Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fairy tale promote a dangerous narrative.

136 replies

Mollymoostoo · 20/10/2022 11:04

My DD (aged 10) has been reading the book series 'The school for good and evil' qnd this has prompted discussions about how dangerous fairy tales are in perpetuating stereotypes and outdated attitudes. For example....
Prince Charming kissed Snow White whilst she was asleep (consent issues)
Red Riding hood naively trusted a stranger in the woods and had to be rescued by a father figure.
Belle put up with the beasts behaviour even though he was aggressive, falling in love with her captor.
Beauty is seen as good, ugliness evil.

AIBU or is it time to rewite the narrative with balanced perspectives. I am not saying go to the extreme of getting rid of heros, but we need to stop putting pressure on boys to be rescuers and girls to be passive in their own stories.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moominfanjo · 22/10/2022 12:44

Once they are old enough to read Terry Pratchett, (I started reading him from aged 12) all will come good :)

MintyFreshOne · 22/10/2022 12:41

ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 11:26

That’s why we read Prince Cinders and Princess Smartpants and the Ruby Redford and looked at Jessica fletcher and other royal models

Wouldn’t you need a passing familiarity with the classic tales to get stories like these? Honest question.

It’s like Biblical reading: you don’t have to believe in it, but you have to know it to understand a lot of later works. I think fairy tales probably work on that level too

ShhDoNotTell · 22/10/2022 12:39

As an aside, there’s plenty of research that suggests children are better able to handle darkness than adults. Their grasp on reality is tenacious and therefore the blurring between reality and fantasy is how they live their lives. Therefore I personally don’t think they should be patronised or considered ‘too young’ for darker concepts. See: Delusion of Death.

ShhDoNotTell · 22/10/2022 12:37

queenofthewild · 22/10/2022 12:10

Most fairy tales were never written for children. Some are truly gruesome and have a very "Tales of the Unexpected" or "inside number 9" vibe.

Over the years they've been adored and changed to different markets and been pushed to children, losing a lot of the original messaging.

’Childhood’ is a relatively recent concept. So therefore fairytales were technically written for everyone.

ShhDoNotTell · 22/10/2022 12:36

Not read the thread but, fairytales are archetypal. They exist across cultures and time for a damn good reason. They tap into our collective unconscious and play a vital role in understanding of the world. That there are issues and roles and stereotypes in them is part of the point, and children generally learn to critically think if you are engaging with them appropriately. Many fairytales have been rewritten, some successfully snd some not.

[N.B. I’m an academic in the area of fairytale]

queenofthewild · 22/10/2022 12:10

Most fairy tales were never written for children. Some are truly gruesome and have a very "Tales of the Unexpected" or "inside number 9" vibe.

Over the years they've been adored and changed to different markets and been pushed to children, losing a lot of the original messaging.

Scottsy100 · 22/10/2022 12:06

Or a fairytale could just bloody well stay a fairytale FFS 🙄 not everything has to be about real life, this crap really winds me up

LondonQueen · 22/10/2022 12:02

Oh bore off it's fiction.

Tallulah28 · 22/10/2022 12:00

Margaret Atwood has already said that the regimes in the Handmaids Tale were based on regimes that are already in existence in the world though, and used them specifically to highlight that fact. So it’s well known it’s not “just a story”… she’s been very vocal about this

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 22/10/2022 10:32

Fairy tales are stories not aspirations. It’s up to parents to voice if and why they don’t agree with the lesson. But the snowflakes can bloody well leave fairy tales alone.

I did LOL a bit about the SJW woke 10yo. Of course she thought of all those problems all on her own 😂

StrawberryWillow · 22/10/2022 10:14

I grew up with all of the Disney classics, Beauty and the Beast, Cinderella etc. And I LOVED them, still do and I will definitely be getting my little girl in the them as she gets older. I never once thought about or questioned 'the other side of the story' to these films that people talk about today, I saw a fairytale with a Prince and Princess in love. I actually didn't even think about what people say these films are portraying until I read about it on the Internet as an adult a few years ago. Watching these films has never affected me or made me feel less worth or that I need to rely on a man etc etc. I was an innocent child enjoying a fairytale. At the end of the day it's a story, and they now make films showing strong, independent woman such as Frozen and Enchanto etc. I would talk to my daughter about these sorts of things when she is a teenager, but certainly not before then, I just think it takes away their innocence.

Pertinentowl · 22/10/2022 10:04

ThingsIhavelearnt · 20/10/2022 14:54

Both my son and daughter - I followed advice from the mighty girl fb page.

but they also see me a scientist with a phd at the top of her field and my box of drills and proudly I can say my son and daughter knew how to use a drill at 4. Likewise neither are allowed to say they have done house work for me (I hated it when my ex husband did that!) they have there own jobs according to their age and they are NOT reminded to do them.

my daughter has to Hoover the hallway once a week and clean the dog bowls out daily with a scrub. (15)
my son put on the laundry when needed and sorts it and puts it on - having checked the weather to see when it is dry as we normally peg it out (9)
both peg out laundry together
they alternate who cleans the toilet and who does the shower
they pick up dog poo in the garden together
daughter puts out the bins and brings them in

🤷‍♀️we correct language all the time
eg refer to a nurse as she we ask why

both can use a sewing machine

we call out as much day to day racism or sexism as we see it and we discuss

eg when doing Africa in school we talked about racism
we went to visit the Colston statue and debated on why it was built in the first place, if it should have been removed and if the people should have been found of guilty of criminal actions for damaging it.

Next time you talk about Africa, will you talk about colonisation? I’m not being funny but my kids are doing GCSE history and it’s woeful. It is complete and deliberate erasure. They threw in apartheid as a sop but that’s actually worse. Look over there! Don’t talk about the British empire! Didn’t happen!
Which means my poor children have to listen to me again. As soon as they find a circus they are running away.

Pertinentowl · 22/10/2022 09:53

I know my sister rewrote Sleeping beauty to make it that she was put to sleep because of her organising ability and higher career achievements (I’m not sure what job she gave her) I found it very amusing and was looking forward to what else she would do.

Id never actually finish a s story with my kids, they would sidetrack me and Id drop the book and end up on a tangent. But for people with non illiterate children, looking for folk stories from other cultures to help fight against cultural erasure would be good if you are worried about the implications of stories.
but do not do what I did when my four year old approached me with her friends and asked how come no one in school would believe they were sisters. One was black, one was white and she is arab. She wanted my helped cementing her lie.
I ended up giving four year olds an hour long lecture which included transatlantic slavery. Did not work. The other mother told them God used all colours of sand to make people. That worked better. The third mother cracked it and got the three of them matching bracelets. That was proof enough for the school friends. Surely only real sisters could have matching bracelets.

OptimisticPrime · 22/10/2022 09:15

OP I agree with you, read very few traditional fairy stories to our children. And Cinderella only once, I had to add that the prince fell in love with her sense of humour and sparkling personality, not just her beauty. I was shocked to be honest.

A PP has suggested The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter. Great book, but please read it first before you give to your DD as it’s very adult. I specifically remember a description of female genitalia ‘gleaming like a split fig’.

Hellothere54 · 22/10/2022 09:02

Might be a little old for your daughter at the moment, but I highly recommend the Robin McKinley books. She has retold Beauty and the beast twice (beauty which is more suitable for younger readers and Rose Daughter which is a beautiful and strange retelling) and Sleeping Beauty (Spindle’s end - sleeping beauty does not spend her time asleep in this version). Some of the Disney’s twisted tails are also very good rewritings if their own films but with a twist.

Canyoubelievethesepeople · 22/10/2022 08:40

I agree to a certain extent but the tales are also an important part of our traditions and heritage. These stories can and should continue to exist alongside discussion.
I, however, am struggling to tolerate the many many depictions of strong female characters scoffing at men and presenting them as stupid, docile beings. We seem to have gone to completely the other extreme, which is just as dangerous!!

sundaydayisnotmyfundayday · 22/10/2022 07:40

In The School For Good and Evil we are introduced to a pretty blonde who believes she's a princess and another girl who is framed as a witch. The whole point of the story is that they aren't who you expect them to be and they save themselves.

In Hansel and Gretel, Gretels wit saves them.

In red riding hood originally she saved herself.

In the little mermaid she decides in the end that she would rather earn a human soul than get the guy

In sleeping beauty she is raped while asleep and the child she gives birth to wakes her. She outsmarts the Queen to survive.

Fairytales aren't the issue really

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 22/10/2022 07:22

DuckTails · 20/10/2022 11:31

I love fairy tales but I also agree. Definitely get your DD a copy of Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber for some feminist fairy tales and for yourself you may enjoy Gilbert and Gubar’s Madwoman in the Attic. Their criticism of Snow White (woman trapped in her home made to do domestic duties for emotionally stunted men and every time she tries to escape her domestic servitude is punished with death) is excellent.

I'm wondering if you have a degree in English and we studied at the same place?

Ghodavies · 22/10/2022 07:15

Gloryofthe80s · 20/10/2022 12:17

I can’t even think of one transgender person in a fairytale.

Maybe that’s because they were written centuries ago and not based on real life. I don’t see many unicorns walking down the high street either!

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 22/10/2022 07:10

HairyHandedSonOfTroll · 20/10/2022 21:01

BTW, I'd have shagged the Beast like a shot, but I wouldn't have given that wet prince at the end the time of day.

Pretty much the topic of my (now ancient) dissertation. Look at Wuthering Heights, Tess of the Durbervilles and so many others - the wet, drippy men are not attractive.

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 22/10/2022 07:03

And another one. Here you go: www.abebooks.co.uk/9780241424230/Fairy-Tales-Millennials-Problematic-Stories-0241424232/plp

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 22/10/2022 07:00

Lots of fairy stories have been retold. Angela Carter has done this, for instance. However, her re-tellings are not suitable for children.

Applesandcarrots · 20/10/2022 22:15

It's the same like various sayongs which used to be encouraging but now are the opposite (curiosity killed the cat but.....).
It all ywists into what someone wanted it into

Chouetted · 20/10/2022 22:02

underneaththeash · 20/10/2022 21:58

Most children don’t read Gary stories, they get told them by their parents in a basic format. 3 little pigs - 2 don’t try hard enough, one does and looks after his brother and the wolf who tries to hurt them gets injured. Goldilocks - goes into someone’s house - steals and gets chased out. 3 billy goats gruff someone bullies them and they fight back.
All okay.
the one I had an issue was - original Noddy Enid Blyton at my mums house and I had to edit whilst reading - awful racist stuff. Posted to Manchester Uni with instructions to bin if they didn’t have a copy already (they didn’t).

I understand some children are sensitive, but half the point of fairy tales is that horrible things happen, and even the magic cuts both ways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread