Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reconsidering private education/labour gov

214 replies

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:41

As it looks increasingly likely that we will have a Labour government at some point, I’m wondering if anyone who was considering private education for their children is now re-considering it? We have put down a deposit for a prep school we really like which we could comfortably afford at the moment but not with significant fee increases. Just wondering if anyone else has concerns along the same lines and if so what are you thinking…

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 20/10/2022 19:13

God, I so hope Labour follow through on this. Imagine if there was actual pressure to reform state education, it would be glorious.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:11

@SurpriseWombat

If you can afford private fees regardless of sacrifice you're not deprived despite your address

SurpriseWombat · 20/10/2022 19:09

Topgub · 20/10/2022 18:22

Why are people arguing thar removing charitable status would result in the collapse of private education, forcing the state to accommodate all privately educated children?

That would never happen.

@Jackiewoo

Do your DC have friends from very deprived areas at their 'indy'?

I was at an independent day school in the 2000s. It was certainly at the cheap end of private schools, full of peeling paint but plenty of academic rigour.

The local secondary schools were dire at the time (amongst the worst in the country then, much better now) and so there absolutely were kids there from deprived areas, often with parents having made huge sacrifices to send them there. More than a handful of kids from working class areas, quite a few parents in manual jobs, single widowed mothers (no maintenance!), and lots of tatty old hatchbacks dropping kids off. A great many of the kids (possibly the majority, my memory doesn't stretch that far) had come from state primary schools.

I'm not trying to suggest all the kids came from impoverished backgrounds - there were two or three kids in my year who had horses at home - but a great many were making big sacrifices to avoid the dire local state secondaries. A 20% fee rise would probably have tipped the balance for a significant number (but by no means all) of the families there.

Over time the local state secondaries got much better, with a good new one opening down the road. Presented with much more acceptable state options, the parents chose those, pupil numbers dropped off, and eventually the school closed, which was a shame.

ginghamstarfish · 20/10/2022 19:05

As many Labour supporters and politicians send their kids to private schools that seems unlikely.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:03

@Jackiewoo

I asked because you said your dc had friends from all walks of life

I'm afraid I don't believe you

Even if they do stay in a 'deprived area' if they're going to a private school it's unlikely they are actually deprived or living in a chaotic home life

SurpriseWombat · 20/10/2022 18:58

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:44

Concerns are that Labour has said they will remove charity status of private schools which will result in significant increases in fees. I expect this will mean many parents like us who have well paying professional jobs but aren’t multi millionaires will end up having to withdraw their children

They've been muttering about that since I was at school in the 2000s and nothing ever came of it. I wouldn't make decisions about my child's education based on a possible policy of a party who aren't currently in power.

If they were to remove charitable status, VAT would be added at 20% but I strongly suspect that there would be a long notice period (at least enough to avoid issues with teenagers having to move schools midway through GCSEs or A Levels) and you'd be far from the only one moving.

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/10/2022 18:56

“We don't want to send him to a schools with loads of children from backgrounds that don't have our values.”

Then you shall raise narrow minded children, surely?

MarshaBradyo · 20/10/2022 18:54

validnumber · 20/10/2022 18:51

@Haffiana fair points.

@MarshaBradyo

'Exactly. It’s such lazy petty politics'
I don't consider education politics 'petty' 🤷‍♀️.
It is and always will be an important discussion.

Of course education isn’t petty - this policy is though.

As a good indication look at Blair who stood on the education line as a core tenant to the election v Starmer going for the envy vote to no real benefit.

Blair got it - build it up don’t appeal to the negative side of people who want to tear down..

validnumber · 20/10/2022 18:51

@Haffiana fair points.

@MarshaBradyo

'Exactly. It’s such lazy petty politics'
I don't consider education politics 'petty' 🤷‍♀️.
It is and always will be an important discussion.

Grumpybutfunny · 20/10/2022 18:50

@GoldenCupidon education isn't a luxury. Paying private school fees is no different to buying a house in the catchment of an outstanding state schools (our best locally has a catchment area of a mile) being in that area adds at least 100k to house prices compared to 2miles away. You don't pay VAT on house prices!

If we got the share of our tax that goes to state schools that we don't use, that would cover the VAT on day fees.

If we allowed more selection in state school admission and allowed parents to pay top ups less would choose private. We want somewhere that reflects our values in life (respect, dignity, moral values), has a good range of extracurricular activities, opportunities to compete in sports against other schools, enrichment activities and a student body of like minded peers. We will get that by either moving house, a faith education or paying private. We don't want to send him to a schools with loads of children from backgrounds that don't have our values. Who wants to work hard to have a successful life and then not give that to their kids.

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 18:39

yes they do @Topgub. Bursaries for some very lovely and talented DC. Another of their friends dads works in a factory, no bursary they just work their nuts off to pay the fees. Another works for the NHS (and no, not a surgeon or anything flashy adminy). They value their DC education, don't like the local state schools and find a way to an alternative. Nobody bats an eye. Why do you ask? Do you have a problem with DC from deprived areas?

If you'd read my previous post you'd see that I think the whole bloody system needs overhauling from scratch. Then we might not need indy schools at all. Either way its always a parents responsibility to educate, not the state's, parents just defer the job to them or can choose to do it otherwise.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 18:22

Why are people arguing thar removing charitable status would result in the collapse of private education, forcing the state to accommodate all privately educated children?

That would never happen.

@Jackiewoo

Do your DC have friends from very deprived areas at their 'indy'?

MintJulia · 20/10/2022 18:22

I'm a single mum with a ds at independent. Fees are calculated down to the last penny. If they go up more than expected, I'll just have to raid my pension.

We're into GCSEs now. We're committed. I'd rather sell the house than change schools at this point.

GoldenCupidon · 20/10/2022 18:22

Amazing how whingey people can be about paying tax on their luxuries isn't it.

Imagine having to pay TAX on the very expensive treat you buy for your children, in order to help them get ahead of other, poorer children. The very cheek of it.

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 18:19

it will stop producing terrible self serving politicians that don't fund state education properly good grief. The majority of independent school DC don't even go into politics, let alone all have the same opinions. Writing independent school DC off as a mass of braying billionaire Boris lookalike toffs is a shitty attitude toward children. The DC do all sorts and aspire to be anything including teachers and doctors, just like teenagers anywhere. And the fees go back into the economy via teachers salaries, supplies etc too, they don't vanish into a billionaires back pocket. And foreign pupils bring money into the economy too, there's loads of them.

My DC at indy has friends from all walks of life, their best friend's parent is a state school teacher, another friend is Finnish, they have a Mongolian friend, its much more multicultural than our local comp. The difference is their friends don't all live in a fixed radius of their school.

A very vocal and very left-leaning teacher I know lives in a house worth 4 x mine to send their DC to the leafiest comprehensive for 50 miles, they talk the big talk but have discreetly gamed the system. And they complain to and about the school all the damned time and get nowhere. But somehow me, in my crap house but using my own money to put DC in fantastic schools they're thriving in is doing something monstrous by comparison. Its ludicrous, I could home ed but not be able to work nearly as much which means I'd pay less tax, so why is that more acceptable? Anti-indy is a straw man argument.

The British state system is just one way of educating but its far from being the only way, to think it should be is overly simplistic and not in the real world. Put 500,000 DC from indy schools into the state system and it would be a disaster in an already overwhelmed system and the already overwhelmed teachers would bear the brunt.

glassdarker · 20/10/2022 18:10

This (ie adding VAT to school fees) woild if pushed through be an absolutely batshitly destructive move by labour.

They would push kids into the already oversubscribed public sector, with the pressure on resources felt by the most needy.

The money made would be trivial compared to the cost. There are approx 600,000 kids in private school. If you assume average fees of 17k a year and that every parent paid this it would amount to approx 2% of the uk education budget. In contrast, for every child that moved from private to state education they would have to find double the cost of the vat income to find their place.

It also won't solve either in the short or long term any inequality. The rich will continue to pay the fees, so the gulf between truly rich and middle class widens, whilst at the same time pressure on the state system means the worst off/ those who find it hardest to access education are worse off still.

This is why I will never vote labour.

MarshaBradyo · 20/10/2022 18:02

Haffiana · 20/10/2022 17:59

How will they pressure Government exactly? By voting?

Then they will simply vote for whichever party doesn't try to tax private school fees. Or put pressure on them to abolish fees, if it is that simple.

It gives me the RAGE that the Labour Party are still indulging in this sort of idiotic mad, leftist SHIT when our economy is tanking. If they want to improve schools then bloody improve them.

Do not try to blame private school parents for the state they are in. Private school parents are actually already paying for the State system same as everyone else. They are simply not actually using what they have paid for.

Exactly. It’s such lazy petty politics.

tissueachoo · 20/10/2022 18:01

All the jealous people flock to these threads.

OP I will never happen.

Haffiana · 20/10/2022 17:59

validnumber · 20/10/2022 17:28

Don't you mean it will mean more pressure on governments to fund schools properly because more middle/high earners will have to use normal schools and those people will help pressure the government? In this day and age no one should have to consider private education.

How will they pressure Government exactly? By voting?

Then they will simply vote for whichever party doesn't try to tax private school fees. Or put pressure on them to abolish fees, if it is that simple.

It gives me the RAGE that the Labour Party are still indulging in this sort of idiotic mad, leftist SHIT when our economy is tanking. If they want to improve schools then bloody improve them.

Do not try to blame private school parents for the state they are in. Private school parents are actually already paying for the State system same as everyone else. They are simply not actually using what they have paid for.

validnumber · 20/10/2022 17:28

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:49

Yes I think seeline is right that many will end up shutting and this will put more pressure on the state sector (which is brilliant isn’t it?)

Don't you mean it will mean more pressure on governments to fund schools properly because more middle/high earners will have to use normal schools and those people will help pressure the government? In this day and age no one should have to consider private education.

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/10/2022 17:24

Haffiana · 20/10/2022 17:19

Well most of them aren't as prejudiced and othering as the sort of person that labels children solely because of their school and labels middle class parents as 'pushy'.

That sort of person is just an idiot who falls for the politics of envy.

Oh give over. Nothing wrong with being pushy anyway, those kinds of people get shit done.

Foxhassmellysocks · 20/10/2022 17:21

ChicaneOvenchips · 20/10/2022 12:39

I would be seriously disappointed in a Labour government that puts even more barriers in the way of children having access to the most suitable education for them as individuals. Not all private schools are about the elite, some are the only option left to young people who have been destroyed by the state school system. There are serious serious issues in the state school sector that need immediately addressing. This should be the next (and current!) governments priority, not making an already difficult to reach last option become an impossibility for children who have been failed by the system.

Agreed. For us, private seems the only viable option for our high functioning autistic daughter. There's no way she can thrive and be happy in a class of 25 plus children - the noise and bustle will be too much for her. Support in the state system for academically able, high functioning autistic children is virtually non existent.

We are not going to have a 2nd child, in part to be able to afford private education for our daughter. We would be gutted to be priced out of that.

Haffiana · 20/10/2022 17:19

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/10/2022 17:14

Possibly they don’t want to send their children to private schools because they don’t want the kind of children who sometimes emerge from these establishments. Halloween Wink Is that milking the state or is it exercising free choice in a market?

Besides, I think the idea is to encourage pushy parents of middle class children INTO the state sector because they will lobby to keep standards high.

Well most of them aren't as prejudiced and othering as the sort of person that labels children solely because of their school and labels middle class parents as 'pushy'.

That sort of person is just an idiot who falls for the politics of envy.

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/10/2022 17:14

Haffiana · 20/10/2022 17:05

If Labour want to raise money for the Education sector, then surely the answer is to require payment in some form from the wealthier parents who use State Education.

Why not penalise richer parents who milk the system by leaving their children in State Education instead of paying for private?

Possibly they don’t want to send their children to private schools because they don’t want the kind of children who sometimes emerge from these establishments. Halloween Wink Is that milking the state or is it exercising free choice in a market?

Besides, I think the idea is to encourage pushy parents of middle class children INTO the state sector because they will lobby to keep standards high.

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/10/2022 17:09

DuckTails · 20/10/2022 17:07

LOL, this is a hilarious comment.

signed, someone whose entire secondary education was under the Labour government.

My entire secondary education was under the subsequent Conservative government, and that got increasingly shite as it went along.