Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We work hard.

140 replies

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 01:17

I keep seeing this on threads about Middle income families having to make cutbacks. The hardest job I ever had was when I worked in a care home as a care assistant doing 12.5 hour shifts for minimum wage. I now do a different job I have more paperwork to do and responsibility but I earn lots more and it's less tiring work. Same with my OH he works from home and his work is a lot less hard then it was when he started out and gets more pay.

AIBU to think if you are earning more money sometimes it's down to luck/personality/ rare skills more so than simply working hard?

OP posts:
FreddyHG · 20/10/2022 11:09

middleager · 20/10/2022 08:28

'People are also paid for being decision makers and taking risks.'

Again, I do this in my job, but am paid an average UK salary.

Then change career so you earn more. Nobody forces anyone to do the same job in the UK.

LindaEllen · 20/10/2022 11:05

It depends on the job. You'll always get people who are lucky, and who just know the right people .. but then there are others who work very hard, study for years, and work their way up the ranks - and that's definitely down to hard work rather than luck.

If you decide to work in industries that typically pay minimum wage, you know there's no scope to rise above that. You need to look at potential career progression when you decide the career you want to be in.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 11:03

woff45 · 20/10/2022 10:54

What I think is really interesting is in all this mess since Covid I've not once heard of supermarkets having shortages of staff (correct me if I'm wrong), except logistics which is a separate thing, and my understanding is supermarket staff are paid relatively well, not minimum wage. Staff discount. Presumably flexible shifts. I suspect that is not a coincidence, and yet the aviation industry couldn't understand why they were in such chaos over summer, it really is simple, pay staff well and you won't struggle to find people, good people.

A tiny tiny bit over NMW. Online they’ll advertise more but it will be with the T&C that you’ll get £2 an hour extra on bank holidays or after 1am or similar. Shifts you’ll rarely get. But realistically it’s usually NMW or just over. And that’s for really stupid shifts most of the time too, not particularly flexible.

Still better than caring or childcare work though, because it’s easier for the money.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:00

The hardest job I ever had was when I worked in a care home as a care assistant doing 12.5 hour shifts for minimum wage
I did this work for a few years too. It was tiring but nothing like mentally and psychology tiring as the jobs I later had that involved having to make pressurising decisions and face the consequences of making wrong ones.

A bit like cooking Vs deciding on the menu each day making sure it is within the home budget but also pleasing the who family so people don't complain, insuring it's not boring, introducing variety but so much that everyone think it's too odd, work out which item is cheaper at which store, what time is best to go to avoid traffic, making sure that no item has been missed out from the list ect...

Preparing the food just following the recipe is tiring but nothing as much as the whole organising of it.

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 10:59

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 10:07

I used to be "Internal Sales Co-ordinator" it was a full time desk job, 9-5 Mon-Fri, salaried so no over time, I have a BTech in Business and Finance, 20+ years experience.

The thought of sitting behind a desk all day made me feel so depressed I just couldn't do it anymore. It's so mind numbingly boring.

I now work as a carer, I'm studying for my NVQ, I work 12 hour shifts over night and it's non stop. I've never worked so physically or mentally hard. It's also hard emotionally and there's lots of studying, training, record keeping, paper work, etc. Yes, I wipe arses for a living but it's so much more than that. It's a challenge every single day, in every way. No two days are the same.

Do I deserve to earn as much or be as respected as in my previous job? Hell yes! All that and a fuck ton more on top.

This on one shift back in the day it's been me and one other carer for 30 people. I had to get 15 people washed , somehow toilet them , change and feed them some with dysphagia. It was the hardest most stressful shift as I had people crying to be changed while I was changing someone else. I now work in management HCP it's more responsibility but more money I've never felt as overloaded and I did for minimum wage.

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 20/10/2022 10:55

There's also something to be said for personal dispositions, which are born not made.

Take sales people. They have a certain energy and attitude to them - almost wolfish. They always WANT something. They can learn techniques, but the attitude is just fundamental to who they are, even if they're crap at it.

Sure, we should always reward people sufficiently, but I think any sort of parity is a pipe dream. People are too different for that.

I, by the way, am middle class, educated, and highly intelligent. People expected huge things from me.

They didn't pay attention to the fact that I'm anti establishment, anti institutional, and a total hippy. All of which don't lend themselves to mega bucks success in most ways.

5128gap · 20/10/2022 10:54

YANBU. My own experience is that as I've progressed to increasingly 'better' jobs, higher paid, more senior, the less hard I've had to work.
I'm very aware that the staff I manage, despite my best efforts to make their work life the best i can, work harder than I do, with less autonomy, variation and flexibility and obviously for less money; by the sheer nature of the jobs we do.
There comes a point when you're paid more for what you know and the responsibility you carry than for what you actually do day to day, leading to very limited correlation between hard work and income.

woff45 · 20/10/2022 10:54

What I think is really interesting is in all this mess since Covid I've not once heard of supermarkets having shortages of staff (correct me if I'm wrong), except logistics which is a separate thing, and my understanding is supermarket staff are paid relatively well, not minimum wage. Staff discount. Presumably flexible shifts. I suspect that is not a coincidence, and yet the aviation industry couldn't understand why they were in such chaos over summer, it really is simple, pay staff well and you won't struggle to find people, good people.

Maverickess · 20/10/2022 10:50

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 10:21

There's literally a nationwide shortage of carers and they're still only offered NMW, so it's not about supply and demand, it's about certain jobs being looked down on by society and vastly underrated.

Not anyone can be a carer, etc, in fact I'd say more so than other jobs, not everyone has what it takes, which is why so many new starters leave after a few weeks (some go home for dinner first day and just never come back).

This is so true when it comes to the supply and demand thing, there's a shortage in hospitality - wages are rising, I moved out of care and back into hospitality because the wages, conditions and treatment are better, ultimately because people are willing to pay more for leisure experiences than they are for their elderly and vulnerable families to be cared for.
I don't work any harder, some days it's on par with my days in care, but I don't feel anything near the level of responsibility - for other people's lives, giving out medication that can kill someone if you get it wrong (with an hour's 'training' to 'qualify' you to give it out) being physically and verbally abused daily, dealing with bodily fluids smeared everywhere, never having enough people to deliver the care expected but then knowing you might end up on the wrong end of a safeguarding for not being able to do it. And I'm paid more for the same level (supervisory) - I might piss someone off by giving them no ice in a drink they wanted ice in, but I'm highly unlikely to kill them, or for it to have a long lasting, life changing effect (although with some customers you do wonder 🤣)

And let's be honest, hospitality is not exactly a high bar when it comes to wages and job benefits is it?! Yet it's markedly better than one of the most essential services to society.

It's not supply and demand, it should be, but if it were we'd be seeing care assistants earning double or treble what they are now.

woff45 · 20/10/2022 10:50

It's not just working hard it's working smart and strategically. My dad probably works harder than I do day to day in his manual job vs my senior management role, he would hate to know what I earn and would probably think it wasn't deserved, however, I have spent a lot of time in education, volunteering, keeping on top of my CPD, going to conferences, networking, making 5 year plans, keeping ahead of the industry to recognise skill gaps, changing jobs regularly to not stagnate. My career is a living, breathing thing I develop, I don't just go to work every day. I've made sacrifices especially in terms of my family, so yes it does really sting when I've been doing this for 15 years but my disposable income will not reflect this to the degree it would have done prior to this mess. So I am bitter, not at anyone else, just generally! And I recognise it's not the same as not being able to eat or heat on a lower income.

(And firmly in the camp of recognising the amount of luck involved too, I couldn't do what I do without my health, my family's health, the leg up my steady childhood got me etc etc)

DomesticShortHair · 20/10/2022 10:45

The hardest jobs I’ve ever done have been the ones that I didn’t enjoy. I’ve worked physically and mentally harder in some roles, but because I was motivated and invested, the impact has been far less than when I’ve just been grinding through the hours, not doing much, but waiting to go home.

Some of the good, well paid jobs I’ve had were down to the effort I had made to have the right skill set and experience. And some of them were just down to being in the right place at the right time. So whereas I’m not saying there isn’t a link between hard work, luck and money, it’s probably a lot more elastic than I’d have perhaps once thought.

thecatsthecats · 20/10/2022 10:39

bonzaitree · 20/10/2022 10:10

They have skills that are valued more by society and may be scarce. That's why people get paid more.

If you work on the checkout, lots of people are capable of doing that job so you are paid less as you are more replaceable

If you're a spinal surgeon not many people can do that so you're paid much more.

It's not a question of who works harder. It's a question of supply and demand.

I don't disagree for the most part.

But I'm also spectacularly wound up by a lot of exec level staff who lack basic office skills. For example, our CEO sent out an excel document. Half the writing was hidden because she didn't know how to adjust it, and half the trustees didn't know how to expand the cells to read the contents.

I know that not everyone has excel knowledge - that's fine. But all of these people work in roles where BASIC excel knowledge would be the norm.

Senior execs who have assistants because they would not have the time to do all their own admin - fine. I find that senior execs who are simply not able to do those things are also more generally clueless, but CONFIDENT with it.

(I've taken a part-time role to fit around training, and the way I get treated by the senior staff in my org, and seeing them confidently bluster their way through things I KNOW to be incorrect, is eye opening)

Kanaloa · 20/10/2022 10:32

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 10:21

There's literally a nationwide shortage of carers and they're still only offered NMW, so it's not about supply and demand, it's about certain jobs being looked down on by society and vastly underrated.

Not anyone can be a carer, etc, in fact I'd say more so than other jobs, not everyone has what it takes, which is why so many new starters leave after a few weeks (some go home for dinner first day and just never come back).

Literally the only thing that got me through my time as a carer was knowing I was only doing it for a few months. If I’d thought jt was a long term prospect I’d have left the first day and never gone back. Hard work indeed.

Realistically, people that brag that they have what they have because they’ve ‘worked hard’ are ignorant. They’ve made good choices and had good opportunities, but lots of people who are paid incredibly poorly work so so hard. And these are people like carers for the elderly and disabled, nursery teachers for children and so on. Not people doing some easy job that they just skip away from at 5pm with no stress on their minds. They’re overwhelmingly people who didn’t have the opportunity to go to uni and become a top lawyer/surgeon/engineer etc. And their contributions to society are incredibly necessary, and sadly totally undervalued.

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 10:21

There's literally a nationwide shortage of carers and they're still only offered NMW, so it's not about supply and demand, it's about certain jobs being looked down on by society and vastly underrated.

Not anyone can be a carer, etc, in fact I'd say more so than other jobs, not everyone has what it takes, which is why so many new starters leave after a few weeks (some go home for dinner first day and just never come back).

thecatsthecats · 20/10/2022 10:17

Asparagoose · 20/10/2022 09:43

Two people work the same hours but one earns £20k and one earns £100k. No, the second person does not work 5x as hard as the first person! They’ve been lucky to get their job. I’m not saying they don’t work hard - of course they do. But they’re not working any harder than anyone else.

What are you calling luck though?

A middle class person might have to work extremely hard to get that 100k role whilst an upper middle class person might walk into the same salary via connections.

My friend was the first in her family to go to university - Cambridge - then joined a top law firm. At times, she was working 120h weeks. These firms operate on a frankly insane survival of the fittest model. She was definitely working BLOODY hard. But was also educated and intelligent.

bonzaitree · 20/10/2022 10:10

Asparagoose · 20/10/2022 09:43

Two people work the same hours but one earns £20k and one earns £100k. No, the second person does not work 5x as hard as the first person! They’ve been lucky to get their job. I’m not saying they don’t work hard - of course they do. But they’re not working any harder than anyone else.

They have skills that are valued more by society and may be scarce. That's why people get paid more.

If you work on the checkout, lots of people are capable of doing that job so you are paid less as you are more replaceable

If you're a spinal surgeon not many people can do that so you're paid much more.

It's not a question of who works harder. It's a question of supply and demand.

BuryingAcorns · 20/10/2022 10:08

One of the easiest jobs I ever had was the best paid.

The hardest workers I know are carers. They are on minimum wage. A brilliant carer I know gave up and became a shop assistant because the hours, conditions and pay were all better.

crossstitchingnana · 20/10/2022 10:08

And with the "we work hard" from middle income I think what they're saying is "we work FT and there's no more we can do, yet we are struggling financially." It comes from the idea that you work hard you will be rewarded. Be that manual or non-manual labour. Thing is no-one is being fairly rewarded at the moment.

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 10:07

I used to be "Internal Sales Co-ordinator" it was a full time desk job, 9-5 Mon-Fri, salaried so no over time, I have a BTech in Business and Finance, 20+ years experience.

The thought of sitting behind a desk all day made me feel so depressed I just couldn't do it anymore. It's so mind numbingly boring.

I now work as a carer, I'm studying for my NVQ, I work 12 hour shifts over night and it's non stop. I've never worked so physically or mentally hard. It's also hard emotionally and there's lots of studying, training, record keeping, paper work, etc. Yes, I wipe arses for a living but it's so much more than that. It's a challenge every single day, in every way. No two days are the same.

Do I deserve to earn as much or be as respected as in my previous job? Hell yes! All that and a fuck ton more on top.

crossstitchingnana · 20/10/2022 10:05

It's also what you perceive to be "middle". Me and dh work for charities, both have worked hard for qualifications but not loaded. We wanted job satisfaction over money. In current climes this is a challenge.

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 09:53

@colddayinhell
a lot of lower paid workers can work part-time hours and then get tax credits or UC so they get their benefits massively topped up

Theyre not “massively topped up” because their total incomings per person are still less than 40hrs/week on NMW. And you can only work part time hours and keep benefits due to young children or ill health. This isn’t an option taken by choice but by necessity.

thecatsthecats · 20/10/2022 09:51

The most physically tiring jobs I've done were events. Racking up a step count of 30k a day, easy.

However, the most grinding work mentally was a mid-level project manager role. Travelling to the four corners of the country, working on the train, working at the weekend, not being able to stop thinking about it on holiday.

And the worst work I've experienced was senior leadership during a crisis. I ended up signed off with stress, and never went back. I still feel the effects today of what was a period of six weeks.

I don't think any job level has a unique claim to working hard. I do think that like it or lump it, if all you have to sell is your PHYSICAL ability to work, then yeah, you're offering the lowest common denominator.

What I sell my hours on is my ability to knock 10% off an operational budget or spend 25% less time on admin. That is innately more valuable to most organisations.

But I'm not going to claim I work hard. I've been there, done that, and the most enjoyable of the three listed above was the events work.

colddayinhell · 20/10/2022 09:50

The difference is that most middle income families don't receive any benefits because they earn over the threshold or have savings whereas a lot of lower paid workers can work part-time hours and then get tax credits or UC so they get their benefits massively topped up. So yes, they often are working harder because they work full time although the job itself might be less physically strenuous they still have to do 5 days travelling into an office and back.

Bunnyfuller · 20/10/2022 09:44

‘Work hard’ is the wealthy’s sop to themselves to justify huge incomes. No one can deny someone doing 3 jobs is working hard. That person doing 3 jobs probably didn’t have the means or opportunities to ‘work hard’ and get a degree, or their foot in the door of something more lucrative.

I don’t see the posts re. Middle class and no help as working on this principle - they’re talking about how above a certain income level you get zero help, and are treated the same as the millionaire, and expected to just suck up the hideous inflation.

working hard is different for everyone, but for those super wealthy saying ‘I worked hard, I deserve this’ is distasteful and rubbishes anyone else’s efforts. Typical Tory I’m alright, Jack.

Asparagoose · 20/10/2022 09:43

Two people work the same hours but one earns £20k and one earns £100k. No, the second person does not work 5x as hard as the first person! They’ve been lucky to get their job. I’m not saying they don’t work hard - of course they do. But they’re not working any harder than anyone else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread