Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.

136 replies

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

OP posts:
CaptainThe95thRifles · 20/10/2022 14:29

Most fiction promotes dangerous narratives. Children's fiction is full of kids with terrifying freedom and a complete lack of safeguarding. Adult fiction isn't any better. At least fairy tales are obviously bullshit - what with all the fairies and trolls and witches.

I'm less concerned with traditional fairy tales than I am with the Disneyfication of them. The tales themselves are generally one-dimensional morality tales with no real scope for identifying with characters, and generally pretty bloody outcomes. I do think there's probably an issue with how they're presented to children in terms of gender stereotypes and superficial stereotyping. I'm uncomfortable with the "my little princess" treatment some young girls get from their parents, and that probably goes for boys with the other side of it too.

I wouldn't want to see fairy tales banned - they're a cultural constant, with parallels between different cultures and threads back through history and literature. Children need to explore all sorts of ideas throughout their childhood, and fairy tales are a part of that. If adults are reading them to children as though they're a textbook for how life should be lived, the issue is with the adult's outlook, not with the fairy tales.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 14:20

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 14:11

But they were never in date. There was never a time when this was the norm. Maybe we should be offended by the sub text of these plots.

I agree. As a historian, I think one of the really dangerous things we do is to presume everything negative in the world must be 'outdated' (and, implicitly, therefore unable to hurt us any more; something we've moved on from). Sometimes the past (and fictions from the past) is better; sometimes it's worse. What it isn't, is a convenient container for all the negative ideas that we'd like to pretend don't influence us any more.

nomoreflyingducks · 20/10/2022 14:20

I think Roald Dahl re-addressed the balance very well in his revolting rhymes...didn't Cindy draw a pistol from her knickers not a euphemism ?

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 14:17

Thanks for all the responses. I won't respond to all as I am now planning to sit down with my kindle and some of the suggestions.

Thank you for all who have responded, it is so great to have suggestions and read people's viewpoints.
I agree that we shouldn't erase these stories as they are teaching tools in themselves. I do still think simply reading them without critique is dangerous and potentially damaging to children, though some may think this is an overreaction.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 14:11

ReadtheReviews · 20/10/2022 13:49

I think calling it dangerous is dangerous and fodder for the love to be offended brigade. Call it outdated, explain why times have changed, enjoy it for the fictional story it is.

But they were never in date. There was never a time when this was the norm. Maybe we should be offended by the sub text of these plots.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:53

JangolinaPitt · 20/10/2022 13:50

Just read Bruno Bettelheim’s ‘the use of enchantment’
see also catharsis/pity and terror.
People really need to get over themselves.

Thanks for the suggestion.

OP posts:
Nolongerteaching · 20/10/2022 13:52

Still the best ad imv. Guardian spin on 3 little pigs

m.youtube.com/watch?v=cnnmc9nBeOY

there is also a children's book that has an alternative take on 3LP - very sympathetic to the wolf and funny

m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=25&v=m75aEhm-BYw&feature=emb_logo

and great to see all the Angela Carter fans👋🏾

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:52

Avidreader69 · 20/10/2022 13:00

I think it's an unusual child who puts any kind of interpretation on a fairy tale. The idea that a prince kisses Sleeping Beauty without her giving consent is an adult, modern concept, not the way a child would react. They either like the story or they don't. Some find them frightening, which many fairy tales are.

Depends on the child.

OP posts:
JangolinaPitt · 20/10/2022 13:50

Just read Bruno Bettelheim’s ‘the use of enchantment’
see also catharsis/pity and terror.
People really need to get over themselves.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:50

Thanks for the suggestions.

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/10/2022 13:50

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 13:22

I can’t think of one talking wolf or actual fairy in real life.

They aren’t real.

Conveniently didn’t copy the rest of my post!

Fairy tales are not biographies. Maybe you could take The Little Mermaid as an allegory about transgender people if you’re intent on representation?

ReadtheReviews · 20/10/2022 13:49

I think calling it dangerous is dangerous and fodder for the love to be offended brigade. Call it outdated, explain why times have changed, enjoy it for the fictional story it is.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:48

LemonTT · 20/10/2022 13:21

Don’t like to LOL but the Handmaids Tale is exactly that. The author deliberately used real life events to form the basis of her story telling. She didn’t just reference theocracies but also act perpetrated by other ideological dictators.
The book is a warning about what happened in the past and what is happening now. She had seen the influence and power of fundamentalists in Afghanistan in the 70’s (and foreseen their rise to power post invasion) and then Iranian revolution. She didn’t think there was much difference between them and religious right in the US.

That's the thing. Some commenter are stating that fairy tales have moral lessons or are for the time period they were written. This doesn't make them any less dangerous if we brush them off as harmless.

OP posts:
Laserbird16 · 20/10/2022 13:46

Don't ever eat the free food or you'll be turned into a pig, swan or have to spend winter in the underworld etc.

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:40

ChagSameachDoreen · 20/10/2022 13:34

My mother got out an old fairytale book of mine from the 80s, with a view to passing it on to my daughter. I looked through it, and gave it back! Nice pictures, but the messages are just not what I want to teach my children.

I got hold of an old Enid Blyton book and was shocked at some of the underlying messages.

OP posts:
Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 13:39

mackthepony · 20/10/2022 13:03

Problem is these tales are still embedded into films

I agree. Me and my DH watched married at first sight and the amount of people talking about finding 'the one's shocking. People want a happy ever after and think that hard work means people are incompatible.

OP posts:
ChagSameachDoreen · 20/10/2022 13:34

My mother got out an old fairytale book of mine from the 80s, with a view to passing it on to my daughter. I looked through it, and gave it back! Nice pictures, but the messages are just not what I want to teach my children.

Applesandcarrots · 20/10/2022 13:27

The original tales are often based on real life events too. Just with additions.
A child disappeared - Hansel and Gretel or Red riding hood
Stepparents issues are most likely about inheritances and none of the bad ones ended up well
You could go on. Stories are inspired by real life then changed up for the story.

Like we have urban legends nowadays woth exploding cans, formaldehyde soaked wedding dress etc. Something inspired it and some things were added for the whoa effect

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 13:22

I can’t think of one talking wolf or actual fairy in real life.

They aren’t real.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:22

Avidreader69 · 20/10/2022 13:19

I am sure these same children, if they are as ready as you say to put adult perceptions on a fairy tale, would have the intelligence to recognize them for what they are - just stories, not an opportunity to start analysing them for infringements of today's woke ideas.

I think you misread me - I said they wouldn't put adult perceptions on them, not that they would.

LemonTT · 20/10/2022 13:21

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:31

I find the comments about these being just stories interesting. Let's take the Handmaid's Tale. Is this just a story? Look at the Taliban, banning education for women, strict dress codes and restrictions on movement etc. And issues in Iran.
These are lived realities dressed up in stories to make the bitter pill easier to swallow.

Don’t like to LOL but the Handmaids Tale is exactly that. The author deliberately used real life events to form the basis of her story telling. She didn’t just reference theocracies but also act perpetrated by other ideological dictators.
The book is a warning about what happened in the past and what is happening now. She had seen the influence and power of fundamentalists in Afghanistan in the 70’s (and foreseen their rise to power post invasion) and then Iranian revolution. She didn’t think there was much difference between them and religious right in the US.

Avidreader69 · 20/10/2022 13:19

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2022 13:05

You know, weirdly, it's absolutely not. You listen to a class of five-year-olds being read stories and they will totally come out with stuff like 'why did he kiss her when she was asleep, that is rude!' or whatever. Of course they won't use words like consent, but they're quite able to recognise that what's being depicted isn't what we'd consider ok today. I have read Cinderella to children before who were very sure it was extremely rude to call the sisters 'ugly' - children hear these sort of platitudes from school and nursery all the time, and they're not slow to apply them to stories.

I am sure these same children, if they are as ready as you say to put adult perceptions on a fairy tale, would have the intelligence to recognize them for what they are - just stories, not an opportunity to start analysing them for infringements of today's woke ideas.

limitedperiodonly · 20/10/2022 13:16

Some distinguished writers and readers are ahead of you OP. I love fairytales as do the writers Angela Carter, Marina Warner, Emma Donoghue and A.S. Byatt to name just a handful who have reinterpreted them from a feminist and funny perspective while keeping the danger and goriness.

Those are for teens and adults but there are lots of children's retellings too.

CaptainMyCaptain · 20/10/2022 13:15

There were loads of books in the 80s redressing the balance but people seem to like the old ones. I think you just have to talk to the children about the stories even things like 'Should Goldilocks have walked into someone's house and eaten their breakfast?'.

www.goodreads.com/book/show/3920964-the-practical-princess
This one is actually from the 60s although I had it in the 80s (as a teacher).

Clever Gretchen and other Forgotten Folk tales by Alison Lurie is another good one where the female characters take the lead in the action.

There are loads of other alternative tales.

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 13:13

Agree with @SarahAndQuack on this... plus, me and 3 year old often get into good ol debates about which book / character is the best... (no DS, it is not the inane train one we have just read 6 times in a row!!). It's the same thing, but with more words!