Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking my manager is hugely insensitive for wearing these things into work?

956 replies

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 21:25

Our department head is very young and glamorous and is fairly new to the company. We know her salary range as it was stated alongside the job advert (a six figure salary whilst the rest of the team are lucky to earn a quarter of that). Every day she swans in to the office like she’s dressed for the catwalk, different designer handbags (the very obvious types - think Gucci, LV etc), Rolex watch, Cartier bracelets, designer belts and shoes. Not to mention the perfect nails, hair and everything else that we just cannot afford these days.

Meanwhile our large team is underpaid and overworked. The recent financial climate means many of us are struggling to heat our homes, worrying about mortgage/rental price hikes and generally having to really cut back. We are all office based and this is something we talk about frequently in conversation, so she’s completely aware of this. She’s previously had the cheek to say that we are all feeling the pinch given the financial situation, which is an absolute insult when she rubs her wealth in our faces 5 days a week.

AIBU in feeling completely incensed by this and wondering how on earth she can think it’s appropriate?! The whole team are upset with this and considering raising it with HR.

OP posts:
OP83 · 21/10/2022 11:02

TheMoops · 21/10/2022 10:50

Being paid more does not mean you work any more.

No but you often have higher qualifications or significant experience. It also often means you have more responsibility.

This is a depressingly common opinion (not just on MN but certainly it's a hot bed).

The sheer distain for anyone who has elevated their own position and/or achieved a level of success is depressing.

The idea always seems to be that anyone in a high position got there through nepotism or sheer good fortune and that everyone on the bottom rung is toiling away all day to 'make the rich richer'.

Whilst this is sometimes the case, dare I say that much of the time, people have worked hard to get to their position (either through academia or career progression). Business owners MIGHT be the child of a millionaire who gave them their start in life OR might have risked everything and worked hard to build a company from scratch.

Likewise this 'nobility in poverty' assertion and the idea that all low-wage staff and slogging their guts our 12 hours a day to pay for the bosses Bentley misses the point. Firstly, I know many people in low-paying jobs that treat their jobs as such. Also (again, with the 'silver spoon' exceptions) many highly paid staff (and business owners) will have paid their dues and, even if they may 'appear' to do less work, their probably reaping the rewards of historic toil.

Hatred of success and successful people is only occasionally justified and, more frequently, is merely jealousy in disguise or regret of a personal path chosen.

Lotusmonster · 21/10/2022 11:01

Xenia · 21/10/2022 10:54

This is an interesting one. Can people be obliged to dress down for work, appear to have clothes from charity shops etc I am not sure it is an HR issue hwoever.

I agree it’s not a HR issue. In fact if HR raised it, I think the boss would probably have grounds herself to raise a grievance. But I do think the boss is possibly showing a slight lack of cultural empathy…there’s a time & place to flash finery and perhaps this workplace isn’t it. The team might be wrong but you can’t argue that the bosses dress choices have created a cold atmosphere.

echt · 21/10/2022 10:58

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:34

Why can OP not exercise her right to try to get this woman sacked? Why does OP have to be the one to leave?

Freedom works all ways - if you think this woman has the right to behave how she wants then OP has the right to address it how she wants.

Let me guess. You are very right wing and you believe an awful lot in rights, but rarely accept that with rights come responsibilities?

  1. Fucking hilarious.
  2. Good luck with getting the manager for sacked for doing absolutely nothing wrong.
  3. Addressing how she wants? That would be the first time MN poster Hmm who bailed several pages ago.
  4. And what responsibilities would this be? And whose?
LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 21/10/2022 10:56

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:34

Why can OP not exercise her right to try to get this woman sacked? Why does OP have to be the one to leave?

Freedom works all ways - if you think this woman has the right to behave how she wants then OP has the right to address it how she wants.

Let me guess. You are very right wing and you believe an awful lot in rights, but rarely accept that with rights come responsibilities?

Nobody has a right to try to get someone sacked when they haven’t broken any rules and are doing their job.
She does have the right to dress how she wants as long as she’s not breaking a dress code.
The OP and her team do not have a right to address this in any way. They don’t get a say in what somebody else wears unless it breaks the dress code.
If anyone has a right to anything here it would be for the manager to not have the team bitching about her, making personal remarks and plotting ways to cause problems for her in the workplace because that’s bullying.

Xenia · 21/10/2022 10:54

This is an interesting one. Can people be obliged to dress down for work, appear to have clothes from charity shops etc I am not sure it is an HR issue hwoever.

GloriousGlory · 21/10/2022 10:53

Lotusmonster · 21/10/2022 10:46

I think the organisational context is important too. I haven’t read back on what OP’s industry sector might be, but if it was a charity for the homeless then, yeah, I can see how having a boss coming in in high value finery all the time might feel a bit weird and kind of disingenuous. Is that the case here?

No this is a bunch of jealous close knit workforce already employed. Nothing about the end client.

TheMoops · 21/10/2022 10:50

Being paid more does not mean you work any more.

No but you often have higher qualifications or significant experience. It also often means you have more responsibility.

GloriousGlory · 21/10/2022 10:50

novalia89 · 21/10/2022 10:03

That's a bit of a dramatic reaction to my comment. In that case, if she already had a very high paying previous job and earnt the money from that (the post makes it sound like it's THIS salary that's the problem, and what THIS salary can buy her), then she can't complain what a previous salary has been able to provide.

You've no need to use capitals we can read without them. Of course it's this salary that's caused the issue, because it's the the jealous OP works at.

I doubt this women went from minimum wage to high flyer and all this is new.

Lotusmonster · 21/10/2022 10:46

I think the organisational context is important too. I haven’t read back on what OP’s industry sector might be, but if it was a charity for the homeless then, yeah, I can see how having a boss coming in in high value finery all the time might feel a bit weird and kind of disingenuous. Is that the case here?

funtycucker · 21/10/2022 10:42

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:34

Why can OP not exercise her right to try to get this woman sacked? Why does OP have to be the one to leave?

Freedom works all ways - if you think this woman has the right to behave how she wants then OP has the right to address it how she wants.

Let me guess. You are very right wing and you believe an awful lot in rights, but rarely accept that with rights come responsibilities?

You have to be a troll

funtycucker · 21/10/2022 10:40

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:25

I do get how it would be VERY hard to bring something like this up with HR, but things that affect company morale are the business of everyone who cares about the company.

Are you being serious? What a person chooses to spend their own money on is of no concern to HR or anyone else within the business unless it's on something illegal or something that affects their performance/ability at work or the reputation and integrity of the company. If she was spending thousands on coke and snorting it off her desk then knock yourself out and speak to HR but otherwise wind your neck in and stop being petty and jealous

BloodyHellKen · 21/10/2022 10:39

user1471538283 · 21/10/2022 10:30

I get it OP. We had a pay freeze for years and our CEO used to tell us all about his three homes in his weekly note. It used to wind me up. Being paid more does not mean you work any more.

Being paid more does not mean you work any more.

No, but quite often it means you've studied harder and gained a higher burden of responsibility so credit where credit is due 🙄

Theblacksheepandme · 21/10/2022 10:38

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:31

OP said "The whole team are upset with this and considering raising it with HR."

I doubt that a simple "slim person wearing fitted clothes" situation would offend.

But if there are a couple of women in the office who aren't particularly slim or attractive, "unlucky in love" types, then if that slim person comes in every day in fitted clothes talking about how wonderful their boyfriend is and how it looks like they might have some modelling work coming up as a side hustle for their friend's lingerie business then I'd be concerned that insensitivity might cause disharmony, and disharmony is likely to reduce productivity and increase staff turnover, other things being equal.

It is hard to see how HR can do much, but surely part of HR's job is to try to minimise staff unhappiness (unless of course they want the staff member gone, in which case it is there job to maximise their unhappiness).

OP never said this person comes into the office bragging. No more than I just asked should a slim person dress in a way to not offend people that are overweight. I actually worked in the office with a girl that did modelling on the side and it never dawned on me to be jealous of her. OP and her work colleagues are jealous of this woman. It is not normal behaviour to go online and check the price of something that someone is wearing.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:34

LindaEllen · 21/10/2022 10:32

She can wear what she wants. It sounds like you're oversensitive. If you don't like it, work someone else, and have the ambition to rise through the ranks.

Why can OP not exercise her right to try to get this woman sacked? Why does OP have to be the one to leave?

Freedom works all ways - if you think this woman has the right to behave how she wants then OP has the right to address it how she wants.

Let me guess. You are very right wing and you believe an awful lot in rights, but rarely accept that with rights come responsibilities?

LindaEllen · 21/10/2022 10:32

She can wear what she wants. It sounds like you're oversensitive. If you don't like it, work someone else, and have the ambition to rise through the ranks.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:31

Theblacksheepandme · 21/10/2022 10:22

Should slim people not wear fitted clothes at work in order to not offend?

OP said "The whole team are upset with this and considering raising it with HR."

I doubt that a simple "slim person wearing fitted clothes" situation would offend.

But if there are a couple of women in the office who aren't particularly slim or attractive, "unlucky in love" types, then if that slim person comes in every day in fitted clothes talking about how wonderful their boyfriend is and how it looks like they might have some modelling work coming up as a side hustle for their friend's lingerie business then I'd be concerned that insensitivity might cause disharmony, and disharmony is likely to reduce productivity and increase staff turnover, other things being equal.

It is hard to see how HR can do much, but surely part of HR's job is to try to minimise staff unhappiness (unless of course they want the staff member gone, in which case it is there job to maximise their unhappiness).

user1471538283 · 21/10/2022 10:30

I get it OP. We had a pay freeze for years and our CEO used to tell us all about his three homes in his weekly note. It used to wind me up. Being paid more does not mean you work any more.

Nanny0gg · 21/10/2022 10:29

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 21:29

You’ve missed the point. It’s not her salary that’s the issue, it’s her insensitively showcasing her wealth in front of us in a very tasteless and excessive way

I'm sorry, but you can't expect her to dress in Primark because you can't afford what she wears.
That's not how it works.

She can wear whatever she likes within the dress code.

Capturetotalelotion · 21/10/2022 10:26

You’d hate where I work! Hahaha, senior people have multiple homes, are dripping in designer and fly private. My boss, who is based outside UK was given a 4 carat diamond by the big boss for her 40th as a bonus. Our clients are even richer and more flashy but I just get on with my low paid role. If you don’t like it, move on to somewhere that fits better with your outlook on life.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:25

meatyryvita · 21/10/2022 10:23

I'm HR and if someone brought this to me, I would genuinely struggle to not laugh out of sheer amazement. As long as she is dressed within the company dresscode, it's none of your business!

I do get how it would be VERY hard to bring something like this up with HR, but things that affect company morale are the business of everyone who cares about the company.

meatyryvita · 21/10/2022 10:23

I'm HR and if someone brought this to me, I would genuinely struggle to not laugh out of sheer amazement. As long as she is dressed within the company dresscode, it's none of your business!

Theblacksheepandme · 21/10/2022 10:22

Should slim people not wear fitted clothes at work in order to not offend?

reigatecastle · 21/10/2022 10:21

I wouldn't even notice what brand people were wearing, I'd just think they looked well put together. Which doesn't take money, my mum looks well put together with charity shop buys.

And who wears a Rolex? You'd spend the whole time worrying that someone was going to mug you for it.

And cars, well people drive expensive cars but they're usually on finance.

You must work in a very odd team to feel like this OP.

Member869894 · 21/10/2022 10:20

Wow!!! good for her! I can't believe you think HR would take you seriously! She can do what she wants with her money. Perhaps you should all stop bitching about her and put your efforts into finding better paid work

YouSirNeighMmmm · 21/10/2022 10:12

Yellowcanary22 · 21/10/2022 10:04

My boss zooms from her lovely house in Richmond with a big view of her sprawling garden.
Im thinking of asking her to start taking meetings from her shed, or to change her background to a landfill site - you know, just to raise team morale a bit.

Clearly these things are on a scale.

If you boss pays your other stuff the absolute bare minimum whilst pleading poverty she is a disgusting person and I hope the staff are deliberately lazy to punish her for her insensitivity.

If she is really nice, pays people fairly or even well, and is generally reasonably humble then it's no issue. She has a nice house.