Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely jealous of mum and daughter?

187 replies

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Treesandsheepeverywhere · 19/10/2022 22:55

Start small OP, rock, paper, scissors randomly for example.
When watching a film, ask her questions about the characters ie, what she thinks about a character's dress, job etc. This will make her open up and not so daunting as she wouldn't be talking about herself, but give you an idea of what she likes.
When at the park, challenge her to jump to touch a tree brunch that isn't too high and praise her in disbelief that's she's so strong/sporty/strong etc.
Play games where you can let her win from time to time to build her confidence.
My dad was playful when we were kids and still is at 81. Mum on the other hand never really involved herself much and as grown ups, never knew how to be around her.
Luckily your daughter is young and still at an age where you can start and it would seem like that's how it's always been.
Good luck.

pitterypattery00 · 19/10/2022 22:53

Only a few select people can make me belly laugh, and my mum isn't one of them! We get on well but she is a relatively serious person. Nothing wrong with that, everyone's personality is different. Maybe there's an activity you can share together - a sport, craft project....?

Lampzade · 19/10/2022 22:50

Flittingaboutagain · 19/10/2022 20:43

I don't know why people feel the need to put others down to lift OP up. Absolutely no reason to doubt this mother and daughter have a lovely fun relationship.

Exactly
I really dislike when posters do that.
That mother and daughter have a similar relationship to the one I have with my girls.
I play rock, paper scissors and staring competitions with my two dds and they are teenagers.

Xmasbaby11 · 19/10/2022 22:46

I think it's important to find common ground or interest to help you bond and enjoy each other's company. I'm lucky my daughters enjoy drawing and so do I, so we often draw together in a cafe or at home. However, my DD 10 is heavily into Roblox and that is a struggle to talk about as I don't understand it!

Maybe you're not interested in animals but can show an interest, try to understand her passion. Even watching silly animal YouTube videos together. As pp have said, if it's important to her, it will make a big difference that she can talk about it.

Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 19/10/2022 22:42

Every mother daughter relationship is different. My mum is different with me than how she is with my sister, not in a bad way just different. I’ve belly laughed with my daughter who’s is 10 many times, we’ve also had heated arguments because of her tiny tantrums. She’s super girly, I’m a tomboy.. we are very different but we do have common interests, doesn’t mean I love her any less. You do what’s right or feels right for you and your dd. Don’t try to build of a relationship you’ve seen because behind the scenes could be totally different.

oakleaffy · 19/10/2022 22:41

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:25

No, sadly never. I've laughed don't get me wrong but more a 'oh don't be so silly' and we move on.

Does your Daughter never make you laugh?
I used to love it when son made me laugh ..He still can make me laugh, of course, but no longer is at home {Adult} It is a lovely feeling just letting go and laughing.
{At home, so no one need see or hear}
It's usually something silly that triggers it, and the story gets built upon so I am breathless with laughter.
Often you need the same type of humour.

I rarely laugh like this with anyone else, apart from one friend I've known many years.

Do you laugh 'Freely' with anyone else?

breathcalmly · 19/10/2022 22:40

I’ve never really enjoyed playing with my 4 kids as like you I work, am tired, have other stresses and household jobs but we do enjoy baking together which has a purpose and a nice outcome or going for a walk or bike ride as less intense than face to face. It’s not common for an adult to be playing thumb ear etc for anymore than a few minutes without getting bored senseless

MytummydontjigglejiggleItfolds · 19/10/2022 22:35

I'm sure it was a wonderful scene to witness, but it's a tiny sliver of a whole.
Don't get caught up in the idea of a manic pixie dream Mum.
Being a constant and being dependable and reliable are wonderful attributes too, especially in a Mum.

CJsGoldfish · 19/10/2022 22:35

My now 20-year old has loved rap music for years and years. I could not care less for Dave, Kanye or whoever. I hate the music. But I let him ramble on, have driven him and friends to concerts and made sure to find out when drops for clothing and shoes etc are and have bought as surprises over the years for Christmas etc. And still now, he comes home and shows me clips or whatever on his mobile that he likes. Because he thinks I care. I don’t, but I care about him. A lot
This made me laugh because I can totally relate.

OP, there is a lot of really good advice on this thread. Don't be disheartened.. you CAN make changes. Pick a little thing that you are comfortable with and start from there.
I also love that, unlike some other weird poster, you did not attempt to tear down this mother but looked at the situation reflectively. I used to go out for dinner with my youngest dd regularly. Sometimes it took a bit of persistence to get to the topic/theme/idea that got the convo rolling but you have that between you, you just have to find it.

NotJustAnybody · 19/10/2022 22:25

I grew up with an ultra strict DF and a really soft DM. I loved and respected them equally but I really wished there was a middle ground. I compartmentalised them, which carried on into later life. I was determined I would be much more fluid with my own child. I'm a single Mum so I have no choice now!
I love how I can cry laughing with my DS, it's special. There's always the repeats too - remember that time ......
It will take time, but gradually introduce fun activities where you can't help but laugh. If she see's the 'lighter' side of you, she may relax more around you, which is a great springboard into opening up more as she grows up.

Cordeliathecat · 19/10/2022 22:22

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 19/10/2022 22:09

Definitely time to fake it til you make it. Don't aim for day one belly laughs. Aim for day one the first small step. Try a new thing together is a great suggestion, as is showing an interest in her likes. Don't block off a big chunk of time and feel awkward that you don't know how to fill it. Start with a simple game or chat ideally while you are doing something else if you drive in the car is perfect. If you feel funny/silly is too far out of your comfort zone go for a word game or try to think of something you could tell your daughter that will surprise her and say the strangest/bravest/silliest thing I ever did was X and then ask her what hers is. When I'm getting little fed back I throw in a silly question. E.g. Me - How was school? DS - fine. Me - Was the Maths test today hard? DS - yeah Me -Are you still reading X in English? DS - yeah. Me - Did any giant purple elephants come into science and trample on the experiments? DS - what? No of course not but Billy Jones did try to set fire to his tie in the Bunsen burner and Helen Brown screamed because there was a huge spider on the wall.
I then tell the best school science story from my school days and bingo we are talking rather than holding an interrogation.

This has reminded me. When they were very little and the answer to every questions was “fine” or “good” I was told to ask more gossipy type questions. Such as “who was the naughtiest in class today” or “what was disgusting at lunch today” or “tell me a drama that happened today and I’ll tell you mine”. It gets them to start ranting and open up a bit more. I still use it now they are teens/pre-teens when they are being quiet.

Concernednan456 · 19/10/2022 22:20

I had a very easy , very fun relationship with my first child. I was a young mum and still had a lot of childlike energy . We’d fool around and sing songs and were a bit like friends in her teen years. This was generally a really healthy relationship as I still maintained certain boundaries and rules and kept her safe and on the right path in life but I do feel sometimes I parented to what came easy and natural to me and perhaps could have done with being a bit more of a grown up. We had a few hiccups where I had to step up and be really firm and give tough love and it was so difficult because she had grown to see me as an equal . By and large we got away with it and she grew to be a lovely confident young women. Many years later ( and I mean an unusually big gap) I had another child whom is deferent and introverted and complicated to me and we don’t share many interests . He much prefers his fathers company and I just seem to do the boring bits. It’s equal in love but less so in friendship to his sister, we both enjoy cooking though and bond over that . Could it be that one or both of you are introverts and you perhaps need to look at connecting in a different way? Introverts are often very creative , enjoy crafts and intellectual hobbies. should you be wandering through a gallery together? or working on a project of some sort , an opportunity to chat and bond while busy? It might be a bit of ‘fake till you make it’ and if all she wants to talk about or do is ponies then you need to try and get involved with that . Then perhaps introduce something more to your taste once you’re in the habit of doing stuff together .

Pikafuckingwho · 19/10/2022 22:19

I have two dd’s one I’m very close too, but we like all the same things and sometimes I have a feeling I’ve kind of moulded her that way. We do belly laugh together, but as she is getting older I can feel her pulling away slightly the more time she wants to spend with her friends.

The older one has asd, her likes are very rigid and she likes to spend a lot of time alone. However, whatever she is interested in, doesn’t matter how much I dislike it, I learn about it and then research ways we can do something related to it together. When she was little this was easier, she was into owls, I took her to an owl sanctuary despite being shit scared of birds etc. now she is older, it’s stuff like cosplay, obviously I won’t dress up as no one wants to see that, but I help her navigate these conventions etc.

I think you just need to show more interest.

CheeryCupcake · 19/10/2022 22:18

I agree with a PP, I think saying you have no style is an invitation to go shopping with her - why not go on a shopping trip and let her pick you out a new outfit? Maybe even let her give you a makeover. You could have a lot of fun together that way.

Applesonthelawn · 19/10/2022 22:14

I think some things are habit. You can get in the habit of having fun with her. Not expensively or anything that requires great planning, just the odd five minutes snatched here and there at unexpected moments in the day. It would require conscious effort at first. But you can be that mum.

Mariposista · 19/10/2022 22:13

You can turn this around OP. You sounds like a great mum, because you actually care so much! Plan a fun day or even weekend, just you and your DD. Get your nails done, go shopping (let her show you what's 'cool - even if it really isn't), go to the cinema, leave your phones in your bags (preferably switched off), forget about work and friends for a bit and just connect. Or have a pizza night in just you and her (let her pick the film). Or bake a cake together, or get her to teach you something that she knows how to do. Plenty of ideas. You will be fine, it sounds like you have all had too many other priorities recently and just need to get back on track. She is still only 11, nowhere near an independent teenager yet, this can be sorted.

onlywishfulthinking · 19/10/2022 22:11

My now 20-year old has loved rap music for years and years. I could not care less for Dave, Kanye or whoever. I hate the music. But I let him ramble on, have driven him and friends to concerts and made sure to find out when drops for clothing and shoes etc are and have bought as surprises over the years for Christmas etc. And still now, he comes home and shows me clips or whatever on his mobile that he likes. Because he thinks I care. I don’t, but I care about him. A lot.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 19/10/2022 22:09

Definitely time to fake it til you make it. Don't aim for day one belly laughs. Aim for day one the first small step. Try a new thing together is a great suggestion, as is showing an interest in her likes. Don't block off a big chunk of time and feel awkward that you don't know how to fill it. Start with a simple game or chat ideally while you are doing something else if you drive in the car is perfect. If you feel funny/silly is too far out of your comfort zone go for a word game or try to think of something you could tell your daughter that will surprise her and say the strangest/bravest/silliest thing I ever did was X and then ask her what hers is. When I'm getting little fed back I throw in a silly question. E.g. Me - How was school? DS - fine. Me - Was the Maths test today hard? DS - yeah Me -Are you still reading X in English? DS - yeah. Me - Did any giant purple elephants come into science and trample on the experiments? DS - what? No of course not but Billy Jones did try to set fire to his tie in the Bunsen burner and Helen Brown screamed because there was a huge spider on the wall.
I then tell the best school science story from my school days and bingo we are talking rather than holding an interrogation.

Cordeliathecat · 19/10/2022 22:03

Don’t beat yourself up. Just treat it as the universe reminding you to connect with your child. We all need reminders from time to time.

I’m incredibly close with my daughter. She tells me everything and we have long deep and meaningful chats, lots of time together laughing and doing stuff we both enjoy. The flip side is that we take our stresses out on each other and can be vile to each other. There are always 2 sides to every coin.

One of the few rules I have imposed upon my kids (much to their dismay at times) is that when either I or they come in from a long day we have to spend half an hour 1 on 1 time talking about our day. This is every day. Then they are free to be on their phones or whatever. It’s this time when I learn what is making them tick. I also make sure I spend at least an hour or 2 every weekend 1 on 1 doing what they want to do. This is easy with my daughter because we just potter around the shops usually. With my son it means PS4 which I hate but he loves so I suck it up and it ends up being fun because he’s so happy.

There are my couple of tips. Hope it helps x

Dweetfidilove · 19/10/2022 22:01

Please try OP. At 11, there's still time to develop a relationship. It may even be urgent now before she hits those rough teenage years.

Find something you like about her or take an interest in one of her activities and work from there. Or take some of the ideas from here.

My daughter and I have belly laughs almost anywhere - no performance parenting here.

Her dad on the other hand is generally more serious, but she knows if she wants to ride a roller coaster/zipwire, she defers to him. He also has a magical way of getting her to tell him everything that happens in school. Even though he's serious, she says he just asks the right questions, whereas I don't.

No-one is perfect, but you have to work to your strengths. Now you've acknowledged there's an issue, I hope you can fix it.

WoolyMammoth55 · 19/10/2022 21:58

OP, this sounds like trouble to me:

"I guess we just don't have much in common, I ask her about her friends and she's not very forthcoming. She likes to spend a lot of time at her friends house whose mum is considered 'cool'. Fashion - she says I have no style. Animals - wouldn't really know what to say as I am not in to animals at all. I just don't feel like I know her."

My kids are smaller than yours but I make (have always made) a lot of effort to be involved and interested in things that interest them - DS1 is dinosaur mad and I've shared in that with him, learnt a million dinosaur facts and helped him build and paint the different types - not because it's a shared interest! But because he's my son and I love him and I want to encourage and share his passion.

I think you should be doing this with her - if she loves animals then read books about them together, write stories about them with her - as the parent you're meant to adapt to your kids interests, not vice versa.

If she says you have no style then why don't you put her in charge just for fun, go shopping together and you try on anything she suggests?

I think you're being hard on yourself in your original post - no parent is perfect - but I do think you need to give your DD some of your love, warmth, attention and time while she's still young enough to receive it. If you go on like this for many more years then the situation will become unfixable.

Best of luck x

LochNessMagician · 19/10/2022 21:55

OP you say you feel like a failure but you most definitely are not. Please be kind to yourself and see if you can do things to reduce the stress you are under. Working full time, parenting, running a house and looking after an elderly parent is a lot for anyone. No wonder you are not feeling like being silly or finding much fun in situations. Stress zaps the life out of you, everything becomes a chore, it doesn’t happen overnight- it sort of creeps up on you and slowly you find that you’ve lost touch with the parts of yourself that you liked and enjoyed. You obviously really care and that is what matters. Others have said it too, but don’t compare yourself to others. I hope you manage to find a way to get help with work or the caring duties you have, then I think you’ll feel happier and lighter and the butterfly effect will kick in and things will get easier with your daughter.

HollyJollypup · 19/10/2022 21:54

If my daughter gets into a new game, I watch her and play it with her so we have something to do together just at home sat down. I do what I can to ‘keep up’ with my daughter and bond with her.

let’s be honest…. I’m not interested in playing Roblox! But my daughter is and that’s what’s important!

PurpleFlower1983 · 19/10/2022 21:54

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:25

No, sadly never. I've laughed don't get me wrong but more a 'oh don't be so silly' and we move on.

That’s really sad 😥

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 19/10/2022 21:54

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:25

No, sadly never. I've laughed don't get me wrong but more a 'oh don't be so silly' and we move on.

What DO you belly laugh at?? Because just incorporate your own sense of humour into your relationship with your daughter. With my DC we are usually teasing my DH, or laughing at funny things that have happened in school that day. Or laughing at the dog, or giggling at the baby. Anything really. There’s always something going on to point out and laugh about.