that they don't like it.

It's not his house that she happens to be in though is it...

It's their house. They are married. You need to get over that and stop projecting it onto your kids.

He sees them without her, she's nice to them (why would she just automatically love them because she married their dad?) I don't see any reason for them to dislike her except you disliking her.

Aussiegirl88 · 21/10/2022 09:25

"what can I say to my DD's to make them feel better"????

Well....... You should Starr by looking inward because the disdain and bitterness is oozing from you and That's very likely the root cause of this issue. Grow up foe the sake of your children and teach them its ok for people to split up and find happiness in others. Regardless of their behaviour or their feelings the outcome is never going to change so you can help facilitate all the resentment or help them grow into respecting their dad, his life and his happiness just as you would expect they would with yours!

if you got a new man and your Dds didn't like him or want a bar of him but you were deservingly happy and in love would you leave him??? I think that's what you mean when you say "putting his wife before his children" right? he's not leaving his wife to make his children happy???

Stop the nonsense for the sake of your children, you are tainting something that could be a nice relationship for them, their SM and their dad

DialsMavis · 21/10/2022 09:25

Ooh @SleeplessInEngland did you get a little thrill pointing out the OP's typo/grammar issue? I hope it set you up for a good day full of positive vibes.

OP, I think at their age that if SM isn't mean to the girls then you sit them down and explain that it is what it is, and that the situation is hard on everyone and they need and will benefit from a pleasant, civil relationship with SM and it is in their power to have that. Be the adult here and be positive about the situation to your DDs and help them learn to make the best of a situation that they didnt choose to be in. It is a very useful life skill to have (I say this as someone that this doesn’t come naturally too and have had to learn later in life than I could have).

AssumingDirectControl · 21/10/2022 09:24

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:57

I didn't say I hate her. Hate is to strong they don't like her.

It’s in the thread title.

It sounds to me like you’re resentful that the family dinners have stopped, your daughters have unreasonable expectations of your relationship with their dad - through no fault of theirs, this is for you to manage - and they’re very aware of how you feel. Again that’s something for you to manage.

decafsoyaflatwhite · 21/10/2022 09:24

RedRec · 21/10/2022 09:17

And here it is. The attitude of most stepmothers who post on here. Very depressing.

So given that their dad does spend time with them alone (would be a different scenario if he didn’t), what exactly do you think should happen other than for them to suck it up?

And this isn’t intended to sound confrontational. Frustrated maybe, but not confrontational!

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 21/10/2022 09:24

They sound very young for their age. Why can’t you go to work and have them at home? Unless theirs special needs or SS involvement why wouldn’t you be able to leave teenagers

youngestisapsycho · 21/10/2022 09:20

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:00

Mrs Keats she stopped our family dinners together. He does see them on his own its when they go to his house and she's there that they don't like it.

You haven't really said why they don't like being around her.... is she mean to them? does she just ignore them? does she stop their dad doing fun things with them? I think you need a good chat with your girls and their dad to see what the actual issue is.

Seaweed42 · 21/10/2022 09:17

So nothing has changed in the arrangements except that you don't have family dinners out anymore, just the four of you.
Could you have a dinner now with the five of you. Or can you not stand being in her presence?
They might get to like her if you can endorse her more. That would be best for them in the long run.

RedRec · 21/10/2022 09:17

KangarooKenny · 21/10/2022 08:07

Then they suck it up.

And here it is. The attitude of most stepmothers who post on here. Very depressing.

decafsoyaflatwhite · 21/10/2022 09:16

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:00

Mrs Keats she stopped our family dinners together. He does see them on his own its when they go to his house and she's there that they don't like it.

She’s his wife. It’s not ‘his’ house, it’s her house too.

You really need to have a serious talk with them. They’re too old for this!

Dixiechickonhols · 21/10/2022 09:16

Can they access some counselling via school to discuss their feelings.
At their ages it’s their decision. If they’d rather see dad alone sometimes that is doable.
It’s normal life moves on having dinner together is confusing and not the norm when separated. I wonder if they haven’t fully processed separation or were hoping you’d rekindle if you were playing happy families.