Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely jealous of mum and daughter?

187 replies

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SnackSizeRaisin · 20/10/2022 21:25

definitelynotlistening · 19/10/2022 21:48

You really don't know the full story. I know a mum who belly laughs all the time. She has 'so much fun' with her kids when they do go out. Yet she works long hours, the kids are always on tech in the house, they hardly interact day-to-day. Even at the weekends they are all at activities. It's great when they do enjoy family time, but it is so rare.
The mum/daughter you saw might go home and have a huge argument. Or the mum may have been jealous of you and your dh. Or 100s of other things.

That might be true but how does that improve the op's situation? Anyway there are loads of loving mums so it's just as likely the OP saw one of those as one who only puts it on in a restaurant.

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/10/2022 21:07

Notmyusernamex · 19/10/2022 23:39

don't worry honestly. the thing to remember is that relationships change and evolve. What really matters most actually is the relationship you will have with your daughter once she is a mature adult - that is most likely to be the longest and most consistent and stable.

believe me, if you have the same sense of humour at that point you will have 20 or 30 years of belly laughs together. that's much more important than what happens when you are 9 or 10.

But if the op has nothing to say to her daughter now they are not going to have a relationship when she is grown up. The OP is quite right to be concerned and to try to improve things now. It's not about having the same sense of humour. It's about being interested in what the other has to say and enjoying each others company.

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/10/2022 20:57

At first when I read the op I thought "how sad and awful to be like that with your own daughter" but actually my dad was like that with me. Nothing much to say to each other. Awkward silence. He did love me though, just didn't know how to interact. Tried too hard and made it weird if anything.
Children want their parents to be interested in them and their feelings and opinions. I think you need to work on finding what she likes talking about. Most children don't like being quizzed about their friends or what they have done at school but they do like to air their opinions and have them treated as important.
Other things that might break the ice are buying her a small treat you know she'll like, paying a compliment, asking for her help with planning or problem solving. Basically treat her as though you are interested in her as a person. Don't be too full on though, and don't try to be funny if it's not you.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/10/2022 20:52

OP hasn't been back so I doubt how much good all this advice is doing.

Teenytinyfeet · 20/10/2022 20:31

5128gap · 19/10/2022 21:09

If its any consolation OP, there's no way I'd have been sitting in a restaurant being daft with my 11 year olds and finding it fun and hilarious. It's not my humour and it's not me.
However, DC are now 20s/30 and we laugh till we cry together. We share a particular type of humour, that we find with each other and very few people outside of that.
My point, you are who you are, and who you are will gel and resonate more with your DD at some life stages than others, and with some activities more than others.
Laughing with an 11 year old is lovely, but its a tiny snapshot of parenting and you will have your strengths too.
Don't try to be something you're not. Be your authentic self and be open, and you'll connect with your DD in your own way.

This!!

YourSpleenIsDamp · 20/10/2022 12:12

lollipoprainbow · 19/10/2022 21:40

My lovely dd 10 has ASD and I feel awful seeing other mums and daughters having lovely times. She's so angry and anxious all the time and we never really get that mum and daughter pleasant time.

I just wanted to say it might not always be this way - mine was similar and there was so much conflict and ordinary chats would often result in chaos with both of us upset. She's now 14, and we get on brilliantly. My absolute favourite bit of the day is when I put her to bed; we have the best chats and cuddles, talking about her day/my day/ silly stuff/ serious stuff, sometimes it gets really late and we have to make ourselves stop wittering! When she was younger and full of anxiety and stress we just didn't have that, and I used to get so upset about our relationship (not in front of her!). Hang in there, things can get better xxxx

Putonyourshoes · 20/10/2022 12:08

I think the idea of a Yes day as suggested by a previous poster would be brilliant for getting involved with some of your daughter’s interests.
Does your daughter enjoy reading and writing? You could make a game with questionnaires about one another. Later on have a quiz and try to recall each other’s answers, the winner gets a prize like picking the film you watch or what’s for tea.
Don’t be too hard on yourself OP, life gets in the way sometimes. What’s important is that you’ve realised there’s some distance between you and your daughter, you can fix that now.

Jerabilis · 20/10/2022 12:00

OP you’ve identified something about yourself that you’d like to change to be more open with you’re daughter. That’s a great first step. You’ve also clearly reflected on your interactions with your daughter.

you don’t need to change 100% overnight. Just try and be more open to looking for opportunities. So in an example you gave rather than going with “stop being so silly” try and look for something that carries on the joke.

small changes easily start to add up.

Pugalicious · 20/10/2022 11:54

Like I said, we are not all the same

Anniefrenchfry · 20/10/2022 11:51

Pugalicious · 20/10/2022 11:49

Do not feel bad because you saw someone else laughing. Not everyone behaves like that. My daughter is 30 and we are very close. We speak and see each other most days. We spend time together because we want to but we don't always laugh like this !
Most of the time when we laugh it is at at the antics of my grandson.
We are not all the same🙂

Did you not even bother to read her posts? It’s not just the laughing, she says if they go out, she sits in silence, that she feels she doesn’t know her, bizarrely that they have nothing in common. It’s not about laughing, it’s much more than that.

Pugalicious · 20/10/2022 11:49

Do not feel bad because you saw someone else laughing. Not everyone behaves like that. My daughter is 30 and we are very close. We speak and see each other most days. We spend time together because we want to but we don't always laugh like this !
Most of the time when we laugh it is at at the antics of my grandson.
We are not all the same🙂

mamabear715 · 20/10/2022 11:43

I'm always giggling / belly laughing with my kids. BUT - I didn't used to. I changed, over the years, & became calmer & didn't worry about every little thing. Do you think that might be it, @canwedoittheniceway ? Stress takes over..

kateandme · 20/10/2022 11:29

Redkettle · 20/10/2022 07:33

Aw. I didn't belly laugh with my mum as a kid but as adults now we do. Sometimes she giggles so much I cry with laughter . You saw only a snapshot. I often saw photos of my friend doing stuff with her kids like skiing and sports with her son and thought I should be doing that with mine, but I also know of the difficult relationship they have and its not all sweetness and light.
I read a book when mine were little on how to enjoy your kids . Smell their hair, touch of their hand, be in the moment with them. Not thinking of anything other than their presence. Helped me chill out with them a lot

My mum still does this now and it’s one of the best feelings even 30 years later.that touch.that shoulder rub as she walks by for no reason.special greeting as I walk in.a note left in the fridge on my water bottle when she’s left.
mand every time used to be her tapping the sofa beside her.coke watch,cuddle,sit etc.I could say no every single time.walk out.god it was awful of me and I hate not accepting.but every single time she would ask again.
you do seem a little more down on yourself op. And a bit afraid to make a fool of yourself.that’s one thing g you need to get passed to get this going with her.she won’t care but you need to be able to be silly and act a fool.

tiggergoesbounce · 20/10/2022 11:25

We used to belly laugh with my mum as we do with our DS. Of course its not constant but ita often, if we are being silly or just someone does something that set us off. Its a beautiful thing, so of course people have those relationships.

OP i think if you are jelous of others having that relationship, work on the one you have with your DD and see if you can find ways of having fun together.
On the flip side some people are just not wired up to be fun, but im sure even your trying will be appreciated if thats the relationship you want.

antelopevalley · 20/10/2022 10:35

Anniefrenchfry · 20/10/2022 07:00

There is also a flip side, and it’s those posters who say oh I’m sure you’re a great mum,to a woman who has just written she sits in silence if she goes out with her daughter, says she’s nothing in common with her, feels she doesn’t know her, has never once belly laughed with her, can’t even imagine sitting laughing with her or playing games, and The child prefers to spend her time away from her parents

no it’s not great. Why would anyone say it is. It doesn’t help the op or her child at all. And if you read the op carefully. She’s not asking how to fix this. She’s not asking how that will impact her child. Or even trying to understand how that must feel to a child.

the op has had plenty of advice to help fix this and there is still time, but that’s not advice she asked for. Nor is it advice she’s responded and said she will try

she is more focused on her own feelings and if her husband thinks badly of her.

I really hope she makes an effort to try to get to know her own child. There is nothing better in the world than a good mother daughter relationship and it’s worth every moment of effort required.

I totally agree with this. And I hadn't noticed, but you are right she has not asked for advice about how to fix it or thought about how her daughter feels.
I remember when my kids were small talking to another woman with three young children who said she knew how to feed and clean her kids, but after that she was stuck. She didn't know how to play with them or even talk to them beyond telling them things.
I think this can be as a result of a neglectful childhood.

DozyFox · 20/10/2022 10:21

You sound a lot like my MIL. She's very well-loved by all her children, children's partners, and grandchildren.

Everyone is different, and that's fine! Making people laugh isn't the only or most important way to value someone.

happygertie · 20/10/2022 10:19

@Redkettle hi OP, can I ask, do you tell each other you love them? Are you tactile with each other? The reason I ask is how you described you and your daughters relationship reminded me of my old best friend from school. Her and her mum didn't laugh or have fun, there was no shared interests or fun activities together. My friend spent a lot of time at my house, and she loved how fun and warm my mum was.

My friend would beam ear to ear if she got a hug off my mum, me or my sisters and she ended becoming an honorary family member.
Looking back as an adult now, I think her mum resented my family as we shone a light on her relationship with her daughter, and was allowed round to the house for sleep overs less and less.

Is there anyway you can talk you your daughter about something fun she would like to do? Maybe if you have bedtime cuddles together, just drop into the chat that you want to do something fun with her and what would she like to do? You could even start with something easy like a cinema trip to see a film she would like ? Or bake together ?

Redkettle · 20/10/2022 07:33

Aw. I didn't belly laugh with my mum as a kid but as adults now we do. Sometimes she giggles so much I cry with laughter . You saw only a snapshot. I often saw photos of my friend doing stuff with her kids like skiing and sports with her son and thought I should be doing that with mine, but I also know of the difficult relationship they have and its not all sweetness and light.
I read a book when mine were little on how to enjoy your kids . Smell their hair, touch of their hand, be in the moment with them. Not thinking of anything other than their presence. Helped me chill out with them a lot

Anniefrenchfry · 20/10/2022 07:00

Cantstandbullshit · 19/10/2022 23:09

Why do we feel the need to put others down to make others feel better?

All the “ it’s just a snapshot”. “they are probably not that way behind closed doors”, “they will probably not be that way when they are older” etc is just weird. You can give her advice without the negative putting them down first.

There is also a flip side, and it’s those posters who say oh I’m sure you’re a great mum,to a woman who has just written she sits in silence if she goes out with her daughter, says she’s nothing in common with her, feels she doesn’t know her, has never once belly laughed with her, can’t even imagine sitting laughing with her or playing games, and The child prefers to spend her time away from her parents

no it’s not great. Why would anyone say it is. It doesn’t help the op or her child at all. And if you read the op carefully. She’s not asking how to fix this. She’s not asking how that will impact her child. Or even trying to understand how that must feel to a child.

the op has had plenty of advice to help fix this and there is still time, but that’s not advice she asked for. Nor is it advice she’s responded and said she will try

she is more focused on her own feelings and if her husband thinks badly of her.

I really hope she makes an effort to try to get to know her own child. There is nothing better in the world than a good mother daughter relationship and it’s worth every moment of effort required.

AutumnLeafInTheSpring · 20/10/2022 02:23

@canwedoittheniceway , my mom and I had a terribly strained relationship for most of my teen and adult life. I became an addict, my mom has serious passive aggressive and poor me issues .. we fought constantly. However, my mom realized that she didn't want me to cut her out of my life entirely and so she started working on herself and reaching out to me more. I got sober, have kids, a husband, and we currently live with my mom while we sort out moving to a different state. Yeah, my mom n I fight, but we have also had a lot of belly laugh moments too... something I can honestly say I don't think ever happened before.
I feel like my mom decided she wanted more laughter and happy memories/moments in her life, so she opened herself up to them a bit more. Which helped inspire me to do the same with my two young children by letting them "help" me cook meals and wash dishes when they want to, letting them make much bigger messes thar I will have to clean up but laughing with them while they do it. Now mom n I are still stressed up to our eyeballs, but I feel like the additional laughter kinda helps me manage the burden a bit better.
My advice is to talk to your daughter, talk to your husband, be honest about how you feel you are drifting apart from your daughter and that you want to reconnect. I know that's difficult to do, but I promise you can develop that type of relationship with your daughter and if you start it now, you can have it forever. Just remember that you aren't trying to he her friend, but rather a fun mom to be around. Take interest in things she likes - like, have her do your makeup or take you window shopping for new clothes, take her to a petting zoo or a visitation farm (if y'all have things like that across the pond, lol), etc. She can teach you about the things she likes and you can make it fun by "letting down your hair" and loosening up a bit. One big thing is, don't worry about looking the fool. Yea, it can really suck getting embarrassed, but to have those close moments with your daughter, you have to basically block out everyone else around you outside of your group, you have to act silly, even a bit childish. It'll take time working up to the same level you saw that mom and daughter at in the restaurant, but you can achieve it if you put in the work to reach it with your daughter.

*so my original wording was makeover, but some things can be a lot longer lived than others, like a haircut lol. If you want to have it be a fun full on makeover, buy super cheap wigs that you both put on and style/cut. If you are feeling particularly brave (and can afford it), then let your daughter pick out one outfit for you that you'll buy (after trying it on in the dressing room). Your daughter is still young enough that reaching a strong connection like that is absolutely possible.
Good luck and sending lots of love to you and yours.

Sunnytwobridges · 20/10/2022 02:08

I totally understand OP. I was the same with my dd. I tried a few times to take her out to eat when she was younger and we never had anything to talk about. We basically ate in silence. I also would be sad to see other mothers with their kids laughing and talking. It never really changed, but I found we do better making a meal at home/getting take out and finding something fun to watch on tv and we will talk about that. At least I feel we connect that way most of the time.

Wiccan · 20/10/2022 01:19

canwedoittheniceway · 19/10/2022 20:19

I am a mum to a daughter who is 11. I was at a restaurant today with my husband for lunch (my daughter was at her friends house).

In the booth opposite us was a mum and daughter, the daughter must have been around 9/10/11. I couldn't tell. It was definitely mum and daughter as I heard the girl call her 'mum'.

They were having so much fun, they were playing rock, paper, scissors, shoot, they were doing staring contests and thumb wars. The little girl was belly laughing with her mum, they were both properly belly laughing.

I felt so much sadness and jealousy in that moment I can't even explain. I love my daughter but we have never shared moments like that, I don't think we've ever belly laughed together. When I've tried to do days out or meals out we just sit in silence, we don't have much to talk about and I suppose she thinks I'm a boring mum.

I couldn't imagine sitting in a restaurant with my daughter and being relaxed enough to play games and be silly but I so badly want to. I've became the serious and not fun mum, I think my daughter wouldn't even know how to interact with me if I suddenly acted like that.

Even my husband looked at them a few times and smiled and it just makes me think he probably would have preferred to have had a child with a mother like that.

I just feel like a failure and to be honest, totally jealous although that's awful to admit.

AIBU?

Some kids are just that ! My daughter was like that . Everything she needed and wanted from us on her and our terms , never enough on her terms . She is now 35 and I am battered by her wants and demands .some kids are fucking horrible no matter what you do as parents so even if you have the" family on the next table " your family won't work out as you want . Don't be so hard on yourself .

Mamai90 · 20/10/2022 01:19

Reading your post I realised I didn't properly belly laugh with my own mum as a child. But she was a wonderful loving mother, she still is. I see her several times a week, we go for lunch and coffee regularly. I adore her and love her company. We are totally different in personality, and that's OK. I'm more like my dad. I've always felt loved and cherished and I think overall that's more important than belly laughs (but we do sometimes have them now) but our sense of humour is just different.

Isthisreasonable · 20/10/2022 01:14

Perhaps she was a single parent. The bond can be much closer if it's just the two of them living together.

deeperthanallroses · 20/10/2022 01:06

Go shopping with her and get you a top she likes? Play which would you rather with animals - whcih would you rather have as a pet, a ferret ora mongoose? The other person answers and says why and asks theirs. Other versions are different questions, basically anything so if I’m still going on the animal theme, which would you rather meet in the jungle , a cobra or a rattlesnake?
etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread