Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reconsidering private education/labour gov

214 replies

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:41

As it looks increasingly likely that we will have a Labour government at some point, I’m wondering if anyone who was considering private education for their children is now re-considering it? We have put down a deposit for a prep school we really like which we could comfortably afford at the moment but not with significant fee increases. Just wondering if anyone else has concerns along the same lines and if so what are you thinking…

OP posts:
Foxhassmellysocks · 20/10/2022 20:39

So do the people supporting VAT on private education also support VAT on private healthcare?

It's the same principle, no?

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/10/2022 20:33

Scaevola · 20/10/2022 20:27

"If a future labour government removed charitable status, won’t this have to apply to universities too, even more so as the latter is not compulsory, unlike education to 18?"

Yes, no, maybe. That's why we need to see exact proposals.

Same for VAT on nursery and university fees, both of which depend at present on same exemption as schools (crammers don't count as schools for VAT purposes)

Ok thanks. I hope this wouldn’t have implications on nurseries! Parents already pay astronomical fees.

BarmyArmy22 · 20/10/2022 20:29

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/10/2022 11:46

Hopefully Labour would improve education for all and less people would need to choose private schools.

🖕This. It's disgusting that we tolerate and perpetuate a two-tier education system. The Tories don't give a shiny shit about education for the masses. If more affluent people can't afford private school then there would be more pressure to improve the varied provision in the state system.

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 20:27

@autienotnaughty hahahaha 'you sense it about me' do you? what a load of tripe. I had a single mum who struggled and have had times when I had to choose between heating and eating when I was young. But of course that wouldn't suit your POV. So please don't lecture me about privilege - now that IS a middle class thing to do (careful, your quinoa is showing).

Oh and the musician is a DD, interesting you automatically assumed I was talking about my son.

Scaevola · 20/10/2022 20:27

"If a future labour government removed charitable status, won’t this have to apply to universities too, even more so as the latter is not compulsory, unlike education to 18?"

Yes, no, maybe. That's why we need to see exact proposals.

Same for VAT on nursery and university fees, both of which depend at present on same exemption as schools (crammers don't count as schools for VAT purposes)

Scaevola · 20/10/2022 20:24

Regularsizedrudy · 20/10/2022 14:05

Boo fucking hoo. They shouldn’t have charity status. How is a school for the most privileged a charity?

Because in law, education is a charitable aim.

Lots of non-school charities provide education among or as their sole activity.

That's another reason why the possibility of unintended consequences is real - other charities don't want changes that mean that some/all of their activities could no longer be supported with charitable assets/income streams.

OTOH, VAT on school fees doesn't carry those risks, affects all private schools rather than just those with one particular legal status, and will raise more for the Exchequer, and has some support in both Tory and Labour parties.

Don't count on schools becoming academies BTW. Selling off to developers is just as (and depending on site, more) likely.

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/10/2022 20:18

DdraigGoch · 20/10/2022 19:37

Charitable status affects things like business rates on buildings and land (the equivalent of council tax). It also affects how you can carry over a surplus - a business has to spend it all or it will be taxed, a charity can save it for a few years.

VAT is a completely separate issue - charities have to charge VAT on chocolate biscuits just like Tesco does. VAT is not charged on education. That applies whether the provider is a registered charity or a profit-making corporation. Applying VAT to education would open a massive can of worms including university fees, private tutors, swimming lessons, music lessons, adult evening classes etc. Under European law (which we no longer have to stick to) it was illegal to charge VAT on education (those who support this policy but also support re-entry would do well to remember this).

The former is much more likely to happen than the latter.

If a future labour government removed charitable status, won’t this have to apply to universities too, even more so as the latter is not compulsory, unlike education to 18?

As for those saying private is only for toffs, my dd transferred from state secondary as she wasn’t coping. A few others have done the same including some of her friends. These independent schools around here are not incredibly expensive Cheltenham Ladies type. The fees are already crippling.

I know dd is in a privileged place for us to do this. However, I don’t see why we should be penalised further when we are actually saving the government at least 5k a year by sending dd then. It should be thinking along the lines of ‘Wow, 5k saved. How are we going to spend it improving the lives of those still at state and struggling?’

autienotnaughty · 20/10/2022 20:12

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 19:58

@autienotnaughty class smass. One of my DC wants to be a rock musician, they'll probably head off in a battered van with a bunch of friends after A levels, balls to university and being saddled with a student loan was a recent comment.

I'm working class actually, because my parents were. So what? My DC might be middle class on paper but who cares, really, its a load of pretentious bollocks ultimately. And I value vocational careers and practical work like electricians, plumbers equally to academically high flying stuff. They're all professionals aren't they?

Its an interesting point though, if we don't aspire for our DC to have careers in anything at all why put them through 15 years of school, the stress of GCSE's, A levels, college?

Poor people care because they are the ones struggling to eat and survive. So it matters to them. Your son may reject middle class life as a young adult because he has the confidence, education and luxury to do so. That is a privilege. You may have grown up working class but I sense you did not go without the basic human rights - food, heat etc. if that's the case you too are coming from a place of privilege which entitles you to reject your status in society.

Pumperthepumper · 20/10/2022 20:00

SurpriseWombat · 20/10/2022 19:54

They care enough to either
a) pay, or
b) put in the significant legwork associated with bursaries and scholarships (and usually then still pay partial fees).

Most children in private schools are at day schools, so the usual parenting still has to be done outside of school hours. I'm sure you can find some child at a boarding school whose supremely wealthy parents have left them there primarily because they can't be bothered to parent, but there's always the exception that proves the rule.

A parent who is indifferent to their child's education will invariably send them to the state school up the road and save the cash.

Paying is not an indication of giving a shit. We had huge attendance issues at the private school I worked in. We had a massive lack of support or involvement from a huge chunk of parents who saw their kids’ education as nothing to do with them, because they’d already outsourced it to us.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:59

@SurpriseWombat

Nah

There's enough rich people who are indifferent on both the education and the cost

Its just the done thing. Mix with the right types.

Find the right rich husband

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 19:58

@autienotnaughty class smass. One of my DC wants to be a rock musician, they'll probably head off in a battered van with a bunch of friends after A levels, balls to university and being saddled with a student loan was a recent comment.

I'm working class actually, because my parents were. So what? My DC might be middle class on paper but who cares, really, its a load of pretentious bollocks ultimately. And I value vocational careers and practical work like electricians, plumbers equally to academically high flying stuff. They're all professionals aren't they?

Its an interesting point though, if we don't aspire for our DC to have careers in anything at all why put them through 15 years of school, the stress of GCSE's, A levels, college?

SurpriseWombat · 20/10/2022 19:54

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:41

@SurpriseWombat

Lol.

Loads of kids in PE are there because their parents don't know any different or cause they've been dumped there.

Fuck all to do with them caring about their kids education

They care enough to either
a) pay, or
b) put in the significant legwork associated with bursaries and scholarships (and usually then still pay partial fees).

Most children in private schools are at day schools, so the usual parenting still has to be done outside of school hours. I'm sure you can find some child at a boarding school whose supremely wealthy parents have left them there primarily because they can't be bothered to parent, but there's always the exception that proves the rule.

A parent who is indifferent to their child's education will invariably send them to the state school up the road and save the cash.

HRTQueen · 20/10/2022 19:49

The money for the vast majority will be found as they want their children in private school

Private schools will have to tighten their belts like state school have had to

this privilege should not be passed on to the most privileged in our society

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:46

@Jackiewoo

It tells me they're not deprived.

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 19:44

@Topgub of course I know what deprived is. FFS.

Those friends work in VERY deprived areas, they want better for their own DC and why shouldn't they? my cousin is a social worker in one of the most deprived parts of the north, and guess where she sends her DC to school? I also know plenty of state school teachers who send their DC to independent schools, what does that tell you?

Independent schools aren't perfect. Some DC don't see their parents for a long time, they seem parked for the cachet of it which is sad. Some smoke, they're teenagers so some have sex, they know all the swears and get up to all sorts. But the small class sizes, the expectations of behaviour, the facilities and access to much more stuff to do in school makes a big difference to my DC at least.

Anyway, if you'd actually bothered to read my post about overhauling the state system so there wouldn't need to be independent schools we could discuss that. This is a parenting forum and education is hugely important, change is needed. But you don't believe me and I think you're just being a GF, which changes nothing.

autienotnaughty · 20/10/2022 19:43

@Jackiewoo you realise the careers you are describing are middle class. And just to be clear not everyone has choice but most of the people who do have money.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:41

@SurpriseWombat

Lol.

Loads of kids in PE are there because their parents don't know any different or cause they've been dumped there.

Fuck all to do with them caring about their kids education

Pumperthepumper · 20/10/2022 19:40

Sodullincomparison · 20/10/2022 19:38

If they reduce the number of children in private education how will they afford to fund them in the state sector?

Several governments I have worked with are actively looking for ways to grow their private sector to reduce their load.

The same as they do now - with huge class sizes, temporary non-trained staff and poor ALN support.

Sodullincomparison · 20/10/2022 19:38

If they reduce the number of children in private education how will they afford to fund them in the state sector?

Several governments I have worked with are actively looking for ways to grow their private sector to reduce their load.

DdraigGoch · 20/10/2022 19:37

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 12:25

Looking at some older mumsnet threads, some people seem to be saying removable of charity status is different to VAT on fees and that’s not what’s being proposed. Anyone able to clarify if that’s correct?

Charitable status affects things like business rates on buildings and land (the equivalent of council tax). It also affects how you can carry over a surplus - a business has to spend it all or it will be taxed, a charity can save it for a few years.

VAT is a completely separate issue - charities have to charge VAT on chocolate biscuits just like Tesco does. VAT is not charged on education. That applies whether the provider is a registered charity or a profit-making corporation. Applying VAT to education would open a massive can of worms including university fees, private tutors, swimming lessons, music lessons, adult evening classes etc. Under European law (which we no longer have to stick to) it was illegal to charge VAT on education (those who support this policy but also support re-entry would do well to remember this).

The former is much more likely to happen than the latter.

Pumperthepumper · 20/10/2022 19:33

is that the parents universally care about the education of their child

That is not my experience of private school at all.

SurpriseWombat · 20/10/2022 19:31

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:11

@SurpriseWombat

If you can afford private fees regardless of sacrifice you're not deprived despite your address

Did I say that there was no element of privilege associated with a private education? Of course not.

But the unsubtle public image of private schools so often features some really rather wealthy parents driving Range Rovers and paying the fees with no real issues.

These things are so full of nuance. A child can have experience of relative deprivation in one aspect of their lives and of relative plenty in others; their postcode vs their school being one example. In some cases they were living between two divorced parents, one well off and one struggling financially. In some cases the home life had many aspects of deprivation but the grandparents were paying the fees.

Two girls in my year alone had babies of their own before we'd left.

About the only area kids at private schools are almost never deprived in, is that the parents universally care about the education of their child.

Topgub · 20/10/2022 19:22

@Jackiewoo

Maybe you don't understand what deprived is?

In fact, you clearly don't if you're citing nhs physios (band 6 basic) and taxi drivers as deprived

Pumperthepumper · 20/10/2022 19:22

Prívate education is definitely a luxury.

Jackiewoo · 20/10/2022 19:20

Exactly! Education IS NOT a luxury, its essential and a passport to life. My parents were both state school teachers, they drummed it into me.

@Topgub that's fine, think what you like it makes no difference to me at all or to the DC. I have an old independent school parent friend who is a taxi driver and another is an NHS physio, they'd think you are a bit potty. I also have friends who went to independent schools who'd never dream of sending their DC to one. Great that we're all different and can make different choices for our DC eh.