Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reconsidering private education/labour gov

214 replies

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:41

As it looks increasingly likely that we will have a Labour government at some point, I’m wondering if anyone who was considering private education for their children is now re-considering it? We have put down a deposit for a prep school we really like which we could comfortably afford at the moment but not with significant fee increases. Just wondering if anyone else has concerns along the same lines and if so what are you thinking…

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 20/10/2022 13:16

I suspect posts like these being Tory HQ as its one of their last ditch defences: don't vote Labour they will abolish private education, and put up tax.

It is not going to be a priority for a labour government.

Scaevola · 20/10/2022 13:13

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 13:01

@Scaevola Thanks for that clear explanation. I think (not sure though) Labour have just spoken about removal of charity status and not vat on fees right? But it seems like a number of people think the latter is likely as well

I think they would be fools to attempt to tackle charitable status, because it's a policy that's going to cost the state more in the longer run.

But VAT on fees is simpler and would raise more

Labour pledged it in 2017 (Corbyn, not sure if it's been reaffirmed by Starmer)

Gove is on the record of being in favour too.

So I think it'll come, it's just a case of when and at what rate.

(And I do think people often don't realise there are two separate issues here; and that if schools could legally relinquish charitable status without having to sell up in line with current law on winding up a charity, they would probably leap at it. But allowing charitable assets to become privately owned could be highly unfortunate. That's why I'd want to see the exact proposal - lots of people have banged on about it being desirable, but no-one has actually shown a good way in which it could actually be done)

CatsAreCrackers · 20/10/2022 13:09

I've lived out of the country for many years, and only been back for a couple, but (and this is a genuine question, not a goady one), what improvements did Labour make to education last time they were in power?

VickyEadieofThigh · 20/10/2022 13:08

Labour were talking about entirely abolishing the private education sector decades ago.

Didn't happen. Charitable status (and not all independent schools have it) wouldn't, as some have indicated, make a massive difference to fees even if labour got around to doing it.

Labour piss me off for different reasons but the way that the Tories are intent on making everyone pay a lot more for most things ought to offset your fears about Labour possibly shoving a couple of hundred on your school fees at some point in the future.

CoffeeHousePot · 20/10/2022 13:06

My eldest is going to secondary and it was a factor in us staying in the day sector, rather than going towards the more expensive day/boarding schools. I am working on the basis 20% could go on the fees in say 18 months and I need to pay for this.

Mardyface · 20/10/2022 13:02

Dorisbonson · 20/10/2022 12:52

Is there any sector which isn't improved by having competition with different ideas, standards and outcomes?

I don't think fees would increase that much anyway. I still think it is immoral to tax education.

Yes, loads. Transport for one. Health for another. Certainly education for most people.

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 13:01

@Scaevola Thanks for that clear explanation. I think (not sure though) Labour have just spoken about removal of charity status and not vat on fees right? But it seems like a number of people think the latter is likely as well

OP posts:
cosmiccosmos · 20/10/2022 12:59

Anyone who thinks they will do this and then use the money to improve the state sector is living in cloud cuckoo land. It will be done as a way of 'proving' that Labour want to 'level up' and it will appeal to the left.

If they do it many private schools will close and there won't be enough secondary places. It will create chaos.

In the long term those who would have chosen private but can't afford it will push into areas and 'create' outstanding schools. Like the one near me that pushes any disruptive children into another school that is part of that academy and all the children and parents in that town just have to our up with it.

Plus the state sector won't improve as they won't use the money in education they will waste it.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 20/10/2022 12:58

Removing charitable status is legally extremely difficult. In part because it’s not the case that the state can just sweep in and take assets that have been left to charity. It would be a complete and utter mess.

However, Adding VAT of 20% to school fees is a very quick and easy job to do and I would expect them to do it pretty much immediately on getting in while they’ve got a massive majority. If you’re only going to scrape by for private school fees, I wouldn’t sign up for it right now.

Scaevola · 20/10/2022 12:53

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:44

Concerns are that Labour has said they will remove charity status of private schools which will result in significant increases in fees. I expect this will mean many parents like us who have well paying professional jobs but aren’t multi millionaires will end up having to withdraw their children

It won't mean a significant increase in fees.

The value of charitable status is about £200 per pupil per term (source: The Guardian). That's less than the variation between fees between schools and of course wouldn't apply to those schools that are businesses.

I have never seen a full proposal for removing charitable status. At present, charities have to be wound up in accordance with the law, which means that all assets must be sold at proper market venue, and the proceeds donated to another similarly-aimed charity. That's going to mean closures, and I really wouldn't want to have a child in either sector as state schools have to accommodate those left with no school as a result of closure. Because they're not awash with money to create new places.

If Labour really is looking at this, I hope they publish an exact proposal soon, as this is very much a devil-in-the-detail issue and the consequences of getting it wrong will affect all school age DC.

Imposing a form of tax on school fees is a totally different question, unrelated to charitable status (currently exempt as still the same as the EU regulation which is no taxation on nursery, school or university fees - same one covers all those). Post-Brexit it is however something that can be done.

I really hope it would be done as part of a proper review of successor VAT, not piecemeal (unintended consequences also possible, and I don't trust any party to be competent). But I think this tax change is far more achievable, and likely to raise considerably more tax revenue

Figmentofmyimagination · 20/10/2022 12:52

One quite realistic outcome, however, depending on the positioning of the chosen school in the independent sector market, might be the entire school being absorbed lockstock into the state sector as an academy. There is precedent for this.

Academic selection would need to end up there are other selection mechanisms apart from ‘academic’ already in use in the state sector.

Absorption of mid-range independents into the state sector is much more likely than closure of the schools, placing pressure on the existing state system.

It’s quite a ‘win win’ for current parents when this does happen as their fees disappear. However the school has usually already been in distress for quite a while before being taken forward.

anyway I expect this will be another aspect of the March of academisation.

Dorisbonson · 20/10/2022 12:52

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/10/2022 11:46

Hopefully Labour would improve education for all and less people would need to choose private schools.

Is there any sector which isn't improved by having competition with different ideas, standards and outcomes?

I don't think fees would increase that much anyway. I still think it is immoral to tax education.

autienotnaughty · 20/10/2022 12:47

ChicaneOvenchips · 20/10/2022 12:39

I would be seriously disappointed in a Labour government that puts even more barriers in the way of children having access to the most suitable education for them as individuals. Not all private schools are about the elite, some are the only option left to young people who have been destroyed by the state school system. There are serious serious issues in the state school sector that need immediately addressing. This should be the next (and current!) governments priority, not making an already difficult to reach last option become an impossibility for children who have been failed by the system.

That is a valid point. Means tested perhaps?

autienotnaughty · 20/10/2022 12:46

VaccineSticker · 20/10/2022 12:33

VAT is coming Labour think they can fix the state school system by penalising the private school sector. They don’t realise the damage it’s going to cause.
I will still vote labour regardless in the next election as all this doesn’t matter in the long run. What matters the most is getting rid of the dirty environmental policies if we want a chance for us and our children to have quality of life in the near future.

OP you also need to factor in inflation to the fees regardless if labour introduce VAT or not. Hope it works out for you guys x

What damage? Money needs to be found and I'd sooner a few middle class people have to use public school (gasp) than the poor continue to starve (conservatives plan)

Kabbalah · 20/10/2022 12:41

At the very least they'll remove their charitable status and hammer them with tax but, given the chance and a sizable majority, the likes of Raynor and Lammy will get rid of private education altogether. So yes, I believe you have grounds for concern.

Mardyface · 20/10/2022 12:41

Oh I thought the title meant because state schools would improve because they'll actually be properly funded. How wrong I was.

EuripidesEumenides · 20/10/2022 12:41

The amount money abolishing the charitable status of private schools would raise would be a tiny fraction of a rounding error in the grand scheme of government spending. By the time a Labour government could be in place, it will be full on battlefield surgery time for the country with much much more profound things needing fixing urgently. I really can't see something as divisive and ideological as this being a priority.

ChicaneOvenchips · 20/10/2022 12:39

I would be seriously disappointed in a Labour government that puts even more barriers in the way of children having access to the most suitable education for them as individuals. Not all private schools are about the elite, some are the only option left to young people who have been destroyed by the state school system. There are serious serious issues in the state school sector that need immediately addressing. This should be the next (and current!) governments priority, not making an already difficult to reach last option become an impossibility for children who have been failed by the system.

jtaeapa · 20/10/2022 12:35

I think that labour would have to think really carefully before just shoving 20% VAT on private fees. The tens of thousands who would be priced out would immediately need state places. And private/state is something that varies massively by area. In some areas, several private schools are thriving because of the very sparse or poor state provision. In other areas, there is little private provision because the state provision is fine. So basically it wouldn't be a case of every state school can take in a few priced out private kids, it would be more like a smaller number of full state schools would be asked to take in tens or even hundreds of kids.

Any VAT would have to be phased in over a number of years.

VaccineSticker · 20/10/2022 12:33

VAT is coming Labour think they can fix the state school system by penalising the private school sector. They don’t realise the damage it’s going to cause.
I will still vote labour regardless in the next election as all this doesn’t matter in the long run. What matters the most is getting rid of the dirty environmental policies if we want a chance for us and our children to have quality of life in the near future.

OP you also need to factor in inflation to the fees regardless if labour introduce VAT or not. Hope it works out for you guys x

jtaeapa · 20/10/2022 12:31

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/10/2022 11:46

Hopefully Labour would improve education for all and less people would need to choose private schools.

How many years would this take though? There are serious problems in education.

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 12:25

Looking at some older mumsnet threads, some people seem to be saying removable of charity status is different to VAT on fees and that’s not what’s being proposed. Anyone able to clarify if that’s correct?

OP posts:
Figmentofmyimagination · 20/10/2022 12:21

VAT is coming. You are right to be concerned.

You should certainly factor VAT into your estimate and if you then can’t afford it, then don’t do it. Nothing worse for your child than being withdrawn from independent sector in a disruptive way part way through their education because you can’t pay. Who knows what state school spaces will still be available to you. Ask yourself what you are prepared to give up (eg downsizing your house) to keep them there if fees become unaffordable.

With a solid majority, I expect labour will have no problem making this change and quickly. In the current climate, you would expect to see this as a labour manifesto commitment, unfortunately for those parents who are caught in the middle.

MouldyCheeseandBiscuits · 20/10/2022 12:11

Education Education Education- Labour

Cut school budgets to the core- Coalition and Conservative

Given recent history Labour will be better for education than any Tory led government.

ChiefPearlClutcher · 20/10/2022 11:53

There has been many threads about this, use the search function. I honestly cba to type it all out. But it won’t happen. And if they try, it will take YEARS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread