Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely jealous of mum and daughter?

187 replies

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

OP posts:
bofski14 · 20/10/2022 00:59

Well get on with it then! They only get one childhood!

lunar1 · 20/10/2022 00:52

My mum never knew me at that age, she never seemed to want to. When you've been told to stop being silly often enough for normal childhood behaviour you do stop, and you close yourself off.

You have time to fix things, probably not completely. But you have to show an interest in her and not be dismissive.

I have an amazing relationship with my sons, it does make me sad that my mum never shared interests with me as a child.

While watching midnight to 3 am basketball matches on tv in the holidays might not be my favourite thing, we really do have fun staying up together, raiding the fridge and sitting under blankets on the sofa. Find something your daughter loves.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 20/10/2022 00:52

Laughter is great but loving and being loved is the most important thing. It sounds as if your daughter has that from you.

It is good that the experience in the cafe has made y ou think about adding things to your time with your daughter. Don't let it undermine you though. Parenting is more than play - of course. It is good that your daughter is forming strong friendships and feels confident enough to be out and about.

I have taught teens/tweens for years and noted that other people's parents were always the cool ones and their own were always lacking. It is probably all about forming that independence that will let them grow into adults.

Are you feeling a bit vulnerable at the moment OP? I wondered if you were depressed in reading the cafe situation and your husband's smile as you did.

melchim · 20/10/2022 00:45

onlywishfulthinking · 19/10/2022 21:07

My mum is 70+, I was very tired after work but went to the pet shop with her and convinced her to buy a squeaking cat toy for her kitten. On the 30 min drive home that bloody cat toy (unreachable on the car seat in the back) squeaked every time a went over a bump or put on the brakes. At first I was sooo annoyed, but then my mum started to giggle and in the end we both had a proper belly laugh every time that stupid toy squeaked! Tears were running down our faces.

And she texted me tonight saying her cat could not be less interested in that toy.. It’s not just about having things in common, just spend unperfect time together and the perfect moments will turn up sooner or later..

This is such a sweet story!

DaughterofDawn · 20/10/2022 00:31

Remaker · 20/10/2022 00:27

DH sometimes comments that every time DD16 and I walk into the house together we are always laughing and he wishes he had that relationship with her. But he talks to her about music which she loves and she respects his knowledge. They have a different kind of relationship but it’s still loving.

You say she likes animals, why can’t you make an effort to share that interest? You could volunteer at an animal shelter together or go to a wildlife park. Sometimes with kids you have to put your own preference aside for a bit and get involved in their lives. Believe me listening to DD wax lyrical about the Billie Eilish concert at 1am was not that fun for me - I just wanted to go to bed! But it mattered to her. It’s about making moments of connection.

This kind of reminds me of when I met my husband. We both love video games but enjoyed completely different genres initially. He really liked zombie shoot ‘em up games. I had zero interest in zombies but he really wanted me to play Zoe in left 4 dead so his friends could meet me. He took interest in my favourite game even though I knew he didn’t like it so I decided to suck it up and entertain him for a bit. It actually was how I got into zombie games and shows. Now I really like them and we have a lot of inside jokes that are zombie related. Might be different between a parent and child but you never know until you try right?

Remaker · 20/10/2022 00:27

DH sometimes comments that every time DD16 and I walk into the house together we are always laughing and he wishes he had that relationship with her. But he talks to her about music which she loves and she respects his knowledge. They have a different kind of relationship but it’s still loving.

You say she likes animals, why can’t you make an effort to share that interest? You could volunteer at an animal shelter together or go to a wildlife park. Sometimes with kids you have to put your own preference aside for a bit and get involved in their lives. Believe me listening to DD wax lyrical about the Billie Eilish concert at 1am was not that fun for me - I just wanted to go to bed! But it mattered to her. It’s about making moments of connection.

antelopevalley · 20/10/2022 00:22

I didn't have much of a relationship with my dad at 11, we had nothing to say to each other. Our relationship never improved.
But that was because he showed no interest in me at all.
You have to show interest in your daughter and take the lead. She is the child.

I really think you would benefit from counselling about your own upbringing.

I also think you need to start small. So maybe say to her that she is right you are not any good at choosing clothes so would she help you? And suggest a day shopping where you will buy and wear one top she chooses for you. You can set a budget. If she gives you silly things to try, try them on. And then say how do you think this would look at a parent's evening? Or at work? Or what do you think gran would make of this? Buy say it lightheartedly.
Buy coffee and cake halfway through.

It takes time to build a relationship so it will not happen overnight. But doing activities like going to the cinema and then talking about the film, or watching a film of her choosing at home, all help.

Sparklythings1 · 20/10/2022 00:16

I’m bad for seeing the perfect family when we’re out. Don’t compare. She maybe belly laughs with her child but works 60 hours a week so doesn’t see her the rest of the time. She’s maybe a rubbish cook and cant make what you can. She maybe fell out with her in the car there and was making extra effort because they’d just made up. She maybe lets her do things she shouldn’t. She maybe has less nice things at home than your daughter. The list is endless of comparisons. You only saw a tiny snippet, like a picture on Instagram of someone else’s life. There are so many things that could be better or worse about her life than yours. If you want to laugh more with your little girl, don’t go and sit in silent situations. Go ice skating with her, go to see a funny film, go horse riding, go and volunteer to walk a dog at a local charity. There are so many ways you can spend time together, get to know her better, bond and maybe even laugh too ☺️

DaughterofDawn · 19/10/2022 23:49

I think you are just a different spirit. It doesn’t not mean you can’t be close though. Try to find what you and your daughter have in common and expand on that. I’ve never belly laughed with my mom but those mother daughter outings meant so much to me. I miss them a lot.

RubyJam · 19/10/2022 23:47

onlywishfulthinking · 19/10/2022 21:07

My mum is 70+, I was very tired after work but went to the pet shop with her and convinced her to buy a squeaking cat toy for her kitten. On the 30 min drive home that bloody cat toy (unreachable on the car seat in the back) squeaked every time a went over a bump or put on the brakes. At first I was sooo annoyed, but then my mum started to giggle and in the end we both had a proper belly laugh every time that stupid toy squeaked! Tears were running down our faces.

And she texted me tonight saying her cat could not be less interested in that toy.. It’s not just about having things in common, just spend unperfect time together and the perfect moments will turn up sooner or later..

This is lovely - just spend unperfect time together - the rest becomes perfect …

Moveoverdarlin · 19/10/2022 23:46

I would say that what you saw is a normal interaction between a mother and her daughter. I don’t believe they were putting on a performance as others have suggested. If anything, if they have this much fun in a restaurant playing rock, paper, scissors, think of bedtime and when they play fight and tickle each other or play in a swimming pool.

Notmyusernamex · 19/10/2022 23:39

don't worry honestly. the thing to remember is that relationships change and evolve. What really matters most actually is the relationship you will have with your daughter once she is a mature adult - that is most likely to be the longest and most consistent and stable.

believe me, if you have the same sense of humour at that point you will have 20 or 30 years of belly laughs together. that's much more important than what happens when you are 9 or 10.

Bluebellandpansies · 19/10/2022 23:36

placemarking. I have the same problem OP. 😩Let's do this.

Cookingutensil · 19/10/2022 23:32

JuliaGooliaaa · 19/10/2022 20:26

Jealousy can be such a useful emotion when it shines a light on something we lack/want in our own lives. I’m sure you can find a way to bring more fun into your interactions with your daughter. It doesn’t have to be like the mum in the restaurant, nothing forced, but something you both enjoy

Such a lovely reply, and so true about jealousy, I hadn't thought of it that way. I agree that you need to find common ground with your DD, OP. What is she into that you could genuinely engage in? Could you watch films, read the same books, do a class together, even an online art class or something along those lines. You could learn a language together - infinite possibilities - don't be strangers.

NotJustAnybody · 19/10/2022 23:29

Interesting to know if you sat in silence with your DH or if either of you mentioned the fun that other Mum and DD were having? Does your DH have a 'fun' relationship with your DD or is he serious too? No judgement, just trying to understand better.

I agree with@FindingMeno - I hate that 'I'm a parent, not their friend' talk. It is possible to be both. You need to work hard on building that close relationship. My DS has ASD and the early years were incredibly hard and I had to put in so much effort to take/gain just the smallest of steps. It almost felt like a battle sometimes but I didn't give up and ever think 'this is what it's going to be like forever'. An example, he loved Minecraft but got frustrated as he didn't understand how to do much. He had zero interest in anything else at the time. I learnt how to play and then showed him. We'd spend hours building. I then understood exactly what he was talking about when he'd tell me what he'd been up to. Yes a bit excessive but that's having an ASD child for you. If you don't go out of your way to understand your DC, who else will.

MyHamsterIsSmarterThanMe · 19/10/2022 23:21

Revolvingwhore · 19/10/2022 20:58

Sounds more like "look at me parenting" more like. There was a dad with his daughter in the pub the other week making such a fuss of having 'daddy daughter time' it was vomit inducing.

Who the fuck do you think you are to judge another person's parenting? I hate people who go on about performance parenting or "look at me parenting" just because they do things differently. No parent does anything because they want to make a good impression on you. Literally nobody gives a shit about what you think. Vomit inducing because a dad and daughter are having special time together and feeling happy about it? Gosh you are vile. I genuinely hope you don't have children. You'd only teach them to be jealous and judgemental of people who are not you.

Gronkle · 19/10/2022 23:16

You can change this, start small and work your way up. Schedule time in if needs be, she doesn't need to know it is scheduled if that would make it less strained. Buy a small game or a pack of cards and sit on the sitting room floor, buy a jigsaw and put some music on at the dining table. It doesn't have to be much, 15m slots and build up. Or watch a silly movie and make sure you laugh in all the right places.

It isn't too late, but she'll be a teenager soon, so start now.

Pinkittens · 19/10/2022 23:10

Why not start small and play Rock Paper Scissors with your daughter?

Try to do something every day that makes her smile or laugh. You mentioned animals - my DC love watching cute/funny animal videos.

I think it's sad that you would react smile but in a "don't be so silly" kind of way. Kids are silly. Kids love silly, even the serious ones. There's different types of silly - it doesn't all have to be toilet humour or nothing.

coffeeandbiscuit · 19/10/2022 23:09

I wonder, you say you don't feel you know your daughter, but with all the demands on your time, and the stress you're going through, do you know yourself? Do you know your own enjoyment and activities?

It sounds (and I might be wrong so correct me if I am) as if you feel like you're drowning with all the obligations you're trying to meet, and with no time for yourself to engage in the things you enjoy, it must be hard to engage in the things your daughter enjoys.

Have you always felt disconnected from your daughter? Or is it more recent?

Cantstandbullshit · 19/10/2022 23:09

girlfriend44 · 19/10/2022 20:28

It dosent mean that mum and daughter will have a great bond when the girls older whereas you might.
Shouldn't ever compare .

Why do we feel the need to put others down to make others feel better?

All the “ it’s just a snapshot”. “they are probably not that way behind closed doors”, “they will probably not be that way when they are older” etc is just weird. You can give her advice without the negative putting them down first.

FindingMeno · 19/10/2022 23:04

I laugh and have a lot of fun with my dd's.
I threw the " I'm their parent, not their friend" rulebook out of the window.
Of course, I'm the parent when I need to be, but first and foremost I'm their friend.
It's fine to allow your own inner child to come out and play and be silly.

Drfosters · 19/10/2022 23:00

i am sure you are a great mum and being too hard on yourself but if you want more fun times An easy place to start is is do what we do, buy a wodge of board games/ card games (think uno, articulate etc), take her (and rest of family) to a family pub early afternoon on the weekends and relax and enjoy games for an hour or so. It means the kids aren’t on devices, it encourages us to laugh and get competitive and often sparks other conversations. Getting out the house helps as you aren’t bogged down with chores. It is only a small thing but if you worry you don’t have fun with your daughter and sit in silence it is honestly an easy way to take a small step to get you to spend a relaxed few hours together. I say this as someone who hates board games. Buy games that encourage silly ness so it helps you show your more relaxed side

AlbertaAnnie · 19/10/2022 22:59

I’m sure your daughter loves you very much! If you want to change then start small maybe watch a comedy together or play a board game that gets you both going! Uno? Scrabble? Cludo? Build from there!

sjxoxo · 19/10/2022 22:58

@canwedoittheniceway please find the energy to make the effort to have something in common with your daughter.
my mum never did with me and it’s still crap between us now I’m in my 30s. How can you have nothing to talk about??? You must do!! You say you’re not into animals - get into them. Go to the shelter and volunteer together, or ‘adopt’ an animal through the WWF and learn about it together with your daughter. I wish even now that my mum had made more effort with me and I’m still jealous of other women and their mums doing nice things together. Find something you can do together and go hard at your relationship before she is a teenager… you’ll need all the closeness you can get!!! Also she will need you even more when she’s a teen. Don’t make her feel you can’t be arsed with her. That’s a bit the impression I get from your post tbh… your relationship with your daughter is surely important enough that you can go all out on making an effort. Good luck xx

oakleaffy · 19/10/2022 22:55

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

@canwedoittheniceway As a child, my 'Ideal' family was one half a mile away that had a really lovely ''Sensible'' mum.
I never heard her laugh much, but she was a good provider of simple home made food and the atmosphere in their house was slightly scruffy and 'Bohemian'..they had a stables and animals..I loved it there so much.
You probably have strengths that your Daughter loves, I do wonder of mothers and sons laugh more, maybe boys are 'Sillier'...But don't do yourself down!

Years later, one of the children in that 'Idyllic' family had a serious nervous breakdown.
The family was not all 'Golden' as it seemed to me at the time, from a child's viewpoint.