Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to raise girls with high self esteem

85 replies

ChangePlease · 19/10/2022 20:44

Following from another thread where poor OPs teenage daughter has been taken in by a total loser/user

I ended up in situations like this myself when younger and still really struggle with knowing what good boundaries look like, standing up for myself, saying no and disagreeing with others

How do you prevent this passing on to your girls?

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 20/10/2022 00:05

@toulet I was probably answering more the bit you had highlighted from a previous poster. I’m really not out to disagree with you, just adding my opinion

To sum up my full position on this…(which may be different than others opinions, and that’s ok)

If a good healthy male role model is available then it is an important factor. If the is an unhealthy male role model then the mothers actions will be far more important. If both the mother and father are unhealthy role models, then hopefully the daughters are either predisposed to confidence and self worth or they can find those role models elsewhere.

Sparklythings1 · 20/10/2022 00:04

Just commenting so I can come back to read the comments, would love to know. I feel like it’s the opposite of what I had. I was and am very much loved by my parents but due to their own insecurities they just never said it. I don’t think they’ve still ever said it. It sounds stupid when they have done so much for me but I feel like all it would have taken would have been for them to say they loved me and to say how proud they were of me when I did things. Instead I did really well at a lot of things (couldn’t have been better behaved, won awards at school, graduated uni twice etc) but either my dad would be busy that day so he didn’t come or would come but would always try to twist things into a joke or sarcasm so he didn’t have to ever go ‘wow, you did great there btw’. That would have meant so much.

UWhatNow · 19/10/2022 23:58

“…a father that spends time with them doing stuff, hiking, cycling, games etc”

Only if his dds want to do that outdoorsy stuff. I think men who only spend time with their DC doing the hobbies that they enjoy are selfish wankers tbh.

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:56

@saltinesandcoffeecups imo it's good to see a healthy relationship & a father figure that respects their partner & pulls his weight with housework/childcare etc. I think it's important, I never said it was the most important though did i?

UWhatNow · 19/10/2022 23:55

echt · 19/10/2022 20:59

I'd say the role of the father is important here. The example he sets of how he treats his wife, speaks of women, treats his children, how he works both in and out of the home.

This ^

It’s all about the role models they have and the male one is extremely important. My dds have robust self esteem because their father has taken an active and affirming (non judgemental) role in every step of their development. They’re young adults now and it’s wonderful to see.

Threelittlelambs · 19/10/2022 23:48

I teach them to say what they want. How to say no.

Even basics … fancy a film Friday, you can say no I won’t mind. Very simple.

Ask them what they think of things in the world … how did that make you feel, what can you do now.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/10/2022 23:45

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:28

@saltinesandcoffeecups what point are you trying to make? The fact your mum divorced your shit dad has no bearing on my upbringing or experiences.

I just don’t know that the dad’s role is the most important thing in raising confident daughters. I think the mother’s example is far more important

Gruffling · 19/10/2022 23:32

Great thread. At the moment I'm working really hard on not apologizing or justifying when my 3 year old makes statements that are honest but rude. She is 3, she doesn't understand social etiquette and has no ill intentions.

sorcerersapprentice · 19/10/2022 23:28

Teach them to stand up for themselves, to not ruminate over things that have gone wrong or personality differences with other people. Bounce back from set backs. Resilience is really important to establish early on so they can deal with any future set backs.

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:28

@saltinesandcoffeecups what point are you trying to make? The fact your mum divorced your shit dad has no bearing on my upbringing or experiences.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/10/2022 23:23

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:10

I'd say the role of the father is important here.

I agree with this. I saw how my dad treated my mum so assumed it was normal so inadvertently have high standards. Also was encouraged by both parents to try everything & that nothing was out of reach.

Eh my dad was shit to my mum but she divorced him. That was a big thing in the early 80’s. That was a very early lesson for me about self worth. She was also not shy about telling us girls as she was doing the bills and making life work to make sure we were never dependent on anyone.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/10/2022 23:21

For the little ones;

-First things first… don’t indoctrinate them in selfless #bekind movement.

-It’s ok to not want share everything and all the time
-It’s ok to not like everyone
-it’s ok to disagree- you won’t always get your way and that’s ok too
-It’s ok to stand up for themselves- again you won’t always get your way and that’s ok too
-Don’t rush to solve problems…9/10 times kids will sort out their challenges if given the chance

For the middle kids
-Let them try things - One of the best things I saw on a news show about confidence in kids was a mother who would have her 7-9yo kid ask random people what time it was. She would clearly be watching, but she said she wanted her kids to have practice dealing with people they didn’t know. She would also send them to the counter to pay for things, and do other kinds of normal interactions all while she was around. This was after I grew up, but I realized that this was the kind of stuff my mum did with me.
-Praise them for standing up for themselves
-Advocate for themselves… again with people like teachers and scout leaders and other adults… I mean don’t abdicate responsibility for them but if they are having a low stakes problem let them try the first whack at solving it. Talk through what worked and didn’t work as they attempted to solve their problem.
-Increase the challenges push them to go outside of their comfort zone in tasks and learning
-Don’t rush to solve problems

Teens-
-Lot’s of talking… Even if you are just commenting on a news story out loud to yourself. They are listening
-Don’t rush to solve problems… by this point they should be able to sort all of the day to day stuff and begin to know how they want to approach the bigger stuff. Let them tell you what they are going to do and when they need your help. Again…use common sense here.

Did you pick up on the big theme. You can still be very close and active while giving your daughters room to grow and experience things. Hate to state the obvious, but confidence comes from experience and usually lessons learned from failure.

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:18

My childhood wasn't perfect though, far from it & I witnessed lots of things. However I think some adversity teaches resilience.

I was also taught treat others as you would like to be treated & look at both sides of the coin.

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:12

6. Never start something but if someone brings it to you, always finish it.

Far more important to read the situation & act accordingly.

grayhairdontcare · 19/10/2022 23:11

I have 2 adult DDs and they have not had any self esteem problems.
I have brought them up to be confident, independent individuals.
They take no shit but don't start any either.

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:11

my mum was also very independent

toulet · 19/10/2022 23:10

I'd say the role of the father is important here.

I agree with this. I saw how my dad treated my mum so assumed it was normal so inadvertently have high standards. Also was encouraged by both parents to try everything & that nothing was out of reach.

Sittingonabench · 19/10/2022 23:03

some of it may be modelling but I think the real learning curve is having your self esteem impacted, recognising it and saying no more. That makes you look inward rather than outward. It’s not something that you can do for your kids though - they have to find the right time and strength themselves but maybe telling them a story of when it happened to you to prepare them may be helpful.

tsmainsqueeze · 19/10/2022 23:02

BecauseICan22 · 19/10/2022 21:06

Mamma to 3 daughters here. 15, 10 and 9. I myself had the most awful and abusive childhood.

These are the key messages I've given them and will continue to do so:

  1. ADVOCATE for yourself, because if you don't, no one will. Eventually even I won't be here so learn how to respectfully but firmly state your needs.
My favourite quote for them is, 'be exactly who you want to be because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind'.
  1. You never have to feel shame for anything.
If you know you are a good person and you are not going out of your way to harm another, don't feel she and don't allow anyone to shame you. We are an Indian family and my oldest daughter is openly gay, my middle daughter is open about her autism and my youngest daughter is her sisters' biggest advocate. My point is, some people will always try to manipulate you and tear you down, own who you are with dignity and fire, it keeps your power with you as opposed to handing it to another.
  1. Always ask questions. If something doesn't feel good or right, it probably isn't. Question it.
  1. Don't just give, remember a relationship regardless of context is a two way street, you need nurturing too.
  1. Stand your ground, even with those in authority. Be respectful while doing so, but stand your ground.
  1. Never start something but if someone brings it to you, always finish it.
  1. Consent is a thing, for you and the other person. Keep that at the forefront at all times.
  1. Remember, you matter just as much as the next person. You can and should have 2 default expectations in all your interactions - respect and kindness.

They are all pretty awesome young girls. Their self worth is not hinged on their appearance, I've kept them away from social media (youngest 2 are too young anyway but my eldest has no interest in any social media at all) and I've always, always had open dialogues with them. Our rule has been, don't Google anything. Come to me and ask and I will tell you the truth. My then 11 year olds first question after starting secondary school was 'what is porn and what are prostitutes?' I told her the truth but within that spoke about consent, drugs and do many other things.

Talk, talk, talk to them.

What fantastic advise , your girls are extremely lucky with you behind them.
I have a girl with 2 older brothers and a good dad , thankfully she has only seen respectful behavior from them and also has 2 good uncles in her life.
I am a feminist and have always told her she can be who /what she wants to be in life.
She does cringe a bit and tells me to shut up but i do talk about relationships and what aspects she should never tolerate, she is quite sensible and even though i have let these kinds of topics seep into conversations since she became more aware i am conscious not to brain wash her , she is her own person and hopefully will become a good judge of character ,she also knows kindness and good manners go along way.
Also she knows i will answer truthfully any questions she may ask me.
She knows i will not tolerate toxic people in my /our families lives and how doing that makes life easier in general.
I also make it known she has a voice and a right to speak out as long as she is polite - just because someone has more authority does not mean they are right my sons were taught the same thing too.

HundredMilesAnHour · 19/10/2022 23:02

It helps massively if you have strong female role models.

I come from a line of strong women on my mother's side. They were poor but ambitious and driven and by God you wouldn't mess with any of them. So being a strong woman is how I was raised. The same goes for my female cousins. To the extent that where I grew up (my mother's family dates back in the area until the 17th century), it's commonly known that you don't mess with the FamilyName women. Looking back to previous generations, they were ahead of their time and I'm proud of what they achieved, very much in the face of adversity and massive sexism.

Of course the downside is that a strong woman often attracts either 1)men who want her to be their mother or 2)men who want to beat her down because they get off on the challenge. So it's so important to learn and maintain strong boundaries.

georgarina · 19/10/2022 22:49

HighlandPony · 19/10/2022 22:38

Raise them with brothers/massive amount of male cousins/women who don’t think like women

aye aye I’m going to be skated for that but it’s true. Women and especially teenage girls are the pits. There’s too much focus on looks and fashion and celebrities etc to have any self esteem unless you can emulate a Kardashian or the cast of love fucking island.

What??? The fact that you have the nerve to say 'it's true'...what you've said is beyond fucking stupid and is just internalised misogyny. You're lumping half of the world's population together and saying they're all obsessed with the Kardashians and Love Island. Have a word with yourself.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 19/10/2022 22:48

From day one give them body autonomy so that when it comes to it there are no inhibitions to overcome to say 'I don't want that' so from brushing their hair for them, to putting on suncream I always say, I want to do that is that OK? Not ok... It doesn't happen. This means they expect their choices to be respected. If they meet someone who doesn't it makes it more likely it will strike an off note and they'll reject it.
They don't rule the house it is just their body their say.
I drip feed the concept all the time, 'don't want to finish your dinner, fine, have you done your best and you're just full, then listen to your body, if it wants to stop, stop.'
Trust your instincts and you say what happens to you. That's the consistent message.
I think it makes it less likely they will question themselves if they aren't comfortable.
Both my kids are expected to respect each others boundaries too. Zero tolerance for failing to listen. Being heard and having your say is their normal.

HPandTheNeverEndingBedtime · 19/10/2022 22:47

For my DD girls rugby made a huge difference, it changed for from a young preteen that was self conscious about her body, she has always towered above her peers and looked older than she is. Verbally she never wanted to 'take up space' trying to shrink and would never voice an opinion. Playing rugby has meant that she has embraced the strengths of her body and is regularly commended on her strength as the 'powerhouse of the scrum'. Shes used to shouting across a rugby pitch now and happily talks in public and during school presentations etc.

Shes only just developing romantic relationships but I hope her new confidence in herself, her body and her worth transfers over to this part of her life too.

Watchthesunrise · 19/10/2022 22:46

I've also mentioned a few times that "I chose Daddy to be your father because he's Kind Energetic and Smart". It gives them a hint about what they should do too, without it being a lecture.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 19/10/2022 22:44

HighlandPony · 19/10/2022 22:38

Raise them with brothers/massive amount of male cousins/women who don’t think like women

aye aye I’m going to be skated for that but it’s true. Women and especially teenage girls are the pits. There’s too much focus on looks and fashion and celebrities etc to have any self esteem unless you can emulate a Kardashian or the cast of love fucking island.

Far from slating you, I completely agree with you. Men are so much simpler, especially in the teenage years!

Swipe left for the next trending thread