Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.

136 replies

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 20/10/2022 21:58

Most children don’t read Gary stories, they get told them by their parents in a basic format. 3 little pigs - 2 don’t try hard enough, one does and looks after his brother and the wolf who tries to hurt them gets injured. Goldilocks - goes into someone’s house - steals and gets chased out. 3 billy goats gruff someone bullies them and they fight back.
All okay.
the one I had an issue was - original Noddy Enid Blyton at my mums house and I had to edit whilst reading - awful racist stuff. Posted to Manchester Uni with instructions to bin if they didn’t have a copy already (they didn’t).

Chouetted · 20/10/2022 21:51

Speaking of Cinderella, that's an interesting one - the step sisters cut off their heels and toes to fit in the shoe, and then get their eyes pecked out for their trouble.

Lots of children love that sort of gore - I did. "The fit cannot be true, there's blood on the shoe!"

I've always been a bit disappointed Disney missed that out.

Joshanddonna · 20/10/2022 21:51

Google Bruno Bettelheim

Chouetted · 20/10/2022 21:48

I really think it depends on the fairy tales. There's a bigger repertoire out there, including many of the traditional English ones.

I was horrified when I saw Brave and she followed the will o'the wisp. I grew up with stories where the wisps are fairies luring you to your doom, as fairies often do. Actually a useful life lesson, since they spawn over boggy moors where children might be tempted to stray.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 20/10/2022 21:09

Pretty little, fairy tales are dark.

Incredibly dark they are about so much more than marrying a prince they are / were a warnings klaxon that we live in a dangerous world, which we very much do.

And it's often step parent's..( Cinderella step nother, Hansel and Gretel step mother etc ) behind the danger.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 21:03

By the same token, Enid Blyton's stories are a bloody good read, and that arguably matters just as much as worthy politics.

I say this all the time but I was surprised on rereading Malory Towers with dd at what little bullies my favourites Darrell and Alicia were. Hard as my dd really is a bit of a Mary-Lou! She was agog at Miss Peters calling two girls ‘little idiots.’ Still love them though!

HairyHandedSonOfTroll · 20/10/2022 21:01

BTW, I'd have shagged the Beast like a shot, but I wouldn't have given that wet prince at the end the time of day.

HairyHandedSonOfTroll · 20/10/2022 21:00

I think that the example you actually set as a woman/a couple matters far more than whether or not you critique fairy tales. You can critique them all you like, and read your child all the woke stories you like - but if what they see is "Mummy doing all the housework/child-related stuff" and "Daddy being big and important at work", that's what they will think is normal. By contrast, if they read about Snow White being woken up by a kiss but see their mum and dad sharing childcare, domestic stuff and work outside the home equally, they'll grow up thinking that's the norm.

By the same token, Enid Blyton's stories are a bloody good read, and that arguably matters just as much as worthy politics.

Mentalpiece · 20/10/2022 21:00

I grew up with these fairy tales, my kids grew up with these fairy tales, now my grandchildren are growing up with them.
We know they are just that....fairy tales. No changes needed.
Everyone knows that frogs don't really turn into princes, people don't really sleep for 100 years and no one can grow their hair long enough to be rescued from a tower.
And they all lived happily ever after.
The end.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 20:52

@TimBoothseyes

Again, this has literally been done several times. There’s The Good Stepmother, Bonus Mom, The Not-So-Wicked Stepmother, Daddy’s Getting Married etc etc. And that’s just picture books for little ones. There’s been nice or normal stepmothers in books for years, some (like those I mentioned above) actively subverting the ‘wicked stepmother’ fairytale trope.

TimBoothseyes · 20/10/2022 16:23

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

It would be good if someone wrote a fairy- tale where the SM was kind and loving, instead of the "wicked SM" narrative that is always mentioned.

Kellie45 · 20/10/2022 16:14

I think we need to put the woke Disney world into perspective. Before that came along children were reading fairy stories with no harm whatsoever. They are more intelligent than we think they are and certainly more intelligent than the woke idiots who imagine apparently that children take these things as reality. Children know these things are fiction. As a kid I was more likely to believe that Robin Hood was a real person than I was in fairytales.

steff13 · 20/10/2022 15:48

If I'm ever put into an enchanted sleep from which I will not wake up unless I'm kissed, I am hereby giving blanket consent for every member of the human race to kiss me.

ehb102 · 20/10/2022 15:44

I got my girl Gender Swapped Fairy Tales. It's hilarious on first reading. It shows up how sexist fairy tales are in a brilliant fashion.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.
JaninaDuszejko · 20/10/2022 15:39

Fairy tales are simple stories that each generation has retold and adapted. The versions we know were written down about 200 years ago, the Grimms got rid of some of the sex in them but not the violence, then Disney removed the violence but kept the gender roles. But the basic stories are very old with multiple versions across the world. They are teaching us something about ourselves, not 19th century European morality but something deeper. The stories allow multiple retellings and multiple interpretations. So Beauty and the Beast could be Stockholm syndrome or it could be a poor but brave and beautiful girl saving her father from death, and breaking the curse on the Prince by teaching him how to treat others with respect. And in the end she ends up marrying the (now handsome) Prince who adores her.

As for a transgender character you can pick The Little Mermaid or The Wolf in Sheep's Clothing depending on your viewpoint. There's a fairytale for everything.

ChocFrog · 20/10/2022 15:30

American ‘Disneyfied’ fairy tales are crap, they always just have goodies and baddies and you can tell who is who by how good-looking they are (clue is in the term ‘good-looking’!). They are most dangerous because they encourage that mindset held by the police, CIA etc that you can do what you like because you are a goodie and therefore everything you do is good.

The original much darker fairy tales, I’ll defend. Yes many have problems but there is also a lot of good advice in them about

  • not trusting strangers
  • not making bad bargains
  • staying on the path
  • striving to achieve greatness
  • not giving up when obstacles appear
  • and for girls, choosing a good guy. Every woman I know personally, her life has been defined not by her career but by the man she chose. Whether he was into drugs, or a workaholic, or a happy kind man who loves his mum. I don’t mind that fairy tales encourage girls to aim high in their choice of life partner and not just say yes to the first guy who asks.
SleepingStandingUp · 20/10/2022 15:16

Fairytale only promote a, dangerous narrative if you're raising your kids to think these are their life lessons. They're fun books amongst a plethora of more politically correct fun books and a perfect opportunity to talk about stereotypes etc.

Why does everything have to be a rules-to-follow educational experience

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 15:13

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/10/2022 13:50

Conveniently didn’t copy the rest of my post!

Fairy tales are not biographies. Maybe you could take The Little Mermaid as an allegory about transgender people if you’re intent on representation?

But mermaids aren’t real.

Michiru · 20/10/2022 15:05

EndlessMagpies · 20/10/2022 15:02

They are fiction, written a long time ago, and there are thousands of more modern works available for children to read.

We should not tamper with historical fiction. That is a very slippery slope.

But the point is we already have, see my post above.

All the fairy tales you can buy now have much happier endings, with most people walking away alive rather than the gruesome endings in the original stories. So much so that many people don't even seem to realise that they have never read the real thing.

EndlessMagpies · 20/10/2022 15:02

They are fiction, written a long time ago, and there are thousands of more modern works available for children to read.

We should not tamper with historical fiction. That is a very slippery slope.

hashbrownsandwich · 20/10/2022 14:57

My husband has always spoiled Disney films with his view similarly to these. Beauty and the beast - Stockholm syndrome at its finest

ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 14:56

www.amightygirl.com/books

Michiru · 20/10/2022 14:55

Haven't read tft so it may have already been pointed out, but you do know fairy tales have been rewritten many times already -

The prince did way more than kiss sleeping beauty, she woke up giving birth.

Rapunzel's witch did not find out she was having a visitor by seeing him climb up, she noticed Rapunzel was knocked up and thre the prince into a bush of thorns where he lost his eyesight.

The wolf died a gruesome death after Red Riding Hood got cut out of his stomach and replaced by rocks, which dragged him under water.

Snow White's step mother got killed by being forced to dance in red hot iron shoes until she collapsed.

Cinderella's sisters both cut parts of their feet off so they'd fit into the glass slipper and later on both got their eyes pecked out by ravens.

And don't get me started on Brother and Sister, which gave me nightmares as a child.

The truth is, fairy tales were horror stories people used to retell for entertainment and they got tones down a LOT before becoming acceptable children's tales. I still have some of the originals in their original language here, books over 150 years old.

ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 14:54

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:28

Love this! Jessica Fletcher as a role model....brilliant. she was tenacious for sure.

Both my son and daughter - I followed advice from the mighty girl fb page.

but they also see me a scientist with a phd at the top of her field and my box of drills and proudly I can say my son and daughter knew how to use a drill at 4. Likewise neither are allowed to say they have done house work for me (I hated it when my ex husband did that!) they have there own jobs according to their age and they are NOT reminded to do them.

my daughter has to Hoover the hallway once a week and clean the dog bowls out daily with a scrub. (15)
my son put on the laundry when needed and sorts it and puts it on - having checked the weather to see when it is dry as we normally peg it out (9)
both peg out laundry together
they alternate who cleans the toilet and who does the shower
they pick up dog poo in the garden together
daughter puts out the bins and brings them in

🤷‍♀️we correct language all the time
eg refer to a nurse as she we ask why

both can use a sewing machine

we call out as much day to day racism or sexism as we see it and we discuss

eg when doing Africa in school we talked about racism
we went to visit the Colston statue and debated on why it was built in the first place, if it should have been removed and if the people should have been found of guilty of criminal actions for damaging it.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 20/10/2022 14:40

DuckTails · 20/10/2022 11:31

I love fairy tales but I also agree. Definitely get your DD a copy of Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber for some feminist fairy tales and for yourself you may enjoy Gilbert and Gubar’s Madwoman in the Attic. Their criticism of Snow White (woman trapped in her home made to do domestic duties for emotionally stunted men and every time she tries to escape her domestic servitude is punished with death) is excellent.

Please don’t give a ten year old a copy of The Bloody Chamber or The World’s Wife.

But I agree, you’re articulating this as if it’s a brand new revelatory idea, OP, and The Bloody Chamber was written in the 70s. Marina Warner’s From the Beast to the Blonde has been around for nearly thirty years. You say ‘is it time to rewrite the narrative’ - it’s been being rewritten for decades now!

Swipe left for the next trending thread