Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We work hard.

140 replies

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 01:17

I keep seeing this on threads about Middle income families having to make cutbacks. The hardest job I ever had was when I worked in a care home as a care assistant doing 12.5 hour shifts for minimum wage. I now do a different job I have more paperwork to do and responsibility but I earn lots more and it's less tiring work. Same with my OH he works from home and his work is a lot less hard then it was when he started out and gets more pay.

AIBU to think if you are earning more money sometimes it's down to luck/personality/ rare skills more so than simply working hard?

OP posts:
fluffylittlesoandso · 20/10/2022 13:12

@Maverickess yes different choices but they become bad when you can't afford to live don't they? And in the U.K. is not an easy place to get by in if you can't afford accommodation, which imo is a massive stumbling point to 'choosing' not to have a career unless you have someone or something else in place to support you financially.

Maverickess · 20/10/2022 13:09

fluffylittlesoandso · 20/10/2022 12:47

Hmm I think middle earners generally have had to work hard at things like their exams, hard at getting seen within their careers, worked long hours to get a decent career carved out. I don't know anyone in my fields who just walked into an above average paid job.

In a minority are those that come from privileged homes that had parents who set their course very early for them and accommodated their success but they are not middle earners.
I know I worked bloody hard and made sacrifices that aren't for everyone (abortion as needed to complete exams) delayed having dc until I'd established my career, got married before dc as believe two earners are better than one, the minute my dh became abusive I made changes in my life to turn that around, I didn't recognise it but I knew it wasn't right and researched on the web what I could do about it and actually made a change.

Lived in a hovel renting as cheap as possible and wore the same clothes Monday to Friday for 4 years to save for a deposit on a house. Was laughed at a lot for this. Moved jobs regularly to help get payrises between payrises, something that takes a lot of energy to do!
Bought mainly second hand clothes (still do this)
Regularly ate little and worked extremely long hours, again this is where delaying dc helped a lot.

I'd say in a vast majority of cases, those that don't earn well and have grown up in the U.K. and gone to school here (and are not disabled or become disabled in any way) have made some bad choices along the way.

Bad choices or different ones?

That's the attitude that I disagree with, I'm actually not that unhappy with my life as it stands, I have made different choices, I'm where I am, and I don't resent that, what I resent is the notion I made bad choices because I haven't achieved what you have. (Broadly speaking).

I have however worked hard to overcome different challenges to yours and do consider that I have achieved more than I would have had I not done that. But because I'm not where you are doesn't mean I have automatically made bad choices. There are very likely completely different circumstances and challenges at play for both of us. That doesn't mean I haven't worked just as hard as you, or you haven't worked just as hard as me.

I often think the reason that people respond with comments about luck, privilege etc is in response to the attitude that if you haven't achieved what someone else has it's because you've done something wrong. That financial achievement is the only yardstick by which to measure the whole person.

I may well have contributed far more towards society with the jobs I have done than you have (I'm not saying that's an absolute, just a possibility) but because I haven't earned as much (and by extension I find the implication of not having paid as much tax) then I am somehow lacking as a person.

I don't resent your earnings, success or status, I do resent the implication that I've made bad choices that have led me to somehow be 'lesser' - especially as for much of my working life I have done jobs that benefit people (and made people a lot of money) and it's not valued.

fluffylittlesoandso · 20/10/2022 12:47

Hmm I think middle earners generally have had to work hard at things like their exams, hard at getting seen within their careers, worked long hours to get a decent career carved out. I don't know anyone in my fields who just walked into an above average paid job.

In a minority are those that come from privileged homes that had parents who set their course very early for them and accommodated their success but they are not middle earners.
I know I worked bloody hard and made sacrifices that aren't for everyone (abortion as needed to complete exams) delayed having dc until I'd established my career, got married before dc as believe two earners are better than one, the minute my dh became abusive I made changes in my life to turn that around, I didn't recognise it but I knew it wasn't right and researched on the web what I could do about it and actually made a change.

Lived in a hovel renting as cheap as possible and wore the same clothes Monday to Friday for 4 years to save for a deposit on a house. Was laughed at a lot for this. Moved jobs regularly to help get payrises between payrises, something that takes a lot of energy to do!
Bought mainly second hand clothes (still do this)
Regularly ate little and worked extremely long hours, again this is where delaying dc helped a lot.

I'd say in a vast majority of cases, those that don't earn well and have grown up in the U.K. and gone to school here (and are not disabled or become disabled in any way) have made some bad choices along the way.

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 12:16

Overthebow · 20/10/2022 11:51

Surely there’s a range on both sides of this. Some minimum wage jobs are hard and some are easier, same for higher paid jobs. However I put a lot of work in to my career, doing an intense 4 year degree (and working in the holidays to pay for it), putting in long hours and taking on extra responsibilities so that I could progress.

I've done minimum wage jobs in the past and whilst tiring from long and physical shifts they definitely weren’t as hard as the higher paid office job I’m in now as they weren’t very mentally draining and I could switch off after the shifts finished. I sometimes dream of going back to those jobs if I’ve had a particularly stressful week, I wouldn’t though as I want the money.

I've also done a 4 year integrated masters degree. I would not say doing a dissertation was as tiring as washing/bathing /feeding/changing /repositioning 15 people on my own.

OP posts:
Heyahun · 20/10/2022 12:13

Yeah it’s true ! I worked in retail and restaurants for years.
it was low pay and bloody exhausting

my current Job is really well paid - it’s fast paced and hard and sometimes involves working late in the evening and overtime etc but I get to sit down all day at a desk and drink coffee and go to the gym on my lunch break. It’s definitely not as hard as other jobs I’ve had

AloysiusBear · 20/10/2022 12:10

Sometimes

Sometimes its a different kind of "work".

Sometimes its that hardly anyone simply has the mental ability to do what needs doing, and therefore they can demand high pay. In this case the luck is having the mental ability for tasks that our economy attributes financial value to.

I am in that bucket currently. I don't work long hours. There's nothing physically demanding about my job. I don't deal with difficult people or disgusting stuff. But sometimes its so mentally hard, that getting my head around it is a total brain fuck. Its complex, subjective, and cross disciplinary.

All i do is individually negotiate the best pay i can for myself. The shortage of people able to do what i can, combined with the financial value associated with it, mean i can negotiate a high pay (6 figs).

Winterthoughts · 20/10/2022 12:02

I think it's like an incantation, reassuring people they are worthy of what they have,but more importantly,that they are in control and outside forces can't turn their life upside down:like illness or disability

PersonaNonGarter · 20/10/2022 11:57

YANBU. I am a lawyer. Piece of piss compared to being a Carer.

Executive stress is nothing compared to actual poverty.

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 11:56

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:27

I am talking legally. A manager can be sent to court, deemed responsible (lack of training, supervision etc...), even sent to jail for a staff member making a huge mistake.

A cleaner is not going to end up in court because their boss didn't ensure the building was secure.

No, not for a staff member making a mistake. Managers are only criminally liable for their own mistakes and only if they have gone rogue and not acting under the direction of their managers.

In most scenarios the worst that can happen is a corporate manslaughter case in which the company is prosecuted and if guilty of negligence (very hard to prove), fined by the courts for compensation for the victims’ families. The manager involved may be sacked (and often have a severance package known generally as a “golden parachute”) , but so too are the staff members but they don’t get a golden parachute…

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:55

Getting someone dressed can cause hideous skin tears. A tiny bit of pressure can cause bruising, you can be prosecuted if you don't do your job properly, people can die from being given wrong medication. If someone dies and you made a clerical error you can end up in court
But that's the point, if you follow what you are told and trained to do, things won't happen. If you make a big mistake and you've been perfectly trained, but somehow your training was a month late because the trainer cancelled, it's your boss that will be deemed responsible.

As a manager, you accept responsibilities and risks that can be beyond your control and blamed for incidents that are really not your doing. That's normal, that's the role of a manager but the reason why you are paid more.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:51

I would like to see one example of a manager being jailed that wasn't a very clear case of managerial criminal and willful neglect
My uncle, years ago. He was a site director. All staff had received training about security, wearing correct boots, helmets etc...one guy decided to go up a ladder without his helmet, fell and horribly passed away. My uncle was made responsible, even though witnesses said that the guy was told to wear it and he said he would only be a few seconds. All because the supervisor had called in sick and my uncle was deemed responsible for not ensuring cover that afternoon. He got 3 years, thankfully not served in prison.

Thankfully it happens much more rarely now because manager do spend a lot of their time assessing risks and ensuring incidents and accidents don't happen.

Overthebow · 20/10/2022 11:51

Surely there’s a range on both sides of this. Some minimum wage jobs are hard and some are easier, same for higher paid jobs. However I put a lot of work in to my career, doing an intense 4 year degree (and working in the holidays to pay for it), putting in long hours and taking on extra responsibilities so that I could progress.

I've done minimum wage jobs in the past and whilst tiring from long and physical shifts they definitely weren’t as hard as the higher paid office job I’m in now as they weren’t very mentally draining and I could switch off after the shifts finished. I sometimes dream of going back to those jobs if I’ve had a particularly stressful week, I wouldn’t though as I want the money.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:45

The vast majority of high paid managers are not in that position
Oh they are, they really are, but as you say, it doesn't happen often because training us given, but managing the risk is a huge part of being a senior manager.

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 11:42

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:00

The hardest job I ever had was when I worked in a care home as a care assistant doing 12.5 hour shifts for minimum wage
I did this work for a few years too. It was tiring but nothing like mentally and psychology tiring as the jobs I later had that involved having to make pressurising decisions and face the consequences of making wrong ones.

A bit like cooking Vs deciding on the menu each day making sure it is within the home budget but also pleasing the who family so people don't complain, insuring it's not boring, introducing variety but so much that everyone think it's too odd, work out which item is cheaper at which store, what time is best to go to avoid traffic, making sure that no item has been missed out from the list ect...

Preparing the food just following the recipe is tiring but nothing as much as the whole organising of it.

Then you weren't taking your responsibilities as a carer seriously.

Getting someone dressed can cause hideous skin tears. A tiny bit of pressure can cause bruising, you can be prosecuted if you don't do your job properly, people can die from being given wrong medication. If someone dies and you made a clerical error you can end up in court.

Try being asked the same question on a loop for four hours straight with no respite for mentally draining.

I could go on, and on, and on...

Blibbleflibble · 20/10/2022 11:38

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:27

I am talking legally. A manager can be sent to court, deemed responsible (lack of training, supervision etc...), even sent to jail for a staff member making a huge mistake.

A cleaner is not going to end up in court because their boss didn't ensure the building was secure.

I would like to see one example of a manager being jailed that wasn't a very clear case of managerial criminal and willful neglect.

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 11:33

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:27

I am talking legally. A manager can be sent to court, deemed responsible (lack of training, supervision etc...), even sent to jail for a staff member making a huge mistake.

A cleaner is not going to end up in court because their boss didn't ensure the building was secure.

The vast majority of high paid managers are not in that position

Why do you think there is all that "compulsory training ?" For example - it covers their arses -

PrinnyPree · 20/10/2022 11:30

I don't know who said it but I suspect the statement "the hardest working person on Earth likely lives in poverty" is unfortunately very true.

I work hard but I also earn enough money that if I quit my job and take 3 months finding another I would be financially okay, I also have the experience in my current profession that finding another well paid job is much easier.

I have been poor before and lived going into my emergency overdraft every month, counting every penny and eaten 10p crisps and a 19p roll for lunch. I don't think people realise the toll and stress being poor adds onto also working very hard and having to tolerate toxic bosses because you can't just quit. It's not just the hard and sometimes soul destroying work, it's the lack of options when you're at the bottom. I have been very lucky in my breaks and pay my taxes willingly.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:27

I am talking legally. A manager can be sent to court, deemed responsible (lack of training, supervision etc...), even sent to jail for a staff member making a huge mistake.

A cleaner is not going to end up in court because their boss didn't ensure the building was secure.

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 11:24

Because that's what happens seniors duck up and the people at the bottom suffer

At worst the manager gets a big payout but usually it's just the lower levels that take the hit

FishBowlSwimmer · 20/10/2022 11:24

Maverickess · 20/10/2022 10:50

This is so true when it comes to the supply and demand thing, there's a shortage in hospitality - wages are rising, I moved out of care and back into hospitality because the wages, conditions and treatment are better, ultimately because people are willing to pay more for leisure experiences than they are for their elderly and vulnerable families to be cared for.
I don't work any harder, some days it's on par with my days in care, but I don't feel anything near the level of responsibility - for other people's lives, giving out medication that can kill someone if you get it wrong (with an hour's 'training' to 'qualify' you to give it out) being physically and verbally abused daily, dealing with bodily fluids smeared everywhere, never having enough people to deliver the care expected but then knowing you might end up on the wrong end of a safeguarding for not being able to do it. And I'm paid more for the same level (supervisory) - I might piss someone off by giving them no ice in a drink they wanted ice in, but I'm highly unlikely to kill them, or for it to have a long lasting, life changing effect (although with some customers you do wonder 🤣)

And let's be honest, hospitality is not exactly a high bar when it comes to wages and job benefits is it?! Yet it's markedly better than one of the most essential services to society.

It's not supply and demand, it should be, but if it were we'd be seeing care assistants earning double or treble what they are now.

I couldn't agree more.

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:22

And the cleaner gets sacked if the manager messes up
How?

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 11:17

And the cleaner gets sacked if the manager messes up

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 11:13

It's also about level of risk. In the example of cooking a meal. The only risk really is to poison the family, under cook chicken, burn it all, or burn oneself. All these are unlikely with good training.

The manager takes a risk by working out menu that are not healthy, that cost too much putting the family in debt, use ingredients not available, not bringing them in time to be cooked, injuring themselves going to get them, etc.... AND being blamed for anything that the cook does wrong.

SnowFir · 20/10/2022 11:13

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 02:05

YANBU. Numerous sociological studies have shown that higher income people tend to over credit their work ethic and under acknowledge the role of luck, privilege and opportunity when portraying the reasons for their success. Sadly, this is more common in higher income people that were upwardly mobile in socio-economic terms with more modest origins. There is a ‘if I can do it, anyone can’ and it’s cousin a ‘if you haven’t done it, it’s because you chose poorly or didn’t work as hard compared to me’ prevailing attitude.

I know someone like this. She had pretty poorly paid jobs but then her dh set up a very lucrative business which she now works for. She makes out she had lowly origins but she went to private school. Thinks if she can make so much money through hard work anyone can. Doesn't realise she's been lucky and could have ended up like the struggling people/single mums she talks disparagingly about.

midgetastic · 20/10/2022 11:13

"If you choose to work in lower paid industry "

Your choice is determined by what your parents know about, what your school makes you aware of , and your moral compass

People don't go into nursing rather than banking ) example £ because they had a complete free choice - they go because they thought that it's very useful and because from a small child they have been aware of how nursing is a job that looks fun and should pay ok

Not everyone is motivated by money alone - most just want enough to get by - a home , food , sone socialising and have a few savings

Not everyone wants the bankers life - especially as it's portrayed in films and tv which is likely to be the basis on which a child makes choices

Swipe left for the next trending thread