Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.

136 replies

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:11

VoiceOfCommonSense · 20/10/2022 13:09

Jesus Christ, I’m glad I don’t live in your house love..

People are all different, though. I love a good MN thread discussing what we hated about Friends or whether Spike from Buffy is a good character or not - this is the same kind of thing, no?

VoiceOfCommonSense · 20/10/2022 13:09

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:10

Lol. My older children would say I am far from woke. I actually think it is important to use these stories to critique. We watched the first Twighlight movie and critically analysed the plot, relationships and reality of how dysfunctional the relationship was.
I'm working on my MA on virtue ethics so this is a hot topic in our house!!

Jesus Christ, I’m glad I don’t live in your house love..

Oysterbabe · 20/10/2022 13:08

I have that Gender swapped fairytales book. It's a bit silly but has made the kids think about the issue at least.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.
To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.
Applesandcarrots · 20/10/2022 13:07

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:01

Are these fairytales or Disney, though?

Exactly because Little Mermaid is not particularly geeat example of how it works out if you go against ehole family for a pretty lad....
Snow White wasn't saved by a kiss while unconscious.
And so on

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 13:07

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:01

Are these fairytales or Disney, though?

I guess Disney is one of the main ways kids in the west engage in fairytales. The Disney narratives even shale non -disney retellings of them. At least res riding hood and princess and the frog (the old one with the golden ball she drops in the well) are like this. I'm not sure what the original sleeping beauty is like and I think original little mermaid is brutal - but kids don't get much of those versions nowdays.

On what some others have said , I love Angela carter - but perhaps not for a 10 year old (?)

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:05

Avidreader69 · 20/10/2022 13:00

I think it's an unusual child who puts any kind of interpretation on a fairy tale. The idea that a prince kisses Sleeping Beauty without her giving consent is an adult, modern concept, not the way a child would react. They either like the story or they don't. Some find them frightening, which many fairy tales are.

You know, weirdly, it's absolutely not. You listen to a class of five-year-olds being read stories and they will totally come out with stuff like 'why did he kiss her when she was asleep, that is rude!' or whatever. Of course they won't use words like consent, but they're quite able to recognise that what's being depicted isn't what we'd consider ok today. I have read Cinderella to children before who were very sure it was extremely rude to call the sisters 'ugly' - children hear these sort of platitudes from school and nursery all the time, and they're not slow to apply them to stories.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/10/2022 13:04

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 12:17

I can’t even think of one transgender person in a fairytale.

I can’t think of one talking wolf or actual fairy in real life.

Fairy tales aren’t true life biographies Confused. I don’t think I understand what point you’re trying to make unless you’re responding to someone else’s post that I’ve missed?

mackthepony · 20/10/2022 13:03

Problem is these tales are still embedded into films

CocoPlum · 20/10/2022 13:03

The original versions are actually so very dark ... I've never had a problem with them, because kids now will bring this up themselves. They are savvy! My 13yo daughter will be "why is he kissing her without consent? That's not ok!" with no prompting, she's actually much better at spotting when something is problematic than I am!

At 10, if she's enjoying SGE (my 13 and 11yos are OBSESSED and I've loved the first 3 and about to start the fourth), she'll soon be able to move onto the new versions of fairytales that turn these narratives around. The Lunar Chronicles by Marissa Meyer is another.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:01

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 12:57

I actually mostly disagree. Sure some are outdated but there's loads of modern ones. It's important to not push little girls into feeling that they have to be independent girl bosses if that's not their character. Kindness and dreamyness are also perfectly acceptable character traits.

Little red riding hood: cautionary tale, from a time folk lived close to forests. Stay on the path!
Snow White: better to be kissed than in a coma, no? Or do you think that life saving operations are also immoral because invade bodily autonomy on patients who cannot consent. Also, jealously will bite you in the arse.
Cinderella: kind and generous, kind to animals, hardworking
Little mermaid: goes against her whole family to achieve her lifelong dream of living on land.
Princess and the frog: don't make promises you have no intention of keeping.
Beauty and the beast is dodgy, I'll give you that.

Are these fairytales or Disney, though?

Avidreader69 · 20/10/2022 13:00

I think it's an unusual child who puts any kind of interpretation on a fairy tale. The idea that a prince kisses Sleeping Beauty without her giving consent is an adult, modern concept, not the way a child would react. They either like the story or they don't. Some find them frightening, which many fairy tales are.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:00

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 12:17

I can’t even think of one transgender person in a fairytale.

It very much depends how rigidly you define 'fairytale' (and how rigidly you define 'transgender'!), but if you're interested, there are a few stories with magical elements that are hundreds of years old and feature individuals changing from male to female or female to male - the Roman de Silence and Yde and Olive are the ones I'm thinking of. They're not really 'fairytales' in the Grimm sense, because they predate the term and the assumptions that go with it, but they're quite similar otherwise.

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 12:57

I actually mostly disagree. Sure some are outdated but there's loads of modern ones. It's important to not push little girls into feeling that they have to be independent girl bosses if that's not their character. Kindness and dreamyness are also perfectly acceptable character traits.

Little red riding hood: cautionary tale, from a time folk lived close to forests. Stay on the path!
Snow White: better to be kissed than in a coma, no? Or do you think that life saving operations are also immoral because invade bodily autonomy on patients who cannot consent. Also, jealously will bite you in the arse.
Cinderella: kind and generous, kind to animals, hardworking
Little mermaid: goes against her whole family to achieve her lifelong dream of living on land.
Princess and the frog: don't make promises you have no intention of keeping.
Beauty and the beast is dodgy, I'll give you that.

BarbedButterfly · 20/10/2022 12:57

Angela Carter has some great feminist reworking of fairy tales.

ErrolTheDragon · 20/10/2022 12:48

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 12:17

I can’t even think of one transgender person in a fairytale.

There's plenty of 'transspecies' and disguise though.

There's a pretty good mix available now, and the old 'maiden rescued by Prince' trope looks, as it is, old-fashioned. There are of course quite a lot of often humorous direct counterpoints to old 'classics' which children greatly enjoy E.g. Roald Dahl's take on Red Riding hood. Or in a slightly different area, the great juxtaposition in one of Anne Fine's anthologies of 'All Things Bright and Beautiful' with Eric Idle's 'All Things Dull and Ugly'

Verv · 20/10/2022 12:42

Some fairytales are hundreds of years old. Clearly some of the attitudes are outdated but this doesn't make them redundant or less engaging as examples of early storytelling.
Modern fairytales are already and have already "rewritten the narrative" to suit current perspectives and there are plenty of those in circulation.

Probably the better idea would be to raise children to be able to identify the differences between the two.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/10/2022 12:41

Your daughter will be too young for it, but Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber has fairy tales reimagined. Excellent book.

I will say though that I don't think that fairy tales are used in the same way they used to. Sure they promote (at best) outdated ideals, but even little children know they aren't real.

DesMoulinsRouge · 20/10/2022 12:41

Plenty of feisty girls in older stories, my favourite being Mary Lennox in The Secret Garden.
She learns a difficult lesson about how to treat other people and not to believe everything you are told.

ForestofD · 20/10/2022 12:28

Angela Carter did this a couple of decades ago.

Dogtooth · 20/10/2022 12:22

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 12:08

Can anyone recommend some of the original versions of the tales? I am interested to see if there is still the black and white of good v's evil, ugly vs beautiful etc.

You can buy a translation of Grimms' tales which contain many of the tales.

The Grimm brothers went round collecting fairy tales in Germany around the first half of the 19th century. They were told stories that people had told each other for a long time because many people couldn't read, write or afford books so stories were just told to each other.

The stories were often told differently for different audiences (the Grimm brothers used doctors etc to gather stories, people edited rude bits out as they didn't want to say smut to doctors), then they've been changed since with different editions and audiences. Eg the Red Riding Hood or Cinderella we know is different from the original.

The stories weren't just for kids, and they taught important lessons eg don't wander in the woods alone, don't trust your stepmother! They came from a time when Napoleonic wars were in recent memory and people had been living in horrible conditions with soldiers coming back and forth, famine and hunger etc.

But from your original point, they're not meant to be stories that set role models, they show the consequences of breaking the rules (eg what happens to Little Red Riding Hood). There are loads of good modern versions as listed here, why not talk to your DD about how attitudes have changed over time, what the role of women is, why freedom is important etc? I don't really like the attitude of 'this doesn't chime with my beliefs so let's not read it'

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 12:17

I can’t even think of one transgender person in a fairytale.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 20/10/2022 12:12

Don'y forget the "evil stepmother" who is a beautiful trophy wife. She is cruel and dismissive of her husband's child and favors her own DC. Oh wait! That's not fairy tales -- that's the collective view of mumsnet (his child, his problem).

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 12:08

Can anyone recommend some of the original versions of the tales? I am interested to see if there is still the black and white of good v's evil, ugly vs beautiful etc.

OP posts:
Livetoplay · 20/10/2022 12:07

The original versions of fairy tales were often incredibly and much better than our versions, but there are many, many re-workings available. Like Ninja red riding hood!

catscatscurrantscurrants · 20/10/2022 12:00

Alan Garner's collection of British Fairytales is a great read - these are traditional tales, some dating back to the medieval period, and there are just as many brave heroines as heroes in them. As a PP mentioned, they are designed to both entertain and teach lessons about life and have little in common with the sanitised stories we think of when 'fairytales' are mentioned.