Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.

136 replies

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 20/10/2022 11:59

Keep the stories as they are and have discussions around it like you’re doing. And new stories have different narratives. Which they often do. So we have a wide range of stories for all!

trebarwith1 · 20/10/2022 11:58

I second Angela Carters the Bloody Chamber and also Emma Donoghue's Kissing the Hag. Excellent imaginative reworked fairy tales for today!

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:58

Thanks for all the book suggestions. I am going to make a list and may well get some of these for Christmas.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:58

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 20/10/2022 11:38

The traditional collected fairytales were not for children and have little to do with the sweetish sanitized versions published outside their area and era of origin.

Yes the Grimm tales are far from the sugary version.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:56

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 11:47

Oh, I am sorry. I feel like a right twat now (I think I've been letting the stress from this shit show in government get to me, but that's another story).

It really is fascinating and if you are looking for reading on the subject, I really recommend Marina Warner's work - it's great!

To be fair, there are a lot of assumptions about what people have access to so don't feel bad.
We are also a mixed culture family so most of my children's books were about traditional tales and cultural role models. It is only now my youngest has started to be interested in films and books that are sort of re writing these tales that I have really noticed the narrative.

OP posts:
Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 20/10/2022 11:52

Somewhere on my shelves is a book of feminist fairy tales called “Don’t Beton the Prince”. I bought in when I was studying A level English, so around about 1990.

But E Nesbitt got in on the act first - just read her short story, “Th Last of the Dragons.” Princess is not happy that she is going to be dragon bait as she is much better at fencing than any prince she knows. And that’s from the early years of the 20th century.

EuripidesEumenides · 20/10/2022 11:47

Most traditional fairy tales have already been edited over time as tastes and cultures shift. If you look at the Grimm / Hans Christian Andersen versions there are plenty of weird / dark / gory elements which don't feature in modern telling of the stories. It's an ongoing process and much less of a controversial idea than many will make out.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 11:47

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:22

Religious bubble. I won't name the religion but there are many adults still very restricted to what they have access to.

Oh, I am sorry. I feel like a right twat now (I think I've been letting the stress from this shit show in government get to me, but that's another story).

It really is fascinating and if you are looking for reading on the subject, I really recommend Marina Warner's work - it's great!

Applesandcarrots · 20/10/2022 11:45

They were not just stories. They were warnings originally. They not only warned of dangerous behaviour and what it can lead to (go to forest alone, do opposite of what parents tell you), they also provided safe space to deal with fears and scary things with your parents while they were telling them the stories.

They were certainly not like these soft versions we have of them.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 20/10/2022 11:38

The traditional collected fairytales were not for children and have little to do with the sweetish sanitized versions published outside their area and era of origin.

Toomanysleepycats · 20/10/2022 11:38

I have always thought that fairy tales were a reflection of the times when they were written, much like Janes Austen’s novels.

When women were denied the same education boys got, had no control over their money and whose honour and virginity was precious. Depending upon what class you were some women were not allowed to work. Misogyny and the patriarchy were embedded into laws and culture.

There has been progress in recent years with more female lead characters in films and novels. I believe in childrens publishing it was widely held for a long time that books with a female hero would not be read by boys, whereas if the lead character was a boy, then both girls and boys would read it.

It will be nice when we finally get to a point when we can see fairy tales as old fashioned as watching characters driving a horse and cart, and feel they have no relevance today.

DuckTails · 20/10/2022 11:31

I love fairy tales but I also agree. Definitely get your DD a copy of Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber for some feminist fairy tales and for yourself you may enjoy Gilbert and Gubar’s Madwoman in the Attic. Their criticism of Snow White (woman trapped in her home made to do domestic duties for emotionally stunted men and every time she tries to escape her domestic servitude is punished with death) is excellent.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:31

I find the comments about these being just stories interesting. Let's take the Handmaid's Tale. Is this just a story? Look at the Taliban, banning education for women, strict dress codes and restrictions on movement etc. And issues in Iran.
These are lived realities dressed up in stories to make the bitter pill easier to swallow.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:28

ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 11:26

That’s why we read Prince Cinders and Princess Smartpants and the Ruby Redford and looked at Jessica fletcher and other royal models

Love this! Jessica Fletcher as a role model....brilliant. she was tenacious for sure.

OP posts:
MoreTeaLessCoffee · 20/10/2022 11:27

You're right but there is so much material and discussion about this that it's now become a jumping off point for discussion - as you are finding with your 10 year old. Even with my 3 year old, I will say things like "that's a bit silly isn't it, waiting for a prince to come to the rescue!" And there are loads of alternative takes on fairy stories out there - Bethany Woolvin is good. So you can provide lots of alternative views.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:27

These are not new musings by any means. I haven't been under a rock.
What has brought this to the fore is the book series DD is reading. They show how trying to change a narrative can lead to extremism. I think it is good to keep having discussions. To say something has already been talked about is unhelpful as the agenda needs to be kept going if society is going to change.

Even looking at how society views people, our own generation's views are not that far from our grandparents. Things haven't changed much. And where people are tying to make changes, we are going to the extreme, where another person's view must be accepted no matter what.

OP posts:
ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 11:26

That’s why we read Prince Cinders and Princess Smartpants and the Ruby Redford and looked at Jessica fletcher and other royal models

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:23

Gymrabbit · 20/10/2022 11:13

Read the World’s Wife with them if you want an alternative take.
Poems by unheard women in mythology and fairy tales. You have to be careful as there’s quite a bit of swearing.

Thanks I will check these out.

OP posts:
HailAdrian · 20/10/2022 11:22

But we already know fairytales and folklore are full of outdated ideas.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:22

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 11:21

Sorry, but my honest response is, have you been living in a bubble? How can anyone have reached adulthood, and had a child, to whom you evidently provide books, and not know this has been done? Marina Warner? Princess Smartypants? Oh, I don't know, a good third of the available offerings in the picture book section in your local library?

Religious bubble. I won't name the religion but there are many adults still very restricted to what they have access to.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:21

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 11:18

One thing I do think is still problematic and unfortunately I still see is the ugly is evil, beautiful is good narrative. I understand where it comes from and conceptually what it’s about but it annoys me. I was talking about this with dd recently as we’re reading Harry Potter together and we were struck by the fact that looks don’t always match with the person’s moral character. So, in Chamber of Secrets, Tom Riddle is exceedingly handsome and well spoken. Hagrid isn’t handsome, traditionally charming, or well spoken. And we see how that plays out and it’s interesting to talk about. In a lot of books for children you can pick out the evil person because they’ll be fat/have warts/have some disability etc. While the good ones will be pretty/pleasant looking.

I love this example! Society places so much value on the way a person looks and dresses and this is seen as an indication of a person character.

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 11:21

Sorry, but my honest response is, have you been living in a bubble? How can anyone have reached adulthood, and had a child, to whom you evidently provide books, and not know this has been done? Marina Warner? Princess Smartypants? Oh, I don't know, a good third of the available offerings in the picture book section in your local library?

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:19

I was raised in a very strict house where only bible stories were allowed and to be honest, those were even worse. Stories of rape, murder, child sacrifice.
Although these a stories, the message they portray is still harmful. There are some great movies now I agree, but just look at films like 50 shades, how far have we actually moved on? Some women couldn't get enough of that drivel.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 11:18

One thing I do think is still problematic and unfortunately I still see is the ugly is evil, beautiful is good narrative. I understand where it comes from and conceptually what it’s about but it annoys me. I was talking about this with dd recently as we’re reading Harry Potter together and we were struck by the fact that looks don’t always match with the person’s moral character. So, in Chamber of Secrets, Tom Riddle is exceedingly handsome and well spoken. Hagrid isn’t handsome, traditionally charming, or well spoken. And we see how that plays out and it’s interesting to talk about. In a lot of books for children you can pick out the evil person because they’ll be fat/have warts/have some disability etc. While the good ones will be pretty/pleasant looking.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 11:13

And as for Twilight, that’s old hat! It’s written specifically by her (a Mormon) to promote her values. Dressed up cleverly with vampires and werewolves to make it palatable to a teenaged female reader. Plenty of criticism about that online too, the problems there are widely acknowledged even in the books’ own fan base.