Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'bro, you are never going to have a daughter, ever'

313 replies

thatlabguy · 19/10/2022 23:12

[after the 20 weeks baby scan]

watching my two sons celebrating that they are having another baby brother, their dad, me, a single child who spent the last 25 years dreaming that one day I will have a daughter of my own, has came to a realisation that this dream will stay a dream for the rest of my life.

As a grown up, I understand that I must 'stay strong', 'accept the fact', 'many parents dream to have three boys', 'be happy that the baby boy is healthy', and 'move on with my life'.

On the other hand, I am extremely worried that deep in my mind I will never accept the fact for not having a daughter for the rest of my like, the negative energy of 'dream not come true' accumulates and one day it will explode. Of course, I'd like to prevent it from happening but I have no idea where to start, it'd be lovely to know how parents who have already been through this and successfully moved on! Should I see a psychologist?

OP posts:
Naem · 20/10/2022 10:51

I have to tell you, OP, that when we were clearing out my DMIL's things after she passed, we found a bunch of the most beautiful baby girl dresses. DH was born 12 years after his DB2 and 14 after DB1 and was the only one born in the UK. My best guess is, in the days before scans, DMIL had thought/hoped that DH was a girl!
DH always says though, that because he was very much the youngest of three boys, he was taught things (like how to cook and help in the kitchen) that his brothers weren't (traditional non European family, so boys not expected to do so) - but because there was nobody else, he sort of slotted into that role. And I have observed that so often people who have all of one sex, and then finally have one of the other (and I am thinking about people with four or five at least here), do end up, overtly or covertly, spoiling the youngest, and it is not good for either them or the other siblings. So you might want to think about it as being in fact best for your family, - best for your existing boys and best for the one on the way! That might help you manage the disappointment (which is real, and as people say, you may need time to grieve). But once the latest arrival comes, likely you will be smitten with their own particular personality. I don't think DH ever suffered because it turned out he wasn't a girl.

MalagaNights · 20/10/2022 10:43

Being disappointed with what you've been given in life beyond your control, and ruminating on how you wish it were different, is futile.

You can acknowledge you'd have liked a daughter and that you're sad you won't have one, and decide to embrace the joy in life you do have with 2 sons.

Choose to live a full and happy life despite not getting exactly what you wanted. This is the secret to a happy life.
Despite what we imagine getting what we want isn't the route to happiness.

You can feel sad about this and choose not to let it impact on experiencing the joy of what you do have.

Everyone says you can't change how you feel, but that's not true. You change how you feel by how you see your situation and how you respond to it.

I have 2 grown sons. I'd have liked a daughter. I decided: so I didn't get exactly what I wanted (who does in life?) but what I did get was the most amazing gift ever and I've been thankful every day for it.
It's the only way to live.

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/10/2022 10:38

Isaidnoalready · 19/10/2022 23:16

I know some one who had eight boys in her pursuit of a girl I wpuod be lying if I told you her sons didn't notice

She now has a granddaughter im hoping she is content with that

Get some help if you feel you need it

I knew someone who kept having girls because she was desperate for a boy. She also made no bones about it that she had never wanted girls at all, and preferred boys.

She, too finally got a grandchild of her preferred sex, but it ruined her relationship with her daughters, and her grand-daughters are just part of the woodwork to her. It was very sad.

Whoputtheramintheramalamadingdong · 20/10/2022 10:33

I totally understand and sympathise OP. When I had a girl after having 3 boys I actually shouted "thank God"! as she came out and I saw she didn't have a willy!
I hadn't even realised how much I wanted a girl until that moment - it was a Freudian slip (admittedly there was some relief in the pain being over too 😂).

I think it's just nature for lots of women to imagine they'll have a daughter one say and do all the things with her they themselves enjoyed - obviously life doesn't work that way though, it doesn't mean you love your boys any less.

Kaliflower · 20/10/2022 10:26

Sorry you're feeling this way, it is a real problem. Yes definitely see someone to help work through it.

I have 2 girls and they are stereotypical girly and we do things like face masks, nails, shopping, watching reality crap on tv. Exactly what I'd hoped for when imaging our relationship whilst pregnant with them. One is slightly tom boyish but still enjoys the above. They are very close and I'm so grateful they have that as i was never close with my brother - we had zero similar interests, he loved football/cars etc and i did not!

So i 100% get why you may feel sad if you'd pictured a girl and now have a boy. And i get you aren't saying you don't love him, just recognising you feel the disappointment.

woff45 · 20/10/2022 10:23

There’s also an aspect of feeling gender loneliness in a family. It doesn’t mean you don’t love everyone but if you are the sole woman or man in a large family of the other gender, that surely has effects. A woman, for example, is never going to have a daughter to moan about periods with. A man isn’t going to have a son to teach about chatting up the girls or shaving or whatever. It’s all small fry stuff but the small things matter to people

I moan to my husband and sons about my periods all the time 🤷‍♀️ they're much more sympathetic than my mum because they don't know I'm exaggerating Grin

SnowFir · 20/10/2022 10:19

HighlandPony · 20/10/2022 01:00

I get you. I’m very much a boy mum. Love being a boy mum, love being a tomboy, love being one of the boys, bored shitless with my sisters. Bored shitless with my 7 lass cousins and do not get my nieces or my great niece. I’m shite with women and fucking terrible with lasses. I had a daughter 13 weeks ago and was devastated. But she’s actually ok. Hoping she grows up mini me and not girly. I get you. I understand the disappointment at not getting what you wanted. I can only tell you that it might be ok, he might be more than you expected in the end

I hope your kids have got a role model in their lives who isn't as misogynistic as you are. I dread to think how bad your deleted posts were if this is the one that stayed.

DonnaBanana · 20/10/2022 10:17

Might, yes, but in the main stereotypes are a reflection of the most typical scenario, otherwise the stereotype would be the other thing! A woman in a family with 3 daughters is going to have a different life than one with 3 sons. On average. Yes, there will be the occasional family where all three sons will naturally turn out as gay ballet dancers.

Feeling outnumbered by gender is a real thing and while it shouldn’t factor into people’s decisions and affections, it’s hard to understand unless you’ve been in such a lop sided situation.

SleeplessInEngland · 20/10/2022 10:14

pinkyredrose · 20/10/2022 10:05

Women bore you 'shitless'?🤔

It's a wind-up post.

KimberleyClark · 20/10/2022 10:13

DonnaBanana · 20/10/2022 10:11

There’s also an aspect of feeling gender loneliness in a family. It doesn’t mean you don’t love everyone but if you are the sole woman or man in a large family of the other gender, that surely has effects. A woman, for example, is never going to have a daughter to moan about periods with. A man isn’t going to have a son to teach about chatting up the girls or shaving or whatever. It’s all small fry stuff but the small things matter to people.

But the daughter might not actually want to moan about periods. And the boy might be gay.

DonnaBanana · 20/10/2022 10:11

There’s also an aspect of feeling gender loneliness in a family. It doesn’t mean you don’t love everyone but if you are the sole woman or man in a large family of the other gender, that surely has effects. A woman, for example, is never going to have a daughter to moan about periods with. A man isn’t going to have a son to teach about chatting up the girls or shaving or whatever. It’s all small fry stuff but the small things matter to people.

DarkShade · 20/10/2022 10:09

saraclara · 20/10/2022 09:38

it’s not about pretty dresses and shopping at all

I suppose it’s about a sense of identification

That. All the posts about frilly dresses and stuff are missing the point. I have daughters, they're very different from each other. I have one super sporty 'non-girly' DD, but she's still female, and I 'get her' and identify with her because I'm female too.

I'm sure that it's also fascinating bringing up boys, because their 'other-ness' is also interesting. But I do get fed up of posters assuming that someone wanting a girl is all about dressing them up etc. It really isn't..

I understand what you're saying, and I don't know what it's like to have adult sons yet as my DS is only 3 but - boys don't feel 'other' when they're your own, at least in my experience.

I also prefer the company of other women and feel that I 'get' them more, but my DS is not like any of those adult men that I don't understand, or any of the child boys from when I was at school. He is mine. In fact, he's the only person in the world who I feel that I really do understand, because I have been aware of every litle thing that has happened in his life. I know how he reacts to things, his character, what makes him laugh. When he does or says something that confuses people, I almost always know what he means and why he's saying it. I see me and my DP reflected back in him, he is so like me in his mannerisms and in what he likes to do, and even the things that are different about him I feel that I understand because they're part of him. I'm sure I would feel the same about a girl, but my point is that your own children are yours, and the bond that I feel, and how much I 'get' them, goes far beyond whether we have the same sex.

pinkyredrose · 20/10/2022 10:05

HighlandPony · 20/10/2022 01:00

I get you. I’m very much a boy mum. Love being a boy mum, love being a tomboy, love being one of the boys, bored shitless with my sisters. Bored shitless with my 7 lass cousins and do not get my nieces or my great niece. I’m shite with women and fucking terrible with lasses. I had a daughter 13 weeks ago and was devastated. But she’s actually ok. Hoping she grows up mini me and not girly. I get you. I understand the disappointment at not getting what you wanted. I can only tell you that it might be ok, he might be more than you expected in the end

Women bore you 'shitless'?🤔

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 20/10/2022 10:03

Badbaddogagain · 20/10/2022 09:57

it takes a prick to know one - and I think you may be a prize prick @RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway 😂

Is that the best rebuttal you can make, Bad Dog?

Badbaddogagain · 20/10/2022 09:57

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 20/10/2022 09:47

Cop on OP, you gender addled, heteronormative prick. You're creating a human being, a lifelong commitment and relationship.

It isn't a dulux colour chart.

it takes a prick to know one - and I think you may be a prize prick @RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway 😂

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 20/10/2022 09:47

Cop on OP, you gender addled, heteronormative prick. You're creating a human being, a lifelong commitment and relationship.

It isn't a dulux colour chart.

Cuppasoupmonster · 20/10/2022 09:47

The reasons for gender disappointment often run so much deeper than ‘you just want to buy cute dresses’. I have a 3 year old girl and currently 16 weeks pregnant with DC2 (sex unknown, but should find out in the next day or two!). I had a bit of a ‘fear’ of having a boy, not because of gender stereotypes but because the men in my family are very difficult characters (alcoholics, abusive etc) who I have struggled to get along with over the years. I reasoned that if I had a DS he would have half my DH’s genes and I would be thrilled to have a son like DH, so I was fine once I worked through those feelings. But I wish people on here wouldn’t be so dismissive.

NoHeavenNoMore · 20/10/2022 09:40

walkersareback · 19/10/2022 23:33

I am one of six, five girls and one boy - I am the oldest - I witnessed many many years of disappointment from my parents after the birth of yet another girl - any idea what that does to your self esteem?

I accept that they were also victims of societal pressure - Indian family - but I still find it hard to be warm towards my parents on my fifties- I love them but it was hard seeing tears, anger and disappointment each time a beautiful new sister was born. The pressures on my poor brother - the youngest - were/are so immense.

I am sorry but I find these kind of thread's depressing- love your kids and be grateful to have them - regardless of sex.

I agree wholeheartedly with this. I am one of three girls and it was obvious that my father only ever wanted a son. He'd roll his eyes at all things to do with being a girl. Never really spent that much time with us. Openly told people, in front of us, that he'd love a son to play football with and take fishing. Never offered to do those things with us.
It was hard growing up knowing I was a disappointment and it's one of the reasons I have very sporadic contact with him now.

saraclara · 20/10/2022 09:38

it’s not about pretty dresses and shopping at all

I suppose it’s about a sense of identification

That. All the posts about frilly dresses and stuff are missing the point. I have daughters, they're very different from each other. I have one super sporty 'non-girly' DD, but she's still female, and I 'get her' and identify with her because I'm female too.

I'm sure that it's also fascinating bringing up boys, because their 'other-ness' is also interesting. But I do get fed up of posters assuming that someone wanting a girl is all about dressing them up etc. It really isn't..

teathyme · 20/10/2022 09:36

I think it's OK to grieve about the things you wanted but are never going to have. I find that as my dc with disabilities gets older, it hurts me more rather than "being happy in Holland" (if you know you know). Counselling is probably a wise step.

DeanVillage · 20/10/2022 09:29

Yeah I think a few counselling sessions would be a good idea OP. I mean this kindly, but it's probably best overall that it turned out this way, as you seem to have unrealistic expectations surrounding what having a daughter would be like (something to unpack in your therapy) and no real living daughter would ever be able to live up to that.

At least your son has no expectations placed upon him and can therefore grow up to be his own person. Flowers

SinisterBumFacedCat · 20/10/2022 09:29

I always just assumed I’d have a girl, I think because I had a close relationship growing up with my DM. By the time I was pregnant I didn’t care either way, ttc for 18 months I was just relieved. He is hilarious, we have the closest bond. Sex really doesn’t determine the personality. He also has a close bond with MIL, and would not consider her to be “other grandma” as another poster said.

NCforthisoneo · 20/10/2022 09:29

I think a strong desire for a daughter can sometimes be rooted in a subconscious desire to reparent yourself, by doing all the things for your daughter that you wished someone had done for you. But you don’t need a daughter in order to do this- you can just do it, for yourself.

Seeing a psychotherapist might be a good idea, especially one specialising in birth and family dynamics.

WarblingEttie · 20/10/2022 09:28

Just the one post from OP?

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 20/10/2022 09:26

Isaidnoalready · 19/10/2022 23:16

I know some one who had eight boys in her pursuit of a girl I wpuod be lying if I told you her sons didn't notice

She now has a granddaughter im hoping she is content with that

Get some help if you feel you need it

I know someone who had a stillborn girl, then 6 boys and finally a girl.

She anticipated ringlets and dolls houses. She
got a rugby mad tomboy who plays for her country.

As someone else said, there’s not a desire for one sex or the other without a ton of sexist stereotypes.