Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was antisemitic and I should have said something?

90 replies

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 16:35

NC in case outing. A colleague at work started a conversation about media coverage of Israel / Palestine after seeing an article in the paper.

He said that in his view media coverage is quite biased towards Israel and what did I think. I didn’t particularly want to have the conversation, tricky subject, not quite right for work etc. so I just said that while I didn’t agree with some of the Israeli government’s actions, I didn’t feel like I knew enough about the reality of the situation on the ground to know if the reporting of xx event was biased in favour of Israel or not. But that I did think the amount of coverage the conflict got was disproportionate compared to things like Kashmir or South Sudan, which were fairly similar in nature but got much less media time, and that there was something a bit strange in the big focus on Israel / Palestine and how invested people that were neither Israelis not Palestinians or had relatives there got in it, vs other conflicts.

He replied and said that he supposed that I was right (about other conflicts not getting attention) and then said that he supposed the conflict got so much pro Israel coverage because the majority of the senior people that worked at the BBC were Jewish.

I was a bit shocked / frozen that he’d said this in such a nonchalant way and mumbled something vague in response like, I’m not sure that’s the case. But it’s stuck with me since and I wish I’d said something a bit stronger. I mentioned it to a couple of people (not at work) afterwards. One was quite shocked and thought it was really AS and the other was like, what are you on about that’s a valid point to make.

Im not Jewish btw, not that it matters.

Views?

OP posts:
voiceofmarion · 20/10/2022 22:11

Sorry a bit off topic but what I find interesting is that Catholics get openly bashed by people and it's seen as openly fair game but the minute Islam faith or Jews get criticised or something intolerant said against them it's heavily frowned upon.

I'm atheist btw but just an observation.

Fromthedarkside · 20/10/2022 22:03

@TightDiamondShoes Apparently it's not a race

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/are-jews-a-nation-or-a-religion

Fromthedarkside · 20/10/2022 21:58

@TightDiamondShoes What's PoC ?

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 21:35

Hawkins001 · 20/10/2022 21:14

There's a.couple of questions

How many managers are of that specific nationality
Is the coverage more weighted in favour of Israel

Then if the results were that your colleague is accurate in his perspectives and the facts back it up, then why does the truth equal anti Semitic ?

Being Jewish is either an ethnicity or a religion or both. It’s not a nationality.

And to answer your questions.

How would he even know how many senior managers with editorial decision making in the news division were or were not Jewish? The BBC probably reports it’s D&I statistics, but not by division or role. So there would be no way for him to know. It’s an assumption on his part and one that cannot possibly be informed by anything.

Even if there were more senior news managers that were Jewish, why would that mean they were a) always pro Israel? b) prepared to let that influence the decisions they made about coverage? And c) always able to override other colleagues decisions?

Even if there were lots of senior managers in the news division that were Jewish, they would most likely be British Jews, not Israeli Jews. They might be pro anti or neutral on the policies of the current Israeli government. And even if they were Israeli Jews they might not be supportive of their country’s government, because they might not have voted for them. In the same way that being American didn’t make you a Trump supporter, or being religiously or culturally Hindu or Muslim wouldn’t make you supportive of Modi or of the Iranian government.

On your second question. How would anyone independently determine if the coverage is biased or not? There isn’t an objective answer to that question.

So the answer to both your questions is that it’s impossible to say if my colleague is accurate or not in his perceptions, but that it’s very unlikely that he is, and that his perceptions quite accurately mirror very old tropes that have been used to justify terrible things.

OP posts:
TightDiamondShoes · 20/10/2022 21:32

@Fromthedarkside so you wouldn’t call out racism unless you were PoC?

Fromthedarkside · 20/10/2022 21:20

Just wondered why his opinions matter OP and how it affects you?

If you were living in Northern Ireland and it was a comment about the situation there, then I could understand it but not the situation you describe.

Hawkins001 · 20/10/2022 21:14

@Koelaid

Hawkins001 · 20/10/2022 21:14

There's a.couple of questions

How many managers are of that specific nationality
Is the coverage more weighted in favour of Israel

Then if the results were that your colleague is accurate in his perspectives and the facts back it up, then why does the truth equal anti Semitic ?

psychomath · 20/10/2022 21:01

Yes I think it was an antisemitic comment, but it's often difficult to think of the right thing to say in the moment when youre caught off guard.

incidentally an Israeli Jew once told me he thought the BBC was biased against Israel because a lot of Muslims worked in high up positions there! I've heard they try to aim for a roughly equal number of complaints of bias from both sides - on all controversial issues, not just Israel/Palestine - and if the numbers are about the same they assume they're getting the neutrality thing more or less right.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/10/2022 20:51

The comment about the BBC was definitely anti Semetic, yes

vera99 · 20/10/2022 20:49

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 20:14

Once you mention Jews as a single entity controlling anything then definitely anti-Semitic. Framing opposition to Israel's treatment of Palestinians then the state is fair game.

I think this is a rather useful rule of thumb, yes!

Naturally, it isn't perfect. Rules of thumb never are. And it is also perfectly possible to be deeply anti-semitic without ever resorting to "the Jews ...".

Since I'm still on a name change: my father happens to be a rabid anti-semite (in my, on this particular subject, not-so-humble opinion). But he will practically never say "the Jews". He talks about "financial elites", "Rothschild money", "George Soros", and a bunch of other dogwhistles.

Personally, I happen to think this is quite a lot more insidious than people who just say "the [monolith of] Jews" as in that it takes a lot more work to unravel it for what it is.

Yes, "globalists" is another . Trump dog whistled away in his final election campaign video despite his daughter being married to a Jew and a great friend of Israel in the end.

www.jta.org/2016/11/07/politics/that-trump-ad-is-it-anti-semitic-an-analysis

Is the ad anti-Semitic? Not declaratively. But in its insinuations, it’s hard to deny it traffics in conspiracies of control and destruction identified with classical anti-Semitism.
Trump’s ad features a portion of his Oct. 13 speech in West Palm Beach, Fla. outlining what he said were “the global special interests” that “don’t have your good in mind.”
That speech, as we noted at the time, was a curious replay of themes and language familiar to those of us who are steeped in the monitoring of anti-Semitism. There were precise echoes of the notorious Russian anti-Semitic forgery, “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,” which I explored here.
What there wasn’t, in the speech, was any mention of Jews. The phenomenon of anti-Semitism absent of Jews is not novel.
Now, in this ad, Trump has introduced Jews — three of them: Janet Yellen, the chairwoman of the Federal reserve; George Soros, the hedge funder and global philanthropist, and Lloyd Blankfein, the CEO of Goldman Sachs (the later two are Clinton backers).

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 20:14

Once you mention Jews as a single entity controlling anything then definitely anti-Semitic. Framing opposition to Israel's treatment of Palestinians then the state is fair game.

I think this is a rather useful rule of thumb, yes!

Naturally, it isn't perfect. Rules of thumb never are. And it is also perfectly possible to be deeply anti-semitic without ever resorting to "the Jews ...".

Since I'm still on a name change: my father happens to be a rabid anti-semite (in my, on this particular subject, not-so-humble opinion). But he will practically never say "the Jews". He talks about "financial elites", "Rothschild money", "George Soros", and a bunch of other dogwhistles.

Personally, I happen to think this is quite a lot more insidious than people who just say "the [monolith of] Jews" as in that it takes a lot more work to unravel it for what it is.

Hont1986 · 20/10/2022 20:05

the majority of the senior people that worked at the BBC were Jewish.

Yes, it was anti-Semitic. It is also quite easily proven to be wrong.

The BBC produced a report in 2018 about their demographics that says (on page 18) that only 1.5% of their senior leadership is Jewish.

This is actually an over-representation compared to the population as a whole, which is 0.5% Jewish in the UK. But it's not anywhere close to the majority.

BEAM123 · 20/10/2022 20:03

Making a comment that from media coverage being pro-Israeli because Jews are controlling the BBC is definitely an antisemitic trope. He may have just been naive /young / heard these ridiculous theories and not questioned them but it is still antisemitic train of thought. Worth robustly challenging it and educating him.

Incidentally many Israelis complain that the BBC is biased AGAINST Israel!

Hoppinggreen · 20/10/2022 19:56

While I agree with some of his points around bias and coverage I think what he said is anti Semitic.
Traditionally I do think the western media tends to be on the side of Israel but I dont believe there’s any big conspiracy or undue influence from anywhere.

JustDanceAddict · 20/10/2022 19:50

Definitely anti-Semitic. I reported an anti-Semitic comment at a job. That person left pretty soon after, he must’ve got a roasting.

vera99 · 20/10/2022 19:47

Once you mention Jews as a single entity controlling anything then definitely anti-Semitic. Framing opposition to Israel's treatment of Palestinians then the state is fair game.

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 19:28

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 19:18

Well I do happen to think that if your reasons for being very invested in a particular conflict are more to do with it being a unfair, or unfairly reported or unjust and not to do with some sort of personal link, then it is odd if you’re not also aware of or somewhat interested by very similar conflicts. I&P and Kashmir are very similar. So I do think if you’re fascinated by one, but not by the other but have no ties to either that is a bit disingenuous.

I don’t think the climate change v feminism example is quite right. There is a lot of difference between those issues and what causes them and how relatively severe and impactful they are on people in various places in the world. A better example would be someone who is really into the environment caring deeply about emissions reduction but not about biodiversity loss.

I think if you care about the environment, you should care at least somewhat about both. Similarly if you care about complicated, racial and religious conflicts that the Brits has a lot of involvement in creating, you should probably be aware of both P&I and Kashmir.

I’m not that sure I get the Holy Land point. I don’t think that many non religious westerners feel especially culturally tied to the fate of the holy land, regardless of the fact that a lot of the Abrahamic religions originated there and some of our ethics and values are based on the tenants of those religions. But I could be wrong.

Roman / Latin / Greek culture was arguably just as influential on the current language, politics, civic institutions, design of our buildings and cities, ways of eating, manners etc. as was whatever came out of the holy land, but I don’t see lots of Brits taking a huge interest in contemporary Italian or Greek politics as a result.

OP posts:
TightDiamondShoes · 20/10/2022 19:23

Bless. Is here care in the community? You’d have to be quite um… “interesting” to believe that the Jews simultaneously “control the media” whilst being pro-Palestine! 😂

Fingernails4Cash · 20/10/2022 19:21

Very very anti semitic

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 19:18

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 19:07

That's not entirely wrong, OP, but also ...

  1. I think there's a certain amount of "whataboutism" involved in your thinking there. There is just no such obligation as "being aware of and caring about any and all comparable situations equally". Different example: it's perfectly possible for someone to be an ardent climate activist but regard feminism as a pretty "yeah, I suppose ..." topic without affording it much personal investment. That doesn't make your views on climate any more or less valid.
  1. Your argument neglects the "Holy Land" aspect entirely! Like it or not, even for non-religious so-called "Westerners" the "Holy Land" does have a special significance in that it is intimately tied up with much of our own cultural and philosophical origins in ways that the China-Tibet situation ... just isn't.

That said, you are not wrong, of course, on the subject of "but 'we' are pretty deeply involved in the origins of quite a few current conflicts". The British Empire does have quite a lot to answer for in that respect.

Well I do happen to think that if your reasons for being very invested in a particular conflict are more to do with it being a unfair, or unfairly reported or unjust and not to do with some sort of personal link, then it is odd if you’re not also aware of or somewhat interested by very similar conflicts. I&P and Kashmir are very similar. So I do think if you’re fascinated by one, but not by the other but have no ties to either that is a bit disingenuous.

I don’t think the climate change v feminism example is quite right. There is a lot of difference between those issues and what causes them and how relatively severe and impactful they are on people in various places in the world. A better example would be someone who is really into the environment caring deeply about emissions reduction but not about biodiversity loss.

I think if you care about the environment, you should care at least somewhat about both. Similarly if you care about complicated, racial and religious conflicts that the Brits has a lot of involvement in creating, you should probably be aware of both P&I and Kashmir.

OP posts:
NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 19:07

That's not entirely wrong, OP, but also ...

  1. I think there's a certain amount of "whataboutism" involved in your thinking there. There is just no such obligation as "being aware of and caring about any and all comparable situations equally". Different example: it's perfectly possible for someone to be an ardent climate activist but regard feminism as a pretty "yeah, I suppose ..." topic without affording it much personal investment. That doesn't make your views on climate any more or less valid.
  1. Your argument neglects the "Holy Land" aspect entirely! Like it or not, even for non-religious so-called "Westerners" the "Holy Land" does have a special significance in that it is intimately tied up with much of our own cultural and philosophical origins in ways that the China-Tibet situation ... just isn't.

That said, you are not wrong, of course, on the subject of "but 'we' are pretty deeply involved in the origins of quite a few current conflicts". The British Empire does have quite a lot to answer for in that respect.

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 18:41

gogohmm · 20/10/2022 17:02

Yes his second comment was antisemitic, his first comments were ok.

For what it's worth the coverage and position of the west/media is different towards Israel / Palestine than other conflicts, the reasoning is very complex though, no related to the religious beliefs of senior bbc executives!

We (as in Western Europe) have been interfering with the politics of the holy lands since BC - starting with the Romans. It's a long lived situation and as I say complex!!

I do get your point to some extent, but there are plenty of conflicts that Western Europe had a big historical hand in, or have other past ties with that get marginal coverage and don’t seem to be the political football / marker of political alignment that Israel Palestine is here.

For example we (Western Europe, in particular France, Britain and Portugal) have been interfering in the Indian subcontinent for a long time. Britain literally created the state of Kashmir and handed it over to an ally in 1846, then just before partition we sent soldiers in to assist the Maharaja and in the end majority Muslim J&K mostly ended up in India. There have been two wars since then, and the Indian army still keeps a huge presence in J&K, in what lots of Kashmiris consider to be an occupation. The dynamics are very similar to I & P.

The UK is also home to a much larger expat population of Pakistanis and Indians, than it is of Israelis and Palestinians.

So arguably the situation in Kashmir should get as much coverage in the UK as Israel Palestine does. But it gets virtually none and most people would probably struggle to point to it on a map.

OP posts:
IsThePopeCatholic · 20/10/2022 17:39

Totally antisemitic. Jews and power is such a well-worn rope.

picklemewalnuts · 20/10/2022 17:31

digestivebiscu1t · 20/10/2022 17:28

I'm sorry but wanging on about BBC execs being Jewish has everything to do with antisemitism and literally nothing to do with Zionism.

True. I got misled by an old argument about pro Palestinians being antisemitic.