Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No presents please, fed up with shite!

63 replies

Catsanddog · 21/10/2022 00:54

So I have a November birthday and family of 6 children and hubby. I have fairly simple tastes and definitely not extravagant but every Birthday/Christmas I'm so disappointed that I've told them not to buy me anything this year. Examples are new purse- no coin compartment so useless to me. Slippers, pj's and dressing gown - all wrong sizes. I like Sanctuary products and they always buy " wannabe" you-know similar colour and branding but not actual! Earrings- I chose exact pair and told daughter which shop to buy from knowing budget allowed last year - smaller pair appeared for birthday and lost their gold after a few weeks as only gold plated. Same box of chocolates every bloody year!! They do not exchange the items or provide receipts so I can get something that fits or that I actually like so I've said really don't bother and they think I'm ungrateful. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
sheepdogdelight · 21/10/2022 09:28

Gift-giving is supposed to be about someone buying something for you. Something that they think you will enjoy or like. The very act of giving you a gift is a display that they love and care about you.

How is giving someone a gift they don't want, a display that they love and care about you? If anything, it's the opposite. If they love and care for you, they would get you something you did want. Or nothing, if that's what you'd specified.

TheHonourableHonoriaGlossop · 21/10/2022 09:27

user1477391263 · 21/10/2022 06:36

Just to add. I go over and above to find something unexpected for each of them that they all love!!

That's nice, but not everyone is good at present giving. Also, you don't necessarily know that they love what you give them. Most people are good at faking gift-joy.

How about suggesting that the kids take on an extra chore each for your "birthday week" or something of that kind, and suggest to your husband that he just takes you out to dinner instead.

I don't want tangible "gifts" either, and find the idea of getting them a bit weird, as an adult. I don't need clutter and would rather choose my own stuff.

I'm sorry but this is such rubbish.
What you mean is "some people can't be bothered to put the thought and effort into being good at gift giving ". I thought the PP who said her DH suddenly got very considerate and thoughtful when she bought him generic, thoughtless presents pretty much summed it up.

I don't buy the "Dh was very disappointed when he realised they were gold plated". He'd have realised that from the cost.

sheepdogdelight · 21/10/2022 09:25

I'm with you OP - I hate getting gifts that I don't really want - it just makes more work for me in working out what to do with them. It does seem that there is a current prevalent view that gift giving is more for the gift giver's benefit than for the recipient's, whereas surely it should be mostly for the recipient's benefit, or the gift giver isn't really doing something nice.

I provide a list of simple, inexpensive items that I am happy and delighted to receive. I have trained my husband and children to not go off piste - or at least to realise that if they do, I reserve the right not to like it (and they know to keep receipts!).

I know that lots will say this is "sucking the joy out of gift giving", but I get to receive something I want; and my family know that I will like it and that I'm not that bothered if they don't get me anything.

now I just need to train my parents who spend a small fortune on things that I have no use for and won't take "please don't buy me gifts" as the end of the conversation

CulturePigeon · 21/10/2022 09:20

I'm sorry, OP, I don't mean to be mean but...

I just don't get the fuss over presents when you're an adult. It's so unimportant!

If you want something, buy it yourself. And I don't get the 'tell people exactly what you want, get them to wrap it up and then unwrap it on your birthday' business. It wouldn't be a surprise, and there would be no element of input from the giver - it would just be a mechanical transaction.

Children - yes - presents are magical and special, and usually they don't have the power to obtain things themselves. But I don't understand why adults set such store by presents. Get what you want yourself and let people give you token presents chosen by them - and do the same for them. Works much better!

StrataZon · 21/10/2022 09:13

Needmorelego · 21/10/2022 01:40

Write a clear and simple wish list, hand it over and say "I would like a selection of things from this list. Nothing different or alternative please. Just from this list"

This^
In our house (DH, me, 2 older teens) we compile a list with a selection of things at different prices we would like and links to them. If I see something in a shop I take a photo of it. I'v just started my Christmas list!
We can also share the list with extended family members who may ask for ideas.
That way we get the surprise gift but it's something we actually want.

Mary46 · 21/10/2022 09:05

Agree with you op. Im January get everyones xmas recycled ha. Just zero thought in it. I stop friends birthdays after this.

Catsanddog · 21/10/2022 08:18

Thanks for all the responses.

OP posts:
Malbecfan · 21/10/2022 08:14

I'm another "sending links" person. TBF DH tries his best and sometimes does a great job, but he routinely fails to think about Christmas until 23rd December. The DDs are now adults so they also remind him regularly. Most things on the list are in the £10 - £15 region so everyone is happy.

Brefugee · 21/10/2022 07:25

Tell them that you want something of this list - give them links to the EXACT products. Say the words "off this list or nothing"

Then ask them to tell you what you have given them and if they're shitty and not right or if they are fantastic and lovely. Maybe you're not as right about what you've given them? or maybe they will realise they're being shitty.

KangarooKenny · 21/10/2022 06:57

I know how you feel. Even saying that you don’t want anything doesn’t work. It’s very frustrating and wasteful.
I’ve put things straight in the charity beg before now, and they still don’t get the message !

ny20005 · 21/10/2022 06:52

I'm with @Tadpoll, it's the waste I can't stand

My kids are only teens so I don't ever say anything. My dh doesn't bother about his own birthday so genuinely doesn't think that anyone else sees differently to him.

I've had conversations so we now don't buy presents for each other & just go out for dinner or away for a weekend.

Tadpoll · 21/10/2022 06:50

user1497787065 · 21/10/2022 06:27

Are you 6?

Just be grateful or otherwise tell them not to buy presents. Simple.

Read the OP. She’s told them not to bother and they think she’s ungrateful.

PorridgewithQuark · 21/10/2022 06:50

I think a different approach is needed to an 11 year old than a husband of 20+ years!

Parents should certainly be delighted with what children buy them of their own free will with their pocket money and not criticise or make the child who's bought a present for the adult feel crap.

With a very long term partner yes, I think you can be honest as you're putting effort into his present in return but I wouldn't be so sure everyone else is as delighted as you think with what you choose them - I notice you don't mention buying them gifts "to order" the way you want them to do for you and wonder whether the buying for others (especially trips away which you get to enjoy equally with the recipient) is something that you derive pleasure from so that you're getting more out of the giving end than the others, who perhaps are simply less invested in both gift giving and receiving than you.

Tadpoll · 21/10/2022 06:48

Henryhooveredoff · 21/10/2022 06:37

I'm in the 'If it's not right don't bother' camp.

If it was Jill who I've only worked in the office with for five years then I could understand that they don't get it quite right.

When it's your husband and family who you've lived with for at least 20 years, they should know you well enough by now to know you don't want tat. Or at least be capable of looking in a wardrobe and working out what size clothes you wear!

Agree.

Tadpoll · 21/10/2022 06:47

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/10/2022 02:32

I don't know, I find it hard to agree with all of this tbh.

Gift-giving is supposed to be about someone buying something for you. Something that they think you will enjoy or like. The very act of giving you a gift is a display that they love and care about you.

I don't really like or agree with the culture of "if I don't get exactly what I want then don't bloody bother". If that was the case, then they might as well just all give you cash so you can buy what you want - but that sucks out the very soul of gift-giving.

It's about the principle really, especially when children are involved. Some people are naturally good at giving gifts - others, not so much. It doesn't mean that they don't care but it's a skill that isn't easy to master if you're not a natural.

It sounds to me like they've really tried to get you something they think you'll like. It's not as if you've been given a tea towel or a new kitchen spoon! The fact it's not 100% right is a shame but hardly cause to throw your toys out of the pram. That just sounds a bit spoilt, if you want my honest opinion.

I agree with you, but it’s the waste I can’t stand.

OP would probably rather get a tea towel, because at least then she could use it.

OP I’m with you - I have a parent who spends a lot on me but they are things I just do not want and will never use. I’d rather have nothing because it is stressful and I feel guilty about the item and the waste of money.

Pinkychilla · 21/10/2022 06:42

You need to point out to your husband how hurtful and throughtless it is especially compared to the gifts you have given him he is just lazy and quite selfish really and can easily guide the kids to getting the right thing, And also making an effort at making your birthday a bit special think you need to say yes I like this dressing gown/slippers but I can't wear them as completely the wrong size seems it's always the mum who ends up with this but you do need to say so they know it's not acceptable way to give gifts and hopefully be easily rectified for this time and if not id not bother with his !

Henryhooveredoff · 21/10/2022 06:37

I'm in the 'If it's not right don't bother' camp.

If it was Jill who I've only worked in the office with for five years then I could understand that they don't get it quite right.

When it's your husband and family who you've lived with for at least 20 years, they should know you well enough by now to know you don't want tat. Or at least be capable of looking in a wardrobe and working out what size clothes you wear!

user1477391263 · 21/10/2022 06:36

Just to add. I go over and above to find something unexpected for each of them that they all love!!

That's nice, but not everyone is good at present giving. Also, you don't necessarily know that they love what you give them. Most people are good at faking gift-joy.

How about suggesting that the kids take on an extra chore each for your "birthday week" or something of that kind, and suggest to your husband that he just takes you out to dinner instead.

I don't want tangible "gifts" either, and find the idea of getting them a bit weird, as an adult. I don't need clutter and would rather choose my own stuff.

user1497787065 · 21/10/2022 06:27

Are you 6?

Just be grateful or otherwise tell them not to buy presents. Simple.

Aprilx · 21/10/2022 06:26

I honestly cannot see the point in telling my DH exactly what to buy me or asking him for cash or a gift voucher. I might as well just buy what I want as we share money anyway.

I am the organiser in our house and I would be just as likely to book a theatre trip for my birthday as I would for his. I don’t see why he needs to do it for me.

Some of what you say sounds weird, like buying things in the wrong size, but I generally cannot think along the lines of “get me exactly what I want or don’t bother”.

AlmostOver22 · 21/10/2022 06:21

I’m not really into gift giving. It’s so wasteful for the occasional thing that people actually use and there are loads of ways of showing love and appreciation for someone.

lentilly · 21/10/2022 06:21

Your DH is useless. You need to explain to him how upsetting it is to be asked exactly what you want to then be given something different. It's worse than being given something else entirely. Maybe don't give your kids any ideas and see what they come up with?

huuskymam · 21/10/2022 06:19

My dh and 2 adult kids are disasters for picking presents for me. I send them links to what I actually want. They're all quite happy I do it, takes the pressure off them.

Bramblejoos · 21/10/2022 06:15

It sounds like they can't bring themselves to spend what it takes - Do you look disappointed when you open the parcel or do you pretend to be pleased?

NumberTheory · 21/10/2022 05:53

My Dh got worse and worse at gift giving. It became really disappointing. The Christmas he took the gift of three books he’d bought me (two of which I already had) and rewrapped them to be one each from him and the kids because he realised two days before Christmas that he’d forgotten to help them get me anything (they were 6) was a low point. I kept going a couple more years but then I just got so annoyed by it I decided not to bother. I still put a lot of effort into the kids presents (and a bit of effort into getting them to get stuff for him, because I think that’s important for them), but my present for him I got generic stuff (and I was late for his birthday).

It only took one year of doing that and he suddenly stepped it up. The last 5 years he’s given me great, thoughtful presents (he doesn’t arrange anything for my birthday because I’ve already done that by the time he comes to ask what I might like - another consequence of being disappointed, but I
m less bothered by that). I’ve gone back to trying to get him thoughtful gifts..

So you could try that, with him and maybe the adult DC. It may not work, but you would probably feel less resentful about it if it didn’t seem so one way.