Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Tory voters here who are switching to Labour this time?

313 replies

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 14:26

Curious because I think this rarely happens and I can't see Labour getting in, I don't think Tory voters change their mind. Am I very wrong? Do you/have you?

OP posts:
scaredoff · 21/10/2022 12:16

WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 12:06

Lib dems don't stand a chance of forming a government due largely to our crap FPTP system

That's true, but lib dems winning large (by their standards) numbers of seats where they are in the running could lead to the best of all possible outcomes: a minority Labour government forced to introduce PR as the price of lib dem support.

scaredoff · 21/10/2022 12:12

Some posters worry that there will be a hard left 'coup' in the Labour Party.

That is SO not going to happen. The rules have been changed to make prospective candidates garner a larger number of MPs' nominations to get on the ballot - and given the modus operandi of the Labour party bureaucracy, if there's any fear of that not being enough they'll just change them again. Even with the system as was, Corbyn only got on it because a bunch of MPs who didn't really support him lent him their nomination "to broaden the debate", not thinking for one moment that he might actually win. Given the Herculean efforts - and the depths of moral depravity - that the right of the party have had to go to to reassert control, there's no way they'll be making that mistake again.

Then there's the fact that they're busily manipulating selection procedures in order to ensure there are as few left-leaning MPs as possible standing at the next GE, particularly in safe seats.

The socialist Labour left is over as an electorally represented political force. Starmer has ruthlessly and methodically destroyed it. The focus of that kind of energy on the street now is in trade unions and protest groups. I guess plenty of people here are happy about that, but people on the left are mostly pretty "meh" about whether to even bother voting Labour at the next election, except for those with an outstanding left wing local candidate who has somehow managed to slip through the net.

There are surely plenty of good reasons not to vote Labour, particularly for those on this thread who are confirmed natural Tories. But fear of reds under the beds at Labour HQ ain't one of them.

BorisIsaSpider · 21/10/2022 12:07

Annihilate the Tories at the next Election, Vote Tactically

FeelTheRush · 21/10/2022 12:07

My instincts are Tory and I'm also wavering. The next few weeks will be interesting

WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 12:06

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 21/10/2022 10:30

I really would be willing to give Labour a go but the women's rights thing is just too big an issue for me.

As a pp said where the hell are the Lib Dems? This country is in absolute chaos, the tories and Labour are an absolute shambles so they could be in there cleaning up. They would definitely get in at the next GE but their apathy is very unappealing.

Lib dems don't stand a chance of forming a government due largely to our crap FPTP system

Tigofigo · 21/10/2022 12:06

mamabear715 · 21/10/2022 10:44

As a conservative voter in a Labour stronghold ("I vote Labour because my father did, & his father before him" - ffs!) no, I won't be changing my vote. To my mind, Labour don't seem to HAVE any policies. They just say the reverse of anything the conservatives say. A GE would be disastrous. Labour piss any money that the UK has got, away. The Unions - aargh. Someone has to be responsible & make unpopular decisions - NOT Truss-like decisions, of course.
In the words of the King, dear oh dear..
It's two years (hopefully) until the next GE. I'm hoping we'll have a strong leader who will make good decisions - memories are pretty short in politics!

I'm astonished, ASTONISHED that your main issue with Labour is that they piss money away, when members of the cabinet and Govt have just cost the UK economy BILLIONS and made the cost of living crisis significantly worse without anything to show for it - except another disgraced PM. Not forgetting they literally funneled hundreds of millions of public funds into their mates (aka their own) pockets during a global pandemic. And got away with it.

BorisIsaSpider · 21/10/2022 12:05

I will vote to get my MP out, one of the cuntiest of all the Torys. So it will either be Labout or Lib dem depending on who has the best chance. I would urge the Lib Dems to not stand against Labour and vice versa if that would result in the Tory getting in. Just this once, they need to learn a lesson

WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 12:04

mamabear715 · 21/10/2022 10:44

As a conservative voter in a Labour stronghold ("I vote Labour because my father did, & his father before him" - ffs!) no, I won't be changing my vote. To my mind, Labour don't seem to HAVE any policies. They just say the reverse of anything the conservatives say. A GE would be disastrous. Labour piss any money that the UK has got, away. The Unions - aargh. Someone has to be responsible & make unpopular decisions - NOT Truss-like decisions, of course.
In the words of the King, dear oh dear..
It's two years (hopefully) until the next GE. I'm hoping we'll have a strong leader who will make good decisions - memories are pretty short in politics!

This is laughable - as if the Tories haven't "pissed away" all the money over the last 12 years. I can't believe anyone still tries to peddle this shit.

WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 12:01

GasPanic · 20/10/2022 14:33

If there is a GE I will read the manifestos and then make a decision.

How else would anyone sensibly make a decision ?

I mean, do people just have some sort of blind allegiance to one side or the other and vote for them no matter what ?

I think a lot of people have the blind allegiance you describe.

Tigofigo · 21/10/2022 12:00

ChocFrog · 21/10/2022 11:54

The last four elections I’ve voted Labour, Lib Dem, Tory, and Green. Floating voters are very real, I promise you!

Haven’t decided yet who to vote for next time. The current Tory party is clearly obsessed with internal drama and unable to run the country. But I’m very upset about Labour’s policies on gender self-ID and attacking private education. Lib Dem and Green policies seem a copy of Labour (with the Greens in particular insane, and obsessed with pleasing trans lobbyists at the expense of solving climate change).

So personally for my family we’re better off under a Tory Government, but I hate them, so keep going round in circles.

I’ll probably just keep it simple and vote for Kier Starmer. I admire him and Angela Raynor, even though they hate people like me.

Sod policies, I love that Kier bought his mum a donkey sanctuary.

You might be FINANCIALLY better off under a Tory govt (as am I), but is your life any richer? When I see the state of the NHS, councils, state education, bills, poverty and hunger, I don't feel better off life-wise!

MyPurpleJacket · 21/10/2022 11:59

I thought I’d be a lifelong Tory voter but they’ve 100% lost my vote. The trouble is, I wouldn’t vote for Labour even if you paid me (well OK, a million might do it) 😉 There’s no other party that’s got any chance to get in so I might as well just not bother because it’s just dumb and dumber as the choices.

Tigofigo · 21/10/2022 11:56

GasPanic · 20/10/2022 14:33

If there is a GE I will read the manifestos and then make a decision.

How else would anyone sensibly make a decision ?

I mean, do people just have some sort of blind allegiance to one side or the other and vote for them no matter what ?

Manifestos are a bit meaningless when the Govt appears to be utterly incapable of delivering them...

ChocFrog · 21/10/2022 11:54

The last four elections I’ve voted Labour, Lib Dem, Tory, and Green. Floating voters are very real, I promise you!

Haven’t decided yet who to vote for next time. The current Tory party is clearly obsessed with internal drama and unable to run the country. But I’m very upset about Labour’s policies on gender self-ID and attacking private education. Lib Dem and Green policies seem a copy of Labour (with the Greens in particular insane, and obsessed with pleasing trans lobbyists at the expense of solving climate change).

So personally for my family we’re better off under a Tory Government, but I hate them, so keep going round in circles.

I’ll probably just keep it simple and vote for Kier Starmer. I admire him and Angela Raynor, even though they hate people like me.

Sod policies, I love that Kier bought his mum a donkey sanctuary.

scaredoff · 21/10/2022 11:48

WallaceinAnderland · 21/10/2022 01:30

3

3, indeed. Although to be fair, the poster may have blinked and missed the third one. 😀

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 21/10/2022 11:19

Abhannmor · 21/10/2022 10:32

@RichardOsmansXraySpecs Libdems are totally into the gender woo. As are the Greens.

Are they? Fgs what's the matter with them all? 😡

OfficeManager · 21/10/2022 10:48

Kellie45 · 21/10/2022 10:08

Starmer backed Corbyn and his policies in his bid to be PM. You say he’s honest?

@Kellie45 - note the use of the qualifier "relatively" 😀I don't think any politicians are completely honest.

mamabear715 · 21/10/2022 10:44

As a conservative voter in a Labour stronghold ("I vote Labour because my father did, & his father before him" - ffs!) no, I won't be changing my vote. To my mind, Labour don't seem to HAVE any policies. They just say the reverse of anything the conservatives say. A GE would be disastrous. Labour piss any money that the UK has got, away. The Unions - aargh. Someone has to be responsible & make unpopular decisions - NOT Truss-like decisions, of course.
In the words of the King, dear oh dear..
It's two years (hopefully) until the next GE. I'm hoping we'll have a strong leader who will make good decisions - memories are pretty short in politics!

Abhannmor · 21/10/2022 10:32

@RichardOsmansXraySpecs Libdems are totally into the gender woo. As are the Greens.

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 21/10/2022 10:30

I really would be willing to give Labour a go but the women's rights thing is just too big an issue for me.

As a pp said where the hell are the Lib Dems? This country is in absolute chaos, the tories and Labour are an absolute shambles so they could be in there cleaning up. They would definitely get in at the next GE but their apathy is very unappealing.

Abhannmor · 21/10/2022 10:25

SwedishEdith · 20/10/2022 18:17

This thread won't be a reflection though - it will pull in the fervent right wingers. Anonymous polling is more accurate.

It will.And also gender critical feminists - whose concerns I share - who won't vote Labour. But are very unlikely to vote Tory.

Starmer is dull and anal retentive. He reminds me of Douglas Hurd , of whom Alan Clark said : ' he might as well have a fucking corn cob up his arse'.

Ditch the identity crap Keir. Identify with people who want decent schools , hospitals, homes and public transport. KISS. Keep It Simple Stupid.

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 10:24

@Abhannmor no, I think an entire generation has been done over by the implication that a degree is “necessary” for so many basic jobs. The only thing they’ve been “lucky” with is the v low interest rates which kept the wheels turning for a few more years.

MarshaBradyo · 21/10/2022 10:17

I wouldn’t go for a GE now.

Labour will face big problems if / when they get in as there is very little room now for either party.

One difference is position on strikes and unions - so imo Labour in an inflationary environment is something to watch. If we are past the war then not as much.

Of course they’ll both face issues with this but their policy does diverge.

The other issue id like more information on is how Labour will get consent for green policies in the community - ie is it on shore or off shore etc and who will say yes

DullAndOvercast · 21/10/2022 10:16

Blindly sticking to one party is exactly what most people do. It’s very uncommon to switch allegiances.

theconversation.com/how-many-voters-really-switch-parties-in-british-elections-what-the-evidence-tells-us-127690

The British electorate is highly “volatile” according to researchers at the British Election Study which begun in 1964.

...

^In 2010, 32% of voters picked a different party than the one they voted for the previous election in 2005. Between 2010 and 2015, 43% of voters switched.
However, in 2017, the figure dropped back down to 33%. This lower volatility is particularly interesting given how much political turmoil unfolded between 2015 and 2017, including the EU referendum.^

Though I'd agree that not many read the complete manifestos instead really on media to interpreted or look at how they come across in the media or in recent years use on-line questionnaire site that match you to manifesto commitments.

RedAppleGirl · 21/10/2022 10:13

Tegelflughafen · 21/10/2022 09:56

But keen on millionaires cutting public services and financial support for the struggling no ? Oh the irony 😂

Do you believe Labour has a way out of the global aftershocks of the pandemic?
Spare electricity, for example, do they have a feasible plan for inflation?

Boris was always left of center fiscally, however, the markets have called time. No more spending for UK plc especially on public services or financial support for the population.
Although the rebelliousness within the Tory party is appalling, completely unstable. That for me is the only reason to call a GE, but this would set a precedent calling for a GE every time a government has to make unpleasant decisions or infighting takes hold.

MarshaBradyo · 21/10/2022 10:09

Tegelflughafen · 21/10/2022 10:02

@MarshaBradyo you don't have to justify your vote to anyone but the fact that you would let a few gobby posters on MN influence whether you vote Labour or not is perplexing. Who knows whether these people are posting in good faith anyway ? Not unknown for Tory HQ to try to direct public opinion. Who remembers the tory fact checking advert at the leadership hustings back in 2019.

Well it’s up to me to decide. As I said I’ll go by the policies at the time. And yes there are probably influencers on here from both sides but you get a feel for who is not.

Mn has many of them and they generally dominate conversation or try to. Labour supporters don’t help their cause, but that’s up to them.

When it gets closer to the time I’ll assess policies and decide on that.