Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was antisemitic and I should have said something?

90 replies

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 16:35

NC in case outing. A colleague at work started a conversation about media coverage of Israel / Palestine after seeing an article in the paper.

He said that in his view media coverage is quite biased towards Israel and what did I think. I didn’t particularly want to have the conversation, tricky subject, not quite right for work etc. so I just said that while I didn’t agree with some of the Israeli government’s actions, I didn’t feel like I knew enough about the reality of the situation on the ground to know if the reporting of xx event was biased in favour of Israel or not. But that I did think the amount of coverage the conflict got was disproportionate compared to things like Kashmir or South Sudan, which were fairly similar in nature but got much less media time, and that there was something a bit strange in the big focus on Israel / Palestine and how invested people that were neither Israelis not Palestinians or had relatives there got in it, vs other conflicts.

He replied and said that he supposed that I was right (about other conflicts not getting attention) and then said that he supposed the conflict got so much pro Israel coverage because the majority of the senior people that worked at the BBC were Jewish.

I was a bit shocked / frozen that he’d said this in such a nonchalant way and mumbled something vague in response like, I’m not sure that’s the case. But it’s stuck with me since and I wish I’d said something a bit stronger. I mentioned it to a couple of people (not at work) afterwards. One was quite shocked and thought it was really AS and the other was like, what are you on about that’s a valid point to make.

Im not Jewish btw, not that it matters.

Views?

OP posts:
digestivebiscu1t · 21/10/2022 09:22

The fact that this discussion has veered into Israel/ Palestine and away from the initial comments about Jews being overrepresented at the BBC is pretty telling tbh.

Echobelly · 21/10/2022 09:17

Some people seem to be incorrectly inferring the OP was saying criticism of Israel was antisemitic, which is not what they saying and,as a Jew, I agree criticism of Israel is not automatically antisemitic.

What is antisemitic, however, is to suggest that Jews are somehow controlling an agenda at the BBC. It's also bullshit as I think the BBC coverage of Israel is actually fairly good and not uncritical.

Blackmetalmama · 21/10/2022 09:17

MangyInseam · 20/10/2022 23:57

He's not wrong that the media treats the Palestinian/Israeli conflict quite differently than many others, and the way which they do that often has a significant political element in it.

He's not right about the majority of the BBC top brass being Jewish, although it is probably the case that the BBC's coverage tends to reflect the political biases of those who are in charge.

Personally, I tend to think that unless someone is actually trying to be an asshole, it's not useful to accuse them of bigotry. Or report them, (with a few exceptions potentially) to HR. People do sometimes get crazy, wrong ideas about facts, which they really believe to be true, and it's often quite possible to say something like "I'm pretty sure they aren't mostly Jewish" and it can make an impression if you already have a good working relationship.

It's way more effective at prompting people to rethink, and to change their own minds in doing so, than cutting them out or reporting them would be.

This^

No reason to report this to HR, what a waste of time. You feel like you should have said something in the moment, but you didn't. That's on you. If anything was said again, you will no doubt react and explain why you disgree on the spot. However, I can't see the purpose of reporting this to HR at all.

Getoff · 21/10/2022 09:09

voiceofmarion · 20/10/2022 22:11

Sorry a bit off topic but what I find interesting is that Catholics get openly bashed by people and it's seen as openly fair game but the minute Islam faith or Jews get criticised or something intolerant said against them it's heavily frowned upon.

I'm atheist btw but just an observation.

In several decades of adult life, in London, I don't remember hearing anything negative said about Catholics. I don't remember hearing any generalisation about Catholics at all.

(I'm aware of goings on in Northern Ireland, and football-hooliganism-related stuff in Scotland. There is also the priest paedophile issue in several countries. Nothing I've heard on any of those issues could be construed as an attack on all Catholics though. )

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 09:08

Criticism of Israel IS anti-Semitic… unless you believe Jews don’t deserve their homeland. Knock yourself out about criticising Israeli government policy much as you would about Westminster - but don’t for one minute think your criticism of Israeli government policies is anything LESS than thinly veiled anti-semitism… that is unless you’re prepared to rant at length about policies of Mauritania, zim, Ecuador, Malta or any other country with questionable policies.

Luckydip1 · 21/10/2022 09:05

Pro Palestine is not anti semitic.

TeamRR · 21/10/2022 09:03

Redup · 21/10/2022 08:27

@FlamingoSocks No I don't. I think it might be an interesting thing to say/think but really can't understand the outrage.

It's not interesting, it's disgusting.

The whole 'Jews control the government/banks/media' thing is an antisemetic trope thats as old as the hills. You're being very disingenuous.

jetadore · 21/10/2022 08:52

Despite what many would try to have you believe criticism of Israel is not antisemitic, however the stuff about the BBC being run by Jews is, yes.

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 08:49

Oh dear - even my damned auto-carrot is in on the game. ENDURE, not ensure.

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 08:48

I first saw this cartoon 15 (?) years ago. It was entered into a competition FOR Jewish artists to take the piss out of all the ludicrous anti-Semitic tropes we ensure.

david baddiel had it right when he said “Jews don’t matter”.

To think this was antisemitic and I should have said something?
Redup · 21/10/2022 08:27

@FlamingoSocks No I don't. I think it might be an interesting thing to say/think but really can't understand the outrage.

FlamingoSocks · 21/10/2022 00:14

@Redup you don’t think someone saying Jews control the BBC is anti semitic?

Redup · 21/10/2022 00:11

Am I living on a different plant? You have a difference of opinion. How the hell is that "anti=semitic". I can't see anything in your opening post that suggests that.

FlamingoSocks · 21/10/2022 00:06

What’s really depressing is that the majority of voters in this thread think you’re unreasonable, and that believing and voicing the idea that Jews control the media can somehow not be anti semitic.

Oh well. Just got to try and keep truckin’ I suppose.

MangyInseam · 21/10/2022 00:01

Yes, "globalists" is another . Trump dog whistled away in his final election campaign video despite his daughter being married to a Jew and a great friend of Israel in the end.

You don't think he might have just actually meant globalists?

MangyInseam · 20/10/2022 23:57

He's not wrong that the media treats the Palestinian/Israeli conflict quite differently than many others, and the way which they do that often has a significant political element in it.

He's not right about the majority of the BBC top brass being Jewish, although it is probably the case that the BBC's coverage tends to reflect the political biases of those who are in charge.

Personally, I tend to think that unless someone is actually trying to be an asshole, it's not useful to accuse them of bigotry. Or report them, (with a few exceptions potentially) to HR. People do sometimes get crazy, wrong ideas about facts, which they really believe to be true, and it's often quite possible to say something like "I'm pretty sure they aren't mostly Jewish" and it can make an impression if you already have a good working relationship.

It's way more effective at prompting people to rethink, and to change their own minds in doing so, than cutting them out or reporting them would be.

voiceofmarion · 20/10/2022 23:20

I wouldn’t report my colleagues for having different opinions to me and I wouldn’t think less of them

same and even if they said something to me that showed they were homophobic etc I still wouldn't report it. I'm gay myself but really couldn't give a hoot what a colleague thinks/says.It's very easy on mn to say report them but in reality this can be dangerous and get your card marked in work. I've heard countless inappropriate shit said at work and report it would mean reporting my established managers at times who were in close cahoots with the leadership. Would hardly end well for me.

I try to keep my head down.

TowerStork · 20/10/2022 23:09

Comments about Jews running the BBC (and apparently influencing coverage to favour Jews) are absolutely anti-Semitic. If someone I was talking to said that I would tell them that it’s unacceptable, not true, and a dangerous old trope.

Regarding the rest of the conversation, it is well established that coverage of the conflict is heavily biased against Palestinians and in favour of Israel. By established I mean empirical, objective studies of headlines, phrasing, sourcing etc. Sometimes that is attributed to the influence of Israeli lobbying on the media, but that’s very different to what your colleague actually said.

Your own points about the volume of coverage and motivations re other conflicts are red herrings. Look up whataboutism.

paintitallover · 20/10/2022 23:07

Odd conversation to start, especially given the speed to other news today.

AnorLondo · 20/10/2022 23:06

Whippetlovely · 20/10/2022 22:39

He is entitled to his opinion what ever that may be. I wouldn’t report my colleagues for having different opinions to me and I wouldn’t think less of them. We often had lively debates in my old workplace , lots of different opinions. No one would ever think of reporting anyone for anything they said, we are grown ups with different political opinions / ideology on a lot of things. It’s nice to see things from other points of view sometimes and sometimes it could steer you in a different direction. Sadly haven’t had this in new jobs I’ve had , too much of PC culture and fear of upsetting people.

It's never nice to hear anti-semetic statements.

Whippetlovely · 20/10/2022 22:39

He is entitled to his opinion what ever that may be. I wouldn’t report my colleagues for having different opinions to me and I wouldn’t think less of them. We often had lively debates in my old workplace , lots of different opinions. No one would ever think of reporting anyone for anything they said, we are grown ups with different political opinions / ideology on a lot of things. It’s nice to see things from other points of view sometimes and sometimes it could steer you in a different direction. Sadly haven’t had this in new jobs I’ve had , too much of PC culture and fear of upsetting people.

VladmirsPoutine · 20/10/2022 22:35

I can't believe he felt so free to espouse his views to you like that!! I'm very hot on my views regarding racism but even I know there are levels to it.

Hawkins001 · 20/10/2022 22:27

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 21:35

Being Jewish is either an ethnicity or a religion or both. It’s not a nationality.

And to answer your questions.

How would he even know how many senior managers with editorial decision making in the news division were or were not Jewish? The BBC probably reports it’s D&I statistics, but not by division or role. So there would be no way for him to know. It’s an assumption on his part and one that cannot possibly be informed by anything.

Even if there were more senior news managers that were Jewish, why would that mean they were a) always pro Israel? b) prepared to let that influence the decisions they made about coverage? And c) always able to override other colleagues decisions?

Even if there were lots of senior managers in the news division that were Jewish, they would most likely be British Jews, not Israeli Jews. They might be pro anti or neutral on the policies of the current Israeli government. And even if they were Israeli Jews they might not be supportive of their country’s government, because they might not have voted for them. In the same way that being American didn’t make you a Trump supporter, or being religiously or culturally Hindu or Muslim wouldn’t make you supportive of Modi or of the Iranian government.

On your second question. How would anyone independently determine if the coverage is biased or not? There isn’t an objective answer to that question.

So the answer to both your questions is that it’s impossible to say if my colleague is accurate or not in his perceptions, but that it’s very unlikely that he is, and that his perceptions quite accurately mirror very old tropes that have been used to justify terrible things.

Excellent points and analysis, much appreciated.

voiceofmarion · 20/10/2022 22:22

It's Christians generally that get attacked for their beliefs in Sky Fairies

no it's more because of the sex scandals which was a minority who did it yet it's fair game to blame every priest etc for it.

Meanwhile if anybody dared tries to taint all Muslims because of the terrorist attacks in recent years they'd be seen to be promoting hate etc.

I don't support either view btw but just irks me how it's ok to bash 1 and not the other.

Fromthedarkside · 20/10/2022 22:17

@voiceofmarion Sorry a bit off topic but what I find interesting is that Catholics get openly bashed by people and it's seen as openly fair game but the minute Islam faith or Jews get criticised or something intolerant said against them it's heavily frowned upon.

It's Christians generally that get attacked for their beliefs in Sky Fairies 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread