Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any Tory voters here who are switching to Labour this time?

313 replies

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 14:26

Curious because I think this rarely happens and I can't see Labour getting in, I don't think Tory voters change their mind. Am I very wrong? Do you/have you?

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 14:36

'The UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank [sic] the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up'
What an utter load of shit.
The government did the bare minimum to stave off unrest, stuffed their own and their mates' pockets full of cash and now, like the banking crisis, the poorest are expected to fund it all? Fuck to that.

red4321 · 21/10/2022 14:10

It's the pandemic that started all this excess of government borrowing.
The mandate was to save lives, but this has come at a huge cost. What the public inquiry is now showing is those policies were actually detrimental to the public and made very little difference.

I agree, and KS was pushing for longer lockdowns and more support. I'll be voting Conservative as there's no other party I'd vote for. If that changes, which I doubt, I'll happily vote for a party that better fits my political beliefs.

I also agree the Conservative government has been a shambles and far too many fiefdoms. But Labour are pro more spending which is the last thing the economy needs given the current level of debt.

RedAppleGirl · 21/10/2022 13:36

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:56

The same people slamming the Tories for their debt and fiscal situation, are probably they same people calling for lockdown after lockdown.

Yes, the tories are an absolute shambles, however, the UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up.

'The UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up'.

This is what is so disappointing about Labour, they need to stop bluffing, stop telling lies, and table some policies to free up the Uk post-pandemic.

House build
Incentivize NHS recruitment etc.
Businesses still need support, maybe a debt forgiveness scheme.
The country also needs a realistic ethical conversation around the aging population issue.

Kellie45 · 21/10/2022 13:32

Abhannmor · 21/10/2022 10:09

Many who left school or college after 2008 have never know 'good times'.

Know many 20 somethings in continuous gainful employment with an actual contract , sick pay , holidays etc ?

You need to visit some of the countries I have done to get ‘good times’ into perspective!

DullAndOvercast · 21/10/2022 13:01

I can really understand why people have voted for them in the past but atm I have absolutely no idea how anyone can watch the news now & think they are doing a great job!

I don't think many do think that - but locally there may be a good Tory constituent MP that bucks national trend.

I have good reason to think my current Labour MP is a really shit constituent MP.

However for that seat last time only three candidates didn't lose their deposit last general election - Labour 43%, Con 42% and LD 6%. Previous election is was just Lab, Conservatives that didn't lose deposit - Lab 50% 40 %. 2015 - it was Lab 41%, Con 32% and UKIP at 15% everyone else lost deposit.

So I can vote for a bad MP, a party clearly failing to govern - a party that seems to be lost or a party with so few voters they lost their deposit.

On top of that I'm in Wales - 20 + years of Welsh Labour running NHS and education it's not looking good and it's affecting my family directly plus I'm aware of recent financial scandals by Welsh Government but then nationally Tory governance is a shit show.

So from where I sit it's not a straight forward choice.

JabberwockyPie · 21/10/2022 12:59

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:56

The same people slamming the Tories for their debt and fiscal situation, are probably they same people calling for lockdown after lockdown.

Yes, the tories are an absolute shambles, however, the UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up.

True.

Stars71 · 21/10/2022 12:59

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:56

The same people slamming the Tories for their debt and fiscal situation, are probably they same people calling for lockdown after lockdown.

Yes, the tories are an absolute shambles, however, the UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up.

Yes, and happily taken furlough, whilst holding down another job.

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:58

Jerabilis · 21/10/2022 12:56

I’m a floating voter. There’s no way I can vote for Labour or Lib Dems with their current stance of planning to remove women’s rights and the Tories are in melt down. So not much choice at the moment.

Depressing isn't it.

If the Lib Dems came up with some well costed, progressive and interesting policies, they would clean up voters like us.

Sadly, they are a non entity.

Jerabilis · 21/10/2022 12:56

I’m a floating voter. There’s no way I can vote for Labour or Lib Dems with their current stance of planning to remove women’s rights and the Tories are in melt down. So not much choice at the moment.

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:56

The same people slamming the Tories for their debt and fiscal situation, are probably they same people calling for lockdown after lockdown.

Yes, the tories are an absolute shambles, however, the UK has eaten at the finest restaurant and drank the finest wine with their covid lockdowns and gov assistance. The bill has now arrived, time to pay up.

RedAppleGirl · 21/10/2022 12:52

Tegelflughafen · 21/10/2022 12:26

@RedAppleGirl so where has all the money gone ? We've had a supposedly fiscally responsible tory government for the last 12 years. Huge cuts to public services, local government spending slashed, especially to less affluent northern councils.
Other countries managed to provide vital financial support during the pandemic, if not more generously and fund decent public services. What's different about the UK ?
Why can't we let someone else have a decent throw at governing the country rather
than rehashes of the same inept crew who have crashed the economy single handedly.

It's the pandemic that started all this excess of government borrowing.
The mandate was to save lives, but this has come at a huge cost. What the public inquiry is now showing is those policies were actually detrimental to the public and made very little difference.

Track and trace were copied from other nations. Turned out it wasn't such a great idea with the British public. I think we've had a sea of populist policies, and incessant narrating from social media.
researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-9309/CBP-9309.pdf

'The Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in very high levels of public spending.
Current estimates of the cost of Government measures announced so far
range from about £310 to £410 billion. This is the equivalent of about £4,600
to £6,100 per person in the UK'.

Then people like yourself accuse the government of NOT spending money on the public. It's absurd. Yes the roads are a mess, yes the NHS cannot clear the backlog, and yes some children are 2 yrs or more behind. This is life post-pandemic.
I agree the Tories have vicious in-fighting, which is disgraceful. However, I've yet to see an honest appraisal economically from Labour.

fromdownwest · 21/10/2022 12:52

Angip3 · 21/10/2022 12:44

"I don't always vote, and have voted tactically a couple of times but this time it could be anyone or no one for me."

please vote! even if its for an independent so they have a chance at keeping their deposit, they just see none votes as apathy, tactical voting for "anyone but them" they can see in the results.

When you have nothing but apathy for all the parties, the system and the outcome, not voting is my only option.

I do not wish to partake in an event that does not represent any of my views. I have always voted, but this time, I just can't.

Angip3 · 21/10/2022 12:44

"I don't always vote, and have voted tactically a couple of times but this time it could be anyone or no one for me."

please vote! even if its for an independent so they have a chance at keeping their deposit, they just see none votes as apathy, tactical voting for "anyone but them" they can see in the results.

Nanny0gg · 21/10/2022 12:40

Cattytabby · 20/10/2022 14:32

I want to, but I just can't. The only thing I can say about Labour is they might be slightly less bad. And then Keir Starmer speaks...

^^This

scaredoff · 21/10/2022 12:37

MarshaBradyo · 21/10/2022 12:29

I do too. Blair’s Labour I got, but what it is now is a different thing.

What do you see as the main differences? Curious about this as Starmer has put so much effort into marketing himself as Blair version 2.0

scaredoff · 21/10/2022 12:35

I feel the same way about labour. That people are voting for something that no longer exists.

How so? Pretty much everyone can see what the Labour party is now: a centrist capitalism-friendly party with a bit more consideration for public services and a welfare state than the Tories, and a bit more tolerance of the taxes required to fund such things. Pretty much the same economic space as the lib dems, although maybe less "lib" on social issues.

A lot of people will vote for that because it corresponds pretty well to what they want. Some disaffected Tories (eg on this thread) will vote for it because it's close enough to what they want while the option they really want is disintegrating before their eyes. Some people genuinely on the left will vote for it simply because they have no better option, even though it's nowhere near what they want, and some won't bother or will vote Green or whatever.

But I've not seen anyone who still imagines that the Labour party is what it used to be.

TightDiamondShoes · 21/10/2022 12:33

For those chatting maternity rights - do you understand that EU countries differ in their offerings? I speak as someone who had 16 week’s maternity leave in the EU. Not a year of baby yoga and sign language.

WatchoRulo · 21/10/2022 12:30

Some posters worry that there will be a hard left 'coup' in the Labour Party.
The horror - you mean like the ridiculously hard right "Britiania unchained" takeover that's happened to the Tories?

MarshaBradyo · 21/10/2022 12:29

JabberwockyPie · 21/10/2022 12:27

I feel the same way about labour. That people are voting for something that no longer exists.

I do too. Blair’s Labour I got, but what it is now is a different thing.

JabberwockyPie · 21/10/2022 12:27

QueueEtwo · 21/10/2022 12:20

Tigo I agree with you! It's like people are talking about the Conservative Party of years ago not this party of second hand car dealers that we have at the moment!
I've never voted Conservative but I can recognise that they have had some amazing politicians over the years, John Major when he speaks now sounds positively statesmen like & he's deemed to be one of the worst of them!

But now we have James Cleverly ( who most definitely isn't!) Nadine Dorris, JRM, Stephen Barclay, before you even start on Truss & Kwarteng!

It's a party split into so many fractions, the ERG, the One Nation lot, they can't agree on anything which is ironic considering Cameron called the Referendum to try & unit the party!

I can really understand why people have voted for them in the past but atm I have absolutely no idea how anyone can watch the news now & think they are doing a great job!

I feel the same way about labour. That people are voting for something that no longer exists.

Tegelflughafen · 21/10/2022 12:26

@RedAppleGirl so where has all the money gone ? We've had a supposedly fiscally responsible tory government for the last 12 years. Huge cuts to public services, local government spending slashed, especially to less affluent northern councils.
Other countries managed to provide vital financial support during the pandemic, if not more generously and fund decent public services. What's different about the UK ?
Why can't we let someone else have a decent throw at governing the country rather
than rehashes of the same inept crew who have crashed the economy single handedly.

QueueEtwo · 21/10/2022 12:20

Tigo I agree with you! It's like people are talking about the Conservative Party of years ago not this party of second hand car dealers that we have at the moment!
I've never voted Conservative but I can recognise that they have had some amazing politicians over the years, John Major when he speaks now sounds positively statesmen like & he's deemed to be one of the worst of them!

But now we have James Cleverly ( who most definitely isn't!) Nadine Dorris, JRM, Stephen Barclay, before you even start on Truss & Kwarteng!

It's a party split into so many fractions, the ERG, the One Nation lot, they can't agree on anything which is ironic considering Cameron called the Referendum to try & unit the party!

I can really understand why people have voted for them in the past but atm I have absolutely no idea how anyone can watch the news now & think they are doing a great job!

scaredoff · 21/10/2022 12:19

Tigofigo · 21/10/2022 12:06

I'm astonished, ASTONISHED that your main issue with Labour is that they piss money away, when members of the cabinet and Govt have just cost the UK economy BILLIONS and made the cost of living crisis significantly worse without anything to show for it - except another disgraced PM. Not forgetting they literally funneled hundreds of millions of public funds into their mates (aka their own) pockets during a global pandemic. And got away with it.

Yep, that anyone can still present the Tories as the party of fiscal responsibility absolutely beggars belief. So much so that I can't even see how to engage with it. It's like flat Earthism or something.

JabberwockyPie · 21/10/2022 12:18

Who would you vote for then tigofigo?

Tigofigo · 21/10/2022 12:17

For those worried about voting eg Labour or Green because of women's rights: Look VERY carefully at what the current govt are doing - or planning to do - in terms of ripping up EU laws which enshrine things like paid maternity leave, pregnancy/ maternity as a protected characteristic, anti discrimination laws, equal pay for women.

NO guarantees any of these things (alongside other workplace rights, environmental protection etc) will stay in place after 2023.