Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'bro, you are never going to have a daughter, ever'

313 replies

thatlabguy · 19/10/2022 23:12

[after the 20 weeks baby scan]

watching my two sons celebrating that they are having another baby brother, their dad, me, a single child who spent the last 25 years dreaming that one day I will have a daughter of my own, has came to a realisation that this dream will stay a dream for the rest of my life.

As a grown up, I understand that I must 'stay strong', 'accept the fact', 'many parents dream to have three boys', 'be happy that the baby boy is healthy', and 'move on with my life'.

On the other hand, I am extremely worried that deep in my mind I will never accept the fact for not having a daughter for the rest of my like, the negative energy of 'dream not come true' accumulates and one day it will explode. Of course, I'd like to prevent it from happening but I have no idea where to start, it'd be lovely to know how parents who have already been through this and successfully moved on! Should I see a psychologist?

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 20/10/2022 09:25

and was afraid I wouldn't be able to change his nappies properly!

Did everyone else’s DH know immediately how to change their baby son’s nappies, because they also had a penis? Mine had zero idea but maybe is the odd man out?

ahunf · 20/10/2022 09:25

Since becoming adults I've gone away with my mum every year / sometimes twice with my kids. Probably 20 odd holidays in total. My sister has been away with my mum twice. My brother hasn't at all. Maybe it's to do with me having kids not that we are female?

kritigirl · 20/10/2022 09:23

And people wonder why boys in this country go off the rails or don't treat women very well. Can't be easy when so many mums say they would prefer girls. Our society really needs to think about this. Children can tell. Very sad

HoppingPavlova · 20/10/2022 09:22

We spend weekends together, go on holidays together, call each other about 3 times a day... the guys are a lot more distant. That may not be the same for every family, but in my family its 100% fact

Definitely not the case for my family nor any of my friends with daughters, we are older with young adult children.

GhostCastle · 20/10/2022 09:18

Sorry the last part of my post wasn’t aimed at you @JobSeekingMissile.

ahunf · 20/10/2022 09:16

WahineToa · 20/10/2022 09:14

Oh Christ so the OP is a man who has been dreaming of having a little girl for 25 years??

ok so this is a bullshit thread

You can't say that though it's sexist!!

WahineToa · 20/10/2022 09:14

Oh Christ so the OP is a man who has been dreaming of having a little girl for 25 years??

ok so this is a bullshit thread

ehb102 · 20/10/2022 09:13

If you have at one point made an intention to have a girl, you may need to unmake that intention. Unwind it, go back to the point it was made and really look at it and process it. Some kind of help would be good. Sorry, I can't do new clients right now but I do TIR - see www.tira.org

It's the little seemingly unimportant parts of women's lives that so often trap us. Everything is important.

lostinthejungle22 · 20/10/2022 09:12

Maybe one day you'll get to enjoy a granddaughter! I'm not saying you should spend the next 20-30 years waiting for your boys to have babies, but you never know! My husband has 3 brothers and no sisters, 2 of them are married now and have daughters, my MIL is delighted!

Sachertorterules · 20/10/2022 09:12

The OP is a man, not a woman. His post is the first time I've heard of a man spending 25 years dreaming of having a daughter, but maybe I just move in different circles.

I'm another who has suffered miscarriages, but I am lucky enough to have one adult child. I can honestly say I was relieved that she was a girl (which we only found out once fingers and toes had been counted and she'd been bathed, as we were just glad the baby was alive and in one piece) because I felt had absolutely no idea of how to cope with a boy and was afraid I wouldn't be able to change his nappies properly!

Badbaddogagain · 20/10/2022 09:11

My XH was crushingly disappointed when we had our third girl, I could see that on his face though he never admitted it in words. We couldn’t have any more. He always struggled to be a good dad to her and I really wish he had talked to someone about his feelings when she was tiny, it definitely would have helped him. And her.

Please, OP, talk to a counsellor about this to get yourself into the mindset of being a great dad to all three of your lovely boys. You owe it to them.

minipie · 20/10/2022 09:09

All of this chat that you must be sexist if you want a daughter and gender means nothing etc, I don't agree. In my family, without exception, the girls and their mums are all best friends. We spend weekends together, go on holidays together, call each other about 3 times a day... the guys are a lot more distant. That may not be the same for every family, but in my family its 100% fact

Assuming other people will be the same as your family members simply because they are the same sex, is the definition of sexism.

I don’t know a single woman who was going away with her mum as an adult, or calling her 3 times a day.

HoppingPavlova · 20/10/2022 09:03

Serious question - what would you be hoping to ‘achieve ‘ with a DD? I ask as usually on these threads when people describe a mother/DD relationship it seems quite fantastical and nothing like real life or anything I have experienced with my DD. My DD is much closer to DH in her personality and interests, whereas I’m closer to some of the boys. I could name many things I have done with sons recently (movies, concerts, interest related shopping) whereas I would scratch my head and have to think of the last thing I did specifically with DD whereas I’m sure DH could come up with something in a millisecond. DD and I love each other dearly but it’s really about personality/btw tests, not what is between everyone’s legs.

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 08:59

UWhatNow · 19/10/2022 23:25

YANBU. I desperately wanted a dd too and would’ve kept going until I got one.

My dds (now young adults) have the most wonderful bond with their dad, and I know they have thrived because of it. Girls need loving, engaged, responsible men in their life. It’s such a shame it won’t happen for you but I’m sure you’ll be a wonderful role model for your sons and you can hope for lovely DILs (possibly) and maybe granddaughters one day.

Er boys also need loving, engaged, responsible men in their lives!!

Listen OP, your child's sex does not dictate what they are like as a person. Try and think about why you wanted a daughter, and why you think a DS can't give you what you want. You'll probably find that they can!

GhostCastle · 20/10/2022 08:54

JobSeekingMissile · 20/10/2022 07:31

@Rockingcloggs people have different experiences in life and you shouldn't stop them expressing disappointment because 'it could be worse'. There is very much this attitude across a lot of threads. "At least you have XYZ", "be grateful for what you have", etc
Just move away from the threads if you feel this way. I say this as someone who had miscarriages & fertility issues but still understands that people can yearn for a son / daughter over and above what they have, or yearn for a second child when certain people think they should just be glad that they have one.
@thatlabguy i think you need to get to the bottom of why you feel as you do, until you find the why it's more difficult for you to process and come to terms with.

I totally agree @JobSeekingMissile. We all have different life experiences. It doesn’t give you the right to shut someone down when they are talking about something troubling them. It’s unhelpful and unlikely to stop the OP thinking the way she does. She needs to deal with it and move on not bury it because she feels ashamed.

Bumpsadaisie · 20/10/2022 08:48

DayOfTheTentacle · 20/10/2022 07:10

We lost our baby boy after a horrific anomaly scan, and then a year later, our baby girl was diagnosed with the same problem and we had to again "choose" to let her go to. It has broken us in ways I can't tell you. The grief is horrific.

We already have a wonderful DS, my DH has another older DS. He has always wanted a girl and would try again for another. But I can't even contemplate it.

For him (and me), having a daughter would have been such a gift. But so is our living son, more than anything. Getting to bring up a healthy child is what we dreamed of. Getting to bring up two, a boy and a girl, would have been the icing on the cake.

You never know what's in your future. I hope you can be happy and settled with your lovely family and come to terms with having three boys.

So sorry xx Flowers

SnowFir · 20/10/2022 08:45

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 20/10/2022 07:05

😂 Excellent wind-up - I think people believed your first post but this one jumped the shark. Points for trying though.

What did it say?

ahunf · 20/10/2022 08:45

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious What kind of men imagine what having a daughter is like for 25 years?

Bumpsadaisie · 20/10/2022 08:41

thatlabguy · 19/10/2022 23:12

[after the 20 weeks baby scan]

watching my two sons celebrating that they are having another baby brother, their dad, me, a single child who spent the last 25 years dreaming that one day I will have a daughter of my own, has came to a realisation that this dream will stay a dream for the rest of my life.

As a grown up, I understand that I must 'stay strong', 'accept the fact', 'many parents dream to have three boys', 'be happy that the baby boy is healthy', and 'move on with my life'.

On the other hand, I am extremely worried that deep in my mind I will never accept the fact for not having a daughter for the rest of my like, the negative energy of 'dream not come true' accumulates and one day it will explode. Of course, I'd like to prevent it from happening but I have no idea where to start, it'd be lovely to know how parents who have already been through this and successfully moved on! Should I see a psychologist?

It's a loss and you are ok to have feelings about it.

I desperately wanted a boy (perhaps as when I was three my much awaited baby brother died at birth) and when my eldest was revealed as a girl at my 20 Week scan I did have to give up the idea of a boy. I expect it stirred up all sorts of very old feelings from when I lost my brother that I was not even aware of/couldn't remember.

By the time my Dd was born though I was already bonding with her and once I set eyes on her - ❤️ apple of my eye and she still is (even when she's a pain!🤣)

My second was a much longed for boy - and I feel the same way about him although totally differently. I certainly don't love either more than the other. I love my son - but he is a real life living boy, I realise my longing for a boy imagined a fantasy boy - and of course my son is not that, how could he be, he is a real person in his own right.

I think you have a fantasy of a daughter. If you had a girl she'd be a real life Dd - complex and multi faceted and the experience of being her mother would be different to what you imagine, for sure.

I bet when you meet your beautiful little boy no.3 you'll love him so much too. You can be sad you won't have a girl at the same time - one doesn't negate the other.

Good luck for your pregnancy.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/10/2022 08:41

ahunf · 20/10/2022 08:33

A man desperately wanting a daughter is a bit weird. Sons I can imagine. My husband has 2 girls. He does one of the most macho jobs you can thing of surrounded by men. He has 3 brothers. He does ok.

Why can't a man want a daughter? I wanted a little boy, is that strange for a mum to want a boy?

Nellynoo182 · 20/10/2022 08:33

YANBU Op ❤️

I am pregnant with my first who is a boy that I am thrilled with 💗

Already I am thinking about the second and secretly hoping for a girl. That’s not to say I wouldn’t be perfectly happy and love another little boy just as much, it would just be different to what I imagined!

I don’t know why MN has to be so judgemental on these types of threads. You’re only human and entitled to feelings too. And saying things about gender stereotypes is a load of rubbish too, my husband can’t wait to take our son to sports and I would love to have a girl I could go on girly weekends with. And if they aren’t into those things when they’re older then that is fine too - it doesn’t mean as humans with emotions too parents aren’t allowed to imagine how things might be and feel sad that they won’t be! And it certainly doesn’t mean that you love your little ones any less 💐

ahunf · 20/10/2022 08:33

A man desperately wanting a daughter is a bit weird. Sons I can imagine. My husband has 2 girls. He does one of the most macho jobs you can thing of surrounded by men. He has 3 brothers. He does ok.

iamnotacatt · 20/10/2022 08:32

HighlandPony · 20/10/2022 01:00

I get you. I’m very much a boy mum. Love being a boy mum, love being a tomboy, love being one of the boys, bored shitless with my sisters. Bored shitless with my 7 lass cousins and do not get my nieces or my great niece. I’m shite with women and fucking terrible with lasses. I had a daughter 13 weeks ago and was devastated. But she’s actually ok. Hoping she grows up mini me and not girly. I get you. I understand the disappointment at not getting what you wanted. I can only tell you that it might be ok, he might be more than you expected in the end

Jesus Christ get a grip. You had a daughter and was devastated? You also sound incredibly sexist.

MsTSwift · 20/10/2022 08:31

Both my sisters are super close to their mothers in law who are fab. They see just as much of them as our family. Have girls but the little lads one of my dds used to hang out with were just adorable

Fedupmum21 · 20/10/2022 08:30

I think it’s normal to feel this way OP as society seems to paint this idea image of “one (or more” of each” as the ideal. I’m currently 24 weeks with my third (very unplanned and a big surprise) baby. I already have two girls, and when I found out I was really hoping for another girl. However when it came down to actually finding out the sex, my last pregnancy was awful (hence not wanting any more as we both almost died) and more than anything I just want to carry a baby to term and to not have IUGR or pre eclampsia.
we did find out the sex, it’s another girl. Although me and DP and happy, even my mum (knows how awful things were last time) was like “oh it’s a shame it’s not a boy”. No- a shame would be if I deliver very prematurely again or get pre eclampsia again that almost kills me and baby. We haven’t announced yet as again we know family will also say what a “shame” it is to have our third girl. Take time to process your feelings but no matter what you will love your baby despite what is, or isn’t, between their legs x