Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be more help for middle class families

384 replies

RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 15:40

This isn't a hate mongering post, those on lower incomes and can't work should be helped. My issue is that there seems to be little to no support at all for middle class families. Myself and partner work 5 days a week and have 2 kids. Not a terrible wage so I can't complain about that but the energy cost, food bills and fuel are going to cripple us soon enough. We also have Christmas to think about and a couple of birthdays inbetween. I just feel so unbelievably stressed out all the time about it. I'm praying this all calms down by the end of next year when our mortgage is coming up to renewal. There is pretty much no help being offered to us (unless anyone has some hints). I can't see it getting any better and its pretty depressing, alongside other personal issues going on at the moment I just want to cry.

OP posts:
Catfordthefifth · 19/10/2022 22:42

@disc

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 22:42

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 22:39

From your previous posts you should not be giving out any advice at all.

I haven’t given out any advice. This isn’t an advice thread.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 22:39

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 22:30

Yeah, this already happened in 2008 (and before). And it will happen again without a government handout. It’s called an economic crisis.

Its a fact of life that hard work is no guarantee of financial security.

From your previous posts you should not be giving out any advice at all.

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 22:30

HappyMeal564 · 19/10/2022 22:24

Why should people have to sell their home they've worked hard for? This isn't about wanting a government hand out or people living beyond their means, its about households who have previously been able to live with a bit of wriggle room being pushed further and further to not affording the life they built and managed to fund because the cost of living had rocketed, people can't manage the mortgages which have jumped, utility bills and the weekly food shop. Also if everyone sells their home the money will very be quickly be eaten up by bills and rent, then what?

Yeah, this already happened in 2008 (and before). And it will happen again without a government handout. It’s called an economic crisis.

Its a fact of life that hard work is no guarantee of financial security.

HappyMeal564 · 19/10/2022 22:24

outtheshowernow · 19/10/2022 20:38

But you have the option to sell those assets don't you which most don't

Why should people have to sell their home they've worked hard for? This isn't about wanting a government hand out or people living beyond their means, its about households who have previously been able to live with a bit of wriggle room being pushed further and further to not affording the life they built and managed to fund because the cost of living had rocketed, people can't manage the mortgages which have jumped, utility bills and the weekly food shop. Also if everyone sells their home the money will very be quickly be eaten up by bills and rent, then what?

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 22:18

nodogz · 19/10/2022 22:11

MC families shouldn't need help - they should have a decent standard of living. Getting haircuts and going out for meals should be normal and expected.

This is a rich country. Ok, current political situation hasn't done much for everyday people but it is a rich country. Children shouldn't be hungry. There shouldn't be this race to the bottom of freezing houses and being grateful for a miserable existence.

If you want public services (schools, hospitals, roads, care homes), you need to pay tax. Tax and public services are good things for average, normal people. And by normal I mean households with incomes under 250k*. (They are also great for businesses who benefit from skills, safety, infrastructure but that's a rant for another day)

I've worked alongside government and it's wasteful to the highest level. I was in a pack of consultants being charged on a daily rate of 6k EACH for months and I didn't have anything to do. I couldn't give a shit about benefit fraud - it's nothing in the grand scheme. It's propaganda and a dog whistle.

  • yes I'm aware this is a WHOLE lot of money. I'd say it's the level where income - that is earned through working - tops out.

On a much smaller scale I've also seen major wastage and overstaffed as in not much to actually do, mainly in the days of the mid to late 00s in the surestart children centres. I remember thinking how much public money is basically being taken the piss out of. When it's public money, its not treated as valuable as the private sector have to.

nodogz · 19/10/2022 22:11

MC families shouldn't need help - they should have a decent standard of living. Getting haircuts and going out for meals should be normal and expected.

This is a rich country. Ok, current political situation hasn't done much for everyday people but it is a rich country. Children shouldn't be hungry. There shouldn't be this race to the bottom of freezing houses and being grateful for a miserable existence.

If you want public services (schools, hospitals, roads, care homes), you need to pay tax. Tax and public services are good things for average, normal people. And by normal I mean households with incomes under 250k*. (They are also great for businesses who benefit from skills, safety, infrastructure but that's a rant for another day)

I've worked alongside government and it's wasteful to the highest level. I was in a pack of consultants being charged on a daily rate of 6k EACH for months and I didn't have anything to do. I couldn't give a shit about benefit fraud - it's nothing in the grand scheme. It's propaganda and a dog whistle.

  • yes I'm aware this is a WHOLE lot of money. I'd say it's the level where income - that is earned through working - tops out.
AloysiusBear · 19/10/2022 21:37

I don't disagree that wealth distribution is mad in our country and full time work should provide a better quality of life.

I think everyone thinks they are "middle class" though. In reality many of the people who consider themselves thus are on (relatively) low incomes.

User38899953 · 19/10/2022 21:00

I think o sort of understand what you are meaning, but you have gone about it the wrong way.

Middle class- I think you mean Middle income, or an average family.

Of course the govt shouldn't be paying for your Xmas/birthday.

The bare bones of the matter is life is getting more expensive, no one can afford what they could a few years ago. Everything has gone up in price and income has largely stayed the same.

Majority of people need to cut back on non essentials

viques · 19/10/2022 20:51

portico · 19/10/2022 19:47

People who buy a second property and had to page 2 lots of stamp duty. I think that is punitively unfair to them.

I was thinking more of the overseas investors who are responsible for apartment buildings lying almost empty, or the people who buy in places like Bishops Avenue and again leave the places empty. But second home owners are not totally innocent !

paintitallover · 19/10/2022 20:50

Hbh17 · 19/10/2022 15:44

Why? It's not the Government's job to just hand out bundles of free money to everyone and - in the end - we would all have to pay for it.

Just the same as the governments in Europe would do!

toulet · 19/10/2022 20:47

I would rather the government put more money into younger generation - better education, better schools, cheaper nursery, teenagers' clubs etc. & NHS, rather than just spend on the adults/elderly, and try to fix the current economy.

I agree with this & hopefully it would lead to a more skilled & productivity population which would in turn provide that elusive growth that is desperately needed.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 20:45

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 18:24

No you get a home equity loan/2nd mortgage. It only took me 3 weeks. I think most people can project out 3 weeks as to when they will run out of money.
Then if things don’t improve you calculate the point at which you put the house up for sale. Waiting for bank repossession results in a loss to the funds you can release.

You’ve obviously never had to do this. So stop telling me I don’t know…I have LIVED this!

That is BAD advice and bad management of your own money affairs! An equity loan/2nd mortgage is not a fix AT ALL. You say you used to own 4 houses, or have over the years, I can see why. I've lived on a lower income for years, never have I felt the need to get an equity loan/2nd mortgage, and I mean I was earning around £1400 per month as a single parent which paid for all bills and monthly outgoings. Sorry but you sound like you are incredibly bad, reckless and nieve with money.

XingMing · 19/10/2022 20:44

I have feet in three camps here: two elderly mothers, one in good health and receiving pension credit, the other relatively okay financially but currently nearing end of life and costing the NHS big time, and us who have just hit 66 and are still working, with a payroll to meet every month, and a DC walking into the maelstrom. Our triple responsibilities mean that there is no single right answer.

outtheshowernow · 19/10/2022 20:38

AssetRichIncomePoor · 19/10/2022 19:24

As the username says. I have peanuts in my bank account. I don't qualify for any help with anything because of the value of assets. So I'm better off than many people asset-wise, but that doesn't pay the bills.

But you have the option to sell those assets don't you which most don't

zoemelb · 19/10/2022 20:37

I would rather the government put more money into younger generation - better education, better schools, cheaper nursery, teenagers' clubs etc. & NHS, rather than just spend on the adults/elderly, and try to fix the current economy. Aren't we all should learn by now that politicians aren't magic, and they can't fix all of our problems. All the news like to blame on them for everything (except for Brexit which is just a shit show from the government).
It's the younger generation that will need to pay taxes later. "Give a Man a Fish, and You Feed Him for a Day. Teach a Man To Fish, and You Feed Him for a Lifetime"

mumofninetofive · 19/10/2022 20:33

Exactly OP, funny and isn't it, a massive amount of people from poor backgrounds, study hard and work hard claw their way up the ladder to earn a middle income. We have put the effort in and deserve some reward for our efforts.

But reward do we get in reality, well the government squeeze you until your squeak and provide no assistance. The really high earners avoid paying at all and those below you income wise think it's only fair they take everything you have worked hard and grafted for because they feel you owe them and it's their right.

Well may be were sick of it, if a political party ever come for middle income families Id be all over them.

As for those beautiful Ng obnoxious to the OP get a grip they owe you just as much as you own them nothing!

XingMing · 19/10/2022 20:25

The problems are going to arise from an acretion of all the tiny economies we shall all be forced into making individually, but the problem when it really blooms will be huge. If someone sells off baby clothes, instead of handing them down... as I did because I could afford to, and doesn't give a box of outgrown Lego away to a friend, then another substantial part of the ecconomy becomes monetized.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 20:21

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 18:41

You have an asset worth tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of £££
Thats the money I’m talking about.

Unfortunately it doesn't work like that. The money is tied in a house, people can be asset rich and cash poor.

Ponoka7 · 19/10/2022 20:21

Yabado · 19/10/2022 19:52

@WaddleAway
not all banks go through bank statements
my son has just bought via Barclays and they didn’t ask to see his bank Statments or savings account in fact they didn’t ask to see any of his bank stamens / credit cards statments
I was quite shocked
They were insistent on a copy of his P60 but that was it
he is doing shared ownership and put down 50k and his mortgage is94k buying 60 percent

it’s crazy as to rent the exact same apartment is 1500
but his mortgage rent and service charge is around £750 -£800

If his solicitor hasn't asked for those then they've broken a lot of laws and legalisation. Unless he has banked with Barclays for at least ten years.

"If we get those back to work that want to or are able and just aren't, we should net that off against higher benefits for those genuinely unable to work"

That's very few people. Most people claiming are in work and are on a top up of benefits. We have a lack of full time, well paid jobs. In many areas we need people to be happy to be out of work because the jobs aren't there.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 20:15

Deguster · 19/10/2022 19:50

2 members of my team (both women) have received promotions recently and turned them down.

One because the difference in salary was not worth the extra hassle and she would no longer be paid overtime (which is regarded by my company as “blue collar” only).

Another because she would be just over the HRT band and had worked out after deductions she would be worse off.

I think “middle’ salaries have just not kept ahead of entry ones. Everyone and his dog having a degree probably not helping.

I'm on the fence with this one. On the one hand I agree with them in why take on extra responsibility for not much financial gain or unfortunately worse off. On the other hand it's shortsighted because it's not always about just the pay but the experience it brings which, depending on the job role, could pay dividends in the future as you have the training, knowledge and experience to progress to higher roles.

For the past 4 years I've taken on more responsibilities in my job for not much extra pay. In those 4 years though its meant I've gained sooo much experience and knowledge, which in turn meant when I went for a job promotion in the summer for a much higher position, I not only got it but my salary has increased by a thousands a year.

It can happen, it does happen and its about looking long term when promotions arise. I do agree though if the promotion just means same shit, same pay, more responsibility with chance of further progression then think carefully.

toulet · 19/10/2022 20:10

yes but let's extrapolate it to everyone's situation regardless 😆

Catfordthefifth · 19/10/2022 20:01

It's not normal at all. It's frankly unbelievable to be honest.

toulet · 19/10/2022 19:56

That's not normal, the vast majority will look at payslips & bank statements

Yabado · 19/10/2022 19:52

@WaddleAway
not all banks go through bank statements
my son has just bought via Barclays and they didn’t ask to see his bank Statments or savings account in fact they didn’t ask to see any of his bank stamens / credit cards statments
I was quite shocked
They were insistent on a copy of his P60 but that was it
he is doing shared ownership and put down 50k and his mortgage is94k buying 60 percent

it’s crazy as to rent the exact same apartment is 1500
but his mortgage rent and service charge is around £750 -£800