Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We work hard.

140 replies

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 01:17

I keep seeing this on threads about Middle income families having to make cutbacks. The hardest job I ever had was when I worked in a care home as a care assistant doing 12.5 hour shifts for minimum wage. I now do a different job I have more paperwork to do and responsibility but I earn lots more and it's less tiring work. Same with my OH he works from home and his work is a lot less hard then it was when he started out and gets more pay.

AIBU to think if you are earning more money sometimes it's down to luck/personality/ rare skills more so than simply working hard?

OP posts:
Signeduptosimplyreplytothis · 20/10/2022 09:38

Both ends are hard work in their own way. Frontline work is physically and mentally draining for little reward but less responsibility if things go wrong. Get senior enough and if the front line gets it wrong you could end up in jail/national papers/life ruined which I'm sure brings its own level of stress! I wouldn't want to be Liz Truss or the chief exec of the Kent hospitals right now for instance.

AmeliaEarhart · 20/10/2022 09:37

As someone has suggested upthread, I think the mental load of people on lower income outside of the workplace is probably harder. So to borrow the previously used example of surgeon and hospital porter; yes, the surgeon has the larger mental burden while performing their role, but are much more likely to able to afford the things that make their lives easier outside of work. For example, high-quality, reliable childcare, a cleaner, supermarket deliveries etc. Whereas the porter might not have access to these things so has the additional stress and workload when they finish their shift. I don’t think this disparity can be overlooked when we’re comparing who works “hardest”.

JamSandle · 20/10/2022 09:24

In general, you're right. I'm at my highest income now and have to work hard but some of my hardest non-stop jobs were paid much less.

There's some sort of quote which says something like if hard work was all it took to be rich, then carers would be the richest of all.

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 09:20

@MissTrip82
Yes I agree. And other posters have said similar things along the lines of “we work hard so we deserve to have nice things (list of luxuries) in our life otherwise what is the point” and “we work our arses off so why should we accept any decline in our lifestyle?”

They feel they work harder than those on lower incomes and so think they are also entitled to government help of some sort to maintain their MC lifestyle. They don’t begrudge the government help to lower income people, so long as it keeps them to essentials only, while they “the squeezed middle” deserve help to have their bit of luxury that they’ve “worked hard for.”

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 09:18

Not all desk jobs are 9 -5

Although I am now on tea break - although these mind breaks are key to creativity

Although I am also glad to be doing something very worthwhile - I couldn't take this stress and pressure without that knowledge

MissTrip82 · 20/10/2022 09:13

I do think lots of people overstate their effort. On the thread about being in the middle and squashed the OP goes from describing normal full time work to ‘we’re working out arses off’ in the course of two posts.

IME it’s quite unusual to work your arse off……especially if your job is one of those involving lots of zoom and some emails.

People feeling like they’re working incredibly and uniquely hard seems to be driving some dissatisfaction currently.

I work > 12 hr shifts and don’t usually get to eat/drink/wee in that time. Still wouldn’t really say I’m working my arse off. Just working, as many people do. I feel glad to have meaningful, difficult work that can’t be done between 9 and 5.

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 09:12

sst1234 · 20/10/2022 07:47

Its about working hard at the right time, right place. Taking risks and stepping outside of the safe zone. A lot of people work hard but miss that one opportunity that presented itself.

True, it is about working hard and being in the right place at the right time (luck). But as well as those who work hard and miss an opportunity, there are many that work hard and never get an opportunity.

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 09:06

LovelyQuiche · 20/10/2022 02:25

you’re being too binary
of course there are people who get where they are through luck / help / whatever. I know a few. But you’ll probably find the majority of middle earners just put consistent work into the right area to end up where they are. So yeah, they do work hard, and have likely studied / taken on responsibility to get there.

My comment wasn’t binary. In fact the exact opposite. To move up you need both hard work/good choices AND luck, opportunity and privilege. The problem is that people tend to over credit their hard work/good choices and under- acknowledge the role of luck, opportunity and privilege.

And your comment is an apt illustration of what sociologists have found:
But you’ll probably find the majority of middle earners just put consistent work into the right area to end up where they are

Just put consistent work into the right area. Just, as in the one and only reason for success. So you’re blatantly over-crediting hard work/good choices by saying for most middle earners it is 100% the only reason for their success.

NotOnTheSofa · 20/10/2022 09:03

The basic point is that being in a senior position on a high income doesnt necessarily mean you have worked harder than anyone else, which is something I see people claim on here all the time and it does wind me up. People always claim they got where they are purely off their own hard work and sensible choices when the reality is there is much more too it than that. There are so many factors at play which determine someone's career path and we don't have control over all of them.

FloorWipes · 20/10/2022 08:48

“The higher you go the more responsibility you carry” It’s also notable though that for some number of people at the very top even when they fuck up that responsibility they still depart with a golden handshake.

Fizbosshoes · 20/10/2022 08:45

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 02:05

YANBU. Numerous sociological studies have shown that higher income people tend to over credit their work ethic and under acknowledge the role of luck, privilege and opportunity when portraying the reasons for their success. Sadly, this is more common in higher income people that were upwardly mobile in socio-economic terms with more modest origins. There is a ‘if I can do it, anyone can’ and it’s cousin a ‘if you haven’t done it, it’s because you chose poorly or didn’t work as hard compared to me’ prevailing attitude.

Exactly this. Any thread about people earning decent salaries, people always mention working hard, taking opportunities, putting in the hours, smart choices etc. All those things can be true but often - not always - coupled with privilege or advantage of some kind. (Having a stable home, going to a good school/private education, being intelligent or having a natural talent , chance to go to university, knowing the right people, opportunities presenting themselves at a particular time... or sometimes...luck) i think some people don't like this pointed out because they feel like you're saying they didn't work hard. But the 2 things are not mutually exclusive, you can be 100% committed and hard working and have some advantage over other people.

It really grated when Victoria Beckham won some kind of entrepreneurial award - she had a huge head start in starting a business in the fact she was a millionaire to start with and didn't have to raise the capital to put into it. She might have worked just as hard as the next person but she already had a massive advantage. (Extreme example obviously!)

DH bought his first house in the early 1980s. He doesn't like it if I point out that in some ways he was lucky to have had the opportunity at that particular period in time. He protests he worked really hard for it (he did) but the point is a young person now working just as hard in a similar level job could never dream of buying the same house.

Darbs76 · 20/10/2022 08:42

In my industry the more senior you get the less actual physical doing of the work but more strategic and carrying the can. More responsibly and more pressure. The person at the bottom doesn’t have to worry once they close their laptop, the person at the top is probably working more late hours.

Hoppinggreen · 20/10/2022 08:37

Both me and DH are very well paid but we don’t really work hard to be honest.
I get paid for having over 25 years of experience and contacts in my field and DH gets paid for having excellent tech skills and a huge amount of responsibility

Kabbalah · 20/10/2022 08:36

LovelyQuiche · 20/10/2022 02:25

you’re being too binary
of course there are people who get where they are through luck / help / whatever. I know a few. But you’ll probably find the majority of middle earners just put consistent work into the right area to end up where they are. So yeah, they do work hard, and have likely studied / taken on responsibility to get there.

Agree with that. Also the higher you go the more responsibility you carry.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/10/2022 08:34

I think most people work hard in one way or another tbh. Physical jobs, high stress jobs l, jobs with long hours or difficult customers. And those doing unpaid work like caring for children or relatives.

A few have a cushy life but percentage wise, not that many.

RoachTheHorse · 20/10/2022 08:34

Mine and my H's take home is decent and we do work hard. As do most people.

What I struggle with is that people who work hard in jobs that are vital, like health care, emergency services, food supply/supermarket, local governance etc are paid a low amount such that they cannot afford to live.

If we paid everyone who keeps the country running properly at a wage that allowed them to live not just survive, then other private employers would keep up. So I have no truck with those private sector workers who say they haven't had a rise so why should anyone else.

It all goes hand in hand.

FWIW I'd be happy to pay higher taxes and have lower take home if I knew it meant the services I make use of would be properly funded and the staff working there properly supported.

Merryoldgoat · 20/10/2022 08:28

I agree. I do work hard but I doubt I work any harder than some people earning significantly less than me.

I definitely don’t work as hard as a social worker, teacher, or nurse and have far less responsibility for more money than most of them.

Luck, the ‘right’ career choice, and whether your face fits makes a big impact.

middleager · 20/10/2022 08:28

'People are also paid for being decision makers and taking risks.'

Again, I do this in my job, but am paid an average UK salary.

luxxlisbon · 20/10/2022 08:28

BitOutOfPractice · 20/10/2022 07:54

I just knew this thread would descend into a “I work harder than you” competition which sort proves the OP’s point.

How is it proving the OP’s point because other people also think they work hard? Why is it acceptable to say you work hard in a care role but it then becomes unacceptable to think you work hard at a desk job?

The reality clearly is that most people work hard, particularly when they have families. Most people go to work and try their best to earn a living.
It isn’t hard work specifically that equates to wages. You don’t automatically work harder because you work a more manual job.

middleager · 20/10/2022 08:25

I see it on here all the time.

The high earners who say they (or their partners )work hard and take work home - justifying the huge salary.

I earn the average UK salary, yet my work carries into the evenings, I'm expected to pick up my work mobile on evenings and days off too.

RedAppleGirl · 20/10/2022 08:24

How about jobs that are physically and mentally demanding.

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 08:21

The desire to divide and "other" people is always strong at times of stress - it's playing out every day on here

Mumski45 · 20/10/2022 08:20

Being a high earner is not just about working hard. In a capitalist system we have supply and demand so some skills are valued more highly in a monetary way if they are in short supply.

Public sector jobs are a bit different in that the wages come from a finite pot which is constantly squeezed so the wages are kept lower.

It's a bit like house prices which can be higher if they are near a good school. People are prepared to pay more as it's worth more them.

People are also paid for being decision makers and taking risks.

luxxlisbon · 20/10/2022 08:18

Both of those things can be true at the same time though. Most lower earners probably work hard and most middle to higher earners probably work hard. It’s not one or the other.
Really we are talking about the difference between manual labour and mental labour and it’s pointless to equate them.

Is it luck that I was academic? Yes and no.
Was it luck that I worked hard to get a degree, while working retail for 7 years and now have a relatively decent job and income? I don’t accept that.

I

vincettenoir · 20/10/2022 08:18

YNBU at all. A lot of low paid jobs are very stressful, exhausting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread