Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pensions to rise with inflation - but what about working people???

592 replies

doris9034 · 19/10/2022 15:57

BBC Website: "Liz Truss and Chancellor Jeremy Hunt jointly agreed to guarantee that the state pension rises with inflation next year - thereby maintaining the "triple lock" - ahead of PMQs this morning, Downing Street says.
In a huddle with reporters after PMQs, the prime minister's official spokesman said the decision reflected the "unique position" of pensioners who are "unable to increase their earnings through work"

But I - and millions of others - are also unable to "increase our earnings through work" because we are in the middle income bracket, our employers do not have the capacity to raise our earnings in line with inflation and we don't qualify for any state related benefits.

So, whilst I 100% don't begrudge the helping of pensioners (many of whom are probably among the better off anyway), I can't help but feeling a bit annoyed that it always seems to be the ordinary working person / family that never gets any respite from the ever increasing cost of living.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 08:52

Still, nobody has tried to explain what will happen in a generations time when millennials start to retire. Having also paid in, but saddled with student debt, mortgaged right up to retirement age or beyond unless stuck in private lets, fewer children and decreased immigration and stagnant wages.
Benefits of any kind, should be for those truly in need. The burden of taxation should be on the very wealthiest and work should bloody well pay.
Some of the today's pensioners don't appear to care very much about anyone else.

walkingonsunshinekat · 22/10/2022 08:35

You can go on the Gov.uk and see if you have "paid in" enough qualifying years for a state pension, currently 10 years min.

The fact that the money from NI isn't ring fenced is neither here nor there.

magicofthefae · 22/10/2022 08:34

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 08:01

Means testing for state pensions doesn't have to be at breadline levels. They could use an income level of £50k like the child benefit claw back. That way the vast majority of pensioners wouldn't be affected. Just the ones with hefty private pensions or rental/investment income who really don't "need" the state pension anyway. Easier to administer too as it could be done via self assessment tax returns in the same way as child benefit.

This.
There has to be a way. A middle ground somewhere. No starvation or frost bite for anyone. But at the same time, working hard needs to pay off more than not working as hard (exempting disability/significant caring responsibilities).
I just think that the current state of affairs needs radical revision. It's unsustainable, and the Tory's who normally are all for austerity and cuts for the rest of the population, are kicking the ball down the road because it would obliterate the living standards of their core voter base, the boomers and older.
The revision will be unpopular, it doesn't have to be bare bones breadline, but it does have to be done. The comforts of the older generations, can't be afforded by the starvation, poor housing and poor education of our children, which is what's currently happening.

Yes we must support and care for older people, there's no denial of that. But if we don't support younger generations, equally, you wont get the capable and competent workforce needed to sustain the economy, pharmacists to prescribe medications, GP for medical appointments, instead you'll get higher numbers in the prison systems, mental care care systems, suicide, etc.

Humans are successful compared to other species, mainly because of our intellect, but mostly because we work together as a society to benefit everyone, not just a certain generation or just the upper or middle classes, but everyone.

Faciadipasta · 22/10/2022 08:25

But what does "people have paid in for their state pension" mean? There is no pension pot. Your NI contributions are not put aside ready to pay back as pension. (If they were then your pension would likely run out long before you did). This perception seems to be part of the problem. NI perpetuates this I think and should probably be got rid of as a seperate tax and just added into general taxation.

walkingonsunshinekat · 22/10/2022 08:14

People have paid in for their state pension, a Pandora's box of legal challenges if they became means tested.

The temptation for future Govts would be to not increase this 50k threshold, see the higher rate income tax for what can happen to once generous thresholds.

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 08:01

Means testing for state pensions doesn't have to be at breadline levels. They could use an income level of £50k like the child benefit claw back. That way the vast majority of pensioners wouldn't be affected. Just the ones with hefty private pensions or rental/investment income who really don't "need" the state pension anyway. Easier to administer too as it could be done via self assessment tax returns in the same way as child benefit.

Blossomtoes · 21/10/2022 19:04

Means testing pensions would mean removing the link with NI so there’d be no point in having it any more. Just subsume it into general taxation. How do you means test wealth?

If you’re excluding someone’s principal residence, everyone will just invest all their wealth in their home so you’d have more older people living in houses too big for them. If you exclude their occupational pension pot, they’ll up their contributions so the tax on that money is lost. If you discourage wealth more people will qualify for having their care home fees paid for them - the cost of that dwarfs the cost of a £10k a year pension.

kitcat15 · 21/10/2022 18:53

magicofthefae · 21/10/2022 14:36

@kitcat15....I understand that you're saying you paid off house and 6 figure savings/private pension is not enough and that you're entitled to a state pension in line with inflation..but what do you say to the kids in schools that go hungry, kids of FULL TIME WORKING parents, not poor enough to fall under free schools meals system, but not affluent enough to afford to pay school meals fees.

I'm sorry, it's simply greed and generational entitlement.....it's this thinking that's got the Tory's in and bar one season of Labour next time, will get the Tory's in again, and again.

Pensions and winter fuel allowance should be means tested. Even it if costs more in admin costs, it's the principle that you're wasting money on millionaires that don't need it, while those from working class and poor backgrounds starve.

People should be encouraged to heavily pay into private pension schemes in the working years early on, so the majority of people rely on a private pension, and not feel entitled to a state pension. There needs to be a culture shift on this, it's the only way it's sustainable long term.

Governments should make more land available, planning wise, and mandates for rapid and extreme house building, so houses are affordable for young generations. This has a knock on effect, if young people can pay their mortgage off in 10-15 years, instead of 30-40 year current mortgages, guess what? They can put large amounts into private pensions. Relieving the burden on the state, come state pension time.

If pensioners try to offload their wealth to children to become entitled to means tested state pensions, they have current measures in place, 'deliberate deprivation of assets', by old people avoiding care home fees, which can be employed to enforce a means tested pensions system.

NI should be abolished, with simple tax put in place, which taxes wealth the same as earned income. This would get rid of the sense of entitlement that 'I've paid my dues'. No, your NI contributions likely are MUCH LESS than the money you would get from a state pension for 30 years of retirement. Current systems have too many loopholes that make it easy to legally avoid tax for the mega rich. These should be shut down.

Before any one says I'm racing to the bottom, no I'm not. It should be one rule for all, if pensions are inflation linked, so should everything else. Wages should be higher, it won't make inflation worse...it will help people survive this winter. In the long term....high wages benefits everyone, people will have money to spend in shops, non essentials etc.

To the people saying means testing pensions rewards laziness, while not rewarding savers and hard workers who are doing the right thing...I say, hard work should always pay off, compared to laziness. But those with large sums invested in private pensions and live in large houses in costly areas....do have a much higher quality of life and living standard than a person solely on a state pension, using pension credits or whatever old age benefit etc to top up the older person renting a room in a private house share with strangers, and skipping meals and getting pneumonia in the winter due to avoiding putting the heating on. It's just that at least with a means tested benefit linked to inflation, at least that old person won't die of pneumonia or starvation and will not die. At least give them that.

I disagree, state pension should not imo be means tested……My savings will pay for the extras until I get my state pension….. …..my nursing pension is more than the state pension and just enough to live on but that’s all…..I’m not greedy…I just want to enjoy my retirement ……and I need my state pension for that as my savings will likely be very low by the time I claim my state pension in 9 years ….I don’t have any private pensions…just my public sector nhs one…I’m certainly not mega rich😂….. there is no incentive for me not to have taken my nhs pension at 55….it was there waiting for me…same as every other nurse of my age who has been in nhs pension scheme…..I don’t live in a large house…just a 3 bed Victorian semi….but it’s just how I want it …..I may not live to be 67 …but if I do I certainly won’t feel guilty for claiming my state pension

walkingonsunshinekat · 21/10/2022 16:12

Octomore · 21/10/2022 15:49

But that poster was comparing it to the old 90% bracket. It's only a sensible comparison if you compare to the highest current rate.

I was referring to the 40% rate, its hard to keep up with which tax rate is in or out atm.

Strange though, as apparently these people earning over 150k also paid £61 billion in tax (2020/21), so one would to assume a considerable number are earning far in excess of 150k
But what is even more odd, is that in 2010/11 the total tax from this group was 35billion, that certainly isn't accounted for by a 5% rise in tax, so we must assume that during a period of almost no income growth for you or i & austerity, the amounts and the numbers earning 150k has risen considerably.

The current tax and wage systems in the UK benefit who exactly?

Octomore · 21/10/2022 15:49

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 15:11

That's the additional rate. About 6 million pay the 40% bracket.

But that poster was comparing it to the old 90% bracket. It's only a sensible comparison if you compare to the highest current rate.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/10/2022 15:34

Newestname002 · 21/10/2022 15:33

I'm very grateful the triple lock has been reinstated (for now). I worked hard for over 40 years (often working three jobs to help myself and my family) and every little helps - especially now. 🌹

😳 read the room

Newestname002 · 21/10/2022 15:33

I'm very grateful the triple lock has been reinstated (for now). I worked hard for over 40 years (often working three jobs to help myself and my family) and every little helps - especially now. 🌹

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 15:11

Octomore · 21/10/2022 15:04

You're replying to a post about the top rate (45%), but only 629,000 people are paying the 45% tax rate in 2022/23, not 'millions'. Approximately 0.9% of the population.

www.rjp.co.uk/higher-rate-tax/

That's the additional rate. About 6 million pay the 40% bracket.

Octomore · 21/10/2022 15:04

walkingonsunshinekat · 21/10/2022 10:54

That was a rate paid by a tiny number of people in the 60s.

Millions pay the higher rate now.

But we are heading back toward higher taxes for the wealthy and not before time, we simply cannot raise the monies needed from the average wage earner anymore.
Economists now believe we will have WFT's on Banks as well as Energy companies.

You're replying to a post about the top rate (45%), but only 629,000 people are paying the 45% tax rate in 2022/23, not 'millions'. Approximately 0.9% of the population.

www.rjp.co.uk/higher-rate-tax/

magicofthefae · 21/10/2022 14:36

@kitcat15....I understand that you're saying you paid off house and 6 figure savings/private pension is not enough and that you're entitled to a state pension in line with inflation..but what do you say to the kids in schools that go hungry, kids of FULL TIME WORKING parents, not poor enough to fall under free schools meals system, but not affluent enough to afford to pay school meals fees.

I'm sorry, it's simply greed and generational entitlement.....it's this thinking that's got the Tory's in and bar one season of Labour next time, will get the Tory's in again, and again.

Pensions and winter fuel allowance should be means tested. Even it if costs more in admin costs, it's the principle that you're wasting money on millionaires that don't need it, while those from working class and poor backgrounds starve.

People should be encouraged to heavily pay into private pension schemes in the working years early on, so the majority of people rely on a private pension, and not feel entitled to a state pension. There needs to be a culture shift on this, it's the only way it's sustainable long term.

Governments should make more land available, planning wise, and mandates for rapid and extreme house building, so houses are affordable for young generations. This has a knock on effect, if young people can pay their mortgage off in 10-15 years, instead of 30-40 year current mortgages, guess what? They can put large amounts into private pensions. Relieving the burden on the state, come state pension time.

If pensioners try to offload their wealth to children to become entitled to means tested state pensions, they have current measures in place, 'deliberate deprivation of assets', by old people avoiding care home fees, which can be employed to enforce a means tested pensions system.

NI should be abolished, with simple tax put in place, which taxes wealth the same as earned income. This would get rid of the sense of entitlement that 'I've paid my dues'. No, your NI contributions likely are MUCH LESS than the money you would get from a state pension for 30 years of retirement. Current systems have too many loopholes that make it easy to legally avoid tax for the mega rich. These should be shut down.

Before any one says I'm racing to the bottom, no I'm not. It should be one rule for all, if pensions are inflation linked, so should everything else. Wages should be higher, it won't make inflation worse...it will help people survive this winter. In the long term....high wages benefits everyone, people will have money to spend in shops, non essentials etc.

To the people saying means testing pensions rewards laziness, while not rewarding savers and hard workers who are doing the right thing...I say, hard work should always pay off, compared to laziness. But those with large sums invested in private pensions and live in large houses in costly areas....do have a much higher quality of life and living standard than a person solely on a state pension, using pension credits or whatever old age benefit etc to top up the older person renting a room in a private house share with strangers, and skipping meals and getting pneumonia in the winter due to avoiding putting the heating on. It's just that at least with a means tested benefit linked to inflation, at least that old person won't die of pneumonia or starvation and will not die. At least give them that.

Quisquam · 21/10/2022 13:13

But we are in this situation precisely because nobodies income has kept up with inflation. Continuing to suppress wages and benefits is just kicking the can down a dead end road

If every business puts up its prices by inflation to pay staff an inflation pay rise, then inflation will stay the same. Nobody benefits!

The truth is wealth is being funnelled upwards from the working classes to the super wealthy and the Conservatives support that. So long as people vote the Conservatives in, contrary to their own best interests, they will get poorer!

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 12:29

Quisquam · 21/10/2022 12:04

I entirely agree. As should wages.

How is this going to work in Small and Medium Enterprises? DH is self employed. His clients were hard hit by Covid, because some of them, also self employed, fell through the gaps of government support schemes. They had no income for months. If DH put his fees up, clients would go somewhere else, low balling.

DH has taken exactly the same amount every month from his business for 12 years. He has not given himself so much as a 1p increase per month. When Covid started, he drew less to reflect the fact, he was saving on train fares, by working at home, although he still had to pay the overheads on his office.

Yet you are suggesting, that while his income has fallen by half, because clients have retired rather than struggle on; all fixed overheads have gone up; he magically has the means to give the staff he uses, a pay increase for inflation? Where you think small businesses can get the money from?

If shops’ overheads have gone up massively (like energy), do you think they can increase prices to recoup that and inflation pay rises for staff - no, they will lose customers, because customers are cutting back.

Many small shops and restaurants on our high street have closed since Covid; and one told us before Covid, their rent was £35,000 Pa. We couldn’t understand how they could afford that and make a profit then, never mind now?

But we are in this situation precisely because nobodies income has kept up with inflation. Continuing to suppress wages and benefits is just kicking the can down a dead end road

Quisquam · 21/10/2022 12:04

I entirely agree. As should wages.

How is this going to work in Small and Medium Enterprises? DH is self employed. His clients were hard hit by Covid, because some of them, also self employed, fell through the gaps of government support schemes. They had no income for months. If DH put his fees up, clients would go somewhere else, low balling.

DH has taken exactly the same amount every month from his business for 12 years. He has not given himself so much as a 1p increase per month. When Covid started, he drew less to reflect the fact, he was saving on train fares, by working at home, although he still had to pay the overheads on his office.

Yet you are suggesting, that while his income has fallen by half, because clients have retired rather than struggle on; all fixed overheads have gone up; he magically has the means to give the staff he uses, a pay increase for inflation? Where you think small businesses can get the money from?

If shops’ overheads have gone up massively (like energy), do you think they can increase prices to recoup that and inflation pay rises for staff - no, they will lose customers, because customers are cutting back.

Many small shops and restaurants on our high street have closed since Covid; and one told us before Covid, their rent was £35,000 Pa. We couldn’t understand how they could afford that and make a profit then, never mind now?

walkingonsunshinekat · 21/10/2022 10:54

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:38

Tax is complicated, think of the fuss now about the top rate of tax being 45% when in the 60s it was 90%. So it isn't just one thing, brackets, percentage, NI.

One uplift isn't enough but it isn't true to say minimum pay hasn't gone up with inflation without adding that in some brackets it has exceeded inflation this year, it has in some previous years as well.

That was a rate paid by a tiny number of people in the 60s.

Millions pay the higher rate now.

But we are heading back toward higher taxes for the wealthy and not before time, we simply cannot raise the monies needed from the average wage earner anymore.
Economists now believe we will have WFT's on Banks as well as Energy companies.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/10/2022 10:46

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:27

I was replying to a post that stated minimum wage hadn't increased with inflation. My point is for apprentices it went up more and in general it went up more than pensions or benefits.

Apprentices weren't well paid in the past and going back to the 60s, when I knew people doing apprenticeships, they certainly wouldn't be expecting to rent flats, if they weren't living at home they were in a room in a shared house.

I literally cannot engage with you ancient gran because you seem so, so far detached from reality on how much anything costs now compared to ‘in the 60s’.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:38

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 10:29

But seriously, wages and tax brackets have lagged behind inflation for years. Decades even. One uplift isn't enough.

Tax is complicated, think of the fuss now about the top rate of tax being 45% when in the 60s it was 90%. So it isn't just one thing, brackets, percentage, NI.

One uplift isn't enough but it isn't true to say minimum pay hasn't gone up with inflation without adding that in some brackets it has exceeded inflation this year, it has in some previous years as well.

1dayatatime · 21/10/2022 10:34

DonnaBanana · 21/10/2022 10:07

State pension should be means tested. If you have assets of over £50k excluding your home or pension fund you don’t get it. You should be allowed to give away assets to get under this level. That would encourage dispersal and circulation of wealth too.

Whilst I agree that this is inevitably what will happen with an ageing population and the cost to the taxpayer of funding the state pensions continually increasing, no political party is ever going to get elected if they propose means testing the state pension.

Plus it would disincentive people from paying into a private pension or to game their assets / wealth prior to reaching the state pension age ( transfer to children etc).

I don't disagree with you in principle but I can't see it working in practice.
What could be done in the meant is to means test or at least make taxable the winter fuel allowance.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:32

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/10/2022 10:21

So a full time apprentice is on half the wage of the average person in 1995. Give me a break, ancientgran.

Do you get what minimum means?

A full time apprentice spends a minimum of 20% of their normal weekly hours training but get paid for them. An apprentice aged 19 will only get the minimum for the first year and then goes onto NMW for their age.

Compare it to what lots of students are getting as loans and it isn't a bad deal which is probably why degree apprenticeships are so competitive, but obviously it isn't for everyone.

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 10:30

1dayatatime · 21/10/2022 10:27

That's a fair point - since 2017 (post Covid and furloughs) and post Ukraine inflation has risen much faster so that increases in state pensions will have further outstripped increases in average wages. So that the differential between average pension income after housing costs will now be much greater than average wages after housing costs than the £20 quoted in 2017.

Quite

Kabalagala · 21/10/2022 10:29

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:27

I was replying to a post that stated minimum wage hadn't increased with inflation. My point is for apprentices it went up more and in general it went up more than pensions or benefits.

Apprentices weren't well paid in the past and going back to the 60s, when I knew people doing apprenticeships, they certainly wouldn't be expecting to rent flats, if they weren't living at home they were in a room in a shared house.

But seriously, wages and tax brackets have lagged behind inflation for years. Decades even. One uplift isn't enough.