Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'bro, you are never going to have a daughter, ever'

313 replies

thatlabguy · 19/10/2022 23:12

[after the 20 weeks baby scan]

watching my two sons celebrating that they are having another baby brother, their dad, me, a single child who spent the last 25 years dreaming that one day I will have a daughter of my own, has came to a realisation that this dream will stay a dream for the rest of my life.

As a grown up, I understand that I must 'stay strong', 'accept the fact', 'many parents dream to have three boys', 'be happy that the baby boy is healthy', and 'move on with my life'.

On the other hand, I am extremely worried that deep in my mind I will never accept the fact for not having a daughter for the rest of my like, the negative energy of 'dream not come true' accumulates and one day it will explode. Of course, I'd like to prevent it from happening but I have no idea where to start, it'd be lovely to know how parents who have already been through this and successfully moved on! Should I see a psychologist?

OP posts:
Prettydress · 21/10/2022 23:37

AloysiusBear · 19/10/2022 23:31

A lot of the stereotype things i expected from my relationship with my daughter i get from my son.

A huge amount is driven by the personality of the child, not their sex.

Absolutely this.

Okaaaay · 21/10/2022 22:48

I don’t think feeling what you feel is shameful or wrong at all (I strongly believe any feeling is valid). It’s how you act on it - that’s where damage / repair is done. See a therapist, work it through, love your sons. It’s hard, be gentle with yourself but firm in that there is a need to address this and not bury it (or keep having babies to try and sort it that way) to

Bugbabe1970 · 21/10/2022 22:22

minipie · 19/10/2022 23:39

Ask yourself why you so want a daughter.

There isn’t an answer that isn’t rooted in sexist stereotypes IMO. Realising this may help you.

Insulting to the OP and does not validate her more than acceptable reaction to having another boy

Overnightoats1 · 21/10/2022 22:17

Three boys here.. both my husband and I would have loved a girl but it wasn't meant to be and 3 kids is definitely enough for us... I definitely grieved a bit after finding out is was another boy but once no 3 arrived all those feelings went away and it was brilliant- A 3rd child is like dessert - we've all just enjoyed our 3rd course so much.. he just fits in and is easy going.. I hope you get to enjoy yours as much as we all do!! The boys are (mostly) brilliant together and are always full of cuddles.. haha- I do look at families with girls sitting quietly and colouring in restaurants and then look at mine wanting to run and play the minute the food is finished and definitely think some stereotypes are true!

Annierob · 21/10/2022 22:07

I always wanted one daughter when I was younger but I had three sons. Of course I wanted a daughter but think it was more for the idea of having a close female to go shopping with not because I didn’t want baby sons.
Honestly, it worked out well as my three sons are amazing and I do not look back and wish I had had a daughter.
Be honest with yourself and allow yourself to feel sad but enjoy your little boys.

Catlover1705 · 21/10/2022 21:34

My children are grown up and it really does happen so quickly. I had same sex children and now same sex grandchildren. Your family will expand and it will even itself out, just enjoy every moment.

PrincessSpanky · 21/10/2022 21:07

My MIL was pining for a wee girl all her life and hoped for a girl when we had our boys. It would be nice having a girl, but I am done. No more here and it really does not bother me that I won't have one. I hope to be a good MIL to DIL's one day.

We didn't know the sex of either until birth.

Againstmachine · 21/10/2022 21:00

'bro, you are never going to have a daughter, ever

Do people actually talk like this, if anyone called me bro, fam or any of that crap I would shut that crap down.

HereForTheCommentsB · 21/10/2022 20:59

Standonamountain · 21/10/2022 19:07

I find it really difficult to understand this.

Gender disappointment always seems to be women wanting girls, never the other way round.

What exactly is it that people believe a girl will bring them that a boy won't? Every possible reason is nothing more than a stereotype.

It's a man wanting a daughter. OP is the Dad.

I also know lots of Dad's who wanted boys.

Standonamountain · 21/10/2022 20:18

But my point is that having a daughter doesn't guarantee so called girly time.

If she wasn't girly and all you imagined then would you still be disappointed.

I'm not being unkind but it seems to be only based on stereotypes of what people believe a daughter will be like.

If a man came on here saying he wanted a son to go to the footy with, but his first pint and help with the DIY I bet he'd be ripped to shreds and rightly so.

BoyMumandSMum · 21/10/2022 20:12

Standonamountain · 21/10/2022 19:21

It's all bullshit about a daughter being a daughter for life and 'girly' days.

What exactly is a girly day? I'm a woman and I'm not sure I've ever had a girly day in my life.

My husband loves his mum and dad to bits and so do most of the men I know.

You are one woman. Hundreds of thousands of women would know exactly what is meant by a girly day. OP is looking for a little comfort to know that his feelings are normal. Just because its something you haven't experienced, doesn't make OP, PP or mine any less valid. There is a difference between a difference of opinion and basically telling someone else they are being ridiculous. In a world where you can be anything, be kind.

Bakingcupcake · 21/10/2022 20:08

Totally get this, I never wanted boys and have 2 healthy girls, but I never found out gender during either pregnancy and either I had of as the anxiety and worry about gender disappointment was soooo real. Its awful to think you don't want a certain gender but deep down you literally cannot help how you feel. I'd love a third but again would want a girl!!!

Duchesscheshire · 21/10/2022 19:30

Oh is eldest of 5 boys. Mil always wanted a girl. First 2 grandchildren were boys. My first a boy..when I told her about my 2nd boy she actually.cried. granddaughter eventually came along. Once she could walk...mil not really interested. Never really interested in her own sons not interested in grandchildren.cauaws
heartache over the years. I however adore my.lads despite hoping for a girl initially. I am youngest of 6. 5 girls 1 x boy. As others have said the characters make up for it. Best of luck x

Standonamountain · 21/10/2022 19:21

It's all bullshit about a daughter being a daughter for life and 'girly' days.

What exactly is a girly day? I'm a woman and I'm not sure I've ever had a girly day in my life.

My husband loves his mum and dad to bits and so do most of the men I know.

wellstopdoingitthen · 21/10/2022 19:13

I had 1 ds (who i nearly lost in infancy) when I fell pregnant with my second child. We went to the first scan hoping it would be a girl. Unfortunately the scan showed the baby had a life limiting condition & the baby wasn't viable. I had a termination.
I had given up having another child, it took another 5 years but I then had another ds. We would have loved a little girl & often daydreamed about what we would have named her.
However I love being a boy mum, I honestly am happy with my son's & have a wonderful relationship with my eldest ds girlfriend who calls me her second mum.

PeachyPeachTrees · 21/10/2022 19:11

Emotionalsupportviper · 20/10/2022 11:49

I agree - what's wrong with a man wanting a girl? And I see loads of dads round here taking their kids to school, and you can see the pride nd protectiveness for their girls.

Plus, even in these enlightened times daughters tend to have a closer relationship with their parents than sons do - the old adage, "A son is a son till he gets a wife, but a daughter's a daughter he whole of her life" still largely applies.

I hate that BS about daughter for life and sons just piss off and join their new family. It's 2022 and this is not the case anymore. These outdated views are why some people gloat about having daughters and others 'grieve' for the daughters they dreamed for and never got.

Standonamountain · 21/10/2022 19:07

I find it really difficult to understand this.

Gender disappointment always seems to be women wanting girls, never the other way round.

What exactly is it that people believe a girl will bring them that a boy won't? Every possible reason is nothing more than a stereotype.

BoyMumandSMum · 21/10/2022 19:06

I have 2 sons and a stepson. My DH has just had the snip. I am in the process of grieving. We are semi comfortable financially and a fourth would have changed that, would have meant a 7 seater instead of a normal car, we're both getting on a bit etc etc. We didn't want another, it made sense all around for us not to have another. But I still feel a sense of grief that I will never have a daughter. Doesn't make me love all the boys any less. Would just be nice to have a girly day every now and again. Years of perfecting every braiding technique under the sun goes wasted on 3 football obsessed boys though! You don't need counselling OP, just a little time xxx

Mumkins42 · 21/10/2022 19:02

It's human and absolutely ok to feel some grief over something that means so much. I agree with looking at the deeper reasons why. I also agree that I see it's more about the personality than sex. I see some with daughter's and don't envy that dynamic at all. It all depends on so many things.

I see that I have a different closeness and bond to my mum than my brother does. I also see women are often more available and supportive in general as adults than the males. But these are just small examples in my own life and these are the reasons that I often wished for a sister. I still think about that now. Regarding my closeness with my mum;I have a completely difficult approach to life and personality in general than my brother. I believe that is a huge reason behind this.

I think it could be really something to learn more about your feelings and explore it all with a counsellor. I love counselling. It has been such a revelation to me.

NoClueForAName · 21/10/2022 18:46

I have three boys. When I found out the third was a boy honestly I cried on and off for a good few days I had always wanted a girl.

But ultimately I had a third because I wanted a baby, not because I wanted a girl. And you get what you get.

Now my youngest is 7 and I adore him (and his brothers!) and can’t imagine them being any different. They’ll all fab. They adore me - there’s something special about mums and boys I think.

So whilst I’ll always be a tiny bit sad not to have a daughter, it’s genuinely ok and I’d not change what I have for the world.

Incognitomum11 · 21/10/2022 18:27

This actually gets to me because I have three children and my youngest is a girl and virtually everyone I meet assume I was carrying on until I got my girl but nothing could be further from the truth…
j was so upset when I found out because I had assumed I’d have three boys and I felt horribly sad for her future growing up in the sexist world.
I love her massively and always did but peoples stupid unfounded assumptions annoy the heck out of me

Macaronichee · 21/10/2022 18:16

I feel so lucky to have three boys, especially having had a late miscarriage. You have a blessing, not a disappointment. Maybe it is understandable to have a moment of regret for the road not travelled but don’t wallow in self pity. How many childless women would love to be you?

petterflies · 21/10/2022 18:11

I’m a boy mum and don’t wish for a girl. If a girl came along, this would be just as wonderful as a boy because all children are special 🥰

miltonj · 21/10/2022 17:29

@AlwaysUphill
I understand what you mean. But I don't expect my children to have to same temperament and personality as me. Not do I think they will experience life the same as I have. But I disagree... i would say there most definitely is a female and a male experience of life! And I can try to help them navigate that, wether they are similar to me or not.

AlwaysUphill · 21/10/2022 17:17

miltonj · 21/10/2022 16:43

I get you.

I wanted girls and I got them. Its valid. It's not about shopping and dresses etc. It's about identification. I know the female experience and I can guide my girls through that. Teach them how to be strong, capable women. I can think about my experience of being a teenage girl and understand how to be there for them etc.
I've never been a boy! I'm sure I'd obviously adapt to being a mum of boys but to me, it seems like a different job. And the responsibility of raising a good man seems too much pressure to me.

But there will be other women out there who are way better for the job than me, so I'm not saying it's better to have girls, I'm just saying I understand why people have a preference and it's unhelpful to say it's superficial and simply about nail appointments and pink things!

Your daughters experience of being a teen girl may be nothing like yours though.

We have a son and daughter. Their experience has been nothing like ours because they’re very different kids to what we both were. There is no one ‘female experience’ or ‘male experience’. That’s just stereotypes.