Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pensions to rise with inflation - but what about working people???

592 replies

doris9034 · 19/10/2022 15:57

BBC Website: "Liz Truss and Chancellor Jeremy Hunt jointly agreed to guarantee that the state pension rises with inflation next year - thereby maintaining the "triple lock" - ahead of PMQs this morning, Downing Street says.
In a huddle with reporters after PMQs, the prime minister's official spokesman said the decision reflected the "unique position" of pensioners who are "unable to increase their earnings through work"

But I - and millions of others - are also unable to "increase our earnings through work" because we are in the middle income bracket, our employers do not have the capacity to raise our earnings in line with inflation and we don't qualify for any state related benefits.

So, whilst I 100% don't begrudge the helping of pensioners (many of whom are probably among the better off anyway), I can't help but feeling a bit annoyed that it always seems to be the ordinary working person / family that never gets any respite from the ever increasing cost of living.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 19:59

Octomore · 20/10/2022 18:24

I consider paying half a century of tax to be neither lucky or unlucky. It normal, it doesn't make someone special.

Did anyone say it did?

There’s been a suggestion that pensions should be means tested @Faciadipasta.

It’s not my maths that’s “wacky” @Badbadbunny.

Faciadipasta · 20/10/2022 19:27

What’s wrong is to suggest that women like me who have paid NI contributions for over 40 years to fund the pensions of at least two generations of pensioners shouldn’t have ours at the end of our working lives

Pretty sure no one is saying you shouldn't get a pension. Just that pensions shouldn't be the only payment that is subject to the triple lock. Why should pensions get it but not other benefits or wages? When it's the workers who are paying for those pensions, they should surely also be able to expect to keep up with inflation as well

Octomore · 20/10/2022 18:24

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 18:11

And we’re not lucky. Unless you consider half a century of paying tax lucky.

I consider paying half a century of tax to be neither lucky or unlucky. It normal, it doesn't make someone special.

Octomore · 20/10/2022 18:24

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 15:30

You must think everyone’s maths is as poor as yours. Any pensioner who pays more than £10k tax in a year has returned their entire state pension to the treasury. Very, very disingenuous.

That's some very wacky maths you're using there! They will only ever pay 45% 'back', the remainder is tax they would be paying anyway on their other income.

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 18:11

And we’re not lucky. Unless you consider half a century of paying tax lucky.

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 18:10

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2022 15:45

But they'd pay tax on only the occupational pension or other income anyway wouldn't they? If they only had state pension, they'd pay no tax. The "marginal" tax on the state pension on top can't be more than 45% of the state pension - fact. Of course, if they have hefty occupational pensions too, then they pay tax on those occupational pensions - why shouldn't they? They should consider themselves lucky to get a state pension many don't actually need and lucky they don't have to pay NIC on their pensions (unlike workers who don't have a choice re paying NIC on wages). Pensioners have enjoyed tax relief on the amounts paid into their occupational pension schemes so it's right they pay tax on the amounts they draw out as pensions. They should also be grateful for the tax free 25% lump sum they'll have enjoyed.

Pensioners have enjoyed tax relief on the amounts paid into their occupational pension schemes so it's right they pay tax on the amounts they draw out as pensions.

Of course it is. It’s also right that we pay tax on our state pension, should we wish to claim it. What’s wrong is to suggest that women like me who have paid NI contributions for over 40 years to fund the pensions of at least two generations of pensioners shouldn’t have ours at the end of our working lives.

Halloweenshock · 20/10/2022 18:02

The UK state pension is so bad compared to other countries pensions due to the different way pensions work in other countries. In many European countries you have no separate workplace pension for instance, all money gets paid to the state pension instead hence the state pension is much higher there!

UrsulaPandress · 20/10/2022 16:39

But presumably your plumber son will put his prices up to cover the wage increases, and on the circle goes.

Oldsu · 20/10/2022 16:25

Faciadipasta · 20/10/2022 07:34

Sure @Oldsu but do they agree with the triple lock for pensions only? Not for pensions or wages too that wouls benefit them as well? Somehow I doubt it.

@Faciadipasta doubt away only not only does my DS support a rise in benefits but also a rise in wages and not because it would benefit him either, as a very successful plumber with his own business it would be doubtful that he would need out of work benefits unless it was sickness or disability ones, as for wages as an employer he gave his workforce a 7.5% wage rise in September, a further 5% is planned in April. Not everyone is selfish in only wanting something they themselves would benefit from personally.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2022 15:45

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 15:30

You must think everyone’s maths is as poor as yours. Any pensioner who pays more than £10k tax in a year has returned their entire state pension to the treasury. Very, very disingenuous.

But they'd pay tax on only the occupational pension or other income anyway wouldn't they? If they only had state pension, they'd pay no tax. The "marginal" tax on the state pension on top can't be more than 45% of the state pension - fact. Of course, if they have hefty occupational pensions too, then they pay tax on those occupational pensions - why shouldn't they? They should consider themselves lucky to get a state pension many don't actually need and lucky they don't have to pay NIC on their pensions (unlike workers who don't have a choice re paying NIC on wages). Pensioners have enjoyed tax relief on the amounts paid into their occupational pension schemes so it's right they pay tax on the amounts they draw out as pensions. They should also be grateful for the tax free 25% lump sum they'll have enjoyed.

Cruisebabe1 · 20/10/2022 15:45

MrMrsJones · 19/10/2022 16:04

Working people who are now receiving their pensions are ordinary people, who have worked hard all their lives

Well said !! I have been through the “ no pay rise” situation for a decade. I have also worked full time for 36 years . So I think people like us have gone through this anyway!

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 15:30

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2022 13:23

The "rich" will only pay a maximum of 45% of their government (i.e. taxpayer) funded state pension back to HMRC in the form of income tax, so the "net" cost to the taxpayer is always at least 55% of the state pension payments.

You must think everyone’s maths is as poor as yours. Any pensioner who pays more than £10k tax in a year has returned their entire state pension to the treasury. Very, very disingenuous.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2022 13:23

Beenaboutabit · 20/10/2022 11:47

If pensions don’t rise with inflation, we’re all screwed when we retire.

I have 15 years more before I retire and OH and I are relying on our state pensions to keep up with inflation even though we will have other pensions we paid into. Half of 1 state pension only pays the energy bills!

those that only have a state pension or pension credit are even more reliant on it keeping up with inflation.

all those rich pensioners being referred to on here - they’re all paying tax on their state pensions. The richest will be paying more that the state pension back to HMRC. It’s not the handout to the rich some people think it is.

The "rich" will only pay a maximum of 45% of their government (i.e. taxpayer) funded state pension back to HMRC in the form of income tax, so the "net" cost to the taxpayer is always at least 55% of the state pension payments.

Badbadbunny · 20/10/2022 13:22

FistFullOfRegrets · 20/10/2022 11:10

@Theluggage15

I didn't say you COULDN'T.

but it's an entitlement after paying into the pension fund for YEARS. It's not a benefit.

It is a benefit. The amount of NIC you pay has absolutely XERO relationship with the state benefit you get. State pension is paid according to NIC "credits" and you can accrue credits without paying any NIC, i.e. earning under the threshold for paying NICs, gaining credits whilst on certain benefits, gaining credits whilst being a SAHM (previously called home responsibility credits).

Your only "entitlement" is that by earning NIC credits you become entitled to a state pension, which is a state benefit!

There is no "fund", neither at a personal nor national level.

Blossomtoes · 20/10/2022 12:07

toulet · 20/10/2022 09:06

The link isn’t nonsense because qualifying years are a minimum, not a limit.

I disagree, I think the age will keep moving out & be means tested in 20 yrs

In which case NI will have to be abolished and subsumed into general taxation because it would become pointless. Additionally a lot of retirees would drop out of paying tax so the treasury would lose income.

Kabalagala · 20/10/2022 11:57

Beenaboutabit · 20/10/2022 11:47

If pensions don’t rise with inflation, we’re all screwed when we retire.

I have 15 years more before I retire and OH and I are relying on our state pensions to keep up with inflation even though we will have other pensions we paid into. Half of 1 state pension only pays the energy bills!

those that only have a state pension or pension credit are even more reliant on it keeping up with inflation.

all those rich pensioners being referred to on here - they’re all paying tax on their state pensions. The richest will be paying more that the state pension back to HMRC. It’s not the handout to the rich some people think it is.

But the problem is wages aren't keeping up with inflation. Nor are other benefits. The government refuses to appropriately tax big business. So where is this extra pension money going to come from?

Beenaboutabit · 20/10/2022 11:47

If pensions don’t rise with inflation, we’re all screwed when we retire.

I have 15 years more before I retire and OH and I are relying on our state pensions to keep up with inflation even though we will have other pensions we paid into. Half of 1 state pension only pays the energy bills!

those that only have a state pension or pension credit are even more reliant on it keeping up with inflation.

all those rich pensioners being referred to on here - they’re all paying tax on their state pensions. The richest will be paying more that the state pension back to HMRC. It’s not the handout to the rich some people think it is.

WoooahNelly · 20/10/2022 11:44

I understand I think what OP is feeling. I am from the generation who;

  1. Are expected to be working as well as mother's.
  2. Are expected to work and contribute for (at least) 7 years longer than their mothers.
  3. Were not given information about pensions or forced into a scheme when starting employment, so massive knowledge/financial deficit.
  4. Have had most final salary pensions unavailable to them...except the ones that rely on our taxes to fund them.
  5. Are told that they are lucky to earn enough to buy a house which, if they lose their job/get divorced will be taken away from them as there is no help from government towards mortgages (before you jump on...I know about the mortgage interest after a year etc...but really what use is that?) no empathy from courts for working mothers as we 'are all equal'
  6. If we manage to buy and retain a house (we are so privileged) its value is used to means test more and more benefits, despite what you may have spent on the house in terms of remodelling, upkeep and mortgage payments, so are we any better off than renters longterm?
  7. Will probably be subjected to increasing cuts to state pension if not it's total removal for those with pensions over a bare minimum amount.

All these things make me think, given how much time and effort went into getting onto the career ladder, being a working mother paying thousands in childcare, paying many many thousands to buy ex out of home, attempting to catch up with a private pension that will pay at least as much as the state pension to give myself a meagre but not breadline existence in my (now shortened pensionable years) and whilst I am still working, I should be grateful for having a job that I get no benefits (other than child benefit) whereby I can just afford the mortgage, heating (ish), food and two or three nights a year in a budget UK hotel chain for a holiday....fuck this if someone tells me I am fucking privileged.

F4chrissakes · 20/10/2022 11:37

Haven't read the thread but any increase in pensions won't be paid until April. That's plenty of time for this shit show of a government to u turn yet again. After all, a week is a long time in politics......

Cuppasoupmonster · 20/10/2022 11:20

FistFullOfRegrets · 20/10/2022 11:10

@Theluggage15

I didn't say you COULDN'T.

but it's an entitlement after paying into the pension fund for YEARS. It's not a benefit.

What ‘pension fund’? What are you talking about?

Kabalagala · 20/10/2022 11:19

worriedatthistime · 20/10/2022 11:08

@Kabalagala pension is not a means tested benefit as technically most have paid in to get it in the first place
Benefits you don't have to have paid a penny to get it
Pensioners who have a private pension and state do pay tax as well

Of course pensions are benefits. They are benefits with qualifying criteria like any other.

Theluggage15 · 20/10/2022 11:18

It is a benefit. It’s defined as one by the government.

worriedatthistime · 20/10/2022 11:13

* £65000

worriedatthistime · 20/10/2022 11:12

@Kabalagala public is lack of money and depends which sector really as some aren't as poorly paid
A gp salary is ok a nurses not
A head teacher good a newly qualified not so good
But does anyone think any goverment will come in and raise it by say 10% but then bot tax you elsewhere on it
I still see the bigger issue as houses, house prices and rent have gone way over the cost of wages and if this had been kept more inline we wouldn't be in this position
In late 90's I earnt £19000, rented a 3 bed at £650 a month, same job in that area now pays around £25000 same house to rent about £1400-15000
Friend at tome bought a 2 bed flat £650000 now worth £320000 thats where the big issue is to me

FistFullOfRegrets · 20/10/2022 11:10

Theluggage15 · 20/10/2022 10:52

Utterly ridiculous. Of course you could means test it.

@Theluggage15

I didn't say you COULDN'T.

but it's an entitlement after paying into the pension fund for YEARS. It's not a benefit.