Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was antisemitic and I should have said something?

90 replies

Koelaid · 20/10/2022 16:35

NC in case outing. A colleague at work started a conversation about media coverage of Israel / Palestine after seeing an article in the paper.

He said that in his view media coverage is quite biased towards Israel and what did I think. I didn’t particularly want to have the conversation, tricky subject, not quite right for work etc. so I just said that while I didn’t agree with some of the Israeli government’s actions, I didn’t feel like I knew enough about the reality of the situation on the ground to know if the reporting of xx event was biased in favour of Israel or not. But that I did think the amount of coverage the conflict got was disproportionate compared to things like Kashmir or South Sudan, which were fairly similar in nature but got much less media time, and that there was something a bit strange in the big focus on Israel / Palestine and how invested people that were neither Israelis not Palestinians or had relatives there got in it, vs other conflicts.

He replied and said that he supposed that I was right (about other conflicts not getting attention) and then said that he supposed the conflict got so much pro Israel coverage because the majority of the senior people that worked at the BBC were Jewish.

I was a bit shocked / frozen that he’d said this in such a nonchalant way and mumbled something vague in response like, I’m not sure that’s the case. But it’s stuck with me since and I wish I’d said something a bit stronger. I mentioned it to a couple of people (not at work) afterwards. One was quite shocked and thought it was really AS and the other was like, what are you on about that’s a valid point to make.

Im not Jewish btw, not that it matters.

Views?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AbsoluteYawns · 22/10/2022 12:17

VladmirsPoutine · 22/10/2022 12:08

David Baddiel deserves an award for the best rebrand I've ever seen. A man who did black face and is now a figure of anti-racism! It's amazing really - sort of like Boris lecturing us on family values. I still find it remarkable to think about.

Read his book - he addresses this point.

VladmirsPoutine · 22/10/2022 12:08

Energeticenoch · 22/10/2022 10:44

Good to know the usual British anti-semitism is alive and well on this thread. Of course what he said was anti-Semitic. He might have been naive and stupid and wrong but it was anti semitic. The Jews control the media rhetoric is one of the most ridiculous anti-Semitic thoughts going back to forever.

Those of you who haven’t, please read David Baddiel’s don’t count. It’s one of the most important pieces of literature on this topic in recent years.

david is Jewish as most of you know, he’s also secular, his partner isn’t Jewish, he has no particular connection to Israel or historically a massive interest in it. He also wasn’t that interested in being connected particularly with being Jewish but he’s the one person who is standing up and speaking about the elephant in the room. That the lived experience of Jews just isn’t seen as relevant as other minorities or taken seriously because people who haven’t a clue about what it means to be a Jew think they know better.

David Baddiel deserves an award for the best rebrand I've ever seen. A man who did black face and is now a figure of anti-racism! It's amazing really - sort of like Boris lecturing us on family values. I still find it remarkable to think about.

AbsoluteYawns · 22/10/2022 12:08

Energeticenoch · 22/10/2022 10:44

Good to know the usual British anti-semitism is alive and well on this thread. Of course what he said was anti-Semitic. He might have been naive and stupid and wrong but it was anti semitic. The Jews control the media rhetoric is one of the most ridiculous anti-Semitic thoughts going back to forever.

Those of you who haven’t, please read David Baddiel’s don’t count. It’s one of the most important pieces of literature on this topic in recent years.

david is Jewish as most of you know, he’s also secular, his partner isn’t Jewish, he has no particular connection to Israel or historically a massive interest in it. He also wasn’t that interested in being connected particularly with being Jewish but he’s the one person who is standing up and speaking about the elephant in the room. That the lived experience of Jews just isn’t seen as relevant as other minorities or taken seriously because people who haven’t a clue about what it means to be a Jew think they know better.

Well said! Baddiel's book is a must read for so many posters on this board saying the comments about Jews and the BBC are a nothing.

Energeticenoch · 22/10/2022 10:50

fathomjournal.org/book-review-jews-dont-count/

Energeticenoch · 22/10/2022 10:44

Good to know the usual British anti-semitism is alive and well on this thread. Of course what he said was anti-Semitic. He might have been naive and stupid and wrong but it was anti semitic. The Jews control the media rhetoric is one of the most ridiculous anti-Semitic thoughts going back to forever.

Those of you who haven’t, please read David Baddiel’s don’t count. It’s one of the most important pieces of literature on this topic in recent years.

david is Jewish as most of you know, he’s also secular, his partner isn’t Jewish, he has no particular connection to Israel or historically a massive interest in it. He also wasn’t that interested in being connected particularly with being Jewish but he’s the one person who is standing up and speaking about the elephant in the room. That the lived experience of Jews just isn’t seen as relevant as other minorities or taken seriously because people who haven’t a clue about what it means to be a Jew think they know better.

memorial · 22/10/2022 10:14

VladmirsPoutine · 22/10/2022 08:31

@memorial You think antisemitism is the only allowed racism?

See my previous response. None of these would have been considered ok or defended if made about any other race. I'm not saying other rascism doesnt exist but it not acceptable. Antisemitism is minimised/allowed/joked/defended..imagine the OP about any other group. The putrage

memorial · 22/10/2022 10:10

ChocFrog · 22/10/2022 09:07

The only allowed racism?! You apply for a job in Wales, or go to a pub in East Glasgow, and tell everybody you’re English, let me know how you get on.

Excellent mansplaining there. I am (non welsh) jew living and working in wales....so! Trust me the antisemitism is worse.
I really dontvget this thread. You would never dare tell a POC that there lived experiences are not racsism because....but its ok to tell Jews its not antisemitic because?? This thread is full of vile low level anti semitism and the fact that people spouting it don't even realise ot acknowledge it is why it's such a problem.
Try be a Jew. Then come back and tell me.

ChocFrog · 22/10/2022 09:07

memorial · 22/10/2022 07:40

Of course its antisemitic FFS. The only allowed racism. Those who are saying it isnt ...imagine he said "its because its all blacks at the top in BBC" that's rascism right

The only allowed racism?! You apply for a job in Wales, or go to a pub in East Glasgow, and tell everybody you’re English, let me know how you get on.

ChocFrog · 22/10/2022 09:06

I don’t think it was anti-semitic, although I can see how others might. I think it’s very dangerous to police this kind of casual discussion and the person who suggested your report to HR is just stirring, that would be a huge overreaction and make you look like a snowflake.

I agree with him that media coverage can be surprisingly biased and it’s no great leap to speculate about why journalists might be biased.

vera99 · 22/10/2022 08:54

Here are American Nazis hailing Trump - they love the chaos he unleashed. Later some started to question his support for 'The Jews' initially they tried to internalise it as Ivanaka's "malign" influence through her husband Jared Kushner.

vera99 · 22/10/2022 08:49

Valeriekat · 22/10/2022 07:26

Donald Trump was prob the most pro Israel President in US history.

Consistency and truth are alien bedfellows in the world of Trump - the speech was probably written for him by his team to appeal to some of the toxic elements of his base.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 22/10/2022 08:45

TightDiamondShoes, not sure I'm reading you right, but your "is he care in the community" / "he must be ...interesting" comments sound as if you're suggesting these are the kinds of views held by people with learning disabilities?

VladmirsPoutine · 22/10/2022 08:31

@memorial You think antisemitism is the only allowed racism?

memorial · 22/10/2022 07:40

Of course its antisemitic FFS. The only allowed racism. Those who are saying it isnt ...imagine he said "its because its all blacks at the top in BBC" that's rascism right

MavisChunch29 · 22/10/2022 07:36

Personally though I had no idea of the Palestinian side of things growing up in the 1980s, all the reporting seemed to be that they were terrorists. When I did modern world studies in GCSE history in the early 1990s and we studied Israel/Palestine and NI conflicts, safe to say there were several lightbulb moments.

I think the reporting is more balanced now, FWIW.

MavisChunch29 · 22/10/2022 07:30

I think you are right, based on your last post @Koelaid

Valeriekat · 22/10/2022 07:26

vera99 · 20/10/2022 20:49

Yes, "globalists" is another . Trump dog whistled away in his final election campaign video despite his daughter being married to a Jew and a great friend of Israel in the end.

www.jta.org/2016/11/07/politics/that-trump-ad-is-it-anti-semitic-an-analysis

Is the ad anti-Semitic? Not declaratively. But in its insinuations, it’s hard to deny it traffics in conspiracies of control and destruction identified with classical anti-Semitism.
Trump’s ad features a portion of his Oct. 13 speech in West Palm Beach, Fla. outlining what he said were “the global special interests” that “don’t have your good in mind.”
That speech, as we noted at the time, was a curious replay of themes and language familiar to those of us who are steeped in the monitoring of anti-Semitism. There were precise echoes of the notorious Russian anti-Semitic forgery, “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,” which I explored here.
What there wasn’t, in the speech, was any mention of Jews. The phenomenon of anti-Semitism absent of Jews is not novel.
Now, in this ad, Trump has introduced Jews — three of them: Janet Yellen, the chairwoman of the Federal reserve; George Soros, the hedge funder and global philanthropist, and Lloyd Blankfein, the CEO of Goldman Sachs (the later two are Clinton backers).

Donald Trump was prob the most pro Israel President in US history.

Valeriekat · 22/10/2022 07:23

NameForAFleetingMoment · 20/10/2022 17:08

NC too, as this could be quite revealing!

Yes, that was anti-semitic!

And I'm saying this as someone who is, generally, considered "pro-Palestinian" (though I don't like the term, I'm generally opposed to nationalism - I will gladly accept "anti-occupation" and "anti-colonialism").

There is an important and, in my opinion, quite clear border between "criticism of Israel" or even "opposition to it" and blatant "anti-semitism". And every hint of "because Jews" crosses it. By several miles!

Do the State(!!!) of Israel and some of its institutional backers engage in deliberate propaganda? Sure they do - as, for that matter, do Palestinians and their own backers! And the British government. And probably the Association of Pro Swedish Academics, too, if such a thing should happen to exist.

Personally, I won't stand for even a hint of "the Jews" or anything that implies "sinister forces at play [insert dogwhistle here]". I've started fights with people and ended friendships over this.

I am, first and foremost, a leftist and thus include anti-racism (including opposition to anti-semitism) in what I consider my core value system. And, despite my views on specific subjects, I won't stand with you and won't fight by your side if you do not. (I'm also, personally, gender critical but refuse to ally with right-wingers and social conservatives on the subject of gender - for similar reasons!)

So, yes, OP, that was definitely anti-semitic and you should speak up!

You have put this very well, thankyou.

MangyInseam · 21/10/2022 18:59

NameForAFleetingMoment · 21/10/2022 14:15

That said, singling out Israel for being "a state that shouldn't exist" does tend to suggest anti-semitic tendencies. Again, unless you happen to be an anarchist or otherwise equally as willing to argue Australia or Switzerland shouldn't exist (the latter of which was argued in earnest by the late Ghaddafi, that doesn't mean he wasn't also a rabid anti-semite, which he was ... he was just also specifically anti-Swiss because they arrested his son).

There are people who argue that places like Australia shouldn't exist because they are colonies, that argue about whether certain countries ought to be, or ought not to have been, partitioned, who think that that ethnic/religious nationalism in general is in some way bad, or that a particular political arrangement is inherently unstable or in fact never going to work for concrete reasons.

All of these kinds of arguments are common and some could be made about Israel without having anything to do with the idea of a homeland for Jews as such. And for that matter, there have historically been Jewish people who for religious reasons oppose the idea of Israel as a political state, which really is about that.

There are all kinds of political discussions that happen about various nations and peoples that encompass similar ideas.

NameForAFleetingMoment · 21/10/2022 14:15

That said, singling out Israel for being "a state that shouldn't exist" does tend to suggest anti-semitic tendencies. Again, unless you happen to be an anarchist or otherwise equally as willing to argue Australia or Switzerland shouldn't exist (the latter of which was argued in earnest by the late Ghaddafi, that doesn't mean he wasn't also a rabid anti-semite, which he was ... he was just also specifically anti-Swiss because they arrested his son).

NameForAFleetingMoment · 21/10/2022 14:09

Bollocks, there is criticism of Israel's actions and criticism of Israel's right to exist as a state.

... and even the latter is not necessarily and always anti-semitic: any anarchist will, pretty much by definition, deny Israel's right to exist as a state. That's not due to anti-semitism but a function of the fact that anarchists aren't really into the idea of states as a matter of principle. In fact, quite a few leading anarchist theorists were both Jewish and strongly anti-zionist. But they're not anti-semitic because anarchists feel the same way about Peru, Malta, ane Nepal, too.

vera99 · 21/10/2022 12:58

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 09:08

Criticism of Israel IS anti-Semitic… unless you believe Jews don’t deserve their homeland. Knock yourself out about criticising Israeli government policy much as you would about Westminster - but don’t for one minute think your criticism of Israeli government policies is anything LESS than thinly veiled anti-semitism… that is unless you’re prepared to rant at length about policies of Mauritania, zim, Ecuador, Malta or any other country with questionable policies.

Bollocks, there is criticism of Israel's actions and criticism of Israel's right to exist as a state. There are many Jews that criticize the actions of Israel are they all anti-semites as well? And yes I'm prepared to rant about a long list of other countries as well including my own.

www.jewdas.org/

Koelaid · 21/10/2022 09:41

Luckydip1 · 21/10/2022 09:05

Pro Palestine is not anti semitic.

You are of course right. But I wasn’t implying my colleague was being anti-Semitic for being pro-Palestine. (Side point, I do think it should be possible to be critical of or positive about aspects of both countries, and not just entirely pro one and anti the other. I don’t agree with some of the policies of the current Israeli government, but I also don’t agree with some of the policies of the PLO and Hamas).

I was saying I thought he was being anti-Semitic for saying that most of the senior people at the BBC were Jewish and that this was why the BBC’s coverage of Israel / Palestine was biased in favour of Israel.

If he’d said most of the senior people at the BBC are Israelis, that would have been a different matter. Equally unlikely to be true but different.

But he was implying that being a British Jew automatically makes you pro Israel and likely to ignore the principles of good journalism in order to present biased coverage of Israel. That’s no more true than saying someone being a British Muslim or ethnically Arab automatically makes them pro the policies of Saudi Arabia or Egypt. It also echoes a very old racist trope that has been used to justify a lot of violence and hatred towards Jews from all nations (Spain, Iran, Britain, Russia, Germany etc)

OP posts:
Echobelly · 21/10/2022 09:28

I agree with @MangyInseam though, and don't run to accuse people of being antisemitic.

I do see people online sharing 'Rothschilds' type conspiracies or other antisemitic dogwhistles, and sometimes people pile on them to accuse them of being bigots. My approach, unless I can see evidence that they are committed to being antisemitic (most aren't), is to explain to them that supporting these conspiracies isn't 'Sticking it to The Man', it's doing the work of bad faith actors who want to blame Jews for problems with the world and distract from the real issues. And it causes real problems for Jews who are real people, even if you haven't met one. And saying 'Oh, I don't mean Jews, just Rothschilds', that doesn't help.

Koelaid · 21/10/2022 09:26

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 09:08

Criticism of Israel IS anti-Semitic… unless you believe Jews don’t deserve their homeland. Knock yourself out about criticising Israeli government policy much as you would about Westminster - but don’t for one minute think your criticism of Israeli government policies is anything LESS than thinly veiled anti-semitism… that is unless you’re prepared to rant at length about policies of Mauritania, zim, Ecuador, Malta or any other country with questionable policies.

Well that isn’t true is it. It’s perfectly possibly to criticise the policies and actions of any state without that making you anti the major religious / ethnic group in that state.

You can criticise American policies without being anti Christian or anti white. Or criticise Saudi policies without being islamaphobic.

It’s important to keep a clear distinction between someone criticising the policies of a state (totally legitimate, and an important freedom and something that people living in and outside that state often do) and someone being racist or anti-Semitic (not legitimate and something that should be condemned).

The two can and do get blurred by some people, but the actions of those people, do not mean that nobody else has the freedom to criticise the actions of the Israeli state without being accused of anti-semitism.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread