Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely jealous of mum and daughter?

187 replies

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

OP posts:
georgarina · 19/10/2022 21:25

Maybe suggest something fun you two can do together. Watch a film, go to a museum, go shopping. Something fun where you don't necessarily have to talk and can just enjoy the activity.

You don't have to be exactly like that mum to spend quality time with your DD, but maybe that's what your subconscious was telling you when you saw them together.

Motnight · 19/10/2022 21:24

onlywishfulthinking · 19/10/2022 21:07

My mum is 70+, I was very tired after work but went to the pet shop with her and convinced her to buy a squeaking cat toy for her kitten. On the 30 min drive home that bloody cat toy (unreachable on the car seat in the back) squeaked every time a went over a bump or put on the brakes. At first I was sooo annoyed, but then my mum started to giggle and in the end we both had a proper belly laugh every time that stupid toy squeaked! Tears were running down our faces.

And she texted me tonight saying her cat could not be less interested in that toy.. It’s not just about having things in common, just spend unperfect time together and the perfect moments will turn up sooner or later..

I love this! Relationship goal for me!

Op hope you are finding this thread useful.

FreudayNight · 19/10/2022 21:24

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 19/10/2022 20:25

I doubt very much that they get on that well ALL the time. You are seeing a public snapshot.

You are not a failure, Flowers but is there some reason why you never have laughs and giggles and fun with your daughter? Were you starved of it as a child? Did you have strict/uptight not-very-affectionate parents?

Of course they don’t get in that well all the time, but OP is very clearly saying she wants some of that. And I think that she is prepared to make changes to make those type of connections with her DD. (And why not, I love the sound of my kids belly laughing.)

I agree that it could be a useful emotion, but OP just needs to practice laughing, doing things which bring joy, and fun.
There is a book called Playful Parenting that OP might find useful. I remember one section where the author describes a game of playing football with Jelly Legs. Could you do that OP? Or sing along to the radio in a humorous way? Or tell a joke you heard?

DillDanding · 19/10/2022 21:24

Comparison is the thief of joy.

I can see it's easy to become a dull parent. It's not too late to change. You need to take an interest in her interests and don't always be the sensible one.

Revolvingwhore · 19/10/2022 21:23

Anniefrenchfry · 19/10/2022 21:15

Are you ok? This isn’t a normal or health reaction to seeing a loving parent child relationship.

It's not normal to talk so loudly and make sure everybody can see your display of love. Who are these people trying to convince?

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 19/10/2022 21:22

Aim to get to know your daughter... the truth is that you have to put a lot of effort in to build a bond and attachment.

It wont magic itself there .

I adore time spent with my teenagers we watch films , eat out together, and cry and laugh together.

But I have put ib an awful lot of work and time to foster those relationships.

BleuNoir · 19/10/2022 21:21

What a sad post OP. It's OK to be jealous. It sounds like it's not your fault in that you're working full-time and an elderly mum not well. That's a lot on your plate.

You've got quite a mountain to climb. I'd be honest with her and tell her how you feel. Tell her what you saw in the restaurant and that you wish you could be close like that. Perhaps your daughter thought you were too busy for her. And maybe you were but it's not your fault, life is just shit at times.

But be honest with her TALK TO HER and be vulnerable. Tell her you feel like a shit mum. Just tell her the truth. She might break down and cry and say Mum I always wanted you there but you weren't and I don't know how to talk to you anymore. I would think she feels the same way. Just try and start to talk. Someone has to be vulnerable. Even if it leads nowhere at least she'll know you tried and you care.

Do you tell her you love her? Every day? And you must have areas of overlap? Is there anyway you could reduce down by one day? To spend more time with her before and after school? You could go out for a meal, know more about what makes her tick?

Revolvingwhore · 19/10/2022 21:21

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 19/10/2022 21:13

Ugh. This is such an MN type thing to say. Drag others down to where you are to make yourself feel better 🙄

Is it really so hard to appreciate that some people are genuinely happy and don’t see the need to hide their happiness in public, so as to not offend the perpetually miserable? I love seeing people having fun together, it’s heartwarming.

Your thought process is utterly toxic.

There is nothing heartwarming about someone talking increasingly loudly incase someone 50 feet haven't heard them. Toxic? Don't be so ridiculous.

magma32 · 19/10/2022 21:19

My mum is like this, doesn’t help she was brought up in a very different culture so there have been clashes but the interest just isn’t there from her as she’s busy with her own stuff, cooking cleaning and doing the social visits to relatives and community which is normal for women of her background so I don’t take it too personally but she does have toxic behaviours which I do blame her for. Anyway I’m the opposite with my kids, I have boundaries but we have fun but I’ve always loved kids and animals maybe I compensated because I felt unloved myself, my 12 yo son and I sound more like that woman and her daughter tbh but it’s because I’ve spent the time with him, something his dad hasn’t done from a young age but now my son is older and more interesting for him he does make an effort which my da doesn’t mind so it’s getting better with him now so maybe your relationship is more like my Dh and my ds, it’s definitely salvageable you just need to make the effort, better late than never.

how about you ask her if she wants to go on holiday, let her pick and make an itinerary together, just one to one (without your husband) and have fun. Spend money and don’t worry about anything. Sometimes a change of scene helps and also try to break the cycle of her reliance on friends, nothing wrong with that but you need to claw her back abit subtley for that quality time. Also, what is her relationship like with her dad like?

momonpurpose · 19/10/2022 21:19

My daughter is 12. Very different interests.She loves Japanese Anime. We have made a game into her picking a series and watch it together. Oddly enough I've enjoyed some of them. Also cooking and baking are fun and bonding maybe try something like that? I think the fact that you wrote this post shows you love your girl and want to be closer

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 19/10/2022 21:19

You sound like you've given up on your relationship already. Your daughter is bloody 11 fgs.

You're the adult here. Find some common ground.

My dd is nearly 14 now, but we've always hopped the train into town for some lunch.

We enjoy musicals and go to the theatre.

I ask her to play some of her music she likes just so I know what she's into. Not my cup of tea, but come Xmas and bday, I will look for merch from a group/singer she likes.

I always have a little chat with her at bedtime. She cba when she gets in from school so I leave her to chill for a bit, but we do always chat at her bedtime.

She shares a lot with me, friend fallouts, funny things that have happened.

And we have the same sense of humour so we do laugh a lot.

It's down to you to fix this. Put some effort in instead of thinking it is a fait accompli

Squeezita · 19/10/2022 21:19

I wouldn’t let it dishearten you.

My mum speaks another language, knows nothing about my career or friends. We don’t have that much to talk about in terms of politics, fashion etc.

However, we’ve just been on a video call for the past 3 hours, barely talking, just doing our thing, watching TV, having dinner etc. Just hearing her pottering about makes me happy 🥰

StarDolphins · 19/10/2022 21:18

Sorry, I just re-read & your DD is 11! Don’t think she wants to be playing ‘boo’🤣

could it be just that she’s growing up & is more reserved? I’m expecting my DD to be like this somewhat when she’s 11 & the other 11 year olds I know aren’t doing what you saw in the cafe.

Darbs76 · 19/10/2022 21:15

ittakes2 · 19/10/2022 21:06

I have started going on short break holidays with my teen daughter or overnight hotel stays with spa. Worth considering if you want to be more relaxed with her.

My 14yr old DD likes this. We both like the theatre and sometimes I treat us to a night in London even though we are only 30 mins away. My DD is very shy, and a quiet child. Sometimes getting her to talk can be difficult. I find when we’ve had time away from laptop / home she does open up more. I do have to ask questions, she then seems to be more chatty for a little while after. Then she generally retreats back into herself. My eldest son (29) I’m very close to and we can chat for 6 months and never run out of things to say. It can be hard at times but this is just her personality.

Anniefrenchfry · 19/10/2022 21:15

Revolvingwhore · 19/10/2022 20:58

Sounds more like "look at me parenting" more like. There was a dad with his daughter in the pub the other week making such a fuss of having 'daddy daughter time' it was vomit inducing.

Are you ok? This isn’t a normal or health reaction to seeing a loving parent child relationship.

CoveredInSnow · 19/10/2022 21:14

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum

Well, at least you’ve identified the problem - now you need to do something about it.

I’d say my childhood experience sounds very similar to your daughter’s in terms of mother/daughter relationships. I don’t have much of a relationship with her now, many decades on, so perhaps that’s a bit of a warning that things don’t automatically improve later on.

StarDolphins · 19/10/2022 21:14

I am more like the lady in the cafe with my DD (she’s only 6 though) constant silly games initiated by both of us & I do joke with her a lot so now she gets the jokes she jokes back.

Could you try slowly introducing stufff like this? Examples are, making up funny rhymes about funny things you/her have done, we play the clapping ‘a sailor went to sea’ but I always add something else in, if there’s anything to decide then I say ‘let’s Rock Paper Scissors for it’. We’re always jumping out saying ‘boo’ I’ll get her to do gymnastics competition where I’m the commentator & I introduce in different accents etc that she loves, these types of things we do daily.

also, asking her questions & bring excited, I will say ‘what was lunch, let me see if I can guess in 3 chances’ or who was student of the day today, what was your fave game today?

just remember though, she absolutely loves her Mum!

Lonecatwithkitten · 19/10/2022 21:14

Not everyone is a belly laugh person - I am not I don't think I have ever really laughed. I am a measured person who never lets go in public.
But my daughter and I have an amazingly close relationship (she is 18). We spend time walking, talking, looking at things. We chat at the table when eating out.
Don't judge your relationship with your daughter by how other people behave.

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 19/10/2022 21:13

Revolvingwhore · 19/10/2022 20:58

Sounds more like "look at me parenting" more like. There was a dad with his daughter in the pub the other week making such a fuss of having 'daddy daughter time' it was vomit inducing.

Ugh. This is such an MN type thing to say. Drag others down to where you are to make yourself feel better 🙄

Is it really so hard to appreciate that some people are genuinely happy and don’t see the need to hide their happiness in public, so as to not offend the perpetually miserable? I love seeing people having fun together, it’s heartwarming.

Your thought process is utterly toxic.

TootMootZoot · 19/10/2022 21:13

I've always laughed a lot with my Mum and I now laugh with my daughters (and my sons). My husband doesn't very much but that his personality.

I think some people just have a more playful nature, it doesn't mean they are better or worse than the next person though. I've always been able to have playful fun with my kids so it not surprising we get on well now they are older.
We actively play games. Lots of board games and lots of video games. This weekend three of my adult kids are coming to stay and we will spend most the time playing things like Mario Party and similar and also playing board games. It's relaxed and we chat and play. It's not very worthy but it's how we like to hang out.
We also share a similar taste in tv comedy. Things like Father Ted or Toast.

I'd try a few things like that. I wouldn't suddenly start trying to do 'silly dances' that sounds hideously cringeworthy if it's not your thing!

If none of this works then I wouldn't worry too much. As your daughter gets older then you will probably have more to chat about. I always think short little positive interactions are the way to go. So, maybe, a quick trip to an icecream palour works better than a whole day going shopping.

Illumicrateme · 19/10/2022 21:12

That sounds awfully sad for you both. Could you perhaps start a regular mother and daughter date day maybe once or twice a month just for the pair of you. Go to the cinema, coffee shops, lunch somewhere and take a game to play (maybe something small like dobble). I often pretend to be interested in the stuff my daughter likes just for her sake. Naturally we don't share interests as she is 6 but it doesn't take too much effort to learn about what she likes.

MargotChateau · 19/10/2022 21:12

@Hugasauras i just bought the book you recommended thank you! My mother was/is a bit of a ‘tiger mother’, and pushed me very hard academically, which I’m glad of, but I’d like to develop a more loving and warm relationship with my unborn child than the often frosty one I had with mine. Thanks for the tip.

@mswales lovely and compassionate advice. It’s never to late to make changes, and it’s always good to acknowledge and own mistakes to your children.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 19/10/2022 21:11

Humour may be that Mum and DDs strength; you and your DD will have your own bond in a different area. Both equally special and unique. Think about it.

onlywishfulthinking · 19/10/2022 21:11

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 19/10/2022 20:58

I asked this. OP seems reluctant to answer.

Just another fake post, there have been lots lately..?

MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 19/10/2022 21:10

I think some of you are being a bit harsh here. OP was asking for advice, she knows there is a problem, she doesn’t know what to do about it and criticisms aren’t helping are they?

OP not everything has to be hilarious but it does sound like you are missing some common ground. A shared love of The Simpsons or Marvel films would be a great conversation starter. Maybe go and get your nails done together and just have a chat, it might lead to an impromptu giggle.

My daughter and I love to sing so we used to go on drives, wind the windows down and sing “Let it go” etc at the top of our voices. It’s good to be silly every now and then. We also love to critique films, and tv programmes and say what we think would improve them, recast them etc. My DD is a bit of a dork though. Maybe your daughter is a bit more serious in character and wouldn’t welcome you being silly or belly laughs. You can still be close and love each other, perhaps read the same series of YA books and go from there?

x

Swipe left for the next trending thread