Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reconsidering private education/labour gov

214 replies

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:41

As it looks increasingly likely that we will have a Labour government at some point, I’m wondering if anyone who was considering private education for their children is now re-considering it? We have put down a deposit for a prep school we really like which we could comfortably afford at the moment but not with significant fee increases. Just wondering if anyone else has concerns along the same lines and if so what are you thinking…

OP posts:
Andante57 · 20/10/2022 15:59

However, much as Labour like to say they are going to do this, so many of the MP's have their kids within these systems that whilst they might talk the talk I think its highly unlikely they will walk the walk.

mummymeister do you mean many Labour MPs have children at private schools?

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 15:58

I'd pay more on school fees if it went directly to state education but of course that's never going to happen, pie in the sky. Whoever is in power its always playing catchup and as parents we don't have enough years in our DC education for the Sisyphean task of pushing for real change.

Fee paying parents who are teachers, plumbers, HCP's, etc would be the first to be priced out so it would make the independent system even more elite, not less which is not a good thing.

If parents are choosing independent school its because our state system doesn't work for them or for their DC for whatever reason, take independent schools away and the state system still doesn't work for them. Turning them into academies doesn't solve that difference.

I'd like to see the state school system completely overhauled. Short school days were fine 50 years ago when I started school, many mothers were SAHM and my working mum was in the minority but society is no longer like that, most adult women work, couples work. The state needs to catch up and support a society in which both parents work with better/cheaper childcare and eg 8am to 5pm school days. Then people who don’t work because of having DC would be able to, hopefully in turn reducing the burden on the state benefits system. Rather than wasting a fortune on the legalities of dissolving charities and buying out independent school premises spend money on bringing state teachers salaries in line with independents and invest in improving and expanding facilities to allow for smaller class sizes. If the state schools were run more like independents, with more time in the day for broader sports, arts and interest clubs (and higher expectations of behaviour in some cases), there wouldn't be a demand for independent schools. I'm talking crap I know.

Luckydip1 · 20/10/2022 15:58

Buying a house in the catchment area is different because you will sell for a high price when you move on so not really a cost as such.

Luckydip1 · 20/10/2022 15:56

They could remove the vat exemption for private schools, that would hurt.

astarsheis · 20/10/2022 15:52

What @EuripidesEumenides said.
I agree. The schools, NHS and economy are in such a mess, Removing charitable status from private schools will be a way down on the list of priorities.
FWIW...find a good local primary school and save your private school money until they go to senior school.

plinkypots · 20/10/2022 15:44

This is a clear example of the left tearing themselves apart over each issue. I have children in the private sector, one of whom is there because the state sector couldn't cater for him. I will still vote Labour and have some faith that the issue will be dealt with by someone with more brains than a radish. The tories unite over their greed. It's their single purpose. It means they are more cohesive. The left fall out over every single issue that doesn't go their way. It makes them easy to divide. I don't like Labour stance on women. I don't like their thoughts on private schools. BUT bugger all has been said about how they plan to deal with either issue. And I refuse to vote the safe Tory option because I disagree with some of what Labour has said in the past.

pigcon1 · 20/10/2022 14:39

PodgePie · 20/10/2022 13:30

There is a far wider impact following any significant increase in independent school fees. The popular schools will become even more over-subscribed and guess what? The houses surrounding them will become more in demand, therefore more expensive. Soon the top state schools will mirror independent schools anyway because only the wealthiest can afford to live anywhere near them. These parents who can afford the nicer areas (and ergo, the nicer schools) can also afford to donate money to theIr children’s schools, because they’ll be saving so much cash from not having to pay fees … thus becoming a semi-privately funded school regardless.

This. Clearly.

LionsandLambs · 20/10/2022 14:22

I’ve got one in year 13 (independent year 7 onwards). Unless I was rich enough to absorb big rises I wouldn’t proceed at the moment. Fees went up 7% this year alone and another 20% added to that, is significant. I’m not sure how charities can have this 20% added and still exist as charities. Dissolving the charity is eye wateringly complex. So it might take some time to implement. If it’s just slapped onto the school, then the school may absorb the cost by stopping bursaries.

CoffeeHousePot · 20/10/2022 14:22

@PodgePie totally agree and that's what happens in the States. Middle class state schools where parents can afford to give large amounts in donations.

What you don't have is all schools levelling up.

It already happens to a certain extent. Houses in catchment areas for certain schools round here are 100K more then houses only a few streets away.

It's a vote winner though.

Although raises questions about nurseries, universities, after school clubs and activities.

Also private healthcare? Same arguments really.

caffelattetogo · 20/10/2022 14:14

If money is remotely tight, do not do it. This government has screwed the economy so badly that all bills are going up. Schools will need to do the same, just to keep the heating on and staff being paid. Costs everywhere are rocketing. If you are seriously rich you'll be fine, if not I wouldn't take the risk.

GoldenCupidon · 20/10/2022 14:12

I think even if Labour did introduce it early it would be set to come in at a later date, they will have civil servants telling them the stuff people are saying here about how many extra kids they may have to accommodate in the state sector.

It's a good idea though, private education (except for children with disabilities / other different cases e.g. parents in the forces who may genuinely have no alternative ) is the definition of a luxury.

We pay VAT on loads of things we actually need. Of course it should be paid on something for which there is a completely valid mainstream alternative used by more than 90% of the country.

MarshaBradyo · 20/10/2022 14:06

LoraOldSpot · 20/10/2022 13:28

Oh wow… and to think that I initially read this as you were potentially going to consider state schooling because state schools would actually be properly funded under a labour government!

It won’t make that much difference after state has to take extra students. Currently some people are paying twice and they don’t take the space although pay the taxes

Regularsizedrudy · 20/10/2022 14:05

Boo fucking hoo. They shouldn’t have charity status. How is a school for the most privileged a charity?

Dorisbonson · 20/10/2022 14:05

LoraOldSpot · 20/10/2022 13:28

Oh wow… and to think that I initially read this as you were potentially going to consider state schooling because state schools would actually be properly funded under a labour government!

I don't think they can put that much additional money into it. Where is the money going to come from? The current lot borrowed money like it was going out of fashion.

Dorisbonson · 20/10/2022 14:03

Mardyface · 20/10/2022 13:02

Yes, loads. Transport for one. Health for another. Certainly education for most people.

Really Transport? Health? Education? You don't like choice? Perhaps it's nice for someone to pick what's best for you? I like free will.

Figmentofmyimagination · 20/10/2022 13:58

I agree that independents converting to academy status is what we are most likely to see in the low-middle price range of the sector.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/10/2022 13:53

@autienotnaughty they could go out and get more hours etc (currently doing a 52hour week at work whilst managing our side line) instead of targeting the middle yet again. My next day off is likely to be bonfire night realistically and that's if DH doesn't buy the house he's interested in at auction!!

OP if they remove charitable status and out law private schools it is likely many will convert to academies with significant "voluntary" contributions for extracurricular activities. I'm banking on the fact most MP won't want their kids in the state system so although they won't say who or how they voted it's likely they will vote against it or the policy won't get through the House of Lords.

Do you have any good state school near you? One near us is comparable with the local boarding school, it selects based on postcode/house price. We've debated moving closer to it vs private as eventually we could sell the house, DS would get the same education and likely a similar group of friends.

PodgePie · 20/10/2022 13:30

There is a far wider impact following any significant increase in independent school fees. The popular schools will become even more over-subscribed and guess what? The houses surrounding them will become more in demand, therefore more expensive. Soon the top state schools will mirror independent schools anyway because only the wealthiest can afford to live anywhere near them. These parents who can afford the nicer areas (and ergo, the nicer schools) can also afford to donate money to theIr children’s schools, because they’ll be saving so much cash from not having to pay fees … thus becoming a semi-privately funded school regardless.

NCFT0922 · 20/10/2022 13:29

@Bluevelvetcake2 it’s certainly on peoples minds. I was discussing this yesterday with a school mum at my DCs school and she is considering sending them to a state secondary school.

CryCeratops · 20/10/2022 13:29

Honestly, I’d be more concerned about general rises in inflation and cost of living increases.

Labour have talked about doing this sort of thing before, but we’ve had Labour governments before and nothing’s changed about private school’s tax statuses.
A new Labour government coming in might make this a higher priority than previous Labour governments have, but I can’t see it coming top of their to do list. I wouldn’t imagine it coming soon.

However, private schools in general have a track record of regularly increasing fees above inflation, not to mention all the hidden costs beyond the termly fees figure.

So you can reliably count on annual above inflation fee rises, plus jumps in fees at certain points as your DC age through the school, as well as all the current uncertainties around increases in the cost of living. Something to bear in mind when thinking about how the finances might work.

LoraOldSpot · 20/10/2022 13:28

Oh wow… and to think that I initially read this as you were potentially going to consider state schooling because state schools would actually be properly funded under a labour government!

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 13:22

Ok it’s useful to know my fears aren’t completely unfounded. Will have to discuss with DH. We had already taken into account yearly rises but not adding on an extra 20%. DH is optimistic about career progression and salary increases, I’m always a bit more circumspect.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 20/10/2022 13:19

Is the fear re charitable status and adding VAT?

I have no idea how long it would take. I would hope it’s gradual so children already started don’t face issues with living to oversubscribed state sector

Topgub · 20/10/2022 13:18

The quicker it happens the better.

Womblesaremyfavouritefood · 20/10/2022 13:17

Indie sector here and we've recently been sent a survey asking specifically if we could afford the fees if they went up by 20% overnight. The survey was from an independent schools group so obviously they are contemplating it, even if it doesn't happen. Interestingly a lot of parents replied that such a rise would mean they'd have to withdraw their DC and go to the state schools (which are hugely oversubscribed here).