Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking my manager is hugely insensitive for wearing these things into work?

956 replies

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 21:25

Our department head is very young and glamorous and is fairly new to the company. We know her salary range as it was stated alongside the job advert (a six figure salary whilst the rest of the team are lucky to earn a quarter of that). Every day she swans in to the office like she’s dressed for the catwalk, different designer handbags (the very obvious types - think Gucci, LV etc), Rolex watch, Cartier bracelets, designer belts and shoes. Not to mention the perfect nails, hair and everything else that we just cannot afford these days.

Meanwhile our large team is underpaid and overworked. The recent financial climate means many of us are struggling to heat our homes, worrying about mortgage/rental price hikes and generally having to really cut back. We are all office based and this is something we talk about frequently in conversation, so she’s completely aware of this. She’s previously had the cheek to say that we are all feeling the pinch given the financial situation, which is an absolute insult when she rubs her wealth in our faces 5 days a week.

AIBU in feeling completely incensed by this and wondering how on earth she can think it’s appropriate?! The whole team are upset with this and considering raising it with HR.

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 21/10/2022 05:50

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 23:39

Thanks everyone, some of the comments are getting silly now, so I’m going to dip out.

Everyone in the team has a heart of gold, all genuine hardworking lovely people. We are very close knit team and look out for one another, which is why we don’t like to sit back and watch someone come in and cause unnecessary upset. I would never dream of bullying anyone, nor is it about jealousy, sexism or anything else!!!

You are incredibly jealous and you're team is coming across as a pretty pathetic bunch of people. If anyone went to my HR complaining of this, they'd be told where to go straight away.

Maireas · 21/10/2022 05:46

Ponderingwindow · 21/10/2022 00:29

I would actually consider reporting, but that is because I work in an industry where we are supposed to watch for signs of mismatch between income and spending. It is a sign that the person is either doing something illegal or is incurring debt that will soon create so much pressure that they may do something illegal.

So you would actually report someone for dressing in a particular style, which may have been bought from discount sites or second hand outlets?

TheMoops · 21/10/2022 05:43

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 23:39

Thanks everyone, some of the comments are getting silly now, so I’m going to dip out.

Everyone in the team has a heart of gold, all genuine hardworking lovely people. We are very close knit team and look out for one another, which is why we don’t like to sit back and watch someone come in and cause unnecessary upset. I would never dream of bullying anyone, nor is it about jealousy, sexism or anything else!!!

I've worked with people like you and your so called lovely colleagues.
You have a pack mentality and it's you against 'the management'. It makes it worse that she's young and female. I suspect you wouldn't be like this to an older male colleague who was more senior to you.

If it wasn't her clothes it would be something else.

You all need to grow up.

siucra · 21/10/2022 05:29

Personally, I would concentrate on getting your work done, stop bitching with your colleagues, support your manager and absolutely ignore what she is wearing. It’s none of your business and it’s embarrassing that you would be so jealous and immature. Just get on with your life and stop using the current financial crisis to criticise another woman.

Seashellsrule · 21/10/2022 05:28

Sounds like the horrible group of ladies I used to work with who bullied me because I was younger and earnt more money than them - because guess what I applied for a role that was higher paid and got the job.

women can be so bitchy!

PatientlyWaiting21 · 21/10/2022 05:18

I’m sorry but you just sound bitter and jealous, this isn’t an HR issue this is a yoi issue. There will always be people in life who you meet that will have bigger and better things (in your eyes) it’s how you deal with them.

rwalker · 21/10/2022 05:15

What a spiteful ,vicious and nasty post
Feel sorry for her working in such a bitchy environment

Bpdqueen · 21/10/2022 05:12

I just can't ever imagine caring to this level about what someone else wears, I don't think I'd even notice. You need to focus on your own life and not worry about what others are doing otherwise you will never be happy. In life there will always be people better of then you and worse of then you, just focus on you.

Ekátn · 21/10/2022 05:07

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 20/10/2022 22:44

It's an HR issue for sure - a similar thing happened to one of my former clients (not her, but her business). It was a smallish business, but there were "factory workers" on minimum wage and then the management and "higher ups" who earned significantly more. She found out that one of her "higher ups" had been chatting in the canteen to one of the guys in the factory complaining about how long her Range Rover had been in the workshop, and how she was buying a new house in a very posh area etc etc. My client's view (which I agree with) is that it's bad for morale in a business basically. There should be more discretion when some earn more than others and it shouldn't be rubbed in their staff's faces

I would bet money what happened is that HR told them people were moaning. Told her it was ridiculous but asked her to not mention her Range Rover just to shut people up. And they will have had a laugh about it.

HR are not going to set out rules that you can only talk about your car if it’s worth less than X. Or tell them they can’t buy car over a certain amount. Or not talk about new houses in certain areas. Or what brands they can wear or price brackets for items.

AgapanthusandAcers · 21/10/2022 05:07

I actually see where you are coming from. I know that realistically you cannot tell someone what to wear, if is in keeping with the company dress code. However, I did a temporary role where I got paid more. I never discussed money or said that I having financial woes near payday etc. I agree that it is insensitive and rather tone deaf at the moment when so many are struggling.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/10/2022 04:57

In what way is she 'flaunting' it though... shes wearing clothes.

If simply wearing clothes = flaunting them, I really don't see what you expect her to do - what if she doesn't HAVE any other suitable work wear? I know I only have a couple of suitable 'work' items for outside the house - if you asked me to change those ALL, immediately, I would struggle..

You have a tiny portion of the information - what salary her job was advertised at, and the clothing she wears.

You have none of the details and very few facts - and all she is doing is wearing nice clothes!

If she is walking around the office slagging off other peoples clothing or telling everyone how fabulous her Manolos are and why on EARTH isn't everyone wearing them they're so comfortable dahhhhhhhhling... then yes you might have an issue for HR... it still wouldn't be her clothes, it would be her behaviour.

Nothing you've said so far suggests she is actually rubbing anyones nose in anything, she's just wearing clothes.

Btw do you work in a knicker factory and is your boss called Carla... mmm!

WindyHedges · 21/10/2022 04:48

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 21:33

I suggest reading my post again. Clearly everyone is missing the point entirely. The whole team are upset so I’m not the only one with this opinion

I haven’t misread or misunderstood your post @Mandarinthyme

I just don’t agree with you.

AJ2009 · 21/10/2022 03:50

God OP your post reek of jealousy! And yes your whole team are jealous as well.

So what that she wears designer clothes? I'll never understand why people say 'I can barely afford to heat my home but she buys designer clothes' an example like that.
Why is it on this woman's shoulders that you can't afford something but she can?

I'm sure the other way round if you could afford expensive clothes you would buy them!

If your that bothered go to uni get a qual and find a better job.
If not then shut up!

emptythelitterbox · 21/10/2022 03:29

DahliaBlue · 21/10/2022 03:12

It seems strange that she earns 4 times more than the people she manages directly. In my experience there isn't usually such a big jump between your and your line manager. Something seems amiss in the pay structure. Are there special features of her job that require such a relatively differentiated salary? Does she perhaps have a huge number of reports?You might discuss the pay structure with HR to know why such a big difference in pay between an operative and direct line manager. If her job is just one step up from yours, I also don't see why none of the team would be considered.

I believe OP stated she is a department head, not a line manager.

emptythelitterbox · 21/10/2022 03:28

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 23:39

Thanks everyone, some of the comments are getting silly now, so I’m going to dip out.

Everyone in the team has a heart of gold, all genuine hardworking lovely people. We are very close knit team and look out for one another, which is why we don’t like to sit back and watch someone come in and cause unnecessary upset. I would never dream of bullying anyone, nor is it about jealousy, sexism or anything else!!!

But you're not really.

You've been asked several times but never responded. Why have none of you been promoted or given pay rises or worked towards those?

I've worked with and have the displeasure of managing your type.
Big chip on your shoulder, us against them, crabs in the pot mentality, and not all that good at your job.

DahliaBlue · 21/10/2022 03:12

It seems strange that she earns 4 times more than the people she manages directly. In my experience there isn't usually such a big jump between your and your line manager. Something seems amiss in the pay structure. Are there special features of her job that require such a relatively differentiated salary? Does she perhaps have a huge number of reports?You might discuss the pay structure with HR to know why such a big difference in pay between an operative and direct line manager. If her job is just one step up from yours, I also don't see why none of the team would be considered.

HoppingPavlova · 21/10/2022 03:11

This has to be one of the most ridiculous posts I have ever read.

One of my colleagues and her DH chose not to have kids or pets to facilitate a wealthy lifestyle, and wears very xxy designer pieces and goes on amazing high end holidays and we drool over the pictures. It’s not inappropriate of her and why should she come in non-designer stuff and pretend she is going on another budget holiday? Wearing this stuff makes her happy, and she can, so that’s fine.

Another colleague drips money, parents alive but has a super family trust fund. I think it’s fantastic that instead of sitting on a couch staring at a wall knowing you never have to work and still be very well provided for, she is with us working her arse off like everyone else. She just does it in amazing designer stuff, with an incredibly high end car and also goes on full lux holidays I could only ever dream of. None of that is inappropriate and I could never imagine any of us even thinking like OP let alone going to HR to complain about it to get her to come in budget clothes and an average car and never talk about holiday plans.

The OP and workmates have serious issues they need to work through, none of which involve the manager!

florenceandthemac · 21/10/2022 03:04

That

florenceandthemac · 21/10/2022 03:04

Even if she wasn't earning a 6 figure salary, her husband might be earning a 7 figure salary, allowing her to have these items.
Or another scenario... she could be on the same salary as you, but completely mortgage free / have inheritance, allowing her to wear these things. How would you feel about it then? You couldn't complain to HE for tang

SnowyPetals · 21/10/2022 03:00

Mandarinthyme · 20/10/2022 21:33

I suggest reading my post again. Clearly everyone is missing the point entirely. The whole team are upset so I’m not the only one with this opinion

This is hilarious! Everyone is missing the point?! Maybe nobody agrees with you, because you are being ridiculous?

Stars71 · 21/10/2022 02:53

Remaker · 21/10/2022 01:17

I understand your point OP, although I agree with many other posters that it’s not an HR matter. I’d probably look for another job in your situation if that’s possible.

There’s a difference between wearing quality, well cut clothes and ostentatious shows of wealth.

I’ve worked in community service roles for many years where our clients are not well off and our colleagues (and ourselves) are not well paid. However some of us have more household money from family or partners with well paid jobs. And we wouldn’t dream of wearing obvious designer labels or flashy jewellery to the office. It would be crass and inappropriate. One of my friends removes her engagement ring every day before work because she counsels families who are struggling and doesn’t feel comfortable flashing a big diamond in their faces.

The responses you are receiving are pretty indicative of our society at the moment, where we worship wealth and flaunt it at every opportunity.

So your friend is being disingenuous then. Its OK for her to buy a flashy ring, but only wear it/not wear it to appease. If she felt that moralistic, she wouldn't be wearing flashy stuff, full stop. That also applies to PP, who said she removes her engagement ring for work. Fake people.

BoxOfCats · 21/10/2022 02:49

I'd better tell my HR my boss needs to sell his Audi and buy a Toyota as that's all I can afford to drive.

Stars71 · 21/10/2022 02:47

This gets worse 🙄. Thanks for cheering me up OP. What an rntertaining read, this has been 😅

knittingaddict · 21/10/2022 02:30

I'm really not being funny about this, but I doubt I would notice. I wouldn't recognise a genuine piece of expensive designer stuff if it jumped up and bite me. I certainly wouldn't envy their ability to buy such stuff.

knittingaddict · 21/10/2022 02:25

How odd. A whole group of workers who can't cope when faced with a colleague who earns more than they do in a senior role. How do you all manage in the world?