Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was antisemitic and I should have said something?

90 replies

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 16:35

NC in case outing. A colleague at work started a conversation about media coverage of Israel / Palestine after seeing an article in the paper.

He said that in his view media coverage is quite biased towards Israel and what did I think. I didn’t particularly want to have the conversation, tricky subject, not quite right for work etc. so I just said that while I didn’t agree with some of the Israeli government’s actions, I didn’t feel like I knew enough about the reality of the situation on the ground to know if the reporting of xx event was biased in favour of Israel or not. But that I did think the amount of coverage the conflict got was disproportionate compared to things like Kashmir or South Sudan, which were fairly similar in nature but got much less media time, and that there was something a bit strange in the big focus on Israel / Palestine and how invested people that were neither Israelis not Palestinians or had relatives there got in it, vs other conflicts.

He replied and said that he supposed that I was right (about other conflicts not getting attention) and then said that he supposed the conflict got so much pro Israel coverage because the majority of the senior people that worked at the BBC were Jewish.

I was a bit shocked / frozen that he’d said this in such a nonchalant way and mumbled something vague in response like, I’m not sure that’s the case. But it’s stuck with me since and I wish I’d said something a bit stronger. I mentioned it to a couple of people (not at work) afterwards. One was quite shocked and thought it was really AS and the other was like, what are you on about that’s a valid point to make.

Im not Jewish btw, not that it matters.

Views?

OP posts:
digestivebiscu1t · 20/10/2022 17:28

I'm sorry but wanging on about BBC execs being Jewish has everything to do with antisemitism and literally nothing to do with Zionism.

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 17:22

Palestinians are also Semitic, surely?

While that is, technically, true it's also, I'm afraid to say, a bit of a trope that's (a bit too often) used in the "some of my best friends are ..." way.

Zionism is a nationalistic movement, whose roots align pretty well with a lot of other, similar movements that sprung up around the same time. It's perfectly alright to not agree with it. Personally, I find the entire notion of nation states rather questionable.

But let's not pretend there isn't a much older, much more poisonous deep seated history of anti-semitism in Europe. Because there is. And it dates back to long before anyone really conceived of the modern concept of a "nation".

If anything, I would be open to the argument that European anti-semitism and its horrendous consequences (including long before the 20th century!) are to blame for the flaming disaster that is I/P.

picklemewalnuts · 20/10/2022 17:12

Palestinians are also Semitic, surely? It's not really a question of antiSemitism, as of anti/pro Zionism.

digestivebiscu1t · 20/10/2022 17:09

gogohmm · 20/10/2022 17:02

Yes his second comment was antisemitic, his first comments were ok.

For what it's worth the coverage and position of the west/media is different towards Israel / Palestine than other conflicts, the reasoning is very complex though, no related to the religious beliefs of senior bbc executives!

We (as in Western Europe) have been interfering with the politics of the holy lands since BC - starting with the Romans. It's a long lived situation and as I say complex!!

You mention the "religious beliefs" of BBC execs. Just to clarify: we (or rather people who involve themselves in these debates) are not talking about religion here, but race. Or "Jewishness" as opposed to Judaism. Antisemitism is racism.

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 17:08

NC too, as this could be quite revealing!

Yes, that was anti-semitic!

And I'm saying this as someone who is, generally, considered "pro-Palestinian" (though I don't like the term, I'm generally opposed to nationalism - I will gladly accept "anti-occupation" and "anti-colonialism").

There is an important and, in my opinion, quite clear border between "criticism of Israel" or even "opposition to it" and blatant "anti-semitism". And every hint of "because Jews" crosses it. By several miles!

Do the State(!!!) of Israel and some of its institutional backers engage in deliberate propaganda? Sure they do - as, for that matter, do Palestinians and their own backers! And the British government. And probably the Association of Pro Swedish Academics, too, if such a thing should happen to exist.

Personally, I won't stand for even a hint of "the Jews" or anything that implies "sinister forces at play [insert dogwhistle here]". I've started fights with people and ended friendships over this.

I am, first and foremost, a leftist and thus include anti-racism (including opposition to anti-semitism) in what I consider my core value system. And, despite my views on specific subjects, I won't stand with you and won't fight by your side if you do not. (I'm also, personally, gender critical but refuse to ally with right-wingers and social conservatives on the subject of gender - for similar reasons!)

So, yes, OP, that was definitely anti-semitic and you should speak up!

lentilly · 20/10/2022 17:06

Now the question is what are you going to do about it?

digestivebiscu1t · 20/10/2022 17:06

100% anti semitic. Also v depressing.

gogohmm · 20/10/2022 17:02

Yes his second comment was antisemitic, his first comments were ok.

For what it's worth the coverage and position of the west/media is different towards Israel / Palestine than other conflicts, the reasoning is very complex though, no related to the religious beliefs of senior bbc executives!

We (as in Western Europe) have been interfering with the politics of the holy lands since BC - starting with the Romans. It's a long lived situation and as I say complex!!

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

is this a satire?

OP posts:
Lesserspottedmama · 20/10/2022 16:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

keeptalkinghappytalk · 20/10/2022 16:54

Yep, culture pigeon

CulturePigeon · 20/10/2022 16:51

Yes, definitely anti-Semitic. How do they know that most people at the BBC are Jewish, and why would that automatically mean they would have one particular perspective on matters?

Like saying that lots of black people work for an organisation and therefore they will all think in a certain way - totally unacceptable.

heldinadream · 20/10/2022 16:50

Well it is the well-worn AS trope that somehow Jewish people are in charge of the media and the narrative and twist it to their own ends. It would have been interesting to challenge why he thinks that, but it's not always easy to catch the moment when someone comes out with something like that.

lentilly · 20/10/2022 16:49

Report it to HR and let them decide what to do

YingMei · 20/10/2022 16:41

Yep it was thoroughly anti-Semitic of him.