Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pensions to rise with inflation - but what about working people???

592 replies

doris9034 · 19/10/2022 15:57

BBC Website: "Liz Truss and Chancellor Jeremy Hunt jointly agreed to guarantee that the state pension rises with inflation next year - thereby maintaining the "triple lock" - ahead of PMQs this morning, Downing Street says.
In a huddle with reporters after PMQs, the prime minister's official spokesman said the decision reflected the "unique position" of pensioners who are "unable to increase their earnings through work"

But I - and millions of others - are also unable to "increase our earnings through work" because we are in the middle income bracket, our employers do not have the capacity to raise our earnings in line with inflation and we don't qualify for any state related benefits.

So, whilst I 100% don't begrudge the helping of pensioners (many of whom are probably among the better off anyway), I can't help but feeling a bit annoyed that it always seems to be the ordinary working person / family that never gets any respite from the ever increasing cost of living.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
XingMing · 22/10/2022 21:51

Statistically older people vote more conscientiously than younger. They/we learn that it matters to shape the society you want. And they vote for what will suit them best.

WindyHedges · 22/10/2022 19:17

There's plenty of research out there showing that younger people (of each generation) tend to vote Labour

Or the research which shows that younger people can’t be bothered to vote at all.

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 17:45

What I am angry about is that years of ideologically-driven austerity and erosion of workers rights have left working people in such an awful position. It should be possible for two adults working in low wage jobs (which are just as essential to society as high wage jobs!) to support a family and have some money left for leisure. Right now, that isn't the case amd that is something to be angry about.

Couldn’t agree more. Which is why the race to the bottom on this thread is so insane. And why I’ve never voted Tory and never would if they increased my pension to £20k a year. Mind, it would make the local foodbank very happy.

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 11:26

Octomore · 22/10/2022 09:39

There are dickheads of every age, its true.

But... I know there are many exceptions (my 70+ parents would sooner gnaw their own arms off than vote tory), but it is notable that it is primarily the older generations voting for this current shitshow of a government.

You know, the government that is keen to dismantle workers rights, end our commitments to the Human Rights Act, keep public sector wages low, continue austerity, prop up house prices at any cost, send asylum seekers to Rwanda...

The 2019 election stats were pretty stark:
yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2019/10/31/2019-general-election-demographics-dividing-britai

And that demographic will be similar in 10 years' time as it was 10 years ago. There's plenty of research out there showing that younger people (of each generation) tend to vote Labour but they change their political colours as they get older.

Octomore · 22/10/2022 09:59

Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 09:45

This is a thread about pensions. Someone having to go to work sick so they can pay the rent isn't relevant.

Actually it is. It is an absolute travesty that working people are unable to afford to take time to recover from illness. That shouldn't be the case in a civilised society. It's part of the wider economic and social picture which is driving this debate.

I am in favour of keeping inflation based increases for pensions, because the basic state pension is a pittance to live on. Means testing (e.g. for those with incomes above £50k) is a separate question, I'm undecided on that.

What I am angry about is that years of ideologically-driven austerity and erosion of workers rights have left working people in such an awful position. It should be possible for two adults working in low wage jobs (which are just as essential to society as high wage jobs!) to support a family and have some money left for leisure. Right now, that isn't the case amd that is something to be angry about.

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 09:57

Who decides who “needs” it? It’s a moot point anyway because nobody with an iota of common sense or foresight would ever support it. I remember one of my aunts saying in the 60s when I was a child “There will be no pensions soon”, yet here I am decades later drawing mine.

magicofthefae · 22/10/2022 09:48

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 09:21

at the same time, working hard needs to pay off more than not working as hard

So how do you reconcile that with means testing pensions? Working hard means you lose your state pension? It’s two completely contradictory positions.

No put the threshold for qualifying for means tested, so that those who don't 'need' it, do they it. I'm not talking about denying those that need it. The actual figures of what the threshold entails, that's the number crunching part.

Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 09:46

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 09:32

You're comparing the fact that people can't afford to take a sick day, to paying ever increasing benefits to people with plenty of money. Ridiculous.

You’re assuming that all pensioners have plenty of money. Ridiculous. The average UK pension is £15k a year.

www.unbiased.co.uk/life/pensions-retirement/what-is-the-average-uk-retirement-income

When did I say all?

Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 09:45

Quisquam · 22/10/2022 09:37

You're comparing the fact that people can't afford to take a sick day, to paying ever increasing benefits to people with plenty of money. Ridiculous.

No, I am not - I am saying it’s hypocrisy to call the elderly selfish, while some of the younger generations are equally selfish!

This is a thread about pensions. Someone having to go to work sick so they can pay the rent isn't relevant.

Octomore · 22/10/2022 09:43

It seems that age 40 is the tipping point. Thank god I don't seem to have been affected yet.

Pensions to rise with inflation - but what about working people???
Octomore · 22/10/2022 09:39

There are dickheads of every age, its true.

But... I know there are many exceptions (my 70+ parents would sooner gnaw their own arms off than vote tory), but it is notable that it is primarily the older generations voting for this current shitshow of a government.

You know, the government that is keen to dismantle workers rights, end our commitments to the Human Rights Act, keep public sector wages low, continue austerity, prop up house prices at any cost, send asylum seekers to Rwanda...

The 2019 election stats were pretty stark:
yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2019/10/31/2019-general-election-demographics-dividing-britai

Pensions to rise with inflation - but what about working people???
Quisquam · 22/10/2022 09:37

You're comparing the fact that people can't afford to take a sick day, to paying ever increasing benefits to people with plenty of money. Ridiculous.

No, I am not - I am saying it’s hypocrisy to call the elderly selfish, while some of the younger generations are equally selfish!

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 09:32

You're comparing the fact that people can't afford to take a sick day, to paying ever increasing benefits to people with plenty of money. Ridiculous.

You’re assuming that all pensioners have plenty of money. Ridiculous. The average UK pension is £15k a year.

www.unbiased.co.uk/life/pensions-retirement/what-is-the-average-uk-retirement-income

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/10/2022 09:28

Some of the today's pensioners don't appear to care very much about anyone else.

Some of every demographic don't care about anyone else. Or any way you choose to slice up society, there will be people who don't care about anyone else. What a ridiculous thing to say.

Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 09:28

Quisquam · 22/10/2022 09:23

Some of the today's pensioners don't appear to care very much about anyone else.

Isn’t that just as much true for younger generations? Look at the threads about people, who knowingly go to work or send their children to school with Covid? Their attitude is “I can’t afford to lose a day’s pay. I put my family first. I don’t care if as a result, the whole class, all their parents and the staff are off sick, or vulnerable people are seriously ill with Covid!”

You're comparing the fact that people can't afford to take a sick day, to paying ever increasing benefits to people with plenty of money. Ridiculous.

Quisquam · 22/10/2022 09:23

Some of the today's pensioners don't appear to care very much about anyone else.

Isn’t that just as much true for younger generations? Look at the threads about people, who knowingly go to work or send their children to school with Covid? Their attitude is “I can’t afford to lose a day’s pay. I put my family first. I don’t care if as a result, the whole class, all their parents and the staff are off sick, or vulnerable people are seriously ill with Covid!”

Blossomtoes · 22/10/2022 09:21

at the same time, working hard needs to pay off more than not working as hard

So how do you reconcile that with means testing pensions? Working hard means you lose your state pension? It’s two completely contradictory positions.

WindyHedges · 22/10/2022 09:21

YABU

Have you looked at the State pension rate lately? Could YOU live on it, particularly as you become older and frailer and need domestic help, or heating on all the time, or extra medical or personal care.

Polkadotties · 22/10/2022 09:15

ancientgran · 22/10/2022 09:08

People who were contracted out got a lower pension. People who are or will get the new flat rate pension will have to have enough years (is it 35 now?) not contracted out to get the full pension.

It was a lower state pension but their work pension guaranteed to pay at least equal to the SERPS element. Now we have to pay full rate NI and full rate private pension conts

magicofthefae · 22/10/2022 09:08

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 08:58

NIC should have been scrapped decades ago when the link was first broken between "paying" NIC (then called the stamp), and getting credits without paying. Now, you can gain annual credits without paying a penny, i.e. low earners above the lower threshold, home responsibilities, on certain benefits, etc. A lot of the "I've paid all my life" brigade really havn't! When it all started, it really was an "insurance" system where you paid your stamp (i.e. the insurance premium) and you got your benefits when needed. Now it's just another tax.

It's all been made worse by tinkering over the decades by the politicians, i.e. graduated state pension, SERPS, state second pension, etc., all of which were aimed at "linking" your state pension with the amount you paid in, i.e. the more contributions you paid, the higher the "earnings related" element of your state pension. Even more complicated with being able to "opt out" of the earnings side of the state pension and have some of your NIC contributions directed to your private/occupational pension instead. All that's now gone, leaving just legacy benefits payable to those who've already started to draw them (obviously on top of normal state pension).

Now there's no actual link between what you've actually "paid" in NIC and the state pension, it really is just another state benefit, and it's right that it's means tested, though as I've said above, at a pretty high level. People with very high occupational pensions, really don't NEED state benefits in the form of a state pension. Likewise they don't NEED a winter fuel allowance.

If that's politically unacceptable, then do it another way. Enact NIC contributions on occupational pension scheme pension payments, so that someone with a £100k pension pays the same tax/NIC as a worker with a £100k wage. It's grossly unfair that workers pay a hell of a lot more tax/nic/student loan deductions, etc than a pensioner with exactly the same income!

You've got it exactly right!

ancientgran · 22/10/2022 09:08

Polkadotties · 22/10/2022 09:05

Many of those who now receive their state pension would probably also paid into a work place pension and been contracted out of SERPS so paid a lower rate of NI. Contracting out ceased in 2016 so those who now pay into a pension scheme have to pay full rate NI.

People who were contracted out got a lower pension. People who are or will get the new flat rate pension will have to have enough years (is it 35 now?) not contracted out to get the full pension.

Polkadotties · 22/10/2022 09:05

Many of those who now receive their state pension would probably also paid into a work place pension and been contracted out of SERPS so paid a lower rate of NI. Contracting out ceased in 2016 so those who now pay into a pension scheme have to pay full rate NI.

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 09:01

Kabalagala · 22/10/2022 08:52

Still, nobody has tried to explain what will happen in a generations time when millennials start to retire. Having also paid in, but saddled with student debt, mortgaged right up to retirement age or beyond unless stuck in private lets, fewer children and decreased immigration and stagnant wages.
Benefits of any kind, should be for those truly in need. The burden of taxation should be on the very wealthiest and work should bloody well pay.
Some of the today's pensioners don't appear to care very much about anyone else.

Nail on the head. Today's pensioners may have paid NIC (though some havn't paid much at all, if any), but at much lower rates. NIC rates have steadily increased over the past few decades. Those now enjoying state pensions etc paid less NIC than today's workers. And yes, today's workers are paying lots of tax, nic, student loans deductions, and are HIGHLY unlikely to benefit from a state pension when they come to retire as it's just a giant ponzi scheme that will ultimately come to an end! Today's workers are expected to pay workplace pension deductions ON TOP OF NIC deductions, so are paying towards their own pensions AND towards the pensions (often not needed) of the retired generation.

magicofthefae · 22/10/2022 08:59

Faciadipasta · 22/10/2022 08:25

But what does "people have paid in for their state pension" mean? There is no pension pot. Your NI contributions are not put aside ready to pay back as pension. (If they were then your pension would likely run out long before you did). This perception seems to be part of the problem. NI perpetuates this I think and should probably be got rid of as a seperate tax and just added into general taxation.

I think current generation pensioners needed to be handed their entire NI contributions back, in the form of state pension, no doubt this would get used up far quicker, once that's used up, it becomes means tested.
To the ones that pass on their home to their kids to meet the means test, or whatever, there are current laws in place 'deliberate deprivation of assets', which can mitigate against this (currently implemented to mitigate for asset rich people trying to avoid paying for their care home fees). If they don't meet the means test, they can use liquidate their assets, downsize their property, get a reverse mortgage.

It's not popular I know. But if cheaper housing was readily available, and wages were reflective of living costs, there would be little need for the next generation of relying on a lottery of whether or not they get an inheritance. Instead young people, regardless of background, could work hard and save aggressively for a couple of decades and own their own home outright, like the boomers had the opportunity. Young people would have no need for your inheritance. So you would be able to afford to liquidate assets if needed, without the guilt of leaving your children and grandchildren penniless.
I know it's not popular....I will get slated for it, but think of your children coming into hard times (the inheritance you gave them, they have to split/loose, with their now ex husband/wife via divorce), your adult child now has to start over in life, without your inheritance, wouldn't you want them to live in a country where inheritance doesn't matter? They can work hard and start afresh again, and it's realistic and possible, because it's affordable.

Badbadbunny · 22/10/2022 08:58

NIC should have been scrapped decades ago when the link was first broken between "paying" NIC (then called the stamp), and getting credits without paying. Now, you can gain annual credits without paying a penny, i.e. low earners above the lower threshold, home responsibilities, on certain benefits, etc. A lot of the "I've paid all my life" brigade really havn't! When it all started, it really was an "insurance" system where you paid your stamp (i.e. the insurance premium) and you got your benefits when needed. Now it's just another tax.

It's all been made worse by tinkering over the decades by the politicians, i.e. graduated state pension, SERPS, state second pension, etc., all of which were aimed at "linking" your state pension with the amount you paid in, i.e. the more contributions you paid, the higher the "earnings related" element of your state pension. Even more complicated with being able to "opt out" of the earnings side of the state pension and have some of your NIC contributions directed to your private/occupational pension instead. All that's now gone, leaving just legacy benefits payable to those who've already started to draw them (obviously on top of normal state pension).

Now there's no actual link between what you've actually "paid" in NIC and the state pension, it really is just another state benefit, and it's right that it's means tested, though as I've said above, at a pretty high level. People with very high occupational pensions, really don't NEED state benefits in the form of a state pension. Likewise they don't NEED a winter fuel allowance.

If that's politically unacceptable, then do it another way. Enact NIC contributions on occupational pension scheme pension payments, so that someone with a £100k pension pays the same tax/NIC as a worker with a £100k wage. It's grossly unfair that workers pay a hell of a lot more tax/nic/student loan deductions, etc than a pensioner with exactly the same income!