Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living with other families to reduce costs of living

130 replies

Ohnoohdear · 20/10/2022 18:53

Does anyone with kids here live with another family with kids (or more than one) like friends/family members? I’ve always liked the thought of doing this as I love a busy household and that way rent etc would be cheaper and also could help eachother with child care and be better off financially due to be able to work more.

I come from a large family and grew up with a lot of people. Big dinners, lots of activities and buzz, never really alone. I’ve lived with family members as an adult and it has worked well. I’m now living with my DP and toddler son and feel lonely. I miss being part of a bigger community.

AIBU to think that this may be the way forward as the economy is making it difficult for families to manage? At least temporarily when the kids are in school.

Does anyone have experience with this scenario?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nex18 · 21/10/2022 13:03

I haven’t read the whole thread, replying while lunch heats up.
I can understand the thoughts behind this, the practicalities are a different thing. I have a few friends, we all divorced within a few years of each other and our children were maybe between 8-18 at the time. We did talk about the advantages of sharing a big house between us, sharing childcare, cooking and cleaning, having a friends around when we’re feeling lonely etc. We didn’t take it any further because of the practical issues. All our marriages broke down for similar reasons, disengaged and unsupportive ex husbands who didn’t contribute fully to family life, we knew we’d support each other.

shivawn · 21/10/2022 10:17

@NCAutumn It actually was very clear, I'm not sure how you're still not seeing it. Or why you're so triggered by the whole thing.

lovelypidgeon · 21/10/2022 09:38

I shared houses with friends when I was young and single and loved it, but really couldn't see it working for multiple families with children. Everyone has slightly different rules/expectations for their children and I can see that small differences in parents' approach could become a big problem- I can imagine the arguments from the DC if for example one family allow theirs to have sweets before dinner but the other don't. I think this will get worse as the DC get older- eg. different expectations over doing homework/staying out late/boyfriends or girlfriends staying over/drinking etc

I've had a few holidays with families that I get on really well with and some of these tensions have started to show even just sharing a cottage for a week. Personally I think this would just lead to a breakdown of the friendship.

I think multi generational homes are a bit different (particularly as usually there are only DC from one family). The main problem I've seen with these (there are several in my extended family) is that one person ends up having to do the lions share of the cleaning/cooking/caring etc (usually either the mother or grandmother) whilst everyone else criticises.

What I would really love is informal communal living (a bit like the shared houses of my youth) if I am ever older and widowed. Retirement villages etc are incredibly expensive and can feel a bit institutional but I think 'golden girls' style shared living for older friends would be great.

Applesandcarrots · 21/10/2022 09:35

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 09:32

"There's one on the end of my road for sale with one!"

One. On the end of a road. Yeah, that's not the norm though. I own a few properties and over the years have bought more than I can remember, viewed thousands.

The fact you thought one family would live in the annexe while the other would live in a 3 bedroom part of the house shows you're not getting it. That's not what living together looks like.

No one actually thought that

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 09:32

"There's one on the end of my road for sale with one!"

One. On the end of a road. Yeah, that's not the norm though. I own a few properties and over the years have bought more than I can remember, viewed thousands.

The fact you thought one family would live in the annexe while the other would live in a 3 bedroom part of the house shows you're not getting it. That's not what living together looks like.

Mosaic123 · 21/10/2022 09:27

If the house is a rented one and the families are not related it (in our area anyway) then would be an HMO - a house in multiple occupation - and there are many more regulations to be adhered to on the part of the owner of the property and a special license to be obtained before it can be rented to two families.

If this is not adhered to the landlord could be fined, insurance would be invalid and a buy to let mortgage withdrawn.

DashboardConfessional · 21/10/2022 09:19

Yes they do. I'm a mortgage and home insurance broker. I spend all day long looking into how to get mortgages and insurance on properties with unusual setups. There's one on the end of my road for sale with one! A lot of people convert their garage into a one-space living area with shower room.

Bunnyfuller · 21/10/2022 09:18

I think if this is the cultural norm, and you are born into this type of thing, then I guess it’s ok. Certainly useful around childcare/cooking/cleaning etc.

But I didn’t grow up with that, like quiet and some time to myself. Cannot bear noisy families, noisy kids charging around everywhere.

No thank you

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 09:17

Nobody has a frigging annexe. It's not 1982 🙈

DashboardConfessional · 21/10/2022 09:16

Applesandcarrots · 21/10/2022 09:14

It was clear about the annexes btw

It was, wasn't it? Thanks! 😁

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 09:15

"It was clear about the annexes btw"

Wasn't 🤣

Applesandcarrots · 21/10/2022 09:14

It was clear about the annexes btw

Applesandcarrots · 21/10/2022 09:13

QuizzlyBear · 21/10/2022 08:39

My MIL comes from a Middle Eastern background and this would be her preference, despite living in the UK for more than 40 years.

She's hinted many times but I've played dumb, I know how it would play out and she'd see herself as the 'matriarch' in that situation who controls the household. I'm way too old and comfortable to be living under someone else's roof, even just metaphorically!

Besides, I love my own place, it's my sanctuary...

None of my in laws live with their family in one flat/sharedhouse.
They do however live in basically apartment building with 3-4 flats, each has own flat and they share garden, garage etc.
Now that can work. But having 2 gen in 1 3 bed flat for example would be quite a no.

This type of typical multigen sharing though doesn't really do what op had in mind and saves on bills because everyone has their space, they just meet up for chats and fun, sometimes dinner etc. It is buzzing, but it is still separate living

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 09:10

"Yes it was. I said UK houses aren't set up for it without annexes and "they" (annexes) often only have one bedroom. I have given an example earlier in the thread whereby 2 households fell out over a shared living space.

The "point" is that I don't think sharing a living space would be a pleasant way to live, as many others have said. Who wants to share a bathroom with someone else's kids when they've got a D&V bug?"

🤣 calm down. Have you been hanging round here all night waiting for a response?

Why would I be sharing a bathroom in that situation? Many houses have 2 bathrooms or at least a separate toilet. And it's not very often people have D&V bugs is it? The last one in our house was in 2012 so I think the savings and other benefits would absolutely outweigh that non-issue.

No, it wasn't clear. It read like "UK houses are not made for this and that even with an annexe they usually have one bedroom." I see now what you were saying and how I misread it but it certainly wasn't "clear".

WhatNoRaisins · 21/10/2022 09:10

I'm guessing in societies where this at least appears to work there is a strict social hierarchy where everyone knows their place and what's expected. We don't have this in our society and it would take a long time, generation or more maybe, before we would develop our own.

MissWired · 21/10/2022 08:57

Our houses are not built for multigenerational living, in general.

We're going straight back to the pre-WWI standard of living, with multiple families rammed into tiny houses, paid barely enough to live on and struggling to survive, living in conditions of intense and unbearable stress, with all the physiological and psychological ramifications this will cause.

All thanks to overpopulation.

That would be ill-advised anywhere, but in the great grey death trap that is Britain, it's literally inviting total catastrophe.

Yes folks, it's mid-14th century time again soon. You can see it coming...as if COVID wasn't enough of a warning!

But apparently we need to actually live the lesson, not just read about it. I don't know why, but there it is.

DashboardConfessional · 21/10/2022 08:51

NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 08:42

"Sorry, I mean annexes have 1 bed, clearly. You wouldn't be able to comfortably have one family in the nice 3 bed bit and the other in one bedroom, long term."

It wasn't clear but no, you don't need an annexe to house share 🤣. You wouldn't put one family in the house part and one in the annexe (who has a bloody annexe these days?). The point is that you share the space you have.

Yes it was. I said UK houses aren't set up for it without annexes and "they" (annexes) often only have one bedroom. I have given an example earlier in the thread whereby 2 households fell out over a shared living space.

The "point" is that I don't think sharing a living space would be a pleasant way to live, as many others have said. Who wants to share a bathroom with someone else's kids when they've got a D&V bug?

Expov · 21/10/2022 08:50

you have picked the wrong site to ask. Whilst I think many people would not like it MN is full of people who freak out if people even attempt to converse with them at the school gate.

I think I’m one of the few who could manage this but it wouldn’t be a case of anyone it would be very few people who I could tolerate.

Ohnoohdear · 21/10/2022 08:44

GalesThisMorning · 20/10/2022 20:23

This was my dream when I was a single mother, and lonely. I didn't want a husband but I just wanted to live with another young single mum with 1 kid like me.

No I'm married and have my more children and wouldn't like it, but at the time it seemed like the solution

It could be only temporary for as long as it works, especially during the small kids stage as I’ve always found it easier to look after 3+ kids with another adult than trying to entertain a small toddler all day by myself. And way more fun too! X

OP posts:
NCAutumn · 21/10/2022 08:42

"Sorry, I mean annexes have 1 bed, clearly. You wouldn't be able to comfortably have one family in the nice 3 bed bit and the other in one bedroom, long term."

It wasn't clear but no, you don't need an annexe to house share 🤣. You wouldn't put one family in the house part and one in the annexe (who has a bloody annexe these days?). The point is that you share the space you have.

QuizzlyBear · 21/10/2022 08:39

My MIL comes from a Middle Eastern background and this would be her preference, despite living in the UK for more than 40 years.

She's hinted many times but I've played dumb, I know how it would play out and she'd see herself as the 'matriarch' in that situation who controls the household. I'm way too old and comfortable to be living under someone else's roof, even just metaphorically!

Besides, I love my own place, it's my sanctuary...

cleaningcarpets · 21/10/2022 08:16

Ohnoohdear · 20/10/2022 18:56

We can’t really afford having more than one child so I really grieve the reality of missing out on having a large family!

You could look into fostering. You get paid for it but it could be a way of having the busy house you'd like, while also helping someone else.

starrynight21 · 21/10/2022 08:04

I grew up in a multi-generational household as a child, but it was very much two separate families . My parents and us kids lived upstairs, and my grandmother and her sister lived downstairs.

There was no shared living except for the fact that my mother did some care for my grandmother , and it was nice for us kids to visit granny and auntie downstairs after school. But this is obviously not what you are talking about. If our two households had shared expenses, meals, etc, there would have been world war 3.

I really can't imagine anything worse than your scenario . You probably liked it because you presumably grew up as a child in this set-up. But for the adults I bet there was a lot of resentment under the surface that you didn't know about !

Rewis · 21/10/2022 07:56

I could see this working with the elderly. Group of old people moving together and hiring one nurse/housekeeper/assistant and sharing the costs. I can also see other scenarios where sharing would work .

As for couples with kids permanently? Nah. I mean I can seee the appeal. It would just require so much from the people living together. Everyone doing their share of the housework, finances be on time, respect the space, so many rules about everything. Who is allowed to be when and where. Not asking where others are going. But still negotiating childcare and everything. Just boundaries all around. I wouldn't want to negotiate in my own house. Also, there is a hierarchy often in multigenerational households. But I'm not sure how it would work with friends when there are 4 adults and 4 children.

I can see the theory but not the practicalities.

In the countryside its common for siblings and parents live next door to each other. It works wonderful for some. But it has also caused divorces. But then on the other hand post-divorce she was already living next to her family so had the support.

DashboardConfessional · 21/10/2022 07:54

I follow an influencer who bought a house with her parents (4 bed new build) and it was quite clearly a disaster. Her parents had a snug and the dining room for living space, she had the lounge. She felt like she couldn't let her kids use the garden when her dad was out there reading/napping and she plus her family ended up using the en-suite only as the parents saw the main bathroom as "theirs". I think the problem came in paying half each for the house when the influencer's family was 4 people and her parents were 2.

Swipe left for the next trending thread