Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reconsidering private education/labour gov

214 replies

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:41

As it looks increasingly likely that we will have a Labour government at some point, I’m wondering if anyone who was considering private education for their children is now re-considering it? We have put down a deposit for a prep school we really like which we could comfortably afford at the moment but not with significant fee increases. Just wondering if anyone else has concerns along the same lines and if so what are you thinking…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DreamItDoIt · 22/10/2023 19:09

@piesforever - oh dear! How about those horrible parents who buy a house in catchment if an outstanding state school, or those that tutor to try and buy a free grammar place or those that buy into an area and then donate loads through parent portal to swell the academy coffers and give their children advantages?

Ohdearanotheryear · 22/10/2023 17:57

WatchoRulo · 20/10/2022 11:44

Well the fees are no doubt going to increase due to this government doing their best to destroy the economy, so you're probably screwed either way.

This.

The need to allow for fee rises anyway?

twistyizzy · 22/10/2023 17:54

piesforever · 21/10/2023 22:50

Absolutely. Parents who use private education are a disgrace.

Wow so you base your opinion on someone just because they send their kids private? Disgrace to who exactly?
How about people who use private tutors to get their kids into best state schools?

twistyizzy · 22/10/2023 17:49

If state schools are so good why have there been multiple posts about toilets being closed, teacher recruitment crisis, so many numbers of teachers leaving etc etc?
The state education system is in crisis. 1 5 billion won't even fix the concrete issue let alone improve state schools. Labour have said nothing about how they will fix the state sector and indeed have said they will stick to Tory spending plans for the first couple of years
The VAT is a clickbait, vote winner to appease the left of the party without being part of an well thought out long term education strategy.

DreamItDoIt · 22/10/2023 15:34

Do you have good local primary schools? What about secondary? If you're concerned send them state until 8 and review. Tutor on top of necessary. Apply for both state and private for year 7 to keep your options open.

Is the private secondary you're looking at selective!

Whatafustercluck · 22/10/2023 08:10

Op, you need to factor in a 20% increase and if you cannot afford it then take your chances with state education like many of the rest of us (and hope that a rebalancing of our education system happens under Labour). Or, given that you have a lot of faith schools around, hold your nose and apply for one of those.

Whatafustercluck · 22/10/2023 08:06

Areallyboringperson · 22/10/2023 04:08

VAT on school fees is coming. Factor that in to future plans.

Private schools around here have been adding £1k to fees for the last few years anyway. Factor that in too.

the institute of fiscal studies has done a thorough investigation of what is likely to happen if VAT is added to school fees and though they admit the variables are significant the overall impact is estimated to be a net benefit to the state of £1.6bn. So factoring in all of the parents who move to the state sector this will still be of significant benefit to the state. It’s going to happen.

Paying fees up front will not mean you can avoid VAT on the fees. HMRC have thought that through already.

It’s not tackling the funding provided to schools which would make me consider state, it’s the clamping down on disruption and violence in the classroom. Left leaning parties are into ‘inclusion’ which means including violent kids in classes. If they instead favoured exclusion (removing violent / disruptive pupils from classes to be taught elsewhere) state education would appeal much more (and I’m sure behaviour would improve overnight if pupils saw actual consequences for their actions!)

I don't understand your comment about left leaning parties being into 'inclusion'. Who has been in power for 13 years? There are so many children with additional needs who should be in specialist schools who are instead in mainstream education. You cannot get an ehcp for love nor money, class sizes of 30+ mean that the problem is exacerbated, and there's a three year waiting list for ND assessments. And for those who are struggling in mainstream, there is little alternative provision for them and so many parents are putting themselves into poverty by homeschooling instead. Yeah, state education and 'inclusivity' has thrived under the Tories. Always amazes me that left leaning parties get the blame for various situations, when Labour have had a fraction of the time in power in the UK than the Tories have.

Warum · 22/10/2023 07:45

mummymeister · 20/10/2022 11:49

I would welcome the change to the charitable status of private schools and am all in favour of this being removed. they arent charities any more than a university is. However, much as Labour like to say they are going to do this, so many of the MP's have their kids within these systems that whilst they might talk the talk I think its highly unlikely they will walk the walk. they had the opportunity to do it when last in power and they didnt so no reason to think that even if they say they will they will do it this time. shame really because it needs reforming.

^^
Exactly this.

Busephalus · 22/10/2023 07:42

Frodis, yes your post is

FrodisCapering · 22/10/2023 07:11

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Areallyboringperson · 22/10/2023 04:08

VAT on school fees is coming. Factor that in to future plans.

Private schools around here have been adding £1k to fees for the last few years anyway. Factor that in too.

the institute of fiscal studies has done a thorough investigation of what is likely to happen if VAT is added to school fees and though they admit the variables are significant the overall impact is estimated to be a net benefit to the state of £1.6bn. So factoring in all of the parents who move to the state sector this will still be of significant benefit to the state. It’s going to happen.

Paying fees up front will not mean you can avoid VAT on the fees. HMRC have thought that through already.

It’s not tackling the funding provided to schools which would make me consider state, it’s the clamping down on disruption and violence in the classroom. Left leaning parties are into ‘inclusion’ which means including violent kids in classes. If they instead favoured exclusion (removing violent / disruptive pupils from classes to be taught elsewhere) state education would appeal much more (and I’m sure behaviour would improve overnight if pupils saw actual consequences for their actions!)

Thisisnotlikehim · 21/10/2023 22:52

Not removing charitable status. Too complex. Just adding VAT. We Have used private Ed and I fully agree. It’s a MASSIVE luxury private Ed. The schools could choose not to pass it on. I fully support the idea. The VAT can help develop the state schools.

piesforever · 21/10/2023 22:50

Topgub · 20/10/2022 13:18

The quicker it happens the better.

Absolutely. Parents who use private education are a disgrace.

piesforever · 21/10/2023 22:48

Bluevelvetcake2 · 20/10/2022 11:44

Concerns are that Labour has said they will remove charity status of private schools which will result in significant increases in fees. I expect this will mean many parents like us who have well paying professional jobs but aren’t multi millionaires will end up having to withdraw their children

Good!! Equality is more important.

MrsSunshine2b · 27/09/2023 12:24

Looking at my own family, we have one child and, having worked in state education for many years, considered independent education for her when she starts school. Our salaries, if we continue to work full time and climb the ladder, would JUST cover it, there would be very little left over.

However, the concept of a 15-20% rise means there's no way we can afford it and we won't be putting her in if there is a risk we will have to withdraw her later. We cannot "absorb the cost" as the extra money is simply not there. If we're not paying for private education, we'll probably reduce our working hours to enable us to do more supplementary activities with her.

So, thats:
£8000 pa for her education in the state system
£2000 in reduced payments of income tax due to reducing hours

We were considering a small independent which would be likely to close if the number of pupils drops. Several of the teachers we spoke to said they would not return to the state sector under any circumstances, so they will then be job hunting, likely to take a pay cut or be out of work altogether. That's another swathe of income tax.

This scheme will not only cost a fortune and make very little back, it will also make independent schools the preserve only of the super-rich and price middle class people out completely.

edwinbear · 22/10/2022 14:03

Also worth thinking about how all the private school teachers who inevitably will end up back in the state school system will fund their TPS pensions. In private schools, that 23% contribution is paid by the school, via fees. If they end up back in the state system, that’s an additional cost for the taxpayer to pick up.

DC’s school employer contributions to teachers pension schemes last year was over £1m. If 500 out of 1300 private schools close, that’s a lot of extra funds for the tax payer to pay. And 500 fewer schools to be charging VAT to.

Scaevola · 22/10/2022 13:50

The value of charitable status is about £200 per pupil per year.

I expect that will easily be covered by a fee increase - it's less than the variation in fees between schools anyhow

Mardyface · 22/10/2022 10:13

VaccineSticker · 21/10/2022 21:19

The state school system will be fixed once the charitable status and vat will be imposed on them in the same way that taxing private hospitals has made the NHS provide exceptional service 🤣🤣🤣.

Nobody said it was a cause and effect issue in education (or in health). It is a question of whether you think money should go into public services or individual pockets. In the case of this particular Labour party it's a bit of both I'm sure but it will bloody DO at this point. Public schools being charities has always been a tax dodge.

VaccineSticker · 21/10/2022 21:19

The state school system will be fixed once the charitable status and vat will be imposed on them in the same way that taxing private hospitals has made the NHS provide exceptional service 🤣🤣🤣.

Davros · 21/10/2022 16:56

Not all private schools have charitable status anyway, check the schools you are interested in. DD's school didn't but the fees were similar to those that did

astarsheis · 21/10/2022 16:54

@LovinglifeAF and your point is?
If you have nothing constructive to say, then move to another thread 🙄

Auntpodder · 21/10/2022 16:50

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/10/2022 11:46

Hopefully Labour would improve education for all and less people would need to choose private schools.

This - the Labour government vastly improved state schools.

LionsandLambs · 21/10/2022 16:48

LovinglifeAF · 21/10/2022 13:20

My heart bleeds for you

Why be so nasty? It could be a really difficult time for this poster to move their children. It’s not their or their child’s fault that state education is underfunded. Having their kids cramming into the states system will only strain it further.

FlirtyMelons · 21/10/2022 13:29

GoldenCupidon · 21/10/2022 13:18

Don't worry about it @FlirtyMelons - sounds like you've had to fight for your kids

Thank you, certainly not as much as some. The provision for SEN, particularly those who appear outwardly that they can manage in main stream, is awful in many parts of the UK.

Digimoor · 21/10/2022 13:23

Given inflation I think you need to prepare for 10% annual increases anyway

A 20% increase due to VAT/charitable status would likely lead to private school closures.